Title: The miracle in the mistake

Pairing: Puck/Kurt

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or anything else you may recognize

Beta: RoseWalton

Summary: What if Kurt and Puck were in a relationship before Quinn got pregnant. How will Kurt react when he finds out that the baby was Puck's and what will happen between them?

Rating: Not sure yet but it will probably end as a NC 17

Author notes: I know I changed the timeline and how the events played out but I had to be creative in order for the story to play out how it should. This is fanfiction so get over it.

AN: Hi I wanted to let you know this chapter is not betaed. I wanted to give all of my readers this chapter as Christmas present. I wrote it a little late and well it is the holidays I am sure my beta has better things to do than look over my work. Hope you all like it and well there is going to be another authors note at the end. Enjoy reading and Happy Holidays!

Chapter 5

"What the hell is going on here?"

As soon as they heard the words the two of them leapt apart. There in the doorway stood the scariest man Noah had ever seen, Burt Hummel in person. He looked livid. Noah gulped in fear. Usually Burt and he got along just fine but now that he was dating his son it seemed as if Burt saw him as a threat. Kurt jumped up and hugged his father.

"Hi dad, why are you home early? You were supposed to be back from Chicago tomorrow. I planed to cook your favorite for dinner."

"I finished my business early. Now how about you tell me what you are doing with Puckerman here?" asked Burt glaring at Noah as if wishing he had a gun.

"Calm down dad, you like Noah, remember?" tried Kurt to calm his father.

"That doesn't mean I want to find him in my living room with you kissing!" Burt growled out.

"Dad you knew I went on a date two weeks ago. You even told me to have fun, which I have, you even knew I went on couple of more dates. Now suddenly you have something against my boyfriend!" Defended Kurt.

"Boyfriend!" exclaimed Burt. Then he said something for which he will swear the rest of his life was the stupidest thing he ever said to Kurt.

"I never allowed you to have a boyfriend!"

"Allowed!" shouted Kurt not believing what he was hearing. His dad was delusional if he could control his life at this point in his life.

"You are talking as if I am 5 years old, you forget dad that I am 16 years old and as you yourself said countless of times more mature than even you were my age. Now you don't trust me enough to be careful with my heart. Well to bad I am going to continue seeing Noah." With his rant finished, Kurt grabbed Noah's hand and dragged him to the veranda.

"I am sorry!" Apologized Kurt. "My father is rather protective of me, but that went to far. I am sorry you had to witness that!"

Noah took Kurt in his arms and hugged him tight. Kurt burrowed his head into Noah's chest.

"It is okay, princess. I am sorry your father had to find out this way. I know you wanted to tell him."

"He would have reacted the same way. It is probably better he found out sooner rather than later."

"Alright, now onto another question. Since when are we boyfriends? Did I miss the moment were you asked me, or where I asked you?"

Kurt blushed. It was true they were only dating which is why Kurt told his dad that they were boyfriends. He knew his dad would feel more comfortable with that than dating in fear Noah was playing with him.

"I am sorry!" Apologized Kurt embarrassed.

"I don't mind princess. In fact I was planning on asking tonight anyway."

"Really?" Asked Kurt, hoping it was true.

"Of course princess, I kind of like the thought of you being mine."

Kurt blushed at Noah's answer. He gathered his courage, stood on his toes and kissed him. About five minutes later, Kurt entered the house glowing with happiness after Noah had left.

Burt was sitting in his armchair in the living room deep in thought. He looked up as Kurt entered.

"Kurt please take a seat." As Kurt sat down his face lost the bright smile and took a serious expression. Burt took note of that and realized that he hadn't seen Kurt this happy since before he lost his mother.

"I know I reacted a little extreme but you are my baby boy. I don't care that you like boys you know that. I always tries to encourage you to be yourself without caring what others thought and I guess I just tried to protect you forgetting that you were a smart kid and wouldn't chose someone who was out to hurt you?"

"I know that and to be honest I kind of liked it that you cared enough."

"I care and I worry Kurt, especially after what happened at your school. I worry that someday I'll get a call that you've been attacked and that you are in a hospital."

"Dad, Noah isn't like that. If it weren't for him you never would have received that tape about the bullying. It was him that got the material."

"I approved him after what I overheard between you two on the veranda, this just hardens my resolve. I am happy you found someone who appreciates and makes you happy, especially since he seems as protective of you as I am."

