Hi. Thanks to all who send comments/reviews. I appreciated them all and am glad to hear that my first Shenny story was well accepted. This is Chapter 2 – a continuation of the first – beginning the next morning…
Penny woke to the sound of her cell phone vibrating on the night stand next to her. A quick look at the clock showed it was 7:30am. Sheldon.
Good morning, Penny. I trust you had a satisfying sleep.
Penny texted back immediately, knowing full well that she wasn't going to get to be back to sleep now.
Yes, honey. Very satisfying. Like last night with you.
She smiled as she pressed the SEND button.
Moments later, it vibrated again. For me as well. I was wondering if you would be up for a visit again this morning.
Penny shivered. I've created a monster. But oh what a monster he was. Never would she have believed that Sheldon had another side to him – a completely sexual side. The man had no real experience but she would have never guessed it if she hadn't known him. He excelled at everything he did. Exceptionally so.
I'm stepping in the shower now. Give me 10 mins and come over.
Penny hurried to the bathroom and stepped into the steaming hot water, washing her body quickly. She could feel her pulse begin to race at the idea of another encounter with Sheldon.
They had both agreed the night before that their "relationship" must remain a secret – for now. Sheldon had insisted that his personal life remain as private as possible, regardless of the circumstances and Penny had agreed.
Before she could finish her shower, Penny heard him enter the bathroom.
"Good morning, Penny," he called out, his voice already husky with desire.
Smiling, Penny pulled aside the shower curtain, no modesty at all in baring her naked body to him. "Hello, honey…care to join me?" He was fully dressed; not wearing his PJs or robe, but Penny looked at him hopefully.
He looked at her lush and wet body with admiration and desire. "While as inviting as that sounds, I just showered myself so I will wait for you in the bedroom. Hurry now."
"I'll be right out."
Sheldon smiled and left the bathroom. Removing his clothes, he neatly folded them and placed them on the chair in her room. Her bed was unmade, and normally he would scold her for that but given he knew he'd woken her and she was rushing to shower before they had coitus, he would forgive her this time. Naked he slipped between her sheets, knowing they were clean having been washing the evening before. He smiled at the memory. It was any wonder they had managed to actually do their laundry last night. Never would he have imagined being with Penny like that. Oh he had fantasized about it – many times – but he always believed it was simply something that would never happen.
He heard the water turn off and felt himself harden. Settling down in the bed, he turned his face to the bathroom door and waited.
Penny came out dressed in a short bath robe. It barely covered her ass and Sheldon admired her shapely legs and tight butt. She smiled and approached the bed, noting his erection already tenting the bed sheet.
"Is that for me?" She moved her hand softly over the sheet, grazing his erection.
"Only you." His gaze fixed on her partially exposed breasts. "Why don't you remove that robe and join me?" He pulled the sheet up and Penny could see his long but lean body, his cock proudly jutting out from between his legs. She swallowed hard. While she was always the sexual aggressor in bed, she liked that Sheldon was showing yet another side to him - his aggressive side. "Take it off."
Slipping the belt loose, Penny slowly pulled the robe over her shoulders and off, sliding down her body to form a puddle at her feet. "Oh yes…" Sheldon hissed as she climbed in beside him and grabbed his throbbing cock.
He kissed her deeply, his tongue forcing its way inside her mouth. Penny groaned in delight as his hands moved to caress her tight nipples, pulling and pinching them while their mouths fought for superiority. She briefly realized that they would always be trying to jockey for dominance over each other.
Between kisses, Sheldon moaned at her touch on his cock. "I…oh…I…need to…"
He climbed up and she let go of him in anticipation. He spread her legs wide, pushing them up further so her knees were near her chest. She understood what he wanted so she held her knees in place as he leaned over her. She felt his cockhead touching her wetness and she groaned as he teased her.
"Oh Sheldon," she sighed. "Please…"
"You want me, Penny? You want me inside you?" He was struggling to speak coherently as his cock leaked pre-cum and he smeared it over her already wet pussy lips.
