Ok, so I like this chapter a lot! So this is where the drama happens so here you go! Enjoy!

I DON'T OWN ANYTHING EXCEPT AUDREY, HAYLEY, AND JOHNNY!

It's been about a month since Hayley and Johnny have started going out and Audrey couldn't be any happier for them. As Audrey was grabbing some books from her locker someone approached her.

"Hey Audrey."

"Oh, hey Johnny, Hayley's in the bathroom. She'll be right out."

"Thanks but I wanted to talk to you. You see, I'm having a hard time in Geometry and I just wanted to know if you could tutor me after school because I know Geometry is easy for you so…" said Johnny.

"Sure! How does 2:30 tomorrow after school sound?" responded Audrey.

"Sounds great, thanks." Soon enough Hayley came out of the bathroom, "Hey you two, what are you talking about?" Hayley asked as Johnny placed a kiss on her cheek. "Well Audrey was nice enough to tutor me in Geometry. We start tomorrow," said Johnny. "That's great! Audrey is so smart you'll have it down in no time. Bye Audrey!" said Hayley as she gave her friend a hug goodbye. "Bye!" said Audrey letting go. The couple walked away leaving Audrey by her locker. She felt kind of weird after her conversation with Johnny. But she just shook it off and headed to her next class.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

"Here try this one. Remember what I told you," said Audrey as she pointed to the problem in the Geometry book. Johnny quickly looked at it and started the problem. When he put his pencil down he let Audrey look at his work. "That's it!" Audrey said. Johnny smiled, so proud of himself. Hayley was coming down shortly to meet the two so that Johnny and Hayley could go on their date. "I think you're going to do great on the next test," said Audrey. Johnny nodded and then there was a moment of silence. "You're really smart Audrey," said Johnny as Audrey smiled. "Thanks Johnny," Audrey responded. Right then he kissed her. Hayley came into the library to see if Johnny was ready to go but all she saw was her best friend kissing her boyfriend. Tears started to stream down Hayley's face and she ran out. Audrey quickly pulled away, "What the hell are you doing?" "You're a very pretty girl Audrey, smart and talented too. Honestly I like you a lot more than Hayley," said Johnny. "No, no, no, you're Hayley's boyfriend, you like her not me," said Audrey as she got up and grabbed her things. "Where are you going?" "Away from you. Don't you ever talk to me again, you ass hole." Audrey hardly ever cursed but she was so angry at this point. She quickly ran out of the library. She had to talk to Hayley about what happened.

When Audrey arrived home she noticed a note on the kitchen counter which read:

Audrey,

Gone for another doctor's appointment with your father. We'll be home by 4:00.

Love you,

Mom

"Great," said Audrey. The person she wanted to talk to the most right now was at a doctor's appointment. Audrey headed upstairs to her room, threw her school bag on the floor, and dialed Hayley's number.

"Hayley I need to tell you something," said Audrey.

"How could you?" Hayley shouted on the phone.

"What?" Audrey responded.

"You know what Hayley. You kissed Johnny in the library! I saw you! He told me everything even before that. How you were flirting with him and leading him on!"

"What are you talking about? He kissed me! I did not flirt with him! He was telling me how I was pretty, smart, and talented and then he kissed me!"

"How could you make stuff up like that Audrey? I thought you were better than that. I thought you were my friend!" Hayley shouted again.

Audrey couldn't believe what she was hearing and she started to cry, "I can't believe this! You would believe some guy that you have just met a month ago, but you won't believe your best friend, the person you have known since you were eight? I guess we aren't friends anymore so you can forget New York and just forget our friendship all together!" shouted Audrey.

"Fine I will! Goodbye Audrey!" shouted Hayley as she hung up.

Audrey stared at her phone, she then put it on her side table. Audrey collapsed on her bed and cried into her pillow, she had just lost her best friend.

"Hey what's going on?" Rachel asked as she came into her room. Audrey sprang up from her bed and ran over to give her Mom a hug. She continued to cry as she rested her head on her mother's chest. "What happened baby?" Rachel asked as she rubbed her daughters head. "Hayley and I got into a huge fight," said Audrey as the Mother and Daughter walked over to Audrey's bed to sit down. "Over what?" Rachel asked. "A guy, well I don't even like him it's just so complicated Mom," said Audrey as she rested her head into her Mother's lap. Rachel started to play with her hair like she always did and said, "Why don't you tell me from the very beginning?" Rachel asked. Audrey nodded and proceeded with the story.

Sunday was Valentine's Day and Audrey was glad that she didn't have to see Hayley and Johnny on the day of love. She woke up on a bright sunny morning still miserable from the argument she had with Hayley two days prior. After she talked to her Mom she felt much better but was still upset that she lost her best friend.

