A/N: Okay, so quick explanation for those who didn't read Truth or Dare or who need a refresher. This story is set during three after Tyler broke the sire bond, but basically April became friends with Rebekah... So Hayley never slept with Klaus and never got pregnant...
The current pairing as of the start of this story are: Caroline/Klaus, Matt/Rebekah, Stefan/Elena, Jeremy/Bonnie, Tyler/Hayley, Katherine/Elijah, April/Kol (I swear it makes sense if you read the first one), and Damon/Alaric (But other people didn't know about it yet and they aren't exactly admitting it to themselves)
"Never have I ever made out with five guys in one night," Alaric said.
Damon had been dared into making out with Jeremy, Klaus, Matt, Elijah, and Kol at the last party. The dare was clearly directed at him as he took a drink.
Katherine also took a drink.
"Never have I ever been bottom to Alaric," Katherine said with a smirk as she was clearly trying to confirm her guess that Damon had been bottom when he had slept with Alaric.
Damon took a drink while Alaric looked down at his own to avoid the glances of the others.
"Never have I ever had sex with Caroline," Elijah spoke up.
Caroline winced a little at that as Damon, Matt, Tyler, and Klaus all drank.
"I have a theory to test," April said with a grin. "Never have I ever been bottom to Damon."
Rebekah and Caroline immediately drank and after a few seconds Alaric muttered something under his breath before drinking too.
There were several smirks directed over at Alaric and Damon and a few confused glances over at Katherine for not drinking.
"What, I like top," She said with an innocent shrug.
Stefan looked over at Damon and Alaric and commented, "You two made it sound like it only happened once."
"But I'm such a magical sex god that he came crawling back for- Hey!" Damon was cut off by Alaric roughly hitting him… It was not a playful hit; it was a shut up now hit. "Can't you keep your hands off of me for two seconds?"
"I hate you so much right now." Alaric told him.
All eyes were focussed on the pair as Kol said, "Never have I ever slept with Damon more than ten times."
Caroline, Katherine, and Alaric all drank, Alaric taking a large chug from his drink. Rebekah managed to get off of the hook for that one.
"Never have I ever been top to Katherine," Hayley said curiously.
At first it appeared that nobody was going to drink, but after a few seconds Elijah did as Katherine smirked.
"Never have I ever slept with an Original," Tyler said.
Damon, Stefan, Caroline, Katherine, April, and Matt all drank.
"I feel like we're playing the get Caroline drunk game again," Caroline pointed out. "I've had to drink more than anyone else here."
"It's not our fault that it's so hard to think of something that you haven't done," Matt commented.
Caroline stared at him in shock for a few seconds before sending him a glare.
"I haven't had to drink yet," Bonnie told her.
"In that case, never have I ever been a witch," Matt said.
Bonnie rolled her eyes a little as she took a drink.
"What we should be playing is the get Elijah drunk game. That's a fun one," Rebekah commented. "Never have I ever been the oldest one here."
Elijah looked unimpressed with his sister as he drank.
Katherine, on the other hand, looked delighted by the new game of trying to get Elijah drunk.
Elena looked directly at Caroline as she said, "Never have I ever made someone cry because they weren't putting decorations up right."
Caroline took a sip of her drink.
"Never have I ever turned into a wolf," Stefan commented.
Hayley, Tyler, and Klaus all drank.
"Never have I ever cheated on Caroline," Klaus said pointedly.
Tyler reluctantly drank and Caroline was a little surprised when Damon didn't.
Caroline debated directing hers at Elena before deciding on something else.
"Never have I ever slept with someone who had a girlfriend at the time," She provided.
Hayley and Katherine both drank.
"Never have I ever slept with Damon more times than he's slept with Katherine," Jeremy spoke up, clearly still trying to figure out what exactly was going on between Damon and Alaric.
Alaric reluctantly turned to give Damon a questioning glance.
Damon gave him a slight nod before Alaric drank.
Bonnie seemed to be on board with the plan to get Elijah drunk as she said, "Never have I ever had a name that started with the letter E."
Elijah and Elena both drank.
It was Damon's turn, so Alaric shot him a warning glare.
Damon didn't seem to notice or care as he said, "Never have I ever been a manipulative little bitch."
Katherine rolled her eyes as she drank. Caroline seemed to inwardly debate with herself for a second before drinking as well.
"Never have I ever killed my best friend," Alaric commented.
"Pfff, you're fine," Damon muttered before drinking. "Don't be such a drama queen."
"Never have I ever kissed five guys in one night and overdramatically pretended not to like it when really I enjoy kissing men," Katherine piped up.
Several sets of eyes turned to look over at Damon who just sat there without moving.
"That means you, Damon," Stefan spoke up.
"I thought that the game was that you only drink if you have done what they say," Damon replied.
"We were there," Bonnie pointed out. "We know that you're lying."
"Never have I ever enjoyed kissing a guy that wasn't Alaric," Damon told them, skipping over most of the people to steal another turn for himself.
A/N: Please read and review! I hope that you guys liked the chapter and thanks for reading. Seriously, you guys are amazing. I posted the first chapter less than 48 hours ago and there's already 56 reviews, 91 favourites, and 164 followers... Wow. :D
If anyone wants me to write a drabble for them, I have a new account on tumblr where I write requests. The url is tvddrabbles and then you just have to add .tumblr and .com
A super big extra special thanks goes out to all of the incredible reviewers of the first chapter: jhemlovesdamon, sammiix23, julia, Saba, chibichibi98, Mystery Girl3, Thevampiresrulez, Look At My Comment, karensevani, fashiongrrlie, xXMaleseXx, SpringOfMay, xxvampiresgreatestweaknessxx, layaboo, red-as-a-rose12335, helfabulousgirl, XXXXKlarolineLoveXXXX, Klaroline66, saule-teja, vampirelovver, Areimis, EllieDolmanxx, Georgia-Will-Suffice, IrishBeauty294, justine, ferrylis, Lovelife05, WeasleysGroupie, lateVMlover, jessnicole, idsaveyouinaheartbeat, Rose Jean Black, Creative Murderer, Riannon, KolsGal88, crazy-pomegranate, Maya, Cathalinaheart, Team Mikaelson, 3, DrawingMyHeartOut, cj moore, Klaroline-teenwolf, glevez25, AngelOfMusic44, beckie2009i, PainfullyShy, LitLover 101, WalkingDeadXOXO, The Hunger Games - My Life, Jenn, MJTE, Nymphadora Lupin 99, vampiremovielove and the two anonymous guest reviewers