"Yessss…please…"
He grinned evilly, relishing that he excited her so much. He put the head of his cock tighter against her hold and slid in slowly, his eyes closing at the amazing feeling. He couldn't believe he'd gone his whole life believing this to be nothing special. He'd been so wrong – not that he would ever admit it.
When he was fully inside her, he leaned down and gave Penny a hot wet kiss before sliding himself nearly completely out before thrusting back in her again. They both moaned and Penny already felt the familiar tingle in her gut. At this angle she could feel him more deeply inside her. She moaned deeply.
Sheldon continued to pull out, and then he thrust deeper, slowly at first, then with fiercer thrusts, practically pushing Penny into the headboard.
"Oh Sheldon! Ohhhhh….!"
"P…Penny…so hot…"
He was thrusting harder now, unable to make it last. He felt somewhat guilty, knowing he wasn't doing much to pleasure her first. He prayed she understood his need and would forgive him.
Sensing something in his demeanor, Penny grabbed his ass and pulled him tighter into him. "Oh do it, Sheldon! Fuck me…cum inside me…it's okay…ohhh…faster!"
Sheldon grunted at her words, grateful she understood his silent plea. He knelt up further and reached down and with his thumb rubbed her clit as he continued to thrust, their bodies sweaty and slick. "Oh…P…Penny!"
"OH…cumming…Sheldon!" she screamed as her orgasm exploded inside her and she clamped herself around him.
"God…I'm…Penny…I'm cumming!" He thrust twice more and came inside her, continuing to thrust with each spurt of his seed inside her. "Oh…Mmmm…"
The collapsed together in a pile, exhausted but deeply satisfied. Turning to her, Sheldon kissed Penny deeply. "I'm sorry, Penny. I couldn't…control myself."
"It's quite all right, honey…I needed it as much as you did." She caressed his face and they kissed again, his hand moving to her right breasts, tweaking the nipple. Penny moaned against his mouth. They lay quietly together, kissing and caressing.
After several moments Sheldon suggested they should both shower again - together. "To save water," he stated as an excuse.
Penny smiled knowingly as she took his hand and led him to the bathroom. They stepped into her shower and proceeded to soap each other's bodies, not missing any body parts. He loved the feel of her body under his soapy hands…how slick her thighs were. How soft and abundant her breasts were. They stood under the hot steam of water kissing, Sheldon's hands on Penny's ample ass, caressing it and pulling her luscious body against his.
"We need to stop, honey. Or we're never going to be clean."
So it surprised her when Mr. Clean-Freak licked her neck and moaning against her shoulder, "You are the only person I don't mind getting dirty with, Penny."
She giggled but forced him away from her. "I'm getting pruney. We need to get dressed. Leonard must be wondering where you are by now."
The mention of Leonard's name brought Sheldon back into reality and he quickly stepped from the shower, grabbing a towel and drying himself quickly off before heading to the bedroom to dress. Penny did the same and moved into the bedroom, albeit naked, and picked out a pair of shorts and a tank top to wear.
"You know, Sheldon…I think you're actually hornier than I am."
"Don't be absurd. No one is as horny as…" he stopped. The evil look she shot him told him it was time to stop talking. "In any case, I feel that I am quite capable to holding off my urges, unlike…others."
Penny snorted. He was suggesting that she couldn't control herself. While she wasn't entirely convinced of it herself, he had unknowingly thrown down the challenge. "Funny but a few minutes ago, you were the one unable to stop." Sheldon blushed at the memory of his urgency to take her. "Okay, Mr. I Can Control My Urges…wanna make a bet?" She stood with her hands on her hips.
"That's silly."
"No, Sheldon…really. I say that the first one to crack and given in to the other loses. If you're so sure of your control, bet me. Come on, I dare you."
Sheldon never backed down from a dare and the look in her eyes only urged him on further. "Very well. We should draw up an agree-"
Penny held up her hand. "We are not drawing up an agreement for this bet, Sheldon. We'll…shake on it…honor system."
