A/N I seriously have no idea where this story is going but I have idea's for after this whole business with Donnelly is over, I am rushing it and I'm sure that will be obvious but ahhhh wellllll!
FBI Headquarters
4.05 pm
67.55.32
Olivia and the team were stood outside the interrogation room getting ready to go back in.
"Ok so you want me to become scared of this guy?" Olivia turned to Huang.
"I think it will work, best bet is to ask about Richard Dwight and see where that takes you, I think he sensed your fear when he mentioned someone knew you, go with that." Huang explained further knowing Olivia hated showing anyone any weakness.
"Ok Elliot why don't you come with me on this one?" Olivia asked she knew she'd feel safe with Elliot by her side.
"Porter?" Elliot asked checking for permission.
"Yeah go ahead." Porter asked. "Just get us names." He added.
"That's what we hope to do." Olivia replied before going back in.
"Ah you're back." Donnelly smirked. "Oh and bought the husband with you my, what did I do to deserve this?" He asked sarcastically.
"Oh just thought we could use an extra body thought Stabler here would do the trick." Olivia replied sitting down opposite Donnelly. "So tell me more about Richard Dwight, the man who knew me." Olivia started to move the conversation.
"Ahh yeah, the thing is there was someone who knew you to." Donnelly smirked turning to look at Elliot.
"Why don't you tell me about that?" Elliot asked in his 'I don't care' manner.
"He actually knew you both ..." Donnelly began his eyes averting to Olivia.
"Ok?" Olivia asked knowing he was about to tell them anything.
"Said her like playing with you." Donnelly began. "He said he had fun playing a game with you and that some day he hoped to play with you again, he said the initials RDK would haunt you for the rest of your lives." Donnelly smiled wickedly as Olivia's face went white, she was also making herself look more scared that she was to tease more information out of him.
"Rape, Dismember, Kill." Elliot whispered making himself look scared too.
"Yeah sounds about right what did he do to the two of you that visibly have you both shaking in your shoes?" Donnelly asked.
He's enjoying seeing you scared, play on it. Huang's voice whispered in Olivia's ear.
"He uh, he copied the uh, serial killer RDK, copied his first two or three murders and sent us on a wild goose chase trying to find him with riddles and poems and puzzles." Olivia explained making her voice quiver to sound terrified of him.
"Ahh a copycat killer, not as good as the real thing so what was his name?" He asked a gleam in his eyes proving how much he was enjoying this.
"I don't ... I don't remember." Olivia shrugged.
"Of course you do, you don't forget any case you ever work but you're terrified of this man so you'd definitely remember his name." Donnelly replied.
"Humphrey Becker." Elliot shivered when he said the name.
"He looked like a Humphrey." Donnelly shrugged.
"Why don't you ... Why don't you tell us more about the guys who escaped with you, any more of them who knew us?" Olivia asked.
"Yeah, I think Neil Donavon and the two you caught me with were the only ones who didn't seem to know you." Donnelly replied.
That didn't at all give Olivia peace of mind, to know that most of the escaped prisoners bar three knew her and or Elliot.
"Who... W-Who else?" Olivia asked trying to look terrified.
"I'll tell you later, I'm hungry now." Donnelly replied.
"Listen you little prick, give us the names before I do something I really regret!" Elliot yelled getting into his face.
"No." Donnelly replied and Elliot grabbed him by his jump suit and threw him into the wall.
"Elliot!" Olivia gasped knowing that this wasn't going to work.
"You give us the names before I kill you, you son of a bitch." Elliot hissed right into his face.
Get Elliot out of there this is never going to talk. Huang hissed almost angry in her ear.
"Elliot leave him." Olivia yelled grabbing his arm.
Elliot gritted his teeth and let Olivia drag him away and out of the room. As soon as he was out in the surveillance space he punched the nearest filing cabinet.
"Elliot!" Olivia yelled grabbing his arm again.
