AN: Second story that follows the alternate universe where Tyler Caroline got together in season one after Haunted. I own nothing it belongs to CW, L.J. Smith and the writers the show. Hope you enjoy. Thanks for reviews. This second story in secret love series only has one chapter.
Secret Love
Story Two
Caroline was lying on the back of Matt's truck, but Tyler had borrowed it for the day. He hadn't said why to Matt just that he sorta needed to borrow it. They had traded vehicles till tomorrow and Caroline was glad. If she could have she would begged Matt. However, they were still a secret, the way they liked it. He could be his real self around her, and that she liked. The Tyler that actually was honest, and didn't have to be trying get in her pants every two seconds.
It was the first warm day in ages, odd for Mystic Falls in the middle of November, but it was warm. It was Friday afternoon they'd gotten lucky school was closed today. It was some kind teacher's work day or in-service. They were parked in the woods on top the hill near the falls. The sun was out and they had brought cover in case it got cold. She looked up at the sky glad that she was here.
They both were avoiding their parents, his mom wasn't so bad, and she was usually drinking something. She would never get how the Mayor could be a hypocrite. He didn't say nothing about his wife's drinking, but catch Tyler and it was hell. The bastard drank too, he hid the flasks all over but he couldn't hide anything from his son.
She didn't think her mom ever noticed if she was drinking, hell she'd been drunk plenty times. Her mom had never been home to notice it though. Bonnie or Elena had been helping her sneak past. Then there was last week Tyler had been saving her from that guy who was just little to grabby. She'd convinced Tyler not to pick fight but they had left. She had got between the guy and Tyler before he could take the swing. She didn't need a reason for the cops to show up there.
"Did your dad say if he was coming home to visit?" Tyler asked.
"Nope," Caroline said. She just wanted to spend time with her dad. She didn't think it would kill him to come and visit for thanksgiving the following week. She felt Tyler's arm around her waist tighten like he knew what she'd wanted. "I got you though, so I got nothing to worry about really," she said giving him a kiss before she jumped up getting off the back of the truck.
"Hey now," Tyler said, he should known he'd have to chase her at some point, but he liked chasing her. Caroline was laughing standing behind one of the trees wondering if he was going to find her. She didn't have to wait long though because when she turned to look to see if he was coming she felt him pulling her into his arms. "You are mine, now, what should I do to you?" he was grinning.
"I think this tree seems nice and strong," Caroline said with smile. He shook his head walking back to the truck. He'd had a reason for borrowing the truck, and sure he might have a random girl against a tree, but not Caroline. She actually meant something to him, more than the ones in the past. It freaked him out that she meant more than most. He would have taken her against the tree few months ago, but not now.
Okay so this had never been on his plans when he'd started the school year. It was farthest thing from his mind, but right now he only saw one thing, scratch that one person, Caroline Forbes. She could drive him insane some days, but the girl had a heart. It was just hiding behind the walls she had, the ones she put up to keep from getting hurt, but unlike his she still showed when she was hurt. That was the last thing from his mind right now. He wanted for some reason make her feel happy, he was happy with her and that freaked him out.
"Tyler, are you going to watch me or are we going do something here?" Caroline asked. He was watching her and not that she didn't want it, but it was starting to get little uncomfortable. Her answer was in form of a kiss instead of words.
Caroline was looking up at him they were under the covers now. Her clothes were somewhere on the back the truck, his too. The sounds from the radio they'd brought playing a CD that she loved. She wasn't sure what was going on at first, but then she'd gotten it. The entire time they'd been together they hadn't done this. They'd had sex on every surface that she could think of even in the locker room just last week, but this was new.
She moved her legs up bending them at the knees so that he was between her legs. She whimpered when he started moving in and out. It was slow, but she wasn't going to say nothing. She was warm with a blanket below her, and he was covering her body, another blanket over him. She remembered weeks ago he'd told her he'd never made love to a girl. It had always been sex then leaving or lay, but not cuddling. This was new and she was touched because she hadn't expected this from him.
She started kissing him again wrapping her arms around his neck; this was why he'd brought her here. They'd stayed there all day just lying around talking listening to music having fun. She caught a glimpse of the setting sun behind her and her heart was doing the whole skipping beats butterflies in stomach thing.
Caroline arched up meeting him with every thrust; it wasn't going to end like most times when they got together. He wasn't budging when she tried to go faster. Caroline wrapped her legs around his back bringing him deeper inside. She heard him let out a hiss when she squeezed her walls around him. She couldn't exactly hurt him though.
He was rocking with her and she felt the build up in her stomach getting stronger and stronger till it finally sent her over. She felt her head hit the truck, but it didn't hurt, because she was in too much pleasure to feel any kind of pain. He finally started moving fast and she was holding onto him. "Tyler," she cried out feeling him fill her up as he came, which sent her into another mind blowing orgasm.
