Title: I Knew You Were Trouble: Never Thought It Would Feel This Good
Rating: M for language and smut.
Pairing: Seblaine, Ex-Klaine; AnderCohen-Chang, Blam, & Blittany friendship.
Genre: Angst, Friendship to Romance
Warning: SeBlaingst (as a whole); underage drinking, rimming & sex (this chapter)
Word Count: 4,874
Summary: In Which, Kurt broke up with Blaine to prove himself in NY leaving Blaine heartbroken. This is a story of how Sebastian became what Blaine needed without either of them realizing it or having been prepared for it.
A/N As you can see I changed the title because I just felt like this would fit better. I like it better for sure. So I had a dream that I got really negative feedback from this so that was a bit disheartening but it was just a dream. Yeah? Here's to not backing out of this one. So this was a lot longer than expected if there is any mistakes sorry, this is un-beta'd so all mistakes are mine, but le smut commence ici! yay!
Blaine walked into his house with the shortest and tightest bottoms he'd ever seen on the boy. He was pretty sure the boy was supposed to be Bam-Bam but he couldn't be bothered to care what he was. Blaine was all bashful smiles and blushing cheeks; it was infuriating.
Sebastian wasn't the type of guy one could easily garner attention from. It took a lot to get him to give you the time of day and if ever he did, it was naturally no more than an hour for a fuck and after that you were yesterday's news. Things always seemed different when it came to Blaine though. The boy had a way of making him feel a million different things and nothing all at once. He was a mix of innocence and sex appeal the way only Blaine knew how to be. Sebastian couldn't get enough and wanted nothing to do with it at the same time and Jesus Christ it was infuriating.
Tonight Blaine was just so sexy and Sebastian was baffled by how anyone, namely himself, was supposed to resist bending the younger boy over and fucking him right then and there. His fellow Warblers, however, made it clear that he was to be nothing but respectful and mindful with Blaine or they'd cut him loose. There was absolutely no risking Blaine leaving again and considering he wasn't anyone's favorite (or even liked to be honest) amongst the Warblers he didn't want to lose his spot as Co-Captain.
It's not that he cared about what those idiots had to say it just he really did love the perform and if standing across the room and keeping his urges to himself meant he got to continue to do that then so be it.
Sebastian watched as Blaine flirted and danced with the eligible gays of Dalton. He fought the flare of jealously that tried to take over his senses, telling him to walk over there and place a protective hand around the boy. He fought the urge to glare at every guy even looking at Blaine, gay or straight, until they backed off because it wasn't his place. He wasn't Blaine's boyfriend nor did he want to be because he doesn't do boyfriends and even Blaine wasn't going to change that so he needed to stop this. The boy had a way of getting to Sebastian like no one else but Sebastian would never open himself up to that. It still didn't stop the greed of wanting everyone in the room to know Blaine was his.
He needed a drink.
"Everyone is so nice!" Blaine yelled brightly over the thump of the music.
Sam, who was the designated driver and therefore sober, grinned ear to ear and shook his head in disbelief. One: Blaine was beyond drunk. He rarely got like this anymore; not since the scandals incident with Kurt last year. Two: Sam was fairly certain the boys Blaine's "everyone" referred to were being a little more than nice. Sure he didn't know a lot about a lot of things but it didn't take a genius to see how the other boys were eyeing his best friend. Some of them he was certain were straight which was amusing if not a little bit confusing for him.
"Blaine I feel like these guys have a little more on their minds than friendship dude" Sam replied amused as he watched Blaine pull Tina towards him back to chest and grinded up against her. The cat woman clad girl laughed and danced along. She was just shy of drunk, dangling off the edge of tipsy, and it showed in the way she moved her body against Blaine's without any reservations.
Blaine completely missed Sam's comment as he lost himself in the music and dance. He hadn't felt this good in a while. All his friends from Dalton were excited to have him back; many he didn't know where happy to get to know him. He felt wanted. It felt good to just be free and dance with his friends and make new ones. He would have to thank his friends later for convincing him to come; maybe this was just what he needed.
Blaine was startled when a pair of soft hands gripped his waist and soft lips pressed up against his ear.
