I don't own John, Randy, or anyone from WWE. I only own the OCs and plot.
Perfect: Chapter 8
It's been a few months since that incident with Jen and Randy and since John cheated for the first time on Maggie. John would have to admit that he never did stop. He couldn't help himself. He continued to cheat on Maggie, especially with Kelly and no one knew except himself and Kelly, but now it was starting to get suspicious and Jen had brought up the subject of cheating to him a couple times now, which meant Jen was getting suspicious about how Kelly and John were so friendly with each other. Jen never told Maggie though. Jen, of course asked Maggie a couple times if she thought that John would ever cheat and Maggie would just reply as "I never thought about it." Truth was Maggie was starting to think about it more and more everyday as John had started to get suspicious in her point of view. John would always be on his phone when she would be doing something like cooking for him at her house or checking his house every five minutes when watching a movie and sometimes when she wondered where he was, it went straight to voicemail and when she heard his voicemail, it worried her the most because he would usually answer his phone after a ring or two.
Maggie went downstairs for a midnight snack after not being able to sleep for the third night in a row and John, of course, not answering his phone for the tenth time. She covered herself more with her silk robe that John had gotten her for their 4 month anniversary and saw Jen going through the fridge and chuckled.
"You're up too?" Maggie asked as she opened the fridge door wider and saw Jen getting milk and ice for a smoothie she was going to make.
Jen chuckled and turned to go to the other counter and put two bananas in the blender with the milk and ice. "Yeah, I couldn't sleep." Was all she replied with before turning on the blender and blending the ingredients for the smoothie.
Maggie got out two cups and sighed as she waited as looked at the floor, biting her thumb nail nervously. She was wondering where John had gotten himself into or where he was. This is the third night in a row he's done this and he hasn't apologized to Maggie for it. He would just think that Maggie never knew about it because he would come crawling into her bed in the middle of the night and acted like nothing happened the next morning. It's been bothering Maggie since and she doesn't know what else to do. Jen looked up Maggie, worried as she poured the smoothie into the cups and took a sip of it.
"Maggie." Jen said as Maggie didn't move from her spot as she continued to bite on her nail as she looked at the floor, getting lost in her own thoughts. Jen shook Maggie.
"Maggie." Jen said as Maggie looked up from her thoughts and saw Jen holding her cup out and grinned.
"Thanks." Maggie replied and took the cup and took a drink out of it.
"What's wrong, Maggie?" Jen asked, not being able to deal with her unstable feelings in the room.
"Nothing, why do you ask?" Maggie asked then Jen looked at her like "come on, you're really going to give me that bullshit." Then Maggie sighed.
"John. This is the third night that he hasn't come home and I'm starting to get worried day by day. I'm scared he's cheating on me with someone." Maggie revealed the secret she has been holding in since John had started doing this and felt like she didn't have anyone to talk to. She guessed she forgot about Jen. She could tell her best friend anything and she felt relief once she revealed her secret and Jen sighed, knowing that John is most likely cheating on Maggie with Kelly. She had heard a bunch of rumors already in both locker rooms and just pushed those rumors away, thinking that John wouldn't do that. Though she didn't know for sure. She hasn't talked to Randy ever since that day she slapped him and told him to leave because of the argument they had gotten into because of Eric and her one night stand with him the night before.
"Have you tried calling him?" Jen asked and Maggie rolled her eyes.
"Of course, I have. I've called a bunch of times already and it goes to voicemail. He doesn't pick it up for the last three days during this time and I don't know why. I wish I knew." Maggie said as she sighed and went to the living room and turned on the TV to distract herself from her nervousness and stress and was happy enough to have a good movie be showing at this time. Jen followed Maggie into the living room and sat down next to her and Randy came into her mind.
"Have you talked to Randy?" Jen asked as Maggie nodded as she took a drink from her cup.
"Yeah, I talked to him before we left the arena." Maggie replied. "Why?"
"Nothing, I just wanted to know if you talked to him since him and I aren't talking." Jen replied as her eyes drifted from the TV to Maggie.
"He misses you, Jen." Maggie revealed something else. Jen was shocked. Why would he miss her if she slapped him because he talked shit about Eric that day? Of course, she missed him too, but Jen would have never thought about that. She thought he was still furious at her.
"Really?" Jen asked a small smile forming across her lips and Maggie nodded with a small grin.
"You should talk to him again. It's awkward when John and I are in a group with you and Randy and you two aren't talking or when you are there and Randy isn't and vice versa." Maggie replied.
Jen chuckled and took her last gulp of the smoothie and continued watching the movie then bit her bottom lip.
"Maggie, I've been hearing stuff in the locker rooms about John and a certain someone else." Jen said as she looked at her best friend and saw her facial expression change. Maggie expression changed from a worried one to more of a perturbed expression and saw her knuckles turn white from gripping the cup so hard, luckily the cup was plastic and it wouldn't break, but Jen knew it would crack soon so she removed the cup from Maggie's grip and settled it on the coffee table in front of the couch they were sitting on and Jen sighed.
"Calm down, Mags." Jen said as she felt regret once she said it.
