I said just last week that I would not be updating this anytime soon but it seemed fate was a fan of the story since I drew the Fosters again, so everybody better be thankful to fate, she is a cruel mistress. If you liked this story please leave a comment/review saying just that, and also this is the end of Don't Dare Me, so do not expect another chapter.
Don't Dare Me
Chapter 2 You Dared Me
We don't own anything; if we did life would have been much more entertaining.
Brandon moaned as Jude and Connor handled him, moving him into place for the two of them. The two have him on his back but they turn his lower half side ways so that they can both fit, Jesus had given them the first go at the shocked Brandon who is now so lost in it all that he does not even put up a fight. Jesus looks on from his brothers desk chair where he is sitting naked and stroking himself slowly, enjoying the show before him. Jude positioned himself at Brandon's stretched hole before pushing in slowly, his older brother moaned as a dick entered him for the first time; Connor soon followed after his boyfriend and pushes into the oldest causing the oldest to moan even louder.
"he's tight" Jude hisses trying to adjust to the tight heat around him and his boyfriend who just lets out a gasp when Jude pulls out and motions for him to follow. Both young teens pull out of Brandon and then push back in slowly, building and both speed and power.
Jesus keeps his eyes focused on the scene unfolding before him, thankful that he had made that deal with his younger brother. Brandon slowly comes back to himself as he feels the two younger teens fuck him slowly, he bites his bottom lip as he tries to hold back his moans, but Jude looks him in his eyes and gives him that smirk before speeding up and giving each thrust more power, Connor follows his lead and the two make Brandon moan and gasp for more not long after their enhanced effort.
Brandon looked over at Jesus where he was still sitting on his desk chair, "y-you c-cheated" he got out between gasps, "you never said we couldn't make deals" Jesus replied still stroking himself slowly. Brandon's lower back started to hurt from the position he was in and the onslaught he was receiving, and no matter how many times he wined for them to stop or at least move him Jude and Connor did not listen, even Jesus looked content to see him suffer.
Brandon started to move his hands to try and change his position but Jude beat him to it and grabbed onto his one arm and Connor did the same on his side, the two held him down while their hips kept up their pace. Brandon's moans were starting to get desperate, he wanted to cum, he wanted to touch himself so that this nightmare could just end already but they weren't having any of it, they wanted him to feel this.
Jesus got up from where he was sitting and moved closer to the bed, he held his phone up and started to film the scene before him, after all that was the rule, take a picture or video of the act as proof and Jesus was going to be revisiting this proof for a long time after this and even making many more videos like this; after all, his brother was his now and he was going to enjoy him.
"You don't get to cum until I knot you, or we can see how many times we can make you cum. What do you think Jude?" Jesus said as he stood towering over the bed. Jude looked up at his older brother and then to his other brother, "let's milk him dry". Brandon could not believe that this was his little brother; he knew that Jude could be evil sometimes but this was new to him, and very scary.
Jesus takes hold of the oldest boys cock and started to match the rhythm that the younger two have set, in and out Jude and Connor went and up and down Jesus followed. They were driving Brandon mad, the pain in his lower back now forgotten as he allowed the pleasure to flow through him; giving into them as he just took what they gave.
Brandon could feel his release building and he would have warned them that he was about to cum but he could not form words as the two young betas kept up their pace. He could not hold it anymore and released his seed all over Jude's stomach and Jesus' hand moaning through it, Connor and Jude increased their pace before cumming inside of Brandon filling him up. They just lay their for a while before Jude motioned for him and his boyfriend to pull out.
Brandon groaned as they laid him back down after pulling out, he could feel his throbbing back and hole. He did not have long to think about his aches before Jesus moved into position and pushed all the way in as soon as he was. Brandon gave a silent scream as his brother filled him, he knew what was coming now and he knew that it was going to hurt more then both Jude and Connor did.
Jude and Connor quickly recovered from their orgasms and moved to make good on the promise that Jude made, they were going to milk Brandon for every drop of cum that they could. Jude and Connor got on each side of the oldest again and then they latched their mouths to his limp member, they are intent to bring it to full hardness again.
Having two talented tongues on him had the oldest hard again in no time and his moans soon followed. Jesus looked at those mouths working his brother for a while, just taking in the way they licked, kissed and slurped around that dick before he pulled out of Brandon and pushed back in, this resulted in Brandon giving little pained gasps, his oversensitive hole not up to the task of another round.