"Don't." He snapped snatching his arm away and walking out.
Olivia stood and watched in shock. She hadn't seen Elliot get so worked up in a long time and it scared her a little.
"Livia?" Dean asked resting his hand gently on her shoulder.
"What?" She asked without moving from her spot to try and stop him.
"We're going to feed him and then hopefully he'll tell us some more." Dean explained.
"Yeah ok." She shrugged feeling a little defeated that they hadn't got much out of him.
"How about we take a walk to the interrogation room next door and see if they're doing any better with Neil Donavon?"
"They caught him?" Olivia asked in shock.
"Yeah, they bought him straight here and Agent Rose and Agent Spencer have been going at him for the past hour." Dean explained leading her away.
Olivia nodded as she pulled the ear piece from her ear as she walked into the surveillance space beside the one her team had been occupying.
"Ah Detective Benson it's good to meet you." A young agent smiled getting to her feet.
"Olivia this is Agent Summers." Dean smiled.
"Nice to meet you." Olivia replied as she shook the young agent's hand.
"Detective Benson is here." Summers said into a long black microphone which Olivia knew fed into one of the Agent's ears.
The two agents came out and smiled at Olivia like they'd known her for a long time.
"Detective Benson I'm Agent Spencer this is Agent Rose." A brown haired man who looked a lot like Dean Porter smiled extending his hand.
"Nice to meet you both." Olivia replied shaking both their hands.
"So you're how is it going with your perp?" Spencer asked.
"Yeah he's making sure we play by his rules." Olivia replied as Jessie walked in with Dean.
"Oh no Detective Stabler?" Rose asked looking at Jessie for a moment then back to Olivia.
"No, Stabler and I haven't been partners for a while." Olivia explained. "This is Detective Jessie Taylor my current partner."
"Ahh Taylor good to meet you. What happened to Stabler?" Rose asked.
"How do you even know Stabler?" Olivia asked frowning and folding her arms.
"We know Benson and Stabler, your interrogation tactics are legendary. Even within the FBI people just dream of being able to see the two of you tag teaming a perp." Rose explained smiling.
"Well should I go and see if Detective Stabler has calmed down enough and give these agents the opportunity to see you working together?" Porter asked knowing that Olivia couldn't say no now.
"Sure." Olivia replied playing with her wedding ring.
"Married Benson?" Rose asked her eyebrows raised towards the rings.
"Yeah, around ten months." She replied a smiled playing on her lips.
"He's one lucky fella." Spencer smirked he'd been eyeing up the detective since they'd been talking.
"I am." Elliot smiled coming into the surveillance space.
"Wait you're Stabler right?" Rose asked turning to Elliot.
He was too busy planting a kiss on Olivia.
"That's Stabler." Jessie answered.
"Wow you married your partner? That's rare!" Spencer replied.
"Well we decided to be selfish and screw the NYPD..." Elliot began
"...and in the process screwed each other." Rose laughed.
"Well we have two kids together so that would be right." Olivia replied laughing back.
"Two kids? I thought you said you were ten months married?"
"Twins." Olivia explained.
"Why don't we all go back next door and see what a classic Benson and Stabler tag team can get out of Donnelly?" Porter sighed knowing they were wasting time.
"Yeah come on El let's go and see more he'll give us." Olivia replied, she was tired and starting to get worn out.
When they arrived back in their own surveillance space Olivia and Huang discussed the different interrogation tactics she and Elliot could do to get him to give them another name.
"Donnelly like your fear but he didn't react well when Elliot became all macho. Let's see if good cop bad cop will work." Huang suggested.
"It won't." Olivia replied. "Like you said he liked our fear, we need to be scared, visibly scared." Olivia explained further.
"Go with the husband and wife routine, make it obvious that you're scared and have Elliot lead with comforting you be very touchy feely such as clutching her hand, squeezing her arm and wrapping an arm around her, react to him and need the comfort he's giving you." Huang explained.