He hesitated. While he might be out of his normal comfort zone now with making love to Penny, he still had his necessary albeit stringent structures to his life. But he knew that she'd never agree to an agreement…and he was willing to do just about anything for her. "Fine, then. What are the rules…of engagement? So to speak."
"As we already agreed, we can't tell anyone else we're 'together'. The best is to try to seduce the other into giving in. Giving in being when the other cried 'Uncle' and beg for either oral sex or…regular sex. No self-pleasuring. But other than that – anything goes. Oh, I hope you're ready because I've a lot more experience at seduction than you."
He grinned at her. He had a twinkle in his eye and Penny could tell he was already spinning that beautiful mind with a plan to best her. "No doubt, however, I have little reservation that your urges will get the better of you. I suspect very soon."
"Oh it is so on, honey," Penny said, putting her hand out. Sheldon stood up and approached her cautiously. Putting his hand in hers, he was startled when Penny pulled him to her and leaning up, whispering in his ear "You're going to miss being inside me, honey…all snug and hot." She licked his earlobe and he fought back his groan.
Sheldon stepped back and let go of her hand. "Yes…well, we'll see…won't we?"
To Sheldon's way of thinking, until he determined what the best course of action to get Penny to break was, he needed to avoid her like the plaque because truth be told, he wasn't entirely sure he could resist her. Not now. Not after their two previous sexual encounters together. She was becoming an addiction and he felt completely out of sorts. He caught himself licking his lips when she entered his thoughts; felt himself tightening imagining her hands on him. But the last thing he wanted to do was allow her to beat him at this game because he wanted to prove that despite his lack of experience, or her abundance of it, she was not immune to Dr. Sheldon Lee Cooper.
When Monday night rolled around, the usual gang found themselves seated in Apartment 4A enjoying the Thai dinner. Several noted that Sheldon and Penny were rather quiet during the meal – they weren't even arguing with each other, which only made the others more suspicious.
Sensing that neither was behaving "normal", Penny spoke up and addressed Leonard. "So Leonard, how's Mandy?"
"Good. She's working on an experiment this week so she's been pretty busy, but things are going good."
"That's nice. I'm glad things are going well for you."
As she went on to try to engage the rest of them in conversation, everyone was staring at Sheldon, not understanding his silence. Before they started the movie, Penny got up and went to the kitchen to dispose of the garbage. As she poured herself another glass of soda, she saw Sheldon get up and move to the sink behind her, rinsing his glass. She looked to the others and no one seemed to be paying them any mind now.
Suddenly she gasped, gripping the counter. Her startled cry got the attention of the others.
"Penny, what's wrong?" Leonard asked.
"N…nothing. Sorry. I just banged my knee on the cupboard." She reached down pretending to rub her knee only to find Sheldon's head. He was on his knees, his hands on her thighs while his tongue licked and caressed the back of her knees. She fought to keep from crying out. It was one of her erogenous zones and as his tongue swept over her, this time moving up her right thigh, Penny felt her knees nearly buckle. She was also feeling herself becoming wet.
Oh this was so on!
He'd caught her by surprise, doing this so blatantly with their friends only in the living room. She couldn't believe that no one had noticed that Sheldon wasn't anywhere in sight. A few moments later, he got up onto his feet and put a paper towel in the garbage. "There was a small bit of…wetness down there that needed wiping," he gave as explanation to no one in particular in case someone was listening.
Penny nodded her head and swallowed hard. Okay, pull yourself together. This is Sheldon. You can beat him!
Settling back into their usual spots on the couch – Sheldon in his spot, Penny to his right – everyone brought their attention to the television. The lights were dimmed to better enjoy the special effects of the movie.
This gave Penny an idea to get back at Sheldon. Giving a quick look around, Penny noted that no one could really see them if they were facing the television – only she and Sheldon were on the couch – everyone else was either on the floor or in a chair in front of them. In the darkness, Penny reached over and put her hand on Sheldon's thigh and squeezed. He jumped in surprise and turned to look at her. She didn't meet his gaze, instead she continued to look at the television but from the corner of her eye she could see his eyes on her – daring her.