"Blaine Warbler, someone wants to meet you" Blaine pulled away from Tina and turned swiftly to face Brittany. The motion caused him to stumble into Sam who helped him get his footing back with steady arms.
"Brittany!" Blaine and Tina exclaimed together circling the blonde into a group hug. The yellow dot in the middle of her white dress was itchy against Blaine's skin so he pulled away and surveyed her costume taking in the dress and her horns and tail. It hadn't occurred to him that he had no idea what the girl was, but now it seemed imperative that he knew.
"Brittany what are you?"
Brittany smiled brightly and flipped her hair. "I'm a deviled egg." She replied as if they should have known.
"That's actually kind of brilliant Brit" Tina giggled into Blaine's shoulder and nodded.
Before they could carry on the tall boy standing behind Brittany cleared his throat as the point of the conversation had veered off significantly and he really wanted to talk to Blaine.
Brittany turned back to him and her smile widened. "Oh Blaine this is Eli!" She clapped her hands excitedly as the boys shook hands. "He really wanted to meet you"
"We actually met last year but you were a bit preoccupied."
Blaine blushed. Eli was really very gorgeous. His accent was something like a dream. He was much taller than Blaine and his dirty blonde bangs, being the longest part of his hair, swooped in front of his blue-grey eyes. He had this sexy crooked smile that left Blaine a bit speechless. There was also something familiar about the boy that Blaine couldn't quite place. The words the boy spoke finally caught up with him and he froze.
"I was pr-we met?"
"Yeah, at the last end of summer bash. You were um busy with your boyfriend. I noticed he's nowhere to be seen, is it too soon to count my lucky stars? I was hoping we could get to know each other now that you're no longer attached to his face." Eli closed most of the distance between himself and Blaine, leaving about an inch of breathing space.
Everything Blaine had been burying down emotionally came rushing back to the surface tearing right through his heart and leaving him breathless in all the worst way. He completely closed in on himself and shied away from Eli's attention, not that the other boy noticed; he was still standing too close for comfort with that stupid crooked smile. Blaine suddenly felt hot, hot under his skin and hot tears threatening to spill out of his eyes.
Sam took one look at Blaine and squeezed himself between the two boys.
"Dude too soon. I think you need to back off."
Eli sputtered as he took in the angry look in the other boys green eyes and then the way Blaine stared blankly at the ground.
"I'm sorry man. I didn't mean to cause any problems. I just wanted to-"
"Just go dude. We'll handle it."
Eli quickly turned away, throwing an apologetic look over his shoulder at Blaine before he was enveloped by the crowd.
"I'm sorry Blaine. I didn't know he was going to hurt your feelings."
"Brit it wasn't your fault. Do you need anything honey? Do you want to go?"
"Dude, we can go if you want"
Blaine barely registered what his friends were saying. It was like the alcohol made the hurt worse. Made it burn a little more and weigh a little heavier on his heart. He needed to not feel like this anymore. He needed more alcohol.
"No, I want to stay. I'll um just get another drink." He didn't look at the worried expressions on his friend's faces as he turned away and headed towards the kitchen.
"What the hell did you say to him?"
"Oi, get your hands off me!"
Sebastian shoved the boy harder into the wall puffing his chest and closing in on the other boy.
"Why do you even care Smythe?" the boy spat angrily.
"I don't I-"Sebastian back away slightly. Why did he care?
"Well you might want to fucking act like it. Besides the boy is already damaged; not much left for you to ruin so don't bother."
Sebastian balled his hand into fist so tight he was sure the nails digging into his palms were drawing blood.
"I suggest you find your way off my property"
"Fuck you Sebastian."
"Oh Eli, you already have. It was mediocre at best; nothing to write home about; I committed the rest of that afternoon convincing myself it never happened."
Sebastian, with as much grace as his inebriated state would allow, turned on the balls of his feet, leaving those words hanging in the tense air before Eli could get a word in edgewise.
He made his way towards the kitchen where he last saw Blaine heading.
Sebastian leaned against the archway with his arms crossed across his chest and watched as Blaine focusing on trying to get every bit of rum he was pouring into his solo cup. He was failing miserably, being considerably drunk and all, but it was adorable and Sebastian couldn't help but stand back and take it in. Even like this Blaine was beautiful.
