A/N: Hello, All! Wow, it's been 7 months since I last updated this story. It wasn't until yesterday that I was going through my computer and found the Sebastian Untold Story files. I re-read the first 5 chapters and remembered how fun it was writing them, so I thought I might continue them. Glee is way past season 3, so this story might no longer be relevant, but I'm still interested in writing it. I had a lot of interesting plot points and characters that I never got to include in the first 5 chapters, so this is my chance to bring them up! So here we go!
Also this chapter is basically what happens in the beginning of episode 5 of season 3 and the rest of the episode plays out in the next couple of chapters. So yeah, I don't own Glee nor the songs. And I hope yall are as excited to keep reading as I am to keep writing!
The Warblers had been working tirelessly in the following weeks on their two performance pieces. They decided on a Marianas Trench song for their high-energy number and were doing everything they could to find out more about the other teams. "Uptown Girl" was the first to be arranged and, after little debate, the seniors decided that Nick would be the lead. They also, however, rewarded Thad and Sebastian for their contribution to the performance and gave them both a couple of solo lines.
In one of their afterschool rehearsals, the guys prepared to do a full run of the back up performance. The Warblers were spread around the room and snapped along to John's beats. Sebastian sat on the back of the couch and joined in happily. On Thad's counts, they came in together with a series of harmonized oh's. Nick, Jeff and David positioned themselves at the entryway of the room and began the simple choreography as Nick sang the opening lines:
Uptown girl
She's been living in her white bread world
Jeff and David danced out of the small formation and were replaced by John and Trent. The two seamlessly transitioned into the spots and continued the choreography. Sebastian smiled. Even with a couple counts of rippled step-slides, the group was looking a lot better. But then...gray striped cardigan, bowtie and gelled hair….Blaine Anderson?
As long as anyone with hot blood can
And now she's looking for a downtown man
That's what I am
Sebastian slowly rose from his position on the couch not taking his eyes off of the unseen visitor.
That *has* to be him, he thought walking towards the shorter boy. Wow, Trent wasn't joking. He moved even closer to him. Blaine was leaning in the doorframe smiling proudly at the guys, also unaware of Sebastian's gaze.
And when she knows what she wants from her ti-i-ime
Nick danced around the room…
And when she wakes up and makes up her mi-i-ind
He sang as the other Warblers gathered at the front. Everyone was still somehow oblivious to Blaine's presence, but Sebastian wanted to make them well aware. Sebastian sang his line just as he and Blaine made eye contact.
She'll see I'm not so tough…
Just because I'm in love with an uptown girl
Sebastian grinned, grabbing Blaine's hand and excitedly pulling him into the formation. The guys finally saw him and, with surprised looks, cheered, sang and danced even more, laughing as Blaine joined in their formation and effortlessly blended in with their dancing. His kicks and spins were timely perfectly with the group. Sebastian was both excited and confused.
How the hell is he doing the choreography so perfectly? Wow, he *is* good, Sebastian smiled as he stepped back and did the slow turn with the rest of the group.
Uptown girl
You know I can't afford to buy her pearls
After completing the turn, the boys came to face none other than Ms. Olivia in the doorway. She was on her way to an after-school French tutoring session and heard the Warblers singing a little too loudly from the Commons. She was attempting to quiet them, knowing that they already weren't in good favor with the administration, yet Nick did nothing but grin at her.
But maybe someday when my ship comes in
Nick jogged towards her and signaled the Warblers to follow.
She'll understand what kind of guy I've been
And then I'll win
Nick turned towards her, excited for his chance to impress his longtime crush. The Warblers and Blaine were lined down the hall stepping and snapping excitedly in sync.
And when she's walking
She's looking so fine
Sebastian hopped out of formation and circled around her, mocking Nick's flirtatious singing.
And when she's talking
She'll say that she's mine
Ms. Olivia couldn't help but shake her head in amusement. Thad also stepped in for his solo, eager for his own chance to impress the young teacher. He sang, flexed, and circled her with a flirtatious grin.
She'll say I'm not so tough
Just because I'm in love with an uptown girl
Ms. Olivia was done with the borderline inappropriate attention. She tried to regain some composure and ushered the boys back into the Commons.
She's been living in her white bread world
Nick still sang to her. She lightly pushed Jeff and aimed a playful glare at John.
As long as anyone with hot blood can
Thad attempted to catch her attention one more time by singing his last line and popping his collar as coolly as he could.
And now she's looking for a downtown man
But Nick got the last word. He sang…
That's what I am
…giving Madelle Olivia one final seductive smile. He then ran to join the group in their circle of claps and oh's. Sebastian had found his way to the middle of the circle.
Sorry, Madelle Olivia. I've got my eye on someone else, Sebastian thought as he jumped into a double spin and launched himself expertly from the ground all without breaking eye contact with the ex-Warbler. A few other Warblers jumped into the center, displaying their own dance abilities (except John who just broke out into The Robot). The boys ran back into their original formation, ready to perform Sebastian's final choreography. Sebastian, however, didn't even care about the choreo anymore. His eyes were still fixed on the cute guy in the gray cardigan clapping along to the beat. Sebastian sang with a smirk, his mind already planning.