Penny made small squeezes of his taut thigh as she moved her hand further up until at last her hand was at his crotch. Pressing her fingers there she smiled when she felt he was already hard. Moving her hand down, she gently cupped his balls and she felt Sheldon shake, an almost inaudible moan escaping his lips. Penny then moved her hand back up and with the entire length of it, she grasped him through his pants, squeezing.
"Oh!" he cried out and Penny pulled her hand away in a flash.
"What's wrong Sheldon?" Bernadette asked him.
"I'm sorry," he apologized. "I just got a cramp in my leg." He reached down to rub his right leg. Satisfied with his answer everyone turned back to the television – everyone but Penny. She watched him as he moved his hand to her left calf and stroked it gently, upwards until he reached her thigh.
He looked at her and she shook her head, mouthing "No."
He grinned mischievously before moving his hand to the warmth between her legs, cupping her. Penny bit down on her tongue to keep from crying out as Sheldon stroked her through the thin fabric of her shorts and undies. Leaning close to her, Sheldon licked her earlobe before saying very quietly – and thank goodness for the volume of the television being so high, "I can feel how wet you are already, Penny. Do you perhaps wish me to…lick you there?"
Penny shook her head again, frustrated but determined.
Sheldon shrugged his shoulders, stroking a few more times before pulling his hand away. She sighed in frustration but moved to put her hand back on his dick. He was still hard and she loved the feel of him through his pants. He closed his eyes as she squeezed him. His breathing got deeper. She knew what it was doing to him but she also knew what it was doing to her. She was so tempted to drag him to his room and take him in her mouth but she fought it. She couldn't afford to lose this bet.
As he did with her, Penny leaned towards Sheldon's closet ear, licked his lobe and whispered, "I'd be happy to help you relieve this pressure, honey…just say the word…and I'll take you in my mouth till you feed me your seed."
He gasped looking quickly to the others but no one had heard him. Grasping her wrist, he pulled her hand from his cock, the relief from the pressure of her hand evident in his more relaxed facial features. Sheldon quickly got up and went to the bathroom. Sensing he might break one of the rules, Penny got up to follow him.
"Where you going?" Leonard asked.
"Bathroom," she replied.
"I think Sheldon's in there."
"It's okay, I have to go so I'll wait outside the door."
"Okay but remember to not talk to him through the door…you know…"
"I know…he hates that."
Moving to the bathroom door, Penny pressed her head to listen but didn't hear anything. She knocked softly. "Sheldon!" she whispered as soft as she could. "What are you doing in there? You better not be…you know…" Then she hissed, "It's against the rules!"
Sheldon opened the bathroom door and pulled her in, surprising her. "Are you crazy? How is this – following me in here – considered in any way subtle in that seemingly above-average brain of yours?"
She huffed and let out a breath. "Me? You're the one who was on the floor licking my legs in the kitchen! Did you think that maybe someone might have caught you?"
"I hadn't given it much thought."
"Apparently."
He took her hand and put it to his crotch. "Oh…and what do you call that little display of 'affection' you did out there that brought about this?"
"I could say the same to you," she growled, grabbing his hand and putting it between her legs. He felt her dampness there and groaned.
Suddenly they were kissing, their hands in each other's hair, pulling their mouths tight together as their tongues fought and mated harshly. Sheldon pushed her against the edge of the sink and put his hand down between her legs again. "You want this?" he asked, his finger stroking hard against her.
Not to be outdone, Penny put her hand back on his crotch and grabbed his cock through his pants, tugging hard. "What you want, honey?"
As they kissed they were rubbing against one another, the friction of their hands on each other bringing them close to orgasm. It was then that they both realized that they hadn't covered this in the rules. They weren't supposed to masturbate themselves but they hadn't specified masturbating each other. And as each fought for dominance over the other, their bodies grinding together in perfect - albeit urgent – rhythm, Sheldon was the first to come to his senses. With every fiber of his being, he stopped moving and gently pulled Penny's hand from his crotch, while also releasing his hand from hers. He stepped back.
