"Never have I ever said that if I was going to sleep with a guy that it would be Klaus," Alaric commented.
"You weren't even there," Stefan pointed out before taking a chug of his drink.
"No, but I hear that it was an instant reaction to the question," The history teacher commented with a smirk.
"Yeah, and I wonder who your choice would be," Klaus commented sarcastically as he looked over to where Alaric was sitting with Damon.
Ric didn't say anything in response, since he had to admit that he had walked right into that one.
"My turn," Katherine said happily. "Never have I ever…"
Elijah grabbed his bottle of whiskey and began to chug out of it. Several seconds passed before he lowered the bottle once again.
Katherine smirked at her boyfriend as she looked over at him and asked, "You do realize that I didn't even say anything yet, so you still have to drink at whatever I choose?"
The Original shrugged indifferently. They were going to make him drink until he was drunk anyways, so why not speed up the process?
"As I was saying," The doppelganger continued. "Never have I ever prevented Rebekah from having a cake with male strippers in it."
Elijah grabbed his bottle and began to chug from it once again. As he did so, Katherine held the bottle up to keep him from stopping drinking, despite the fact that he didn't seem to be planning on stopping any time soon.
When she let go, Elijah still drank for a moment longer before he put down the, now empty, bottle.
"I'm going to need more alcohol," He commented as he stood up to go find himself another bottle.
"So Elijah's going to be fun when that hits him," Kol commented as soon as his brother was out of the room.
Once Elijah was sitting back down with a new bottle of whiskey, he said, "Never have I ever had someone mistake me for a woman."
After drinking, Klaus shook his head and commented, "Your hair was longer than mine."
"Yes, but you're the one that they thought was a woman," Elijah pointed out.
It was April's turn next, so she spoke up with, "Never have I ever accidentally started a fire while babysitting."
Elena took a swig of her drink before she commented, "It was a small fire and I thought that we agreed never to speak of that."
"Oops," April said with an innocent grin.
Caroline had barely been listening to the last several turn because she had been too busy replaying the events that had happened in the kitchen over in her head. Klaus was just sitting there, completely unaware of the fact that his words were helping more and more every second as she replayed them over and over in her mind.
As Caroline's memory reached the end of the conversation, she realized that Klaus had smirked a little just as they were about to leave the room… She replayed what she had said just before that over in her head and then it finally dawned on her.
"You realize that I'm not kissing you forat leastanother century, right? …And that's only if you're good."
The blonde shook her head a little because she knew that Klaus had picked up on the way that she had implied that they would be together for at least another century long before she had. A slight smile formed on her lips and she rolled her eyes as she slid her hand into his.
Klaus wasn't sure of what had just made Caroline grab his hand, but he didn't plan on ruining it by asking. So instead, he just gave her hand a light squeeze and smiled to himself without risking turning to look at her.
"Never have I ever had sex with a doppelganger," Kol spoke up.
Damon, Stefan, Elijah, and Matt all drank at that.
"Don't look at me like that, Bennett," Katherine said when she noticed the look that Bonnie was giving her. "Half of those were Elena… Besides, Matt, Rebekah, and Stefan have all slept with as many people in this room as I have. And Caroline and Damon have slept with more."
Caroline turned and buried her face in Klaus's shoulder as she let out a quiet groan.
April turned her head to look at Kol, whose lap she was still sitting in, and asked, "So basically everyone here has slept together?"
"I think I have it figured out," Kol responded. "Out of the people in this room, I've only slept with you... You've only slept with me... Bonnie's only slept with Jeremy... Elena's slept with Stefan and Matt... Hayley's only slept with Tyler… Tyler's slept with Hayley and Caroline... Matt's slept with Elena, Rebekah, and Caroline… Rebekah's slept with Matt, Stefan, and Damon… Stefan's slept with Elena, Katherine, and Rebekah… Nik has slept with Caroline… Caroline's slept with Nik, Tyler, Damon, and Matt… Jeremy's only slept with Bonnie… Damon's slept with Alaric, Katherine, Caroline, and Rebekah... Alaric's only slept with Damon... Katherine's slept with Elijah, Damon, and Stefan... And Elijah's slept with Katherine."
When Kol was finished going around the room, he smiled triumphantly when no one corrected him.
A/N: Please read and review! I hope that you guys enjoyed the update and thanks for reading! I'm hoping to have the next chapter up sooner, but I'm not sure whether that will really happen or not... It sounds like you guys want more flashbacks, so I'm definitely going to put some more in future chapters. And once again, another super great giant thanks goes out to all of the reviewers of the last chapter who helped me to reach over 200 reviews on this story so far! :D
Also if you're ever waiting for an update on one of my stories and you want me to get it up faster, please send me a PM because I promise that it will help motivate me. I promise that for every PM that I get telling me to write or work on any of the stories that I'm currently updating, I will go work on the next chapter and make sure that I at least get some more written.
REVIEW ANSWERS:
Hello: There will be more Beremy coming up.
saba: I was already planning on having Elijah getting wasted... I'm not sure about Kol though. I think that he might have to remain relatively soberish or not too drunk.
3rd Bookworm: Matt and Rebekah are a couple in this and they're probably going to get more couply in future chapters. And yes, I'm definitely planning on having Stefan and Damon start to mend their brotherly-ness.
LitLover 101: I hope that they have more of Damon and Stefan's relationship in season 5 as well. :)