You were starving. Not just a little peckish or hungry, but starving. The last thing you'd had to eat was half of a bologna sandwich at your motel room in Nebraska before the boys dragged you out after finding the vampire nest. Your stomach grumbled once more at the thought of that uneaten half of your bologna sandwich.
"I should have made Dean stop somewhere on the way home," you groaned. I guess I could go out to the kitchen and get something to eat, you thought as you began to walk toward the door. A breeze from the vent made you realize you were only wearing your panties and one of Dean's T-shirts. You glanced toward your overflowing laundry basket and realized that you'd forgot to do your laundry once again. Now, you would have to quickly and quietly rummage through the kitchen for something to eat. This can't get any worse, you thought as you tip-toed out of your bedroom and into the hallway. The hallway was still lit up as you made your way to the kitchen, but as you looked at the space underneath Dean's room and then Sam's you noticed the lights were out. Phew, you thought, they're still in bed. As you continued down the hallway, you also noticed the lights to the library were still on as well. You couldn't believe how irresponsible the boys were as you flipped the switch and the library went dark leaving only the kitchen and part of the hallway illuminated. Your stomach made another groan, almost like a whale, and you shushed it before quickly hopping out of the hallway and into the kitchen. You froze and waited to hear any sign from either bedrooms that their occupants were awake. Silence. You let out a sigh of relief as you slid over to the fridge and opened the doors. You couldn't decide what to eat until you saw something glimmering from behind the carton of milk. You moved the milk aside and your taste buds almost exploded. The glimmering was coming from the plastic container of one big slice of deliciously looking apple pie. You licked your lips at the thought of that first delicious bite when the thought hit you. It was the pie Dean bought at the gas station just a couple minutes before you'd arrived back at the bunker. Your heart sunk as you backed away from the fridge, but your stomach urged you on with another loud growl. You reached out hesitantly only to finally give in, grab the container, and set it down on table. You scrambled for a fork, but then you thought of the vanilla ice cream in the freezer.
"Dean would be absolutely horrified if I didn't at least eat it right," a smirk crawled across your face as you went to get the ice cream. You didn't spare any thought before you had two hefty scoops of ice cream right next to the slice of pie. You looked around to see if the boys had gotten up, especially Dean, before taking a bite of the pie. Your taste buds exploded at the deliciousness of the pie. Dean really knows how to pick his pies, you thought.
"What are you doing up so late, baby?" You froze, the last bite of pie and ice cream only inches from your mouth. Dean had woken up and was now looking at you eating his pie. His pie! Shit! You quickly put the bit of food in your mouth and tossed the plate and fork into the sink.
"Nothing, just a little midnight snack. I, uh, haven't eaten since we were in Nebraska…" your voice drifted when you turned around and noticed he was focused on your body. Specifically what you were wearing.
"Y/N, why are you wearing only your panties and- is that my T-shirt?" you chuckled sheepishly as you looked down at your attire.
"Well, I- you see, I forgot to do my laundry again and-" Before you could finish your sentence Dean jumped across the room and had pinned against the wall.
"You shouldn't have come out here like this, baby." You thought you could hear the warning in his voice, but the feeling of his half erect cock against your thigh made you think otherwise. You smirked devilishly and glanced down at the bulge in his boxers.
"Oh yeah? Why's that?" Your smirk began to grow, but you were taken by surprise when Dean turned you around and bent you over the table. Dean pressed his now pulsating cock against your ass and you couldn't help the moan that escaped your lips.
"You've been a bad girl, baby. Coming out dressed like this, practically teasing me, and not even caring that Sammy might see you? Tsk tsk-" He stopped and looked over towards the container sitting on top of the trash can. You began to grind your ass against Dean's cock, clueless to the fact that Dean had found the empty pie container, when Dean suddenly backed away and sat you down onto the kitchen table.
"What-" Dean brought his finger to your lips and placed the empty pie container beside you as he sat in the chair in front of you.
"Haven't eaten since Nebraska, hm?" Dean gestured to the empty pie container that sat beside you like a big sign that read 'GUILTY' all over it.
"Yes." You looked down at him anxiously as he continued to stare at you. And if looks could kill, well, you'd be dead. You frantically searched for something to break the silence until you'd thought of something.
"So, Dean, uh, what are you doing up this early?" Your eyes shifted frantically between Dean and your lap.
"Well, Y/N, I woke up to the sound of you rummaging through the fridge and I thought I'd check and make sure you weren't getting into my pie." He uttered the last word so heavily that you felt yourself scooting further onto the table.
"Your pie?" You gulped. You continued to slowly inch farther and farther away, but Dean knew what you were doing and matched you pace by standing up.
"Yes, my pie." Dean scooted the container towards you until the plastic crunched against your leg.
"I, uh- well…" Your voice drifted as you looked down in bewilderment as his hand slid up your leg.
"Y/N?" He sounded so assertive now that you didn't dare respond, "Baby girl, look at me. Now." Now you were screwed. He'd played the 'baby girl' card. Reluctantly, you looked up at him.
"Yes?" You tried to make yourself sound as innocent as possible, but that didn't help your case. His other hand followed suit and continued up your legs until they stopped at your mid-thigh.
"You ate my pie." He said through gritted teeth as he suddenly flipped you around and dragged you back to the edge of the table. You clawed at the table to try and drag yourself back, but the sting of Dean's palm upon your ass cheek made you freeze, "Don't lie to me, Y/N. You ate my pie, didn't you?"
"Uhm… no, I thought it was Sam's pie because, well, you see-" Dean's hand rained down on your ass again. After two swats, he pointed to the label on the container that read 'Property of Dean Winchester: Do Not Touch". Guilt spread across your face as you realized there was no getting out of this.
"I'm going to say it one more time, baby girl. You ate my pie, didn't you?" His hand hovered over your cheek. You hardly get out the words before Dean laid down two more swats.
"Okay, yes!" Dean's hand froze over your ass.
"I'm sorry, yes what?"
"Yes, I ate your pie" Dean's hand rubbed your ass as he tossed tossed the container back into the trashcan.
"Good girl. Now," Dean pulled you up off the table and faced you towards him, "If you're not on my bed naked in the next 2 minutes, there will be hell to pay." Dean smacked your ass once more and pulled you off the table. But it'll be heaven to me, you thought with a smirk.