They were both gasping, fighting for breath; fighting for calm.
"I think we may need to reconsider the idea of an agreement." Sheldon tried to straighten himself, adjusting himself though still wishing he could release the pressure. "Clearly we didn't think of all the variables."
Penny was grasping the sink, fighting for air. She felt weak in the knees but nodded her head. "I think you may be right, honey."
Straightening herself up, she crept to the bathroom door and peaking out. No one had become suspicious and sent looking for either of them. Sheldon left first given he was supposedly in the bathroom first. Penny waited a minute to follow – her breath still coming in ragged gasps.
Wow. Okay so we didn't think that one through at all.
Neither made any attempt at seduction for the rest of the evening and Penny retired to her apartment when the rest of the gang headed for home. She needed a long and very cold shower, especially since being on the honor system, she knew she couldn't just masturbate and get herself off. She didn't want to cheat.
Sighing heavily as she stepped under the cold water, she had no idea how she was going to survive this game.
Tuesday managed to go quickly for both Sheldon and Penny while they were at work, but when the boys showed up for their usual Tuesday dinner at the Cheesecake Factory, Penny groaned in frustration at the sight of Sheldon sitting in his normal spot at the boy's table.
Not that she didn't want to see him. Oh she did…she wanted to see all of him – in his naked glory – hot and hard for her. But seeing him also reminded her of what she couldn't currently have and the frustration grew. She'd actually considered caving in late last night when she was laying in bed, wishing he was there with her – making love to her. She groaned again and sucking in a deep breath, she made her way to the table.
"Hello Penny," Sheldon greeted her before the others.
"Hi guys," she responded, standing away from Sheldon somewhat. She didn't want to get to close to him and smell his soapy scent or she'd jump him right there in the restaurant, in front of all the guys.
They greeted her with warm "hellos" before looking over the menu. Of course, Sheldon got the same thing every week so he had no need to look at the menu so instead he watched her. Penny fidgeted on her feet, feeling his eyes roam over her, a small quirk on his lips before he licked his lips.
Oh damn, she thought weekly. I don't know how much longer I can do this! Penny bit her lip to keep from screaming.
At last the guys placed their order and Penny went to the kitchen to put the order in. She had no other tables to wait on so she stood near the back and watched Sheldon. As usual, he was very animated in his conversation with his friends – regardless of the subject matter. It was a few minutes more when he caught that she was watching him from the hidden area near the kitchen and he smiled at her. He looked away to Leonard but she caught movement of his left hand that had been resting on his thigh. He was trying to get her attention and when he turned his head again and saw she was paying attention, he wiggled his index and middle fingers in a motion that was clear what he was thinking.
Penny gasped. Then felt herself get wet. Sheldon continued to move his fingers in such a manner that there was no mistaking he was suggesting what he could do to her with those sexy fingers.
She groaned again in frustration before grabbing their drinks and bringing them to table. She set Sheldon's lemonade in front of him and suddenly felt those same to fingers on her inner thigh. She jumped away in surprise, nearly spilling Raj's diet Coke.
"Anything wrong, Penny?" Sheldon asked innocently.
"No, honey…everything is just fine."
Penny turned and went back to the kitchen, then went down the corridor and opened the back door, stepping out into the alleyway for some fresh air. With her hands on the wall, she took a deep breath and exhaled. This was going to kill her. She was already running out of ideas on how to seduce Sheldon.
What is wrong with me?
Moments later she felt a hand on her hip and she jumped in surprise. "Shh…it's only me," Sheldon whispered in her ear, his warm breath making her body quiver.
"God Sheldon, you scared me."
"I apologize. I didn't mean to frighten you." He was sincere and she knew it. He would never intentionally hurt or frighten her in any way.
He placed his other hand on her other hip and pulled her close to him, his breath against at her ear. "I just had to come and see you. Touch you."
"Oh honey…" she sighed pressing back against him.