Sebastian shook his head of his thoughts, rushing over towards Blaine, and placed a hand over the cup before it reached the boy's full lips.
"I think you've had enough, Killer."
Blaine snatched his hand away effectively spilling much of the cups contents on his chest. "Screw you. I can drink if I want to." He glared down at his chest then back up at Sebastian. "You made me spill my drink" he pouted.
Sebastian stared down at Blaine's chest. What he wouldn't do to shove the smaller boy against the counter and follow that liquid trail with his tongue.
"Don't be ridiculous B." Sebastian broke his gaze away from Blaine's chest opting to stare into his honey eyes instead. "At this rate, if you drink anymore, you'll poison yourself. A night in the ER is hardly what I had in mind for the last Warbler summer party."
Blaine scoffed "Like you would even stay with me"
Sebastian turned away, busying himself with pouring a glass of water for his drunken friend. Blaine's doubt hurt more than he was willing to let on.
"I would. We're friends now Blaine and I don't want to see you hurt."
"Is that what you told yourself when you tossed that slushy laced with rock salt at my face."
Ouch.
He deserved it. He knew he did, but it hurt like hell to hear it thrown back in his face. He truly was sorry for what had happened to Blaine that night. He'd gotten out of hand and Blaine paid the price, not to mention Blaine still harbored unresolved anger from how the situation was handled (or not handled). Yet for some reason he knew he would take it because he wasn't going to give up on Blaine.
"I'm aware of what I did Blaine and I've already apologized. You're angry, I get it. It's not about that night, but I'll let you take it out on me if it means you're not drinking yourself to the point of a medical emergency." Sebastian took the solo cup out of Blaine's hand and replaced it with the glass of what he poured.
Blaine sighed dejectedly and muttered a "thanks" before taking the glass and downing it. Sebastian observed the muscles in Blaine's throat swallow the water down. Blaine's body was mesmerizing, even when doing something as mundane as swallowing water.
The boys stood silently in each other's company while Blaine finished off his glass of water.
"I guess I'll just-" Blaine pointed awkwardly at the Kitchen entrance as a way of indicating his return to the party.
Before he could walk away Sebastian grabbed his arm and asked, "Do you um. Do you want to dance?"
Silence.
"I, uh"
"You don't have to, I know you don't-"
"Yeah okay"
"Yeah?"
"Yes Seb, C'mon"
"Shit what are we doing?"
"Well Seb. I don't know if you need me to lay it out for you step by step, but I'm pretty sure we're about to fuck."
This was an unforeseen turn of events. It was only hours before when the two boys were stumbling back into the party awkwardly trying to find a rhythm with the music and each other's bodies. Before he realized it, Blaine spent hours grinding against Seb, the sexual tension steadily rising.
It started out tame enough with a generous distance between the two boys but the lack of space found them flush against each other basically grinding and it was hot. At one point one of Sebastian's hands found itself squeezing Blaine's ass, the other running through his curls, tilting his head to the side as he whispered what a good dancer he was and how beautiful he looked. That's what did it for Blaine, he realizes, landing them against the wall, next to the door leading to Sebastian's room, with Blaine's legs wrapped around Seb's waist, kissing like they air was a non-issue.
Sebastian reluctantly pulled his lips away from Blaine's neck and stared into the curly haired boy's lust blown eyes. His own eyes were dark with want and he was panting to catch his breath. There was no doubt this was what he wanted. It was all he wanted since he first laid eyes on Blaine but he needed to know that other boy wanted this too.
"Maybe we shouldn't. We're drunk and shit Blaine."
Blaine reached between their bodies, slid his hand past the waistband of his pants and boxers, gripped Sebastian's erection and squeezed.
His voice was low and husky in Seb's ear when he spoke. "I haven't had a drink in hours Seb. I've sobered up considerably. I'm just drunk enough to allow myself to give in to what I want and what I want is you. I want you inside me Seb. I want you to fuck me."
Sebastian growled and crashed his lips against Blaine's. The kiss was dirty from the start, all teeth and tongue and no finesse but it was hot as shit and everything they needed. Seb wrapped one arm around Blaine's tiny waist the other gripping his round ass for support as he pulled away from the wall and crashed through the door into his room.
