Disclaimer: I do not own Pretty Little Liars
Author's note: Wow, thank you all for your kind words! I'm so glad you like it, so without further adieu, here's chapter 2! (lol, that rhymed)
Aria woke up and her head was pounding. She opened her eyes and they started to focus on her surroundings, which were unfamiliar to her. Suddenly she realized that she wasn't lying in her own bed. On top of that, she soon noticed that she was lying next to someone else, a man! Aria shot upright in bed, in complete shock, as she let out a shriek. She saw that the person next to her stirred a bit after she shrieked, but he remained asleep. Aria took a good look at him and noticed that it was someone she had gotten to know recently. "Oh my god, it's Ezra", she thought to herself.
Aria wondered what had happened last night. She couldn't remember what had happened after the whole Matt ordeal. She had gone to "The nine circles of hell" in order to get drunk and forget all about Matt. She remembered ordering shots of tequila and drinking them, but everything after that was all a blur. She narrowed her eyes at the person next to her as she thought, "Did this jerk take advantage of me while I was drunk? Did I sleep with him? Oh no…" The thought of him sleeping with her in her drunken state made her sick to her stomach, or maybe that was just the bad hangover.
Aria needed to know what had happened last night, so she decided she needed answers right now. In her upset state she wacked him hard with the back of her hand across his bare chest, in order to wake him up. Ezra jumped awake in surprise, and in pain, while yelling, "Ouch!" He looked at her quizzically, and wide-eyed he asked, "What the hell did you do that for?" Aria narrowed her eyes at him again and in an accusatory tone, she asked, "Why am I in your bed?"
Ezra smirked at her when she asked him that question. So she had no recollection of what had happened last night. His chest still hurt and because he wanted some payback for that, he decided to have a little fun with her. Ezra gave her a sly smile and stroked her arm with his index finger seductively, while suggestively saying, "Why do you think?"
Aria turned pale all of a sudden and she slapped away his hand. She opened her mouth to speak, but she couldn't find the words. Then she finally uttered the words, "So we…uhm…?", her eyes widening to emphasize what she wanted to say, but couldn't. With a smug look on his face, Ezra replied, "Oh yes, multiple times. You were quite the vixen." Suddenly Aria let out a cry in shock as she covered her open mouth with her hand. Aria just sat there like that, in shock and wide-eyed, internally freaking out for a while. She was beating herself mentally for losing her virginity to some guy she barely knew, when she was drunk no less. Not to mention the fact that she couldn't even remember any of it. Was it good? Probably, seeing as they did it multiple times. And he had told her she was quite the vixen, that was a compliment, right? Oh boy, what had she done?
Ezra was getting worried about Aria, seeing as she was sitting on the bed, not moving and not speaking. Apparently his joke wasn't so successful as she thought it would be. Ezra put his hand on her arm and asked, "Are you alright?" Clearly upset she replied, "No, I'm not. And get your hands off me!" Ezra looked a bit lost, feeling bad about joking about sleeping with her, but he obliged and took back his hand. Then he said, "Relax, it was just a joke." Aria turned all her attention on him and asked, "What was?" Ezra replied matter-of-factly, "We didn't have sex." Aria looked at him warily, not really knowing what to believe anymore. She asked, "We didn't? Then why on earth would you say that we did!" Ezra explained, "You slapped me, hard, I might add!"
Aria just sat there, trying to take this all in. So he had made it up, just because she had slapped him? What was he thinking? Looking at him unbelievably, she asked, "So you thought it would be funny to have me believe I slept with a complete stranger!" Ezra looked at her with a apologetic look on his face as he replied, "I did. I don't anymore though." Aria was really angry with Ezra for lying, so she told him in a fiery tone, "Well, probably because it's not funny!" Then she pushed him off the bed with all the might she could muster at the moment, the bed sheet going with him. Aria felt really cold all of a sudden and as she looked down at herself, she noticed she was in her underwear. Frantic about the realization of Ezra undressing her, Aria yelled, "WHY AM I IN MY UNDERWEAR!"