"This uniform does nothing to hide your beautiful body. Your breasts…so perfect. Oh and your legs…I can feel them wrapped around me still."
He had no idea (or did he?) that his words were a seduction on their own. She felt herself melting against him, so wishing he would just reach around and down and show her exactly what he'd been thinking of doing with those big fingers of his. She groaned and rubbed her ass against him and she felt his hardness quicken against her lower back.
Abruptly he turned her to face him and his head leaned down like he intended to kiss her. She closed her eyes in anticipation but instead she felt his mouth on her throat, just above the open collar of her uniform. He licked the spot and groaned against her skin. "I really wish I could taste you, Penny." She groaned again, her hands clutching his arms for support. His mouth suckled a bit and then he raised his head. "Too bad that you'll have to say 'Uncle' and beg me first," he said with a growl before letting her go and going back into the restaurant. Penny stood standing there in shock - and completely full of lust.
Damn him!
Penny returned inside and picked up their orders. She served their table and was grateful that another table in her section was now occupied and she quickly moved away to wait on them, ignoring the righteous gaze of Sheldon's. She had to give him credit – he played this game far better than she had originally thought. It was then that she remembered that they hadn't drafted an agreement to cover all the rules after all and that's when an idea hit her.
The rest of her shift went quickly and the boy's had left to return home to play a game or watch some Star Trek related movie or show, so Penny left work and happily anticipated her next move. Climbing the steps to her apartment, Penny was grinning to herself – her plan was flawless and she was sure this would bring Sheldon to his knees – both figuratively and literally. She giggled when she reached their floor and could hear the guys shouting about something animatedly.
Slipping quietly into her apartment, Penny stripped and jumped into the shower to wash away the scents of the restaurant on her. When done with her shower, Penny slipped into her tightest pair of cut off jeans and a button down tankini which showed off a lot of her stomach. She left the top two buttons undone and slipping on a pair of flats, she went across the hall to 4A. But not before grabbing a small container from the fridge.
Opening the door she found the four guys engaged in some electronic game she didn't recognize. They offered her quick "hellos" before she moved to sit in her spot next to Sheldon. Putting the container on the coffee table, Penny bent over and slowly slipped down into her spot on the couch, allowing Sheldon on time to ogle her ass. She knew that the bottoms of her boy briefs were sticking out of the bottom of her jean shorts, and that part of her ass cheeks also showing. Shifting her hips to get comfortable, Penny leaned forward and grabbed the container from the coffee table.
She could see Sheldon eyeing her and she smiled as she opened the container. "What do you have there, Penny?" Howard asked her with interest.
"Chocolate pudding," she moaned softly pulling the spoon from her mouth. She could see Howard gulp and knew that it was the response she'd get from all of them. "Mmm…it's so…creamy. It just slides down my throat so smoothly."
Howard and Raj exchanged glances as Leonard shifted uncomfortably in his chair – their game temporarily ignored.
"Hey Sheldon…isn't chocolate pudding your favorite?"
Sheldon could only nod as he watched her put the spoon in her mouth and sigh again. Good God but she was going to push him over the edge. So when a rather large blob of pudding fell off the spoon and landed on the valley between her breasts, he nearly lost it and it took everything in him to not grab her and lick that pudding off her breasts until he got every last spot of it.
"Oh, opps!" she exclaimed, giggling. "How clumsy of me!" Unbuttoning another button on her tankini, Penny then put her fingers to her chest, scooping up the pudding and licking it off her fingers. She continued to do this till she'd gotten it all.
"Holy…" Howard said.
Sheldon was so uncomfortable now that he shifted in his spot, trying to adjust himself so the others didn't see his raging hard-on. He groaned softly as he watched Penny continue to eat the pudding – watching her tongue move over and around the spoon. He felt like he was losing his mind!
"Mmm…" Penny sighed again. "Oh I'm sorry…don't let me interrupt your game boys…continue on as if I wasn't here."