Once in the room Sebastian gently tossed Blaine onto his bed, spread his legs and settled between them, their mouths finding each other's immediately. The kiss was softer than the previous, Sebastian licking across Blaine's lips seeking permission to enter. Blaine recognized the request immediately and opened his mouth to let him in. Sebastian's tongue ran along the top of Blaine's mouth causing the younger boy to whine high in the back of his throat. The sound caused any remaining blood in Sebastian's body to rush down to his cock. He grabbed Blaine's hips and aligned their bodies and ground down hard.
Blaine jerked and wrapped his legs tight around Sebastian's waist, moaning loudly into the older boy's mouth. Upon hearing Blaine's moan, Sebastian knew he could dedicate the rest of his life to making the curly haired boy to make that sound. Sebastian ground down again and again, quickly finding a slow hard rhythm and reveling in the sounds Blaine was making.
"Bet you never thought it would feel this good did you B." He whispered hotly in his ear. Blaine whimpered in his ear in reply.
"Tell. Me." He punctuated each word with a hard thrust causing the curly haired boy to cry out.
"F-feels so good Seb. Ahhh b-better than I thought. S-so g-good."
Sebastian could feel Blaine's body tensing in the tell-tale sign that he was about to come and abruptly halted his movements sitting up and staring down at Blaine. Blaine's body shuddered and he whined as he opened his eyes to look at Sebastian. God this was happening. He was going to have sex with Sebastian.
"Do you want me to fuck you Blaine." Blaine nodded. He'd feel embarrassed by how eager he was at the notion of having Sebastian's cock in his ass but he couldn't find it in him to car. He wanted it. He wanted to be filled and fucked within an inch of his life.
"Yes, please Seb."
"D'you like getting fucked?" Sebastian's hands were roaming all over Blaine's body. Stopping every once in a while to squeeze his nipples or grip his waist and grind their clothed cocks together making it hard for Blaine to think never mind answer him.
"I've uh only ever fuck b-bottomed a few times, but, uh y-yeah."
The light in Sebastian's eyes was unmistakable. He leaned down and grazed his lips against the shell of his ear before whispering: "I'm going to make this so good for you Killer."
With that Sebastian leaned over to his bedside table switched the lamp on, and flooding the room with nearly too much light. He could almost hear the self-conscious thoughts filling Blaine's mind. He paused his search and turned to the curly haired boy in time to see him trying to shield himself.
"Stop that B. The light stays on." He continued to search through his drawer, momentarily fearing that he might not have the supplies he needed. Luckily he found the a half empty bottle of lube and a condom, and with a small cry of victory he returned to his spot between Blaine's legs. "I want to see you and I want you to see only me." He brushed his fingers over Blaine's lips and across his cheeks. Green eyes met honey-green and smiled gently. "I want you to only think of me. You have nothing to worry about Blaine, you're beautiful." Sebastian didn't know if he'd ever get another chance like that and he wanted to savor every bit of this experience. He hoped Blaine would go along with it, but he would never force it.
Blaine visibly relaxed against the pillows underneath him and smiled in return. Sebastian took this as a sign to continue and ran his fingers softly down Blaine's chest past his navel to outline the bottoms of Blaine's costume. He waited in silent request until Blaine nodded.
Blaine watched as Sebastian eagerly pulled down the bottoms to his costume and his deep blue boxer-briefs in one go. He waited on baited breath as Sebastian took in the sight of his exposed cock, thick and pink and glistening with pre-come from the frotting. It seemed like forever of Sebastian just staring, saying nothing, and Blaine squirmed with uncertainty. He heard Sebastian let out a heavy sigh and looked up to find his eyes had darkened (if even possible) his irises almost completely gone.
Sebastian leaned back down over him and whispered hotly into his ear. "You've got a pretty cock Blaine. So big, bigger than I expected. God you're so beautiful like this, laid out for me to fuck you."
His voice was gravely and thick with lust causing Blaine's dick to twitch in response.
"So fuck me. Please. Clothes off."