Audrey put on her pink robe along with her white bunny slippers and headed downstairs to have breakfast. "Happy Valentine's Day!" said Rachel as she handed Audrey a plate of heart shaped pancakes, "You too Mom," said Audrey as she gave her Mom a hug and smiled. Audrey sat down at the table next to her Dad. "Happy Valentine's Day," said Finn as he rustled Audrey's wavy brown hair. Audrey laughed, "Thanks Daddy," she responded. "Do you guys have anything special planned?" Audrey asked as she began to eat her pancakes. "Well I'm taking your Mom to a romantic restaurant outside of Lima," said Finn. "It better be vegan," said Rachel jokingly. Audrey laughed as she continued to eat. "What are you going to do sweetheart?" Rachel asked. "I'll just stay here, order some food and watch some movies. Don't worry about me, you two have a good time," Audrey said with a smile.

"Oh, I'm so fat," said Rachel as she finished putting her outfit on. "What do you expect Mom? You are pregnant," said Audrey. Rachel sighed and both of them headed out to the foyer. Finn was waiting for Rachel at the door. "You look beautiful," said Finn. "Finn don't lie, I'm so fat," responded Rachel. "No you're not. You look so beautiful," Finn insisted. Rachel smiled and Finn gave her a quick kiss on the lips.

Soon the doorbell rang. Audrey was sitting on the living room couch when the visitor entered. She got up to see who it was, "Grandma Shelby!" Audrey said with delight as she hugged her Grandmother. "Did you really think we were going to leave you here by yourself on Valentine's Day?" said Finn. Audrey smiled and gave her parents both a hug goodbye. "Thanks Mom for coming, just make sure she's in bed no later than 10:30 she has school tomorrow," said Rachel. "You're welcome sweetheart and I will," said Shelby.

After Finn and Rachel left Shelby and Audrey ordered pizza and watched the Notebook. "So what's been up with you sweetheart? We haven't talked in a long time," said Shelby. Audrey sighed, "Well Hayley and I had a huge fight on Friday and basically we're no longer friends," said Audrey. Shelby could tell that her Granddaughter was upset so she didn't want to ask for details. "What's going to happen to your New York City trip?" "Well I told her that she couldn't go so I'm not even sure if I'm still going," responded Audrey. "You miss New York so much Audrey, I can see it. You're a New Yorker and you should still go, Hayley or no Hayley," said Shelby. Audrey smiled and hugged her Grandmother. "Thanks Grandma, I needed that." After Audrey and Shelby's conversation they continued to watch the movie.

Finn and Rachel entered through the door and saw Shelby sitting on the couch. "Hey how did it go?" Shelby asked getting up from the couch. "It was great! It really was a romantic restaurant. We had a great time," said Rachel. "What did you two do?" Rachel added. "We ordered pizza and watched the Notebook. What's that?" asked Shelby. "Oh we picked it up for Audrey on our way home. Rachel thought it was cute and she wanted to get it for her," said Finn holding up a white bear holding a heart in its hands. Shelby laughed, "It is very cute. Alright I better get going. Audrey went to bed about an hour ago, good night. Happy Valentine's Day!" she said as she gave hugs to the two of them. "Happy Valentine's Day," Finn and Rachel said in unison.

They both entered Audrey's room and placed the bear next to her so that she would see it when she woke up. They both watched her sleep for the longest time which they used to do when she was a baby. The two of them headed to their bedroom to head in for the night.

"We have got to talk to Sam and Quinn tomorrow about this. Audrey is just not herself, you should have seen her Finn," said Rachel as she got under the covers next to her husband. "I can't believe Hayley wouldn't believe her when she tried to tell her what happened," said Finn. "I also blame Johnny, he's the one who really started this," said Rachel. Finn nodded in agreement towards his wife. Rachel leaned into Finn as he put his arm around her. "Do you think it was a smart choice, moving here, making Audrey change her life style, leaving a place she loved dearly. Everything in New York was perfect," Rachel asked. "Yeah I think it was Rach. I mean most of our family is here anyways. Audrey will be fine she's a strong girl. And we did this because we love her, right?" Finn asked. "Of course Finn," said Rachel. Finn gave her a long kiss on the lips. "I love you," said Finn. "I love you too. Oh and thanks for not kissing me on the cheek. I think that was worth a dollar," said Rachel as Finn laughed and so did she.

Ok so right now Hayley and Audrey aren't friends, sadly. I hope you all liked how I brought Shelby back. Oh and more Finn and Rachel which I thought the story was lacking a lot of. Again another Audrey and Rachel moment. I know a lot of you like the Audrey and Finn moments so I really hope to have one in the next chapter.

The drama will continue in the next chapter. What will Sam and Quinn say about all of this? Will they believe their daughter or what Finn and Rachel tell them?

This will all be answered in the next chapter!

Please Review! Thanks!