None of them was sure that was possible but they turned back to the television and continued their game. Sheldon was playing half-heartedly, unable to keep his eyes off Penny and her affair with the little spoon. Every time her tongue swirled out to lick the spoon, Sheldon felt his cock jump in his pants.
Then suddenly, Penny stood up. "Oh I almost forgot! Sheldon, you said you were going to help me with that box in the top of my closet. Do you have time now before we forget again?"
Sheldon did his best to act like he knew what the hell she was talking about and he stopped the game. "Yes, Penny, I can help you now. We should all take a bathroom break anyway."
He moved to follow her out the door and across the hall to her apartment. As he shut the door behind him he heard "What the fuck was that about?" by Raj.
They entered Penny's apartment and the second her door was shut, she pushed him up against the door and kissed him hungrily. He didn't resist as his hands reached down and cupped her ass, pulling her tighter against him. Then his mouth left hers and trailed down, searching for remnants of any chocolate pudding between her breasts. Penny moaned as his tongue snaked out and gently sucked on the swell of her left breast.
"You…are…such…a…tease…" Sheldon said between nips at her skin.
Penny smiled knowingly that her plan had worked so well. She knew he couldn't resist a seductive enjoyment of chocolate pudding – his favorite.
He reached down and unfastened the button of her jean shorts before pulling the zipper down, his mouth on her breasts still.
"S…Sheldon?" she stuttered as his mouth continued to tease.
"We didn't…do up…an agreement…for this…" he replied, his hands pulling the tight jean fabric down her hips until they settled around her knees.
"B…but…" Penny was unable to think clearly as she felt his fingers slip inside the top of her panties and down to her wetness. "Oh!" she gasped when she felt a finger enter her, stroking her deeply.
"Let me show you what I was thinking about earlier," he groaned, slipping another finger inside her. Penny cried out and clutched at his arms as he stroked her slick opening.
Sheldon wiggled his fingers and Penny started to hump against his hand. Sheldon laughed and by her breaths could tell she was close. So close. Then abruptly he pulled his hand out, pulled up her jeans and refastened them, his fingers glistening with her juices. He chuckled again as Penny stood there in complete surprise.
"You bastard!" she hissed as he licked his fingers.
"Just say the word, Penny and I would be happy to finish you off."
"Agrh!"
She could see that he was hard against the fly of his pants, but he apparently was more resistant to this than she was. She groaned in frustration and she heard him chuckle. He'd beaten her at her own game. If she tried the same thing with him, he'd be suspicious and wouldn't succumb. Damn him!
He leaned down and kissed her deeply, his tongue teasing her mouth before he nipped at her lower lip. Then opening the door, Sheldon strolled across the hall smugly and entered his apartment leaving Penny gawking at him in disbelief.
It was just after 2am when Penny sat up in bed and said, "Enough was enough."
Slipping on her robe and slippers, she quietly left her apartment and with her emergency key, she opened the door to 4A and crept quietly to Sheldon's bedroom door. With stealth precision, she opened the door and stepped inside; she allowed her eyes to adjust to the darkness as she quietly shut the door behind her. Slipping off her robe and slippers, she approached the bed.
He looks so peaceful, she thought. Too bad she was about to interrupt his REM cycle.
In the silence of the darkened bedroom, Penny stripped her shorts and tank top off and stood next to the bed naked. She wasn't sure how she would do the next thing without waking him but she knelt down next the bed taking care to not jostle it and awaken the sleeping giant. She fought back a giggle.
This was going to prove difficult considering that Sheldon wrapped himself in his blankets like a cocoon. Gently she started to pull the sheet and blanket closet to her out from under him, holding her breath that he wouldn't wake up. With a lot of effort and some patience, Penny was rewarded when she was able to lift the covers from his body and drape them over to the other side of the bed. He wore his usual Tuesday PJs and she smiled at what a goofy creature-of-habit he was. Well for everything but sex apparently.
