"Never have I ever lit my hair on fire with a birthday cake," Matt said.
All of the Originals as well as both Salvatores and Alaric turned to look at the couch where Caroline, Bonnie, and Elena were sitting only to be surprised when none of them drank. Instead it was Jeremy who drank, rolling his eyes as he did so.
"One time," He muttered under his breath.
"Actually it happened when you were like three too," Elena spoke up in an amused tone.
Jeremy silently gave his sister a death glare, although she did not seem particularly phased by it.
"My turn," Said Rebekah. "Never have I ever dreamt about sleeping with Katherine and Elena at the same time."
There was a brief pause before Elijah took a large chug out of his drink. As soon as he had drank, others soon followed. Damon, Stefan, Kol, Katherine, and Alaric all drank.
"What?" Katherine asked with an innocent shrug even though nobody had even bothered to ask.
"Why did I even come here?" Alaric pondered out loud.
"To come see my pretty face," Damon answered mockingly.
"Why did I even come here?" Alaric repeated, slightly more dramatically.
Elena decided to take her turn still even though she had moved to a different position. "Never have I ever had a father named Mikael."
Clearly she was also on board with the plan to get Elijah drunk.
Rebekah, Kol, and Elijah all drank while Klaus smirked a little. His smirk fell when his eyes met Caroline's glaring ones.
"Never have I ever thrown up on Klaus," Stefan said before he took a chug of his drink.
"That's not how the game works," Jeremy pointed out as Rebekah and Klaus also drank. "You're supposed to say something that you haven't done."
Stefan shrugged innocently as he said, "Maybe I wanted to drink."
It was Klaus's turn and as he began to speak, his eyes flickered to Caroline who resisted the urge to tell him to not even look at her.
"Never have I ever intentionally compelled someone to cheat on Caroline," He said.
"How the hell do you 'accidentally' compel someone into cheating?" Caroline demanded, crossing her arms over her chest.
"What I said was go find someone else," He responded. "Not to go sleep with her while he was still with you."
"You still compelled him!" Caroline pointed out, outraged that he thought that made things any better. "You were still trying to compel him to go find someone else instead of being with me."
"I'm the bad guy, I do bad things. That's not exactly news," Klaus replied. "After he slept with her the first time, he blamed me. I took the compulsion off and then made him forget why it had happened. I thought that he'd just gone back to you, but apparently he just kept sleeping with his wolf slut considering you walked in on them later."
"Sitting right here," Hayley pointed out in an annoyed tone, clearly not appreciating being referred to as Tyler's wolf slut.
"Are you seriously trying to pretend that you're innocent in this situation?" Tyler demanded as he looked over at Klaus.
"More innocent than you are," Klaus responded pointedly.
"You're the reason that I slept with her in the first place!" Tyler pointed out angrily.
"But you just kept sleeping with her and sleeping with her and you couldn't even admit it to Caroline, you just kept her thinking that you were perfectly loyal," Klaus argued. "And I'm not so convinced that you wouldn't have slept with Hayley anyways."
"You acted like you were so shocked and disgusted that I would ever cheat on Caroline just because you wanted to be the one to comfort her and act like you were so much better," Tyler retorted. "The whole thing was probably just some stupid plan to try and get her."
"I acted disgusted because I was!" Klaus replied. "Because you were stupid enough to keep cheating on her."
"Both of you shut up!" Caroline said in an exasperated tone before Tyler had the chance to make any kind of retort. "You're both jerks and fighting over who's worse is just making you even more annoying. I'm mad at both of you."
A/N: Please read and review! Sorry that this update took almost three weeks. I'm super sorry and I'm really going to try and get the next one up way quicker. I hope that you guys liked the chapter and thanks for reading! :) Another super giant thanks goes out to all of the incredible reviewers of the last chapter and I was definitely glad to see that so many of you actually read the author's notes.