A/N: This story occurs after the events of ROTG, HTTYD, and Brave, but before the events of Tangled. I am not going to do Merida's accent to make it easier to understand.

~I do not own ROTG, HTTYD, Brave, or Tangled.~

Jack's POV:

We arrive back at North's workshop.

"North!" I yell.

"What is it Jack?" He asks when he appears from my left. "Please be quieter next time, and were you not able to find Hiccup?"

"We found him, but..." I start.

"Pitch turned him into his own nightmare prince!" Merida blurted out/ interrupted.

"What?" North asked.

"I'm not sure what Pitch exactly did," Punzie starts "but Pitch called him his nightmare prince, and he can control nightmares!"

"He is now evil!" Merida exclaims.

North just stands there, lost in thoughts. He finally speaks. "This has happened, only once before." His voice is quiet and he appears somewhat sad.

North's POV:

"So, what happened?" Merida asks.

This happened many years ago, and I haven't spoken of it since.

I sigh, and start the story.

"It was about 400 years ago, give or take a few. I was already a guardian, along with Bunny, Tooth, and Sandy. We weren't alone though, we also had another member. Her name was Cupid. She was the newest and youngest of us all, but also the sweetest." I stop for a second, and then continue." It was 2 days until Valentine's Day and she was very excited. I was passing by her castle while on a practice run, when I heard the scream. It was unmistakably hers. I rushed down, but I was too late. By the time I got there she was gone, and all that was left was a half written card and some black sand. Right then I knew it was Pitch who took her."

Rapunzel's POV:

Wow! I wonder what happens next.

North continues: "I rushed back to the workshop and signal the other guardians. As soon as they got here they noticed the look on my face and that someone was missing. I told them what happened before they had the chance to ask. Everyone was worried, especially Bunny. I honestly think he may have liked her. Anyway, with Valentine's day so close we decide to head out the next day."

"When the next day comes we gather at my workshop and head out. We all take my sleigh, even though Bunny repeatedly refused. I took out a globe whispered to go to Pitch's lair and threw it. We go through the portal and land on the ground in front of an old rickety bed. We knew it was Pitch's lair. We got off the sleigh and headed towards it. After some arguing, Bunny would go first, then me, Tooth, and finally Sandy. We all finally reach the bottom, thanks to Sandy's help since we can't all fly. There is no sign of Pitch anywhere, or Cupid. We decide to split up in twos to look around. It was Tooth and Sandy, and Bunny and I as partners. We start to look around, but have no luck. Until, I hear an evil cackle behind me, and turned to see the face of the one and only Pitch Black."

Merida's POV:

"He looked at Bunny and I and smiled. He then said, 'Well what do we have here, two guardians all alone. Where are the others? Looking for me, or your little friend Cupid, or maybe even trapped and surrounded by my nightmares. Wait! That is where they are! Now how about you two?' Bunny then asked, 'Where's Cupid?' 'Oh her, she's right over here, why don't I show you. One more thing first, she's not Cupid anymore, she's my Nightmare Queen,' Pitch replied back to us."

Queen? Hiccup's supposed to be the prince. It's the exact same thing,

"I didn't know what he meant until Cupid came out. She looked different, she was in black clothes, was riding a nightmare horse, and had an evil look in her eyes. 'Hello boys,' she said with a dark voice. I wasn't 100% what was going on just yet, until more nightmares than I could count came at us. We fought them off until they were all gone. Just then Tooth and Sandy decided to show up. 'What have you done Pitch?' Bunny asked. 'Nothing really, just got myself a queen,' Pitch answered."

Jack's POV:

"Before we could react to what he said Cupid charged at us, with Pitch and some nightmares on her tail. We all fought, but we knew we couldn't hurt Cupid. She may be evil not he outside, but we knew she was the same, sweet girl on the inside. They were just too strong, especially together. We weren't completely prepared for this, so we ended up having to leave. We finally left when Pitch and Cupid, together, created a huge, nightmare dragon. It was almost impossible to defeat. We all were starting to become tired, and if they could create that nightmare... we had no idea what else they could create."

"We ended up leaving. Sandy left first so he could spread dream sand. I was pretty sure there wouldn't be many good dreams tonight though, especially with Pitch AND Cupid. Tooth was already flying home and Bunny was using his holes. I took one more look back at Cupid before leaving the lair and heading back to the workshop. The whole way they I was thinking, what had Pitch done and what to do now?" North finally finished, and I couldn't believe it.

We all stood there in silence until Punzie broke the silence.

"So, where is she now?" She asked.

"I'm not sure," North say. "We never figured out how to change her back, or what Pitch did. None of us have seen her since, and it has been about 400 years since that happened."

"So, now what do we do?" I asked.

No One's POV:

Pitch stood there, thinking, when Hiccup interrupts.

"What's wrong my king?" His prince asks. "Isn't everything as you hoped.

"No, not just yet," Pitch says.

"What do you mean?"

"We're missing someone."

"Who?"

"Well since there's a nightmare prince, there needs to be a nightmare princess. I just don't know who yet."

They both just stand there thinking until Hiccup breaks the silence.

He says, with an evil look:

"I know just the girl."

A/N: A long chapter, finally! I hope you enjoyed this chapter, it took me forever to write it, I put a lot of thought into it. My spring break is over, so that means school, and their may be some days where I forget to post a new chapter, so, yeah…

Thank you to midnightsky0612 for reviewing, I'm so happy that you like my story! Also, thanks to Marzlover for favoriting this story. Finally, thank you to UnknownBlackHand for following and reviewing, I really appreciate your review; I honestly did not think that the last chapter was all that good, but you helped me think otherwise.

Who do you think Hiccup is talking about? Let me know in the reviews.

Thanks for reading! :P