Uptown girl
She's my uptown girl
You know I'm in love
With an uptown girl
My uptown gir-r-l
Do you know I'm in love
Nick walked up, proudly crooning his last line.
With an uptown girl…
Blaine clapped enthusiastically and walked up to hug Nick.
"You guys killed it as always!" he said to the beaming group of boys.
Trent pushed his way towards Blaine, "We'd sound so much better with you back in the mix. Is this your triumphant return to Dalton?" he responded, as casually as he could. "Please?" he begged. John smirked at Trent's pleading. It was obvious his old feelings for Blaine still remained. But the rest of the guys still turned to Blaine expectantly.
"Actually I'm here to invite you guys to my opening night at McKinley. West Side Story," he announced pulling out a stack of tickets. "I reserved a whole block of tickets just for the Warblers." Trent's hand immediately reached for the tickets. "It would mean the world to me if you guys could come," Blaine said, handing the tickets to a smiling Trent.
"We'll be there," Sebastian said suddenly. "Once a Warbler, always a Warbler, right?" he said staring right into the eyes of the old lead and his new interest. Blaine returned the glance with a confused smile.
"Yeah!" all the guys agreed patting Blaine on the back, breaking him out of the slight trance Sebastian's stare held him in. The Warblers began to head towards the door. Rehearsal was over and most of the guys had other practices and meetings to go to. Sebastian, however, didn't move.
"Blaine Anderson, Sebastian Smythe," he introduced himself grabbing Blaine's hand.
"Hi," Blaine smiled, regaining his composure. "Are you a freshman?" he asked innocently. Sebastian was taken aback and his smile quickly faded.
"Do I look like a freshman?" he responded with a raised eyebrow.
"Uh?" Blaine looked down and laughed nervously. "I'm sorry. I didn't— " Sebastian decided to forgive the insult.
"I'm just kidding. But no, I'm a junior."
"Oh, so transfer student then?"
"Exactly."
"So how are you liking Dalton?"
"You wanna grab a coffee? I haven't had my daily dose yet," Sebastian interrupted, still smiling.
"Umm, sure," Blaine responded hesitantly. Blaine wasn't sure why, but this new Warbler made him feel a bit uneasy.
"Excellent," Sebastian smirked.
Sebastian jogged into lacrosse practice 20 minutes late, but his conversation with Blaine was worth it:
So you're a legend at Dalton…Don't be modest. I was like, I don't know who this Blaine guy is but apparently he's sex on a stick and sings like a dream. So sucks that I missed him…Alright, since I'm working to recreate your meteoric ascent, I need to ask. Why did you leave Dalton? Were you bored with all the preppies around here? Or is it that you broke too many hearts to stay?...I have to go. Lacrosse practice. But could we meet again? I could really use some more insights from you Blaine. You know, Warbler to Warbler…
"Smythe!" he heard an angry voice call. The coach was furious and was charging up to him when Joe jumped in the way.
"I'm so sorry, Coach. I forgot to tell you Sebastian had a dentist appointment," Joe turned to Sebastian with a stern look. "He would've made it on time, but the dentist took longer than expected. I just forgot to tell you. Sorry, Coach."
"Fine," the coach calmed down. "Well hurry up and join the others on offensive drills."
"Yes sir," Joe said grabbing Sebastian's arm roughly and pulling him towards the rest of the team. "That's the last time I cover for your ass," Joe said as Sebastian jerked his arm away. Joe, frowning, shook his head and jogged towards the team, bumping Sebastian's shoulder as he went past him.
"What the hell are you guys looking at? Offensive drills! Come on!" Joe shouted at the players watching his and Sebastian's interaction. They rolled their eyes at Joe's yelling and continued passing the ball. Sebastian joined them, but his mind was too preoccupied to even care about practice or Joe's temper.
Blaine Anderson has accepted your friend request.
Sebastian smiled at the notification. He clicked Blaine's name in the sidebar and started to chat him:
Sebastian
Hey ;)
Blaine
Hi, Sebastian.
Sebastian
I'm glad we got to talk today. Still freaking out that I got to meet The Blaine Anderson. Damn, should've asked for your autograph.
Blaine
Haha. Oh, stop.
Sebastian
Maybe I can get another chance to. We should definitely meet again soon. Any ideas?
Blaine
Well there's this coffee house I always go to called the Lima Bean, but it's a little far from Westerville.
Sebastian
Perfect. How does 5 pm sound?
Blaine
Uh, sounds great!
Sebastian
Great.
Sebastian sat back in his chair. "Blaine Anderson, you don't know what you've gotten yourself into," he smiled, logging out of Facebook and opening another tab.
GOOGLE: "gay bars near Westerville, Ohio"