Rachel POV
I fell asleep on Finn's shoulder on our way back to the auditorium. We just had the most amazing sex I don't know where he learned to do all that stuff but I'm not complaining. When we get back the auditorium everyone is sitting on the stage talking. Finn walks up on the stage and sits down with me in his lap. Then that's when I notice it.
"Where's Quinn" I ask
"Oh after you told her off, she went to go see her dad in California for the summer" Santana said
"Oh" I say
"Yeah it's a good thing that no one really cares, right guys?" Puck says everyone just nods there heads in agreement.
"Okay well girls are going to the Choir room, are you guys staying here?" Mercedes says. All the guys shake there head in agreement.
" Come on Rachel" Kurt says jumping up and grabbing my hand. I look down and Finn and back up at Kurt. I grab his hand and I am actually able to stand up. That's a relief. I hear Noah saying something to Finn about "getting it in" and I just roll my eyes and laugh as I walk with Kurt to the choir room.
" Okay spill Berry!" Santana says
" What is she spilling?" Britt asks. I just shake my head
" Spill what?" I ask half laughing
" What was your first time like! We all know you guys were out doing the dirty, if you guys were just making out he wouldn't have carried you into the auditorium and you wouldn't be so tired" Mercedes says
" As much as it grosses me out that Finn's my brother and you're my best friend, I WANT TO KNOW WHERE, WHEN AND WHAT IT WAS LIKE!" Kurt practically yells.
"Okay fine ill tell you, pull up a chair boys and girls" I say grabbing one myself. Everyone is waiting for me to tell the story and I love telling it its so sweet and romantic.
" Okay so it happened after the last football game of the year, we got back together the day before in the library. As you all know after he scored the winning touch down he dragged me into the middle of the field and kissed me and I mean really kissed me in front of the whole school. After the game we went back to his house and started making out a little bit after he showered and did some things in his room. He came back downstairs and we started making out again but it got a little more heated this time and clothing was being shed very fast. I was prepared for this to happen so I'm on the pill but he was so gentile and caring and never pressured me to go any further then I wanted to so I new it was time."
" I'm ready Finn" I say and he looks me straight in the eye.
" are you sure Rach I'm fine just like this, we don't have to do anything you don't want to" he says smiling
" I'm sure" he picks me up carrying me to his room and kissing my neck as he does. He sets me down and tells me to close my eyes. I walk in and open his room looks amazing he had candles lit and rose peddles spread out across his bed and floor.
" Finn when did you do all this" I ask in awe
"I kinda was hoping tonight would be the night so I put all of this together before." he says smiling and looking down at the floor.
" its perfect" I say bringing him to look me in the eye. We start making out again and move onto the bed. He's very careful not to crush me. He takes of his shirt and my shirt and unhooks my bra. He kisses me hard on the mouth and them moves to my neck leaving a nice bruise and then peppering light kisses along my jaw line and down to my breasts. He takes my breast into his mouth and starts licking it and nipping at it lightly and then he gives the same attention to the other one. He does soft kisses all the way down to the waist band of my skirt and looks up at me for permission to continue. He pulls down my skirt kissing the skin that is revealed. After he removes my skirt he removes his jeans so were both left in just our underwear. He looks at me and I nod my head for him to remove my panties and he does. He sees me completely naked for the time and looks at me to absorb it all in. He takes off his boxers and his erection springs free. My eyes widen at the sight thinking "that has to go in me". He looks at me again and says
" Baby are you sure you want to do this we can stop if you want to"
"No I want to do this I love you and I'm ready"
" I love you to baby, but this might hurt, If I'm hurting you just tell me to stop" with that he kisses me and enters me. He stops letting me adjust to his size then continues on. He sees a tear start to form and gets upset but I encourage him to go on because I know that the pain will only turn into pleasure. It doesn't last very long because the feeling of being complete makes me loose it and my walls flutter around him and he explodes inside me as we both ride out our orgasms. He kisses me sweetly for a few moments still inside me as I play with the hair on the back of his neck. He slides out of me and laces our fingers together and we cuddle for a while until we eventually fall asleep.
" Aww" I hear everyone say
" yeah it was amazing and he was so sweet" I say
" Wow he wasn't that nice when I slept with him" Santana says
" Really San really?" I say
" Oh right sorry Rachel" she says but it doesn't bother me anymore because I know when he did it with Santana it didn't mean anything. We all start talking and hear the guys walk in.
" Hey baby" Finn says kissing me eagerly and leaving me breathless
" Well hello to you too" I say in a whisper tone
" Okay Finchel enough, we just got your first time story we don't need to see the thousandth time happening in front of us" Santana says. Finn and I start laughing and sit down me on his lap. When Noah walks in with beer and wine coolers/
" Who's ready to get this party started!" He yells and everyone cheers, I just stare up at Finn smiling, lucky that I have the most amazing guy in the world as my boyfriend. He looks back down at me and smiles. Yeah Finchel's going strong.