"HOW THE FUCK AM I SUPPOSED TO CALM DOWN WHEN MY BOYFRIEND IS PROBABLY, MOST LIKELY CHEATING ON ME WITH A SLUT THAT EVERYONE KNOWS!" Maggie screamed at the top of her lungs and Jen flinched at her screaming then shrugged fearfully and continued to look at her best friend.
"Look okay, I don't even know if it's true yet, alright." Jen said quietly and Maggie rolled her eyes.
"You don't even know it's true and you're telling me? Dumb bitch, you're putting things in my mind." Maggie said harshly then Jen stressed her eyes at Maggie and got up, her height of 5'5 going over Maggie's height of 5'1 and she started to raise her voice.
"Look, okay, I was just trying to help! I heard some fucking rumors about John and Kelly in the locker rooms and it seems to be true, especially by how they act when they are around each other! Now you can call me to come back home when you're ready, because I'm not dealing with you blaming me because John is probably cheating on you. I'm done with it." Jen said her final words and went upstairs to go pack some things for herself. She wasn't going to take the blame for something she didn't do. She already had to deal with that when she was growing up with her siblings, she isn't going to continue to grow up with the same problem for the rest of her life. She slung the North Face backpack over her shoulder and grabbed her car keys and slammed the front door when she left. Maggie was still fuming and went upstairs, furious at Jen for putting stuff in her mind. She was also still fuming about John.
OoOoOoOoOo
John was driving home finally after another night with Kelly and was smiling the whole way back to Maggie's house. He furrowed his eyebrows when he didn't see Jen's car in the driveway and wondered where Jen had gone off to. He just shrugged and grabbed his equipment from wrestling and headed inside. Strangely, the lights were on and he heard crying upstairs. He dropped the duffle bag near the door and took off his jacket and hung it up in the closet downstairs and slowly went upstairs and heard something with glass hit the floor, he already knew small pieces were on the floor and ran up the stairs to find Maggie having a breakdown and he quickly held her and twirled her and sat her on the bed. It obviously wasn't easy as she fought against him and told him to let go of her and she cried and cried and continuously tried to comfort her, but nothing was helping. He lifted her and sat on the bed and placed Maggie on his lap. The only thing different this time was that she was gripping him like she usually would whenever she would have a breakdown from stress.
"Honey, what's wrong?" John asked soothingly as he stroked her back gently trying to get her to stop crying.
"Don't call me honey, you bastard." Maggie said as her voice cracked. John looked at her with wide eyes.
"What?" John asked, did he just hear what she think she said?
"I said don't call me honey, you bastard." Maggie said harshly and got up from his lap and walked around the glass that was shattered on the floor and walked downstairs, appalled.
"Hey, hey, wait, what's your problem?" John asked as he grabbed her wrist and turned her to make her face him and stop walking.
"Are you cheating on me?" Maggie asked angrily and John swallowed roughly. How did she found out? Did someone tell her? Shit, he was in deep trouble now.
oOoOoOoOoOoOo
Jen drove into the driveway of a house and rung the bell and slightly grinned when she saw the person at the door.
"Hey." Jen greeted
"Hey, we haven't talked in a couple months." Randy said tiredly as he rubbed his eye. He was in a tank top and gym shorts.
"Yeah, I know. Sorry about that. About what I did that day." Jen apologized and Randy smiled tiredly.
"It's fine, Jen. Can I ask why you are here?" Randy asked as he chuckled slightly and Jen smiled.
"I need a place to stay for the night or maybe a couple days." Jen replied and Randy chuckled and opened the door wider for her to come in.
"You can sleep in the guest room if you want." Randy said as he closed the door after she entered.
"I'll just sleep on the couch." Jen said and smiled when she saw Randy's dog and petted the dog's head and placed her backpack in one of the one person seat and took off her bunny slippers and Randy laughed.
"Nice shoes." Randy said and Jen rolled her eyes, playfully.
"Shut up." Jen chuckled. Randy went to get Jen a blanket and handed it to her when he came back to the living room.
"So can I ask why you came here and how did you know I live here?" Randy asked as he crossed his arms and look at Jen open the folded blanket and laid back on the couch and made herself comfortable.
"Maggie and I got into an argument and I got your address from someone because they wanted us to make up and be friends again or whatever." Jen said
"So you never forgot it?" Randy asked and Jen shook her head.
"It was on a piece of paper in my backpack." Jen replied and snuggled her head into one of the pillows and Randy chuckled once again. He found her to be so adorable at times and he loved it.
"Alright, whatever. I'm going to go back to sleep and I'll see you in the morning, night Jen." Randy said as he headed upstairs back to his room.
"Night, Orton." Jen replied and Randy smiled as he heard her.
oOoOoOoOoOoOoOo
John's bags were at the door. He was truly leaving this house, he called his second home. He can't believe the argument didn't go beyond his and Maggie' reach.
"Can't we talk it out?" John asked and Maggie shook her head as she crossed her eyes and turned her head towards the TV in the living room and John sighed. He grabbed his two huge bags and carried them to the car.
"I won't stop loving you, Maggie." John said and all the response he got was a slammed door to the face. He saw the lights slowly turn off in the house, he sighed and put his bags in the car and drove away. He was now going home and away from his home. He didn't want to leave. Now he realized he has made the biggest mistake in his life. He needed Maggie back.