"Thanks dad, that means a lot to me. Especially since we can't be seen together in Lima." Relived Kurt stated, getting on his feet. Before he could leave the room Burt jumped on his feet and shouted:

"I'll kill Puckerman. How dare he try and keep your relationship a secret as if he was ashamed of you."

Kurt couldn't believe what he was hearing. One minute his father was totally supportive of his relationship with Noah and the other he was threating him.

"Dad, dad, calm down. I asked him to keep our relationship a secret and he agreed although only until we both felt comfortable with each other." Explained Kurt at the same time trying to calm him down.

"Fine, as long as you agree with it." said Burt in a gruff voice as he sat down. Both knew with that the conversation was over.

It had been a couple of weeks since Burt found them in the living room together. Every moment they spent together made them more sure that they were in love. While Burt was the first person in Lima who knew about them, he wasn't the last. In fact there were five more persons who knew. The first people they told voluntarily were their best friends. Noah told Artie whom he was a friend with thanks to their advanced calculus class. Kurt meanwhile told his best friends Santana, Brittany and Mike whom he was friends with since kindergarten. After Kurt's mother died the four of them became inseparable. Santana, Brittany and Mike became quite protective of Kurt once the problems in school started. Sometimes they even got detentions for their retaliation pranks, which is why when Brittany threatened him with Lord Tubbington if he hurt Kurt, Noah knew that threat was real. He had often heard from others that were violent towards Kurt say that Brittany told them Lord Tubbington was coming from them and the next day the very humiliating retaliation prank hit. The other two persons who knew were Noah's mom and his little sister Sara. They told Sara, for Kurt wanted to spend as he called it girl time with her. They went shopping together, he painted her nails and helped her braid her hair. Sara in fact felt as if she had suddenly an older sister along with her brother. Noah's mum meanwhile found out the same way Kurt's dad did. She walked in on them. She was quite upset over the whole ordeal although not for the reason Kurt would have thought. Kurt was afraid she would be upset because he was male, he sure as hell wouldn't have thought that she was concerned for him! In fact she tried to convince him that Noah wasn't any good for him and would end up hurting him. What Kurt upset the most, was that she all that told him in front Noah that is why he exploded on her. He told her loud and clear for the whole neighborhood to hear that she had to get over what ever went wrong in her life and to stop blaming her son for it because lets be realistic it could not have been Noah's fault. Then in a calmer voice he explained her that even if Noah did end up hurting him, he was sure it would not be intentional, and that he took that in price when he choose to go out with Noah because lets face it getting hurt is part of life and he sure as hell would not end up hiding from it, like she did. Two days after the altercation between Kurt and his mom Noah got the biggest surprise in his life. His mom apologized to him telling him it was wrong of her to blame him for his father's wrong doings and some of hers. While their relationship isn't as good as it could be it was better than it was two days prior to Kurt's chew out.

It was now two weeks until the start of the school year and they were spending the evening at Kurt's house since his father was away on business. It was supposed to be a special evening, not only was it their two months anniversary but Kurt finally felt ready to take a step further in their physical relationship. He wanted to take the step and give everything he as to Noah.

As Kurt lay in Noah's arms he couldn't help but sigh happily. Everything was perfect in his world, sure he wished they could be open about their relationship but he was realistic. They would lynch the two of them for daring them to be different. Noah had the same thought as Kurt just that he did not see the necessity of hiding which is why he started.

"I want to be open about our relationship, when the school starts in two weeks."

Kurt flinched at that. He detangled himself from Noah, the sheets on the bed and stood facing his lover.

"Why do you want us to be public? Why destroy what we have?"

"What do you mean destroy? Just because we are public doesn't mean it would destroy our relationship." Argues Noah vehemently his point.

"Of course it does! What do you think will happen once people find out that in their midst live two gay boys. It won't matter that you are bi."

"You are exaggerating. After all the Berry's live in Lima, they are married and even have a daughter. You don't see them pretending to be something they are not."

"Of course not, the moved to Lima, they weren't born here. The people see them as outsiders; they are never included in anything. If it weren't for my dad I would be excluded as well. Actually I already am, at least by our classmates or do you think I got a text informing me about the party tonight, like you did?" Kurt was giving his best trying to convince Noah that it would be better for him to keep their relationship secret. Sure it would hurt hearing rumors about Noah's fictional conquests but it would be better than losing Noah when he couldn't take the treatment the others would rain down on him.