"That we can do." Elliot smiled as Olivia began putting the small plastic ear piece back in place.
"Let's go." Olivia said nervously, they had an audience this time and they bloody well had to get something more out of the creep.
Olivia and Elliot walked back in and were greeted by a smiling Donnelly, it turned Olivia's stomach.
Don't show your disgust. Huang's voice warned her.
"Donnelly, I know you want to cover your own back but uh, we uh, we really need to know who else escaped." Olivia said trying to keep up the pretence of fear.
"Because I think you deserve it I'll give you another name. Mike Jergens."
"No." Olivia whispered still keeping up the act.
"Liv, Baby who is it?" Elliot asked wrapping his arm around her shoulder to comfort her.
Olivia had to think fast because she wasn't sure who he was for a moment.
"He uh, he was the rapist I had to go undercover with a dating service to catch, he was a surgeon." Olivia explained. "He then married his unstable girlfriend and then she drank because he said he was going to kill himself and then she ended up brain dead." She explained further.
"Yeah, he seemed slick." Donnelly shrugged.
"He took the right to switch off her life support from the mother, I thanked him for letting her mother hold her hand when she died and he turned around and said he wanted her death certificate drafted because he'd added her to his life insurance policy when they married and he was getting a one million pay out." Olivia explained. "He's pure evil and wouldn't be surprised if he was a psychopath."
"I remember the rapes, he picked locks with his surgical tools right?" Elliot asked.
"Yeah." Olivia nodded.
"His name as given you a scare Detective Benson." Donnelly smirked.
"Like I said, he's a psychopath." Olivia shuddered, he had scared her back then but she hadn't thought about him in years.
"Who else?" Olivia asked.
"Ah wouldn't you like to know?" Donnelly smirked.
"Who else?" Olivia asked again trying to sound extremely scared again.
"Let me see, someone has to scare you as much as the last one ...Hmm." Donnelly smirked.
Don't get angry Olivia, keep yourself together. Huang whispered knowing she was getting impatient.
"Daniel Hunter." Donnelly told them.
"I don't ..."
"You wouldn't." Elliot replied before Olivia had even finished talking, he knew what she was going to say.
"Who..."
"Daniel Hunter held me and Melinda hostage in a bank after he kidnapped his kid sister for ransom and Melinda found she had leukaemia. He shot his father and then he was going to walk out into suicide by cops but Melinda shot him in his leg saving his life." Elliot replied.
"God I remember that now, you and Melinda were really shook up from it." Olivia whispered.
"Yeah Mel more than I've ever seen her before, I mean, she was shot and she wasn't as shook up as she was when she shot the kid." Elliot replied.
Olivia crashed her head into his shoulder, the truth was she was scared, this wasn't acting because some of the worse people alive were out of prison and a lot of them had a grudge against her and her husband.
"El I can't do this anymore." She whispered before getting to her feet.
"What?" Elliot asked.
"I can't." She shrugged before leaving the room.
"Livia what happened?" Porter asked as Olivia pulled her ear piece out in frustration.
"I can't sit there and listen to him telling me about people we collared and lock up for some of the worst crimes ever imagined and watch him enjoy my reaction, do what you want with him for the next sixty hours Porter because I'm done, I'm going back to the one six and I am going to help find these bastards instead." Olivia explained.
"Ok, Huang call Fin and have him come here until then me and Porter can work on him." Elliot sighed knowing there was no point pushing Olivia if she didn't want to.
"But Olivia you've gotten so much out of him." Porter said rubbing her shoulder making her and Elliot uncomfortable.
"I know but I don't want to hear it anymore, radio me if he gives you more names or any other details we can use but I can't sit here and talk anymore." Olivia explained pulling on her jacket. "Come on Jess." Olivia added and the red head quickly followed her out.
I was bored of the interrogation and thought you'd like to see some of the criminals collared badass Benson style ;)