AN: This is part two of Forgotten :) And I will be updating Forbidden and writing whatever requests people gave me, but I am focusing on We Are Not Perfect right now. :)

Silence

Lucy watched the sun set. The water was calm and everything around her was quiet. That is until a certain blue cat came up to her.

"Hey Lucy."

"What is it Happy?"

"Why are you crying?"

"No reason. Why don't you get back to Natsu."

"But..."

"I'll be fine and Happy?" Lucy stopped the cat. "Please don't tell the others."

"Sure." Happy flew off leaving Lucy alone with her thoughts.

'It's only right Erza ends up with Jellal. I mean...he is a boy, she is a girl. I could never compete with that. Plus they have known each other for awhile.' She thought sadly.

…...

Erza walked into the cabin that she was sharing with Natsu, Gray, and Lucy. The boys were both sleeping. Natsu was snoring and Gray was naked. Nothing unusual. She looked around and noticed that Lucy wasn't in the room. Happy flew in through the window and saw Erza.

"Happy. Have you seen Lucy?"

Happy scratched the back of his head. "Uhhh...no."

"Are you sure?" Erza stepped closer to Happy and he backed up slowly until he was against the wall.

"Okay! She is sitting by the water!"

"Why is she out so late?"

"I don't know...but she was crying."

"Crying?" Erza walked out the door. Happy sighed and went to lay beside Natsu.

…...

"Lucy." Erza walked up to the girl who was now sleeping. She had her arm over her eyes and was laying flat on her back. Erza sat down by her and shook her gently. Lucy tried hitting her hand away and rolled over. Erza sighed. "Lucy what are you doing out here?"

"Mmm..."

"Lucy please wake up."

"Go away Happy..."

"Last time I checked, I wasn't a flying cat." Erza said. Lucy opened her eyes and turned to see Erza looking at her worriedly.

"Erza." Lucy rubbed her eyes.

'Great...I wasn't ready to see her so soon...' Lucy thought nervously.

"Lucy why are you out here?"

"I