Sebastian nodded and removed his shirt, pants, and boxers in record time. Blaine audibly gulped. It would have been comical under different circumstances. Sebastian was huge. Like really huge. Bigger than him, and he was generously endowed. His cock was longer and thicker, curved a little to the right, hot and hard right in front of him in all its glory and Blaine couldn't quite figure out how that was supposed to fit in him, but he wanted it. God he needed it!
"I'm up here Blaine" Seb joked. He laughed as he watched Blaine's hazel eyes slowly roll away from his dick and up his body to meet his eyes.
"You ready?" Blaine nodded his body flushing down to his chest with arousal at the anticipation of what was to come (no pun intended)
"Spread your legs for me baby." Blaine spread his legs as wide as he could, his feet lifting off the bed a little, giving Sebastian a clear view of his dusty pink hole. The older boy let out a soft moan at the sight. He placed his hands on the backs of Blaine's knees and pushed his legs further apart, licking his lips and smirking. He scooted closer so he could maneuver the head of his dick to rub across Blaine's entrance watching has it clenched and unclenched trying to take in what it could.
"Please Seb" Blaine whined. He really needed to be fucked, and Sebastian was teasing him.
Sebastian backed up a little then bent down to put his face in direct proximity of Blaine's ass and swiped his tongue over the boy's hole.
"Yesssss!" Blaine moaned loudly, his hands fisting the bed covers until his knuckles turned white.
Sebastian continued to swipe his tongue over Blaine's hole over and over not applying enough pressure to do much but keep the want burning in his gut, reducing the boy to a whimpering mess.
Blaine wanted nothing more than to grip Sebastian's hair and push his face deeper into his ass until he got what he wanted but couldn't bring himself to be so bold. Eventually Sebastian had mercy on him and stiffened his tongue over Blaine's hole. He pushed slowly past the first ring of muscle until his tongue was as far as it could go. Blaine let out a long drawn out "Uhhn" breaking off into a high pitched whine and the slick feeling of Sebastian's tongue fucking in and out of his tight hole.
Sebastian grabbed his ass cheeks and pulled the globes apart for better access.
"Uhn, uhhnn. Fuck Seb yess. Ah, ah, ah" Seb moaned in response causing Blaine's hips to jerk forward. "Shit Sebastian." At this point Blaine was a heaving, moaning mess. His legs were shaking and sweat layered his skin. Sebastian could feel that he was close to coming so he pulled away causing the boy to groan in protest.
Sebastian reached for the lube as he crashed his lips to Blaine's to distract him as he lubed up his fingers and slip two in at once. He wanted to be thorough, he knew he was bigger than average, but his neglected cock was so hard it hurt and he needed to be in Blaine's tight heat. Blaine moaned wantonly at the contact holding nothing back. He was past the point of being self-conscious about the noises he was making.
Sebastian pumped roughly in and out of Blaine's tight heat, scissoring his fingers before adding a third. He paused and waiting for Blaine to adjust remembering that this wasn't something he was used to. When Blaine nodded he continued his quick thrusts and crooked his fingers.
"FUCK! Theretheretherethere! Uhhnnn Ahhh" Blaine arched off the bed, gripped Sebastian's shoulders and dug his blunt nails into his skin as he fucked himself down on Sebastian's fingers. Sebastian leaned down close to his ear and licked and sucked at the lobe. The noise Blaine was making was hot enough for him to come off alone but he couldn't yet. Not until he was buried in that tight heat and god was Blaine tight.
"I don't want you to regret this in the morning Blaine. I don't want you to regret me, but even if you do, I want you to always remember how good it felt to have me inside you with my mouth, my fingers, and my cock. I want you to come just from the thought of me. You're so hot right now fucking yourself on my fingers. So good Blaine"
"I won't, I uhhn yess fuck yess. I won't re-fuck-gret this. Want you. Need you Seb. Fuck me now!"
Sebastian pulled his fingers out. He grabbed the condom, opened the wrapper with his teeth and rolled in onto his cock, the friction causing him to grunt and thrust into his fist a couple of times. He grabbed the lube and poured some into the palm of his hands, slicking up his cock and wiping the remainder over Blaine's stretched hole.