"Why do you think that is important to me. If I wanted to go to all these parties don't you think I would go, however I am here with you. Even if I were not I wouldn't go. They all want Puck, they don't see me."

"They will make you an outsider. They will try to get you to quit the teams. All your friends will ignore you…"

"I'll live! Interrupted Noah, if my friends can't accept that I am happy in a relationship, even if it is with a dude, well that just means they weren't really my friends."

"Why are you so insistent on people knowing?" Kurt was grasping at straws.

"Because I don't want to have hide how I feel about you in the school. I want to be able to hold your hand and kiss you whenever I damn well please! I want to show the entire Lima how amazing you are and how much I love you." With these words Noah suddenly stopped. He couldn't believe what he said. He was mortified, he just admitted to Kurt that he loved him, what if he was rejected or Kurt laughed at him for admitting his feelings this early. Kurt though could not believe what Noah just admitted. Here he was trying to convince his boyfriend that it would be safer for them to stay a secret and Noah goes and destroys all his fight. The only thing he could bring out was a question for confirmation on Noah's words. As Noah nodded Kurt's world was spinning. He loved Noah, he knew that for a couple of weeks already and everything in him was screaming to protect Noah from the cruelty of people. Now though he wanted nothing more but give in. his mind was battling his heart and it seems his heart was winning. He was so focused on debating what to do that he almost did not hear Noah's question.

"Why do you so badly want to stay a secret?" as soon as he heard the question Kurt knew he had the ammunition to win this argument, he just wasn't sure if he still wanted to. He looked around his room and his eyes fell on a box. The box was full of ruined clothes. That was the push he needed to decide.

"I love you Noah, started Kurt knowing that the next part would wound his boyfriend enough to accept the fact they needed to stay a secret. I am just not sure if I want to get hurt for that reason."

Noah did not believe what he was hearing. His boyfriend admitted to loving him but in the same breath he admitted to not being sure if Noah was worth of that love. He couldn't stay here; he needed to get out. He picked up his discarded clothes and left ignoring to the pleadings Kurt was shouting.

Twenty minutes later Noah found himself in front of Quinn Fabray's house. It was the place where the last summer party was held. He needed the distraction and booze.

Kurt meanwhile was stunned at what just happened. He knew what he did was a huge mistake. In fact he was sure he just ruined his relationship with Noah. He called the one person he knew wouldn't judge him.

"Santana!" answered a voice on the other end of the phone. In the background he could hear loud music, catcalls and he knew that Santana was at the party. Kurt hated that he would drag his best friend away from the party but he really needed someone to talk even if he wouldn't tell her right away what happened.

"San…" was all he needed to say.

"We are on our way, do we need ice cream?" asked Santana while giving Brittany a sign to find Mike because they were leaving.

"Yeah, I'll order the pizza."

"We'll be yours in twenty." At that Kurt realized he couldn't let his friends see his room in this state and he really had not the inclination to clean up. Which is why he said:

"Better at your place," at that Santana immediately knew something happened. She voiced her approval and disconnected the call.

Noah couldn't believe it, he forgot to draw his curtains close last night and now he was paying for it. He opened his eyes and groaned. The light was making a bad hangover worse and it made nearly impossible to think about why he even had one in the first place. He groaned as he remembered his fight with Kurt. He sat up in the bed, noticing he was naked although not giving it much thought and looked around the room noticing it wasn't his. Suddenly he felt movement next to him. He looked at the person in the bed and saw it was a naked Quinn Fabray. Now only realizing that he was naked as well the only thought going through his head was 'Fuck!'

Tbc…

Authors note: First off all I am sorry for the spelling mistakes, as I said earlier this wasn't looked over by my beta I will replace it as soon as I get it back. Now about the chapter I am sorry it took this long but I really wasn't happy with it. I rewrote it about 20 times and still am not happy but I guess this is the best version I have. Now I know I wrote that Mike is part of the best friend group and well I plan on writing a short story to explain the friendship between them all. This, I am sorry to say, isn't the whole chapter since there is some lemon that I plan on posting on . I have a link to it on my profile. Now please do vote on my poll since I don't plan on updating until I have the answers. Sorry! To those that already voted, this is a new one.