AN: I have always thought they would be a good couple. I wrote this and I hope that you all will enjoy it! Please don't steal my idea for the story. Please review and let me know what you think! (:

Forbidden Souls

Chapter 1: What A Beautiful Mess I've Made

Quinn Fabray flipped her hair off of her shoulder as she walked down the hallway. Normally, she loved the fact that everyone was staring at her, but not this time. She averted her eyes to the floor and walked straight to her locker.

In one month, she had lost her spot on the Cheerios, became just another Glee reject, everyone hated her, and she had the darkest secret.

She grabbed her history book and slammed her locker shut. Everyone eyed her as she walked past. She tried to keep her head up, but she didn't have the strength. Finn approached her with a smile on his face.

"Hey, babe!" he greeted. Finn wrapped his arm around her waist, comforting her.

Quinn forced a smile on her face, "Hey…"

He raised a brow, "What's wrong?"

She shook her head. What wasn't wrong with her life? "Everyone is staring at me wondering how I let this happen to myself…"

Finn placed a hand on her tiny, bulging stomach, "We created a baby, Quinn. Things like this happen all the time. I mean, what's that show you are obsessed with—"

"Teen Mom."

"Yeah, that's the one. People are just jealous that I am the star quarterback, and you are the head cheerleader—"

"Was the head cheerleader."

"Regardless," Finn took her hands into his. "Look Quinn, I know that this wasn't planned, but I am going to step up for our baby."

Her stomach flopped. This was killing her. She wanted to wake up from this horrible nightmare, but she couldn't escape reality.

Finn gently raised her chin until she made eye contact with him, "You are perfect. Don't let other people get you down."

"Thanks," she said as she wiped a tear from her eye. "I'm going to class."

Her heart was racing and her palms were sweaty. She had been standing at his door for ten minutes now, trying to knock.

FLASHBACK

"What are you doing here?"

"I wanted to talk to you about Glee club…" Quinn said startled.

Will Shuester took off his jacket and placed it on the coat rack. He ran his fingers through his curly brown hair. He caught Quinn staring. She turned her head and blushed.

He took a seat next to her, "Did Terri let you in?"

She nodded, "Yeah, she is going to help her sister with the kids, or something like that. I wasn't really paying attention."

"What can I do for you?"

Quinn sighed, this hadn't been an easy decision, "I have to quit Glee club."

Will instantly knew that Sue was behind this. She never liked the Glee club and was itching at the seams to tear them apart. He placed a hand on her shoulder. Quinn looked up at him. She felt the warmth in his touch.

"Are you sure that's what you want to do?"

"I…I have to…" she trailed off.

He shook his head, "Look, Quinn, you are an amazing singer. Why would you want to give up on your talent?"

Quinn gave him a small smile, "Sue told me that I couldn't be in that club." She stood up and tried not to look into his eyes. "Everyone thinks that we are losers. I am the mot popular girl in school and this club is killing my status. Sue says that I am going to be seen as a reject if I keep it up…and off the team."

He exhaled and gently pulled her until she was sitting next to him, "You are beautiful and talented, Quinn. Glee club isn't going to change that about you."

Her eyes locked on his. "Thanks—"

"I don't think that you should quit. Sue isn't going to lose her best Cheerio. She is crazy, but not that crazy." He placed a hand on her knee. Wiping away a tear, "Don't give up on your voice, or yourself."

"Thanks, Mr. Shue," she whispered.

"If people say that you are a loser, so be it," he cupped her face with his hands. "You are still beautiful and have one of the best voices in Glee."

They gazed into each other's eyes. She felt the warmth of his breath against her face. inches from each other's face, their lips somehow collided.

Quinn felt something inside her electrify. His hands wrapped around her and gently pushed her down on the couch. She pulled him closer to her. Almost on instinct, she started to unbutton his shirt.

He stopped kissing her and looked into her eyes. He knew this was wrong, but he didn't want to stop. It felt right. He gazed into her hazel eyes which were now a shade of green.

Their lips collided once more and the connection was still there. She pulled off his shirt and began to kiss his neck. He let out a soft moan. It seemed like a blink and their bodies were being intertwined.

She took a deep breath as he entered her.

"Quinn?"

Quinn shook her head and looked at Will. He stood in the doorway just staring at her. She gulped, "Is Terri here?"

He shook his head and raised a brow, "No, why?"

"Can I come in?"

He pushed open the door. Quinn took a seat on the couch that she knew all too well.

Sensing something was wrong; he decided to break the silence, "What's going on?"

Quinn looked at him, and then the floor, "I'm pregnant."

"I know, with Finn's baby," he said in a matter-of-fact tone.

She shook her head, "No…it's yours…"

He froze. He tried to think of something to say, anything to say. "What?"

"I only told Finn that because how can I explain that you are the dad?" she asked as she began to breakdown in tears.

"What have we done…"

AN: Review and let me know if I should continue!