Ezra was shocked as he felt her push him off the bed. He felt against the laminate floor with a loud thud. He sat up, shook his head in disbelief at her and said, "You know, I really pity the guy that is going to be waking up next to you every day for the rest of your life." Demanding an answer from him, she repeated, "Why!" Trying to lighten the mood, Ezra pretended like her question was about his previous comment, "Because you're loud and quite obnoxious." Aria sighed, trying to suppress a smile, but she was failing at it. Faking exasperation, she tried to clarify, "I mean, why am I in my underwear?" Ezra replied very seriously, "Because I didn't think you would want to sleep in your clothes, it's not really comfortable." Then the expression on his face changed as he took a good look at her, "You look lovely in your lingerie by the way."
Aria gasped, gave him a mean look and said, "Pervert!" Then Aria leaned over to where he was sitting, said, "I'm cold" and pulled the sheet roughly off of him so she could cover up herself with them. It was then that she noticed that he was completely naked and he was sporting a morning erection. Aria's eyes widened in shock as she uttered the words, "Oh my god!", and then she turned her head to the other side and closed her eyes. Ezra chuckled and said, "Yeah, I sleep in the nude. And yes, oh my god is the correct response. I told you I wasn't compensating for anything else." Aria replied with just an "ugh!" in disgust and threw one of the pillows at him. He covered up his erection with it.
Ezra teased, "Oh come on! Why so shy all of a sudden? You were all over me last night. You were practically begging me to take you home with me." Aria looked at him with one eyebrow raised in disbelief and replied, "I sincerely doubt that. But if by any chance it is true…going off on the hangover I'm experiencing right now, I was pretty drunk. Which is by the way, the only moment I would ever consider sleeping with you." Acting fake hurt, Ezra said, "Ouch! You are seriously not a morning person. And this is the thanks I get for making sure you were okay? So you didn't wake up in some random guy's bed?"
Aria looked at him unbelievably and yelled, "I did wake up in some random guy's bed! And he's naked!" Ezra rolled his eyes and said, "Don't tell me you're one of those people who have a problem with nudity…" Aria shook her head and replied, "I don't . I just have a problem with your nudity at the moment." As she said this, she gestured with her hands towards his covered up penis. Ezra raised an eyebrow in amusement as he teased, "Why? Is it turning you on?" Aria let out an exasperated moan at his perversity. Ezra joked in response, "Oh…that's not the kind of moans I'm used to." Aria looked at him annoyed and asked, "Oh my god! Does everything that comes out of your mouth have to be related to sex?" Ezra grinned and replied with some questions of his own, "Why does that bother you? Am I getting to you? Am I making you all hot and bothered?"
Aria raised her chin, pretending to be unaffected, and claimed, "No, you're not. In fact, it's quite the opposite, you're putting me off." Ezra raised his eyebrows in surprise, he smelled a challenge. Ezra shrugged and asked her innocently, "Really now? So when I say: I'd love to watch you writhe beneath me as I lick every inch of your body, that does nothing to you? In fact, it's a huge turn-off?" Aria swallowed hard as she imagined Ezra doing exactly that to her body. Her gaze was getting heated and she looked away to the side to avoid his eyes. Why didn't that comment turn her off in the least? It was so wrong, she shouldn't be feeling this way. Ezra half smiled when he saw her reaction and smugly said, "Thought so." Ezra got up from the floor, then put on some boxers from his clothing drawer and said, "You can look now, I'm decent." Aria looked over at him, rolled her eyes and replied, "I would hardly call that decent." Ezra smirked and teased, "You're one to talk, you're in nothing but lingerie."
