Rachel watched Jesse closely in rehearsal later that day hoping for a sign as to whether he liked her or not anymore.
'Kurt can you please drop it. We just got home from rehearsal!' Rachel snapped, more irritated with herself than him.
'What's wrong Diva?'
'He has a girlfriend, and she's really pretty,' she managed to choke out in between sobs.
Kurt glanced at Rachel that night as she didn't sing along to Funny Girl. That's it he needed to talk to St. Jerk, I mean this is Rachel, she always sings along to Funny Girl, it's her go to movie.
The next day Kurt was grabbing coffee before rehearsal when he saw St. Jerk with the girl. Well I should just hurry up and get this over and done with.
'Jesse, can I talk to you for a minute?'
'Sure,' he said detaching himself from the girl.
'I thought you liked Rachel,' he said jumping straight to the point.
'Well I do,' he said trying to choose his next words carefully, 'but she always seems to be dating someone.'
'So now you're dating a blonde, that can't possibly be your type?'
'Look, once I thought Rach and I were perfect for each other, but she always brushes me aside, she gets defensive about her ex-boyfriends if I so much as mention them, she drives me crazy and besides I've hurt her too many times,' he sighed.
'So you're with this blonde because you're afraid of something real?'
'I'm not even dating Amanda, we're just friends, but if Rach and I were to date I'd need to know that's it not just to make her ex jealous again, Brody right?'
'Come with me.'
Sung:Thoughts
Summer after high school when we first met
We make out in your Mustang to Radiohead
And on my 18th Birthday
We got matching tattoos
Used to steal your parents' liquor
And climb to the roof
Talk about our future like we had a clue
Never planned that one day
I'd be losing you
In another life
I would be your girl
We'd keep all our promises
Be us against the world
In another life
I would make you stay
So I don't have to say
You were the one that got away
The one that got away
I was June and you were my Johnny Cash
Never one without the other, we made a pact
Sometimes when I miss you
I put those records on (Whoa)
Someone said you had your tattoo removed
Saw you downtown singing the Blues
It's time to face the music
I'm no longer your muse
He used to inspire me so much with my music. I used to sing and be happy and now I always feel sad, especially when I sing a song we've sung together.
But in another life
I would be your girl
We'd keep all our promises
Be us against the world
In another life
I would make you stay
So I don't have to say
You were the one that got away
The one that got away
The o-o-o-o-o-one [*3]
The one that got away
All this money can't buy me a time machine (Nooooo)
Can't replace you with a million rings (Nooooo)
I should've told you what you meant to me (Whoa)
'Cause now I pay the price
Why did I let him go for Finn. I thought that I was doing the right thing but he never really understood me like Jesse. Jesse was my soul mate, my other half and I let him just walk out the door.
In another life
I would be your girl
We'd keep all our promises
Be us against the world
In another life
I would make you stay
So I don't have to say
You were the one that got away
The one that got away
The o-o-o-o-o-one [*3]
In another life
I would make you stay
So I don't have to say
You were the one that got away
The one that got away
Pfft, she's talking about Brody.
'Jesse, what are you doing here?'