Sebastian placed a pillow under Blaine's hips for a better angle and laced his clean hand with Blaine's above Blaine's head. With his other hand he guided his cock to Blaine's entrance.
Slowly he pushed in and it was like the air was punch out of him. Blaine. Was. Fucking. Tight. Like a damn virgin. He resisted the urge to slam in and fuck Blaine roughly until he climaxed like he usually did with other lays. Blaine was different, this had to be perfect so he pushed in slowly until he was buried to the hilt; his hips flush against Blaine's ass.
"Blaine" He moaned breathlessly. "You fuck. You feel so good."
Blaine for his part felt like he was going to explode. He felt so full and stretched to his capacity. It hurt a lot at first, but now it was like a dull burning that was more pleasure than pain. He could feel Sebastian shaking from trying to hold still so he squeezed Sebastian's hand in his and pulled him down by his hair with the other and kissed him rough and dirty. "Move"
Sebastian let out a sigh of relief—he wasn't sure he could hold off much longer. He pulled back slowly then thrust back in marginally quicker over and over and until he found a rhythm that worked for them; Blaine meeting him thrust for thrust.
Blaine's Ah, Ah's grew louder and higher in pitch and the thrust grew faster and harder. Sebastian's grunts weaving with his moans making the most beautiful sound he thinks. (which is a feat considering thinking is proving more and more difficult.)
Sebastian wrapped Blaine's legs securely around his waist, leaned back on his heels, and held Blaine's hips up as he fucked into him fast and hard. Throwing his head back and groaning Blaine's name long and drawn out.
"Ahh Seb. Fuck. Ahh ahh, uhhhnn" Blaine arched off the bed his body vibrating with pleasure. He hadn't felt this good in months. He never wanted this to end, but he could feel himself getting close. "I'm close, I'm close fuUCK!" Blaine broke off into a yelp as Sebastian pulled him up so he was sitting on his lap, the new angle making it so every thrust brought Seb's cock in contact with his prostate."
"Fuck Seb yesyesyesyeyes. Rightthere shit right there ah Seb I need, I need" without any further instruction Seb wrapped his hand around Blaine's cock, causing the boy's body to spasm and him to cry out. He was practically wailing at this point and Seb couldn't get enough. Seeing Blaine like this was the hottest thing he's ever witnessed and it was all because of him. He's thrust were becoming erratic and he could feel his climax building.
"Do you want to come B?"
"Yes, yes please Seb. I need it."
"Then come sweetheart. Come for me"
With that Blaine's eyes rolled back, he tensed then fucked himself down hard and fast, almost violently so, as he came hard, covering both of their chests with come and crying out nonsensical things interwoven with fucks, shits and Seb's name over and over again.
A half a dozen thrusts later and Sebastian was falling over the edge as well. The combination of Blaine clenching and unclenching on his cock, and the curly haired boy constantly whispering, "fuck Seb" in his ear proving to be too much. He fucked into Blaine roughly though his orgasm then fell forward on top of Blaine as he came down from the best orgasm he's had in a very long time. Blaine was still shaking from the aftershock of his orgasm when Seb pulled out of Blaine, covered their naked forms and laid on his back next to a very sated Blaine.
"Fuck B. That was"
"Yeah."
He wasn't sure what to do now. Most of the time he kicked his partners out after the deed unless they passed out, in which case he expected them to be gone before he woke up the next morning but he never wanted this to end with Blaine. He wanted to keep him here in his bed for as long as he could have him. It scared him; wanting Blaine this much. Shouldn't the they at least get cleaned up?
Luckily Blaine curled into his side, wrapping his arms around Seb's waist muttering something that sounded like goodnight and putting an end to his dilemma for the night. He hesitantly wrapped his arms around the younger boys form and buried his nose into his curls. Blaine smelled like sex and apple cinnamon spice. He smelled amazing and Seb tightened his hold on the younger boy. They could get cleaned up later. Sleep pulled him under giving him the best rest he's had in a long time.
END A/N
That ending was kind of blah but it's 4AM so hopefully it will suffice. This is my first time writing posting smut so…*hides* No preview tonight. Maybe I'll post it tomorrow. I'm going to bed now!