She reached out and gently touched his groin, feeling the outline of his soft cock in beneath her fingers. He stirred only slightly with a sigh and Penny smiled evilly. Gripping him a little tighter, she watched in amazement as he began to harden beneath her manipulations. Yet he didn't waken. She got bolder, stroking him more, urging his cock to tent inside his PJs. She wondered how he couldn't feel it as she carefully pulled the elastic of his PJs up and over his erection, which was straining through the hole in his underwear.
Gently easing the material around his hard cock, she exposed him to her lust filled gaze and took him in her hot little hand. Standing up she bent over and licked the head, tasting his pre-cum. She fought to suck him deep or groan because she felt like she was losing control. Licking him some more, she closed her eyes and relished the idea of what she was doing to him. He was right earlier – there was no agreement in place that stated she couldn't touch him and taste him – she just couldn't take him completely unless he begged. And she prayed to God that he would beg her soon.
He stirred again as she stroked her hand up and down, loving the size of him in her small hand.
"Beg me, honey," she whispered. "Beg me to suck your cock right now."
Sheldon groaned and when she lowered her head again to lick the pre-cum from the head, she suddenly felt his hand on her thigh. He was awake! His hand moved higher up her thigh as his eyes adjusted to the darkness, seeing her leaning over the bed, his hard cock in her hand.
"Penny. Penny. Penny," he said shaking his head. "Did you really think this ploy of yours would work?"
Then she knew. He'd been awake the entire time. "How…? When…?" she stuttered.
"Since you undressed and came to the side of the bed. I could smell your lemony scent, mixed with your arousal."
"Oh you! You're too damn smart for your own good!" She chastised him.
He chuckled, touching her intimately now, stroking his fingers as she moaned. "I know."
Penny moaned again as he slipped two fingers insider her so she began to stroke him, harder now.
"P…Penny…may I recommend a mutually satisfying solution to our wager?" He groaned from her manipulations.
"W…what?" she sighed, moving her hips to get his fingers deeper inside her.
Sheldon sat up, looked her in the eyes and said simply, "A truce. We agree that we equals in this game and call a truce. Game finished…so we can…ah…get back to the tasks at…uh…hand."
Penny hesitated for mere seconds before climbing over him, straddling his hips and taking him in her hand, she guided him insider her. Sighing, she looked to him and said, "Agreed" before sinking down on top of him with a deep, heavy moan.
Sheldon groaned as her slickness enveloped him and he took her hard nipple in his mouth and sucked – hard. "I've missed you," he said hungrily.
"Oh honey…I've missed you too!"
And she began to move her hips. Sheldon laid down and thrust his hips upward to meet her downward thrusts and soon they built a fast and hot rhythm, neither wanting to delay their pleasure for another minute. Reaching down, Sheldon flicked her clit and then began to rub her with his thumb as Penny reached back and gently cupped his balls.
"Oh my!" Sheldon cried out.
"Sheldon! Oh…oh! Fuck me, honey. Fuck me!"
Sheldon grabbed Penny's hip with his left hand as his right continued to rub her little hardness and Penny felt the familiar ache rush through her. "Cumming!" she shouted as she continued to ride him.
"Oh…P…Penny…me too!" And with a final thrust upwards, Sheldon spilled himself inside his lover.
With him still inside her, Penny collapsed atop him and they kissed, deeply and passionately. Sheldon held her head and caressed her ass with his other hand, while they deepened their kisses. When finally he slipped from her, she rolled to her side and with a hand on his chest, Penny fell asleep, her left leg over his.
Sheldon laid there for another hour thinking of how lucky he felt to be with her. The way he felt now, he wasn't sure he would ever be tired of making love to her. The way she sighed or the way she called his name in passion or the way that she seemed to take great pleasure in his body as much as he took from hers. He sighed. His physically attraction to her notwithstanding, Sheldon knew he admired her in many other ways: her determination, spunk, toughness but feminine too. He liked everything about her – even the parts that drove him to insanity sometimes.
He loved her. He realized that now. Looking down at her sleeping peacefully against her, Sheldon had never felt so happy in his life. He gently kissed her forehead and closed his eyes. He would tell her soon.