A/N: So once again I received questions about pairings in reviews on the last chapter. I doubt that the people asking are going to read this, since I had an author's note explaining things at the start of last chapter and got questions anyways, but I guess I'll put it here just in case anyways...
The current pairing as of the start of this story are: Caroline/Klaus, Matt/Rebekah, Stefan/Elena, Jeremy/Bonnie, Tyler/Hayley, Katherine/Elijah, April/Kol (I swear it makes sense if you read the first one), and Damon/Alaric (But other people didn't know about it yet and they aren't exactly admitting it to themselves)
"Never have I ever enjoyed kissing a guy that wasn't Alaric," Damon told them, skipping over most of the people to steal another turn for himself.
Although Damon had gone when it wasn't really his turn, the others decided to allow it and drank anyways.
Hayley, Katherine, Elena, Rebekah, Bonnie, Caroline, April, and Alaric all had to drink.
Next it was technically Elijah's turn still, so he spoke up with, "Never have I ever cried over a ruined dress."
Rebekah, who it had been targeted at, and Elena both drank.
Elena had cried over a dress that her mother had given her getting badly stained beyond fixing after the car accident that had killed her parents.
"Of course you haven't," Katherine commented with a suggestive smirk. "That's because you like being the one to rip them off."
Elijah didn't bother responding to that as he just turned and waited for April to take her turn.
"Never have I ever been daggered by Klaus," She spoke up.
Kol grinned happily since not only did he get to drink, Elijah also had to. And Kol was beyond on board with the idea of getting Elijah drunk. Rebekah also seemed happy with Elijah having to drink as she drank from her own cup.
"Never have I ever-" Kol began.
"Try not to take five minutes to think of one this time," Katherine interrupted him to suggest.
"Never have I ever had sex in a moving car," Kol said, having to include the moving part so that it would be true.
It wasn't overly surprising when Rebekah, Damon, and Katherine all drank… What was surprising was when Elijah did, although Katherine's drinking did at least explain it. Nevertheless, Kol still felt the need to raise an eyebrow at his brother and smirk before turning away.
"Never have I ever slept with someone before telling them that I already had a girlfriend," Hayley said, turning to look over at the person sitting next to her.
Tyler reluctantly drank as all eyes turned to look at him, knowing exactly who that had been directed at.
"Never have I ever compelled someone to cheat on Caroline," Tyler said as soon as he had finished drinking.
Caroline's head quickly whipped around to look at Klaus in a combination of shock, confusion, and sheer disbelief.
There was a painfully long pause before Klaus ever so hesitantly brought his drink to his lips.
Although Tyler hadn't been positive that it was what had happened, he had definitely had a suspicion about it for a long time and had decided to take the opportunity to find out. He had thought that he would be happy to know, but he was anything but that.
Caroline's right hand, which had been intertwined with Klaus's left one, quickly pulled away as she shifted to sit farther away from him while staring at him with a gaping mouth and wide eyes.
Klaus turned to look at her with guilty eyes as he said, "I believe that my exact words were-"
"Don't." Caroline said sternly, her facial expression filled with rage that was waiting to be let loose.
Klaus opened his mouth to try to speak again, which only made Caroline even more infuriated.
"I said don't," She told him, raising her voice as she did so. "I don't want to hear your crappy ass explanation; I couldn't care less about what your exact wording was."
"Caroli-" Klaus tried as she moved to stand up.
"Don't talk to me!" She snapped at him as she headed out of the room.
Elena and Bonnie both got up in perfect unison to follow after their friend. Klaus also moved to get up, but Bonnie quickly turned to him and warned, "You've done enough damage already. Sit back down or I'll fry your brain."
Klaus desperately needed to explain himself to Caroline and hated being the one who had made her so upset, but it was clear that Caroline didn't want to talk to him anyways. He reluctantly sat back down, trying to ignore the several sets of unimpressed eyes that were staring over at him as he kept his gaze on the doorway.
Bonnie and Elena followed Caroline into the kitchen and then closed the door behind them so that the spell that made the doors soundproof even to supernatural creatures would take effect.
"Are you okay, Care?" Elena asked gently.
"I should just stop going to stupid Mikaelson birthday parties," Caroline commented as she wiped at her eyes. "I'm always the one that ends up crying."
"But at least you know what he did now," Bonnie said quietly.
Caroline nodded a little before she replied, "And clearly Klaus was never going to tell me… He was just going to keep on pretending to be the good guy and acting like he was so disgusted that Tyler could ever cheat on me when he's the one who caused it."
Elena hugged her crying friend and Bonnie quickly joined in, forming a group hug around the blonde.
"I don't even know what to think," Caroline told them. "If Klaus hadn't done that, would I still be with Tyler or would he still have ended up with Hayley? I'm so confused… And angry."
"I don't know either," Bonnie admitted.
"Do you want to leave?" Elena asked.
"No," Caroline replied, surprised by the sureness in her tone. "No, let's go back out there."
"Are you sure?" Bonnie asked in surprise.
"Positive," Caroline confirmed.
She took a second to compose herself and then wiped the last remaining tear away from her eye and headed towards the kitchen door, head held high.
Everyone was more than a little surprised when Caroline emerged from the kitchen just a few very brief minutes after having stormed off into it. It was clear that she had been crying from the puffiness around her eyes, but she now seemed to have an almost eerie amount of composure as she walked straight past Klaus, without so much as a glance in his direction as she snatched up her drink on her way by, and then sat down in the center of the empty couch next to Kol.
While Caroline and the other two had been out of the room, April had moved from her spot on that couch to go sit on Kol's lap in his chair. Kol wrapped his arms around her waist as Bonnie and Elena sat down on either side of Caroline, each seeming more unsure of coming back than Caroline was.
There was a brief silence as everyone looked over at Caroline, trying to figure out what they were supposed to do, before the blonde spoke up.
"It's your turn, Matt, isn't it?" She asked.
Caroline had thought that people were giving her shocked looks before, but that was nothing compared to the ones that she got after asking that.
"…Yeah," Matt said awkwardly. "…But are you sure that you still want to play?"
"I'm positive," She replied firmly. "I'd like to find out what else people have been hiding from me."
A/N: Please read and review! Sorry that this update took longer and I hope that you guys liked the chapter! :) Thanks for reading and a super giant thanks goes out to all of the awesome reviewers who helped me to reach over 100 reviews on just the first two chapters! :D I'm not going to list you all off, but just know that I read and appreciate every single review! So lately I've been getting a lot of questions over and over that I've already answered many times, and not just on this story (By the way I've explained the pairings again in an A/N at the top). It really is starting to feel like nobody is actually reading my author's notes which is a little frustrating when the answers to questions that I keep getting are right there. So if you've actually read this A/N then please include the word 'banana' in a review. Oh, and a big thanks goes out to all of you who have been reading the A/Ns :)