"WAIT!" Prinsessrock shouted as she ran down to the Ski Village, Eva and their puffles by her side.

They were accompanied by Lennyice, Tweakbunny, Kwazii, Peso, Shellington, Tweak, and Tunip the Vegimal.

Herbert mumbled something to Klutzy, who then jumped on Barnacles head in reply.

"Ah here come my fellow Octonauts now." Herbert smiled, even though he felt rather shocked that the agents had escaped.

"Look it's Klutzy. That must be Herbert!" Rookie gasped.

"No I'm Captain Barnacles, I keep telling you." Barnacles turned to his friends while trying to shake Klutzy off his head.

"No I'm Barnacles!" Herbert growled back,

"But I am!"

"No I am!"

"I am!"

"No I AM!"

"And I'm Kwazii!" Kwazii yelled as he pounced on Captain Barnacles, "Ya scurvy Herbert!"

"Kwazii what are you doing?" Barnacles gasped, as Kluzty fell off and ran to the sea,

"Kwazii wait we don't know who's the real Captain Barnacles yet!" Lennyice exclaimed.

"Good to see you agents, I was getting a bit worried, why are you late? And I'm guessing your friends are the Octonauts?" Gary asked as Kwazii jumped back to the Octonauts.

"Yes that's right G." Eva began, "But the reason why we're late is because Herbert captured Peso, and then us when we tried to rescue him. Captain Barnacles Bear and Kwazii Cat came to the island looking for him, Kwazii found us, but Barnacles came here, as far as we're aware from your phone call G. Herbert found out that Barnacles was here, and he has been trying to impose as him from what I can tell." Eva looked to the two polar bears.

"So which one's Herbert and which one's Captain Barnacles?" Shellington Sea otter asked.

"I don't know?" Eva said puzzled, "Which one came here first?"

"That one, I presume." Gary pointed to Barnacles,

"But what if when they both went into the forest that Barnacles managed to capture the real Herbert?" Rookie wondered,

"Now it's even more confusing." Dot sighed.

"Yes I have my hat, I'm the real Captain Barnacles." Herbert lied again.

"Well prove it then!" Kwazii said,

"Yes prove it by telling us these Octonauts names." Prinsessrock asked.

Herbert gulped.

Barnacles smiled realizing what the penguins were doing, but gasped in shook as Herbert began to recite their names.

"Well, you're Kwazii Cat, you're Peso Penguin, you're Tweak Bunny, and you're Shellington Sea otter." Herbert smiled triumphantly.

Then Peso realized, "Oh no, I told Herbert each of the Octonaut's names when we were captured!"

"Well now we're stuck." Tweak sighed.

"Or maybe not..." Eva realized something, "You didn't say who this creature was." Eva picked Tunip up,

"Chipa chipa!" the Vegimal giggled.

"What is that? I've never seen anything like it!" Gary gasped in amazement.

"I would tell you, but the Captain knows who and what this is." Shellington turned to Herbert.

"Why don't you tell us Captain Barnacles?" Tweakbunny asked.

Herbert shuffled uneasily, "Well, why don't you tell Gary here what this cute creature is?" he asked Shellington,

"No I insist that you tell him Captain." Shellington insisted, "If you really are our Captain."

"Erm of course I am! Well, this creature is... is... umm... a vegetable animal?" Herbert said unsurely.

"What be his name then?" Kwazii asked.

"Umm..."

"I know!" Barnacles exclaimed, as he pulled away and escaped Herbert's grip,

"Because I am the real Captain Barnacles of the Octonauts." Tunip then ran to the captain,

"Chipa chipa!" he cried,

"Hello Tunip, nice to see you too." Barnacles stroked the Vegimal.

"That means..." Gary realized, "you're the real HERBERT!"

Herbert smiled evily, "You may have foiled this part of my plan agents!" He turned to the four friends,

"But this was only part of it! My crabs are taking over the Octopod as we speak! And I'll escape this island forever! MWAHAHAHA!" Herbert ran back into the forest, dropping Barnacles' hat along the way.

Jet Pack Guy flew after him followed on foot by some agents. But Herbert's laugh could still be heard in the distance as the agents returned empty handed.