Before she fell asleep snuggled up against him after coming down from their high she risked it. "You don't have to feel the same way, you don't have say it back, but I'm in love with you," there it was out, she'd said it. Caroline didn't know why she'd said it, she swore she never would. She could already hear the other side her conscience, he's going break your heart. She'd wait for him to say it though, it was Tyler after all. She knew he could be a good guy. If she waited long enough he'd prove everybody else wrong and her right.
Caroline woke up feeling her cell phone vibrating against her. She groaned at the noise snuggling up against Tyler ignoring the phone. They hadn't gone home last night it dawned on her and that meant her mom was probably freaking out. She reached over grabbing it at least to stop the goon squad of deputies to come after her. She wasn't lost or hurt, she felt pretty good right now.
She thought about the different positions she'd convinced him to try. Caroline wasn't going to be telling anybody. She had finally convinced him after winning a bet of who would cum first, that sex against a tree was hot. She was pretty sure that he was thinking the same thing after last night. She knew that fantasy that was in his mind.
They had both gotten drunk after they'd been rejected that night at the back to school night at the falls. Stefan rejected her for Elena; Vicky had shoved him away for Jeremy. They'd never had sex then, but they sure had gotten drunk. Now he was hers though because Vicky was no where around, and if she was then it wouldn't matter because Tyler chose her.
The name on the phone however said Matt. What the hell was he calling her for? Caroline hit the talk button before she could notice it was Tyler's phone, "Matt, why are you calling me, it's Saturday, you sleep in on Saturday's," she grumbled. It was almost ten by Tyler's watch but still, she needed more sleep. Her body was sore from the countless rounds they had gone after the first time of the night.
"Caroline?" Matt asked, "What are you doing answering Tyler's phone?" he'd supposed to have met his best friend at the Grill half an hour ago to switch vehicles back.
Caroline started rambling about mistakenly grabbing Tyler's phone at the Grill. She wasn't sure this was best way for people start finding out. She wasn't sure if he was buying it but when he said yeah okay she let out a sigh hanging up. "We're so busted," Tyler laughed beside her because he was holding her phone. The phone that was now saying Matt on the caller id.
"No, you say that you didn't know you had my phone okay," Caroline said pulling the covers over her head moving down leaving trail of kisses. She smiled as Tyler talked to Matt. He really could lie when he had to. The line about grabbing the wrong phone really did work even though theirs weren't even similar.
She was going get him back for early this morning, she'd still had another round in her, but he'd passed out. She couldn't see his face, but she was sure by the strangled sound he'd made it was hard to talk on phone. She sucked on just the head his already hard cock making him ramble something she didn't even understand besides one o'clock and the Grill before he hung up.
She kept sucking and humming around him till he was filling her mouth. He'd tried to get to her but she'd just pushed him back down running her nails down his abs. It worked like a charm every time she did that. "Next time I'll just have to check see if its mine or yours," She said kissing him before she sank down on him.
"Next time don't answer the phone," was his reply holding her by the hips helping her move. He didn't want to go anywhere, hell he didn't want go back to their lives. Here they could be themselves, the real them. The ones the world never would get to see. It was what they wanted to hide away. They had their labels so why make people think differently.
Caroline knew they had to go back to town, but right now she'd just stay close to him and keep kissing him. It couldn't hurt to just keep laying here kissing him working their way to another orgasm. Her body was still sated from last night and the early morning that she couldn't move anymore. She wanted another hour sleep, but reality was waiting.
Tyler flipped them over finishing what she'd started taking them into another orgasm. She could get used to this even more than she already was. She would just have to cover up the hickey's he'd left on her. Her friends might start thinking Damon, but it wasn't as bad as the one's he'd left on her. He could never hurt her. Even if her subconscious told her to sometimes run, she'd already given her heart over to Tyler.
Caroline walked into the Grill that afternoon noticing that it was a slow day. She got one the back booths hiding away from the world far as she could in there. There was few people playing pool and she saw that both Salvatore brothers were there, Bonnie too, but she was talking to Elena. She was sure when they noticed her that they'd be over here. Bonnie and Elena at least she'd been gone all day Friday and half the day today.
She was texting not noticing anybody coming in and out of the Grill when she felt somebody behind her. Her phone vibrated with message on it, "don't turn around, thought tell you that I rather be there still" she smiled at the text before giving a reply "rather be there too, wish nobody was here"
She really wanted him beside her, but it wasn't going to happen. It was the deal, however she wanted to change that deal now. She wanted to do the whole public couple thing, but it could wait she thought. She loved the secret looks they could give each other. The text message and notes they left each other. She loved the way he could talk to her and make her feel so alive.
"You want anything to eat?" Matt asked. She'd almost forgotten he was working there now. She was starving actually ordering a plate of cheese fries and bowl of soup. She didn't get to eat breakfast since she'd been too busy wanting to get few last minute kisses in before they had to split up. She added coffee to her order before she watched Matt leave.
Caroline was waiting for a reply but instead of a text message she found a napkin in her lap. She smiled when Tyler sat down across from her. "I ordered up there," he said nodding towards the bar. Caroline grinned but tried to not show it too much. She read the napkin that he'd put there and smiled at what it said. She'd keep it with the rest the notes she had in a box from him.
