Enter: Princess Pony head

Star and Marco waited until Moon and River had left before continuing their conversation. The cooks brought out their food. Both got a plate of meat with vegetables and a large platter of corn. For a drink, the two were given alcohol-free juice in golden goblets.

"Wow. This juice is really good. What is it? Oh, sorry, I forgot." Marco started to eat and looked up at Star. "Is everything alright, Star? You're pretty quiet."

"Sorry, I'm just trying to remember everything, but now I have a headache." Star's cheeks were a bright pink.

"Let me see if you have a fever." Marco walked over to Star and felt her forehead. Star was grateful that her cheeks were already red. She didn't want Marco to notice that she was blushing. "You feel pretty warm. Do you want me to tell your parents?"

"No, they looked pretty tired. Do you really think everything will go back to normal?" Star reached out and hugged Marco. Marco smiled and returned the hug. He was glad that she was starting to feel comfortable around him again.

"Of course I do, Star. If we can't remind you, then we'll just have to recreate your entire life."

"Marco, you're crazy! But, thanks, it means a lot to me."

Without warning, the doors slammed open to reveal a floating unicorn head that was approaching at alarming speeds.

"Marco, B-fly, I came as quickly as I could. I had to clean my room and then I had to steal my father's dimensional scissors." Pony Head flew in between Star and Marco. "I'm sorry, was I interrupting something?"

"No! Look, we need to help Star. Stop trying to twist the situation." Pony Head moved directly in front of Star. Star stared back before raising a finger and poking the unicorn on the nose.

"What is going on with you? Are all unicorns like this, Marco?" Star turned away from Pony Head and looked at Marco.

"B-fly, you really don't remember me? I'm your best bestie! We spent most of our life together sneaking out to the Bounce Lounge. Then there was that time I went to St. O's."

"Sorry, I don't remember anything." Pony Head looked crestfallen. "If it makes you feel any better, I think your hair looks pretty cool."

"Aw, thank you, B-fly! Marco, what happened?"

"We're not sure, we just know it was a spell Star was working on with her mother."

"Whoa, you were spending time with your mother! Did something happen between you and her?"

"I don't know! Geez, when will people get that. If I could remember, I would." Star went back to fuming angrily about her situation.

"Marco, give Star a hug. She likes you so make her feel better." Marco hugged Star who had her arms crossed.

"Star, come on, we're only thinking of you."

"But nothing's working Marco. This is all just a waste of time. I want to remember just as much as anyone else, but it won't happen. What if I never get my memories back, what if I'm like this forever?" Star began to cry. She was helpless and finally gave up trying to remember. "Can I just go back to sleep? I don't feel good and I'm not hungry anymore."

"I guess, but I'm not giving up. What do you say Pony Head, will you stay up and help me think of something?"

"Of course, I'd do anything for Star. I just need be home before my parents wake up. I'm already grounded." Star left the room, leaving Marco and Pony Head to talk about everything they had already tried, and what their next step should be.

Star walked angrily back to her room. I wish I could remember, I really do! Even if it was just a handful, I'd be happy. Star slammed the door to her room and threw herself on her bed. She pressed her face into her pillow and cried. She was distraught and needed someone who understood the turmoil within her. Star decided to change into something comfortable being laying down. In the process, she came across a tiny book.

"What are you?" Star opened the book to find that it was her diary. Star decided that this would be the best thing to help her. Star read what she could understand, immersing herself in the days she had once lived in. So, I…do a lot of fighting with my mother. That's why Pony Head was so surprised. I'm glad I found my diary. Now I'll know how to act around everyone tomorrow.

Star went to put back her diary and noticed there was another notebook. Bringing it closer, she saw that it was a spell book made by her. I made a spell book? Oh, yeah, Dad said the other one had been gone for a long time. It only makes sense that I would make my own. Star opened the notebook and looked at all the spells she had created. Star pulled out what she could only assume to be the wand and practiced the patterns for the Narwhal Blast. When she felt she was comfortable with the motions, she tried out the spell.

"Narwhal Blast!" A light erupted from the wand and a series of narwhals appeared. The narwhals hit the wall and vanished into thin air. "Cool! Narwhal Blast. Narwhal Blast." Star continued to use the spell until she started yawning again. It's about time I went to bed. Star laid in bed and looked outside. She stared at the stars until her eyes finally closed.

Star sat on a balcony while a make shift battle waged on below. The scene blurred and revealed a smaller version of Pony Head with shades. The two where in a place filled with bright colorful lights and dancing people. Again, the scene blurred to reveal Marco kissing another girl with blonde hair. Star guessed this was the girl named Jackie. The last image to appear was a haunting image of monster made from green goop. The yellow eyes burned into Star's mind. Before she could react, one of the hands reached out and grabbed Star. Star screamed and fought back, but the goop swallowed her up. She couldn't breathe or scream. She thrashed around until she felt hands shaking her.

Her eyes snapped open to find Marco looking down at her. Star felt something wet on her face as she remembered where she was. Marco wiped away what turned out to be tears. Star sat up and hugged Marco, letting the tears flow from her nightmare.

"Star, were you having a nightmare?" Star nodded as she rested her head on his shoulder. "What was it about? You can tell me." Star moved back and wiped away her tears, outside the sun began to rise and brighten up the sky.

"I think I was remembering some stuff. But, the last one was this giant green monster made from this thick goop. It had yellow eyes, and then one of its hands grabbed me and pulled me into the goop. I couldn't breathe, I thought I was going to die." Marco pulled Star into another hug.

"Star, that last one was of Toffee. You told me that you drowned in the wand, inside of that goop. You…you relived dying." Star was shocked by this information.

"Do I always dream like that? Of Toffee?"

"Yeah, at least once a week. The first time, you caused your parents to take away your wand because you were saying spells in your sleep. Everyone was afraid the nightmares were going to have serious side effects. During the first week, you asked me to sleep with you so you weren't alone."

"So…this is normal? What about Jackie, won't she get mad if she finds out?" Star looked at Marco who looked down.

"I was going to tell you on the day you lost your memories, that me and Jackie broke up. She was angry when I first left to see if you were okay. When I went to tell her I was staying on Mewni with you, she decided it just wasn't going to work out. She told me we could still be friends, but she said I clearly liked you more than her. You didn't see it when I showed you my memories because I pulled you away before you could."

"Marco, you didn't have to leave her for me." Star laid a hand on his shoulder to reassure him.

"It's alright, it's way better here on Mewni. Besides, I really need to work out my feelings before anything else. Do you…want breakfast?" Star's stomach answered before she could. "I'll take that as a yes." Marco waited outside so Star could change, before the two left for breakfast.