Chapter 4 YAY!

The First Time

POV: Puck at first, Rory afterwards.

Location unchanged. Takes place right after chapter 3. Thanks for your kind reviews. By the way, I don't have any correction device for spelling mystakes on my computer, so if you find any, tell me. I don't own glee.

Puck:

"So, how do you want to welcome our little sex leprechaun?", I asked Finn, who was sitting on his couch only in boxers.

"What about all naked just with a towel around my waist?"

"Nice, but what about all naked?"

"What if my neighbour sees me?"

"What if I open the door?"

"I guess, that would work. Oh by the way my nieghbour is a creepy old lady anyway. I don't think that my parents would believe her."

"So all naked Puck it is?", I asked.

"All naked Puck it is", he said.

Rory:

I knocked on the door and heard some rummaging behind it. I expected to find Finn opening the door, preferably a fullyclothed Finn. But what I got wasn't bad either. An all naked Noah Puckerman. He took me by my shoulders and pushed me inside. Finn, just in his boxers and a shirt, which seemed to be Kurt's came up to me and hugged me, while Puck closed the door behind me. I felt Finn's growing manhood pressing against my leg while I awkwardly tried to free me out of this hug. I knew I'd have sex here, but I did not expect a sex attack by the two jocks. But whatever, i might just play along. I pulled Finn in a passionate kiss and we started making out until Puck interrupted us by clearing his throat.

"Yo, guys. Let me join."

I thought, that nothing was more awesome than making out with a guy. I was mistaken. Making out with two guys is the best. Whenever a tongue quit my mouth, it was replace by another or I could watch two hotties making out. We were caressing each other's bodies and played with our nipples, which of course made Puck go mad. He moaned and groaned in our mouths and soon Finn's shirt and boxers were down on the floor and I realized I was the only one, who had any clothes one and I was still fully dressed. The others seemed to come to the same conclusion, as a second later, I had one hand removing my shirt, while another was working on my belt. Now I was standing topless and in my unzipped jeans and boxers in Finn's living room. I started going from twirling Puck's nipples to licking them, while Finn finished the job of stripping me. He then went back to making out with Puck. After a while, Puck pulled me up by my hair.

"Ro, we need to talk to you."

I glanced at the two of them, as they shared a glance themselves.

Finn started talking.

"Look, Rory. Blowjobs are awesome and don't get me wrong you ace them, but there's something else we would like to try with you."

"Are you talking about..."

"Fucking you, Irish. I want to fuck you.", Puck interrupted me.

"I'm still a virgin."

"We know. But not for much longer. It has been decided.

"Look, Rory.", Finn addressed me again, "We'll be really careful. We do not want to hurt you. It's just, that we need some kind of relief. And your butt looks just perfect."

"Do you have lube and condoms?", I asked nervously.

"Not gonna make the same mistake twice.", Puck answered. I looked puzzled.

"Quinn and I had a baby."

I remembered hearing something like that in glee.

"It's okay. I'll do it.", I told them.

After getting my permission, the two smiled and led me to Finn's room. I got up on the bed and tried to find a comfortable position. I lied down on my back and spread my legs.

"I'll finger you first, okay?", Finn asked.

"Do it."

He lubed up his finger and started to find his way to my hole. I spread my buttocks. He started pushing his first finger in my hole. This wasn't that bad, as I sometimes did the same to myself wihtout caring about lube, so this went pretty easy and without any pain. He started to move his finger in and out. I moaned. Puck, who was just standing next to Finn, climbed up the bed and placed himself upon me, his dick hanging down on my face and started licking my shaft to calm me down. I also started to lick his balls and soon had both of them in my mouth and started sucking on them. He soon started sucking on my manhood, as Finn tried to get a second finger inside me. It didn't go as easy and painfree as the first, but was still bearable. I started giving Puck a blowjob, when Finn put a third finger in my tight hole. It hurt like hell and I accidentaly bit on Puck's cock. He screamed and I apologized.

"Sorry man, i did not mean to do that."

"Well, it's too late now and I want revenge. I guess it's time you get fucked."

I got a look of sheer horror on my face. Finn started lubing up Pucks cut cock and climbed on me like Puck did earlier. He started giving me head to calm me down and, surprisingly, it worked. I was really calmed down until I felt Pucks dick enter my virgin hole. I screamed out of pure pain, when I felt the head inside of me. Puck let it in there for a while until I got used to it and the pain seemed to vanish.

"Hush honey, you're not the first person, whose virginity I take."

He continued to push his dick in me and the pain reappeared. He however ignored my screaming and simply pushed a little harder until he was absolutely buried in my hole. I started to cry out of frustration and pain. Finn kissed me to calm me down, but not even he could help me now. I was unvirgined. I was in pain. I hated Puck for doing that to me. But soon, as Puck started moving again and I was fucked for the first time, the pain was really gone for good and i started feeling pleasure.

"Harder.", I begged. Finn looked shocked, as I was crying a second earlier but neither Puck nor him ignored me. Puck fucked me harder and Finn sucked me harder. Soon I was about to cum. I told finn to let go, but he swallowed all of the sperm sooting out from my cock. He then put his own dick near my mouth with a questioning look on his face. I nodded and he put it in my mouth. Concentrating on Finn's cock, I did not feel any pain left. Puck kept fucking me and it felt awesome, just like I dreamt it would. Puck started to pant and I was sure, that he was about to cum. He however did not retreat, but shoot his cum right in the condom in my butt.

"Noww, you might feel a little pain again, Flan.", he said, as he pulled out his cock inch per inch and he was right. When his dick plopped out it hurt like hell, but I still had a cock to focus on in my mouth.

"Stop it, Irish, I'm taking over. You have done your job.", my first fucker said and Finn pulled his cock out and bent over to Puck who now started licking along the shaft. Still in some kind of mixture od excitement, pain and pure frenzy, I watched Finn cumming in Puck's mouth. Then they smiled and shared a kiss.

"Oh man, have you seen what time it is? I have to leave."

"Yeah, you better go, my parents will come over soon anyway, I guess.", Finn said.

Puck got dressed, smacked my ass and left.

I was still lying on the bed and soon started sobbing.

Finn came over to me.

"Hey man, what's up? Sorry for surprising you like that."

"It wasn't that I guess. I agreed to get fucked. It's just so painful. I should never have done this. I still feel the pain."

"Is it really that bad? You won't have to do it again. Ever. I promise. But if it is that bad, why does everyone do it in porn?"

"Because it also feels good. When you get used to it, the pain goes away. But Puck did not let me get used to it."

"I feel so bad right now. I will never let him do that to you again. I won't let anyone do that to you ever again."

"Well, you should."

"Why?"

"Because, if there's one thing I know for sure, it is that you should have been my first. You would have been much gentler and with you it would have been much more pleasure."

"Rory, stop it. I will never do that to you. I saw how painful it was."

"But I want you too. Well, we shouldn't talk about it now. I guess i'll go home now. I'm tired.", I said, tears still running down my cheek.

"If you want, you can also sleep over."

"Is that ok with your parents?"

"Of course. They know or the think that i am straight, so they don't care if some guy sleeps over."

"Well i don't have any clothes to sleep in."

"You don't need any. I won't rape you. You can trust me."

"I know I can."

This is the story of my first time sleeping in Finn's arms.

A/N: Shoutout to MikeChangsAbs. I accidentaly used the same name for my story as he did for his. It's a great one. Check it out (Nude erections by MikeChangsAbs). Have a good day everybody.