"What's up with this picture?" Bonnie asked looking at Elena then over to where Caroline was sitting.
"I don't know, maybe he just wanted to sit down, I mean they are friends, we all are Bonnie," Elena reminded her, because it was true even if Tyler could be a dick she remembered him before they hit high school.
If he was dating Caroline it wasn't her place to say they shouldn't. Caroline seemed happy and she actually saw a smile on Tyler's face a lot lately. She of all people knew the secrets that he hid away from the outside world. She still remembered the party he'd got so drunk he'd let some stuff slip out. Caroline had been there too when it had slipped out his mouth.
"Elena did you hear what I said?" Bonnie asked.
"Sorry what did you say?" Elena asked smile still on her face wishing high school hadn't changed them.
"I asked, do you think they are going out?" Bonnie asked again looking over to where Caroline and Tyler were. "It's something there," she added.
Elena wasn't sure but long as he wasn't being a dick to her, she would stay out of it. Caroline was sometimes annoying but she didn't want her getting hurt. She knew why Tyler acted like a dick, Caroline and her both did. She still wanted to throttle him for beating Jeremy up, but she always felt bad for him too. "Long he doesn't go all Damon with her then I think we should leave it alone," Elena finally replied.
She remembered last spring too, when he'd stayed in the hospital with her till she could get out of there after her parents died. Tyler had been there when they'd brought her in. He hadn't left till he'd known she was okay. It was far between and in small bursts but that Tyler was still under all of the I-really-don't-caries. He'd actually made her laugh when she'd been crying for so long.
Ever since her parents died it seemed like he had changed, then again maybe it was her. She used to party with him and get just as wasted. She still thought he in some odd way blamed himself for the crash. It was at his party she'd got stranded at; her parents came to take her home. It was the last time they had been alive.
Bonnie wasn't so sure about it though, she looked back over again but let it go, "Fine, but he hurts her then I'll think of something," she said. She was new to the witch part of her, but she might could find something to do to him. Caroline was her best friend like Elena was. It had been the three of them growing up together, along with Matt and Tyler.
Caroline was walking out of the Grill, Tyler had left few minutes earlier and was meeting her at her car. It was parked on the other side of the road and he was standing beside it leaning against the side the car. She got to him and was surprised when he pulled her in kissing her. It was out in the open, anybody could see them, but he was doing this.
She felt his hand slip under her shirt pulling her closer. It was colder than yesterday, but he was still warm even in the cold. She continued kissing him knowing this could be seen by their friends. He had her against the car where she couldn't move and she loved it. She felt how hard he was against his jeans as he stood against her.
"Tyler," she moaned out as he started kissing her neck. She whimpered feeling him move closer as he could be inside of her with their clothes still on. She was grinding back against him not missing a beat. He kept her body blocked from the view of the Grill knowing that Elena and Bonnie had been sitting at the window seat. Caroline realized what he was doing and it turned her on. She brought her arms up around his neck holding him close before she kissed him again.
Caroline whimpered his hand had slipped inside of her skirt. She was thankful that there were no cars going by right now. She gasped as he started stroking her clit, she couldn't believe he was doing this right here. However, she felt a rush going inside of her as she saw past her looking at the Grill. She saw Elena and Bonnie coming out with Stefan. If they spotted them and came over would Tyler have enough time to move? Would they guess what was going on?
His lips against her neck again had her holding him as he continued stroking her clit making her buck against him. She bit the side of his neck to stop from crying out as she felt her orgasm rip though her. Her legs were shaking as he thrust his fingers inside of her opening making her almost pass out as another orgasm went through her. She couldn't stand up any more. Her entire body went slack against him.
She couldn't think about what they'd just done all she thought about was how good she felt. The tension that had been there was gone from her. If anybody had seen they were saying nothing and she didn't see a cop car around. Nobody had called the cops on them for what they'd been doing.
"I told you I was going make you cum," he grinned against her lips kissing her. She thought back to the note. She'd waited in the Grill for him to do something to make her cum. It had never happened until now. She was a risk taker and she defiantly took one with him.
"Safe for another day," she muttered before she got in her car him in the passenger seat.
Tyler grinned; he wouldn't have carried if they'd gotten caught. Then again it depended on who was doing the catching. He hadn't done it for a show if their friends saw them. He'd done it for her; she'd looked tense ever since Bonnie had asked her inside if they were together. She'd left it with a maybe and he knew it wouldn't be long before she told Elena or Bonnie. Then again Caroline could keep a secret; they'd been going out since Halloween.
It was a week from Thanksgiving now and he didn't want think about how he was going make it through that holiday without her. He knew she wanted to go see her dad, but he secretly wanted her to stay. It wasn't fair to ask that so he didn't. He just kept quiet as they drove towards his house. His parents were gone the rest the weekend.
The End Story Two
AN: This was story two of the secret love series I got going. Hope you enjoyed. This chapter is complete. Next one I post will be stand alone just in this universe.