Brandon did not know what to feel, the pleasure that he was being given or the pain that came with it, Jesus was longer then the two youngest and with each thrust back into him Brandon could feel his brother getting closer to that one spot that would make him forget the pain and crave more of this sweet hell that was his pleasure.
Jude moved his mouth up and away from his brother's member and started planting kisses around his navel, he moved his free hand that was not holding him up to Brandon's nipple and pinched it hard just as Connor took all of him in his mouth and Jesus pounded into his prostate. Brandon screamed so loud the whole neighbourhood could have heard him but he did not care as he was currently on cloud nine and moving on up to heaven.
Brandon had cummed again from that sudden burst of pleasure, coating his stomach in his own seed. Jude had moved his head just before his oldest brother came; he was now smirking up at Jesus who was pulling a face while still pounding into Brandon hitting his prostate on each inward thrust. The tightness was almost too much for Jesus and he knew that if he stopped to wait it out that he would cum too and he did not want that yet, so he kept on pounding into his brother.
Brandon had tears forming in his eyes, Connor who had pulled off as Brandon released was hard back at work getting the oldest ready for another round, Jude was helping by kissing and biting his brother's pulse point and abusing his other nipple. Connor used his free hand to play with Brandon's ball, fondling them and squeezing them, Jesus had his eyes closed because if the tightness didn't do it for him then the hot scene of those two pleasuring his older brother would. After all of this Jesus was going to have to work something out with both Jude and Connor.
Brandon was moaning with tears in his eyes as his dick was hard again, this time around Jude returned to sucking him off while Connor focused on sucking on his balls. He could feel all of it, but he could mostly feel the numb pleasure filled pain that Jesus was giving him by continuing to assault his prostate, he could not take it anymore, he hurt all over and he just wanted it to stop.
The three younger teens continued to fuck and suck on the oldest for what seemed like hours though it was only about half an hour. Jesus was close, he could feel his knot expanding, Jude was looking up at him and could see that he would not last long. The feeling of his brother's knot expanding in him brought Brandon back out of his haze; he had to get his brother out of him before he knotted him, before he made him his bitch for good. But there was no escaping.
Jesus kept fucking into his brother and with each thrust back in his knot expanded a little more until he felt like he could not hold back his orgasm any longer, he thrust in one last time and felt his knot expand inside of the tight heat of his brother, he had finally knotted Brandon and he was in heaven as his cum filled him and just kept filling him. "Keep going" Jesus heard Jude say, he did not even realise that he had stopped moving, he started bucking into his brother unable to pull out but still able to thrust in somewhat.
Brandon cried as he felt his brother's knot fill him and against his own will he came but nothing came out of him, and it hurt like hell, he wanted this to be over but he knew that now it would never be over, he would have to endure his brother knotting him a lot more from now on and the thought scared him, he hated himself for starting that damned dare game with Jesus and he cursed Jude silently for helping Jesus.
Connor and Jude kept playing and teasing Brandon while Jesus' knot was still swelled up, Jude loved seeing Brandon like this and he had to make a plan so that he could see this again and again, he did not want this to be a one time thing. After a long while Brandon felt Jesus' knot go down and his brother slip out of him; before he passed out he could hear Jesus say to him, "get some sleep Brandon, you have a long week ahead of you since the girls won't be home anytime soon".
Hoped you enjoyed it, if you did then let me know, if not also feel free to let me know and explain yourself if you do choose to point out why you did not like it. Also read the Halloween AN that follows. Thanks for reading Don't Dare Me.
So Halloween is coming next month and we have discussed it, we would like our followers to choose a special Halloween fic that will come out along with our normal weekly fics, so here are the rules for the draw.
1) Two fics must be chosen, one m/m and another f/f
2) The fics can be the same show, movie, game, cartoon, anime, real person, book or whatever you want; though we do decide which fic we will ultimately write with the same means we decide every other fic, by fate. All Halloween requests will be written down and put in a hat and then we will randomly draw one m/m and one f/f.
3) Along with your request you should add two tags, we will then do the same with all of the tags entered and draw two for each story, in this way the story will be something good and new.
4) Last rule, we will think of the story, so do not add a summery with your requests for the Halloween competition. Though we will follow certain guidelines you might add like, "Nico and Percy dress up as each other for Halloween" or "Karma and Amy tease each other with explicit costumes", so let loose those imaginations.
Written by Incubi. Work is at AO3 and