Aria narrowed her eyes as she was getting really annoyed with him, this guy knew how to push all of her buttons. She asked accusatorily, "And whose fault is that?" Ezra shrugged and replied, "Hey, if it were up to me, you wouldn't be wearing anything at all." Aria sighed in exasperation, rubbing her temples with her fingers. Because of that, she had let go of the sheet that was covering her and Ezra could see her perky breasts that were covered up by her red lace bra. Ezra groaned inwardly, his erection getting harder at the sight of her. Ezra looked really uncomfortable and suddenly said, "I'm sorry." Aria looked at him in confusion, why was he apologizing all of a sudden? Had he grown a conscience in the last couple of seconds? Ezra suggested, "You should probably get dressed now…you're actually making me all hot and bothered.
Aria could tell she was making Ezra uncomfortable in her underdressed state and it made her feel powerful. Wanting a little payback herself she thought, "Two can play that game." She looked in his eyes and in a too innocent sounding tone, she asked, "Should I?" She pushed the sheet aside to reveal her matching red lace panties and the rest of her body, laid down on the bed and said, "I was actually just getting comfortable." And then she stretched out, arching her back and letting out a moan of contentment as she closed her eyes. She couldn't see him, but she could hear him groan. Inside, she was smiling at herself, feeling victorious.
Suddenly she was surprised when she felt an extra weight on the bed and when she opened her eyes, she was shocked to see that Ezra was hovering over her. He raised an eyebrow at her playfully, but his eyes were alight with passion, "You're playing a very dangerous game, you know that?" Aria swallowed hard, feeling slightly intimated, but majorly turned on by his proximity and his playful threat. She didn't want him to notice, so she just shrugged innocently and asked, "Am I now?" Ezra smirked and replied, "Yes, you are. And you're a fool to think that you could beat me at it." Aria scoffed and said, "There's no way you'd ever win." Still smirking at her, he said, "Really now? Okay then…" And then he went to make his point, that she really couldn't beat him at his game.
Ezra bent down and started kissing all over her neck, which caused Aria to throw back her head to give him better access. She closed her eyes and moaned in pleasure. She could feel him smirking against her skin, but she didn't care, this was too good. He started moving his kissing south, down to her breasts and her breathing fastened as he released one of her breasts out of its cup and started tugging at her nipple and then he sucked it. He started massaging her other breast with one hand and started kneading at her hip with his other one. Aria moaned louder and Ezra released her other breast from its cup and licked and sucked at that nipple, now squeezing the breast he was just sucking seconds ago. He started kneading at the other side of her hips and Aria felt herself getting hotter and hotter by the second. She had gotten so wet in the meanwhile and she started feeling a certain pressure building in her lower abdomen. As it kept building and building, it made her breathing ragged and she was getting flustered. All of a sudden, Ezra blew some air against the nipple he had just sucked wet. It was so cold and because it took her completely by surprise, it tipped her over and she cried out in orgasm.
Her sudden orgasm had took them both by surprise. Ezra raised an eyebrow, feeling pretty good with himself, as he teased, "Did you just…?" Aria was still trying to catch her breath, coming down from her high. She was quite mad at her body for betraying her like this. He was the first man to have ever given her an orgasm, and even though it was the most amazing sensation she had ever felt, she was slightly embarrassed. Mad at herself, and him, she pushed him off of her, saying, "I have to go." Then she walked over to where her clothes and clutch were lying, picked them up and walked out of the room. As she made her way out of the room, she heard Ezra ask, clearly enjoying what had just happened, "What? No thank you?"
Aria walked down the hallway in her underwear until she noticed the bathroom and walked inside. She locked the door and then she leaned against it, slowly sliding down until she was sitting on the floor. She put her head in her hands and let out a big sigh. Why had she allowed him to touch her like that? She didn't even know him! Suddenly she heard a knock on the door and she heard Ezra ask, sounding genuinely worried, "Are you okay in there?" But Aria didn't answer him, because she was too disgusted with herself. She heard Ezra speak again, "Look…uhh…I'm sorry, what's your name?"
Aria let out a shriek in horror, what had she done? She had allowed a strange man to take her home, touch her like that in the morning and give her an orgasm….and he didn't even know her name…
Ezra wanted to beat himself over the head for what he had just asked, "I just made it worse, didn't I?" Aria yelled in response, "You think!" A few moments passed and then Ezra asked, "So?" Aria had no clue what he was talking about, so she asked in an annoyed tone, "So what?" Ezra realized he wasn't doing well here, so he replied really calmly and friendly, "What's your name?" Aria bit back, "What's it to you?"
Ezra didn't understand why she was so upset by it all, I mean, there was nothing wrong with what they did. Ezra jokingly said, "Because I like to know the names of all the women I have given orgasm to." Aria replied sardonically, "Why? So you can put it in your book on conquests? Would you like a picture to go with it too?" Ezra smirked at himself and said, "Well…if you're offering…There is one kind of picture in particular I wouldn't mind receiving from you." Aria narrowed her eyes at him, even though she knew he couldn't see it, and said, "You're lucky there's a door in between us." Ezra couldn't help chuckle at her threat, he teased, "Why? Want to kiss me?" Aria rolled her eyes and replied, "Less kissing and more strangling." Ezra shrugged and said in a playful tone, "That could work too, it sounds pretty kinky."
Aria let out a frustrated grunt and got up. She put on her clothes quickly and then went to look into the mirror. Her hair was a mess! She opened her clutch and got out the barrette. She fixed her hair the best she could and then put the barrette in again. When she had made herself look presentable, she unlocked the bathroom door and got out. When she came out, she saw that Ezra was leaning against the wall opposite the door. He was still only in his boxers, one knee bended so that the sole of his bare foot was against the wall. He had his arms crossed and he flashed her a pearly-white smile. Aria felt weak in the knees as he did that, he looked so good against that wall, it was like he was posing for some underwear add.
Aria didn't want him to know how attractive she thought he was, so she just decided to ignore him altogether. Ezra's smile faded when he noticed that Aria walked away from him, without saying a word or without giving him another look. She walked until she reached the living room and located the front door. In the meanwhile, Ezra had started following her with a confused look on his face. He asked her, "Where are you going?" Aria turned around, raised an eyebrow at him and replied, "Where do you think? I'm going home."
Ezra blinked a couple of times, not understanding why she wanted to leave. Ezra couldn't describe what he was feeling right now, he wanted her to stay, but he had no clue as to why. He looked confused and sad as he said, "Are you serious? Come on…stay…" He looked deep into her eyes as he said that last word and she felt a strong pull towards him, but there was no way she was going to let herself give in to it. She turned around and headed for the front door again, but Ezra went after her and grabbed her arm to stop her. He turned her around so she was facing him again and he pleaded, "Don't leave…"
Aria looked at him warily and then she snarkily said, "Why not? Do you feel like you have some unfinished business here? No woman is allowed to leave your apartment unless you've bedded them first?" Ezra explained, "For your information, you're the only woman who's ever even been to my apartment. Well, besides my mom and my housekeeper." Aria nodded her head, "You know? I actually believe you. I'm thinking you go with them to their place, right. Since it's much easier to get rid of them the next morning that day. You can just sneak out when you want to." Ezra looked annoyed and upset by her snarky, but accurate, comment. Aria sighed and said, "Goodbye Mr. Fitz."
Aria could hear the desperation in his voice as Ezra asked her, "At least tell me your name then?" Aria shook her head and replied, "I'll never tell you my name." Ezra urged her, "How about one final kiss then?" Aria looked at him quizzically and said, "Final kiss? I don't recall kissing you at all." Ezra nodded and said matter-of-factly, "Exactly. You didn't. Which is why you should." He took a step closer to her and the sexual tension was through the roof as they looked into each other's eyes. It was making her uncomfortable, she wanted to give in so bad, but she couldn't. She couldn't let him win. She leaned her head back and parted her lips slightly. Ezra took this as an invitation and he leaned forward to kiss her. Just before he could touch her lips, Aria whispered "No" against his lips and then she turned around and headed for the door. She opened the door, turned her head to face him and said, "Looks like I win after all." Then she walked out and closed the door behind her, leaving a baffled Ezra behind.
So that was it for chapter 2, hope you liked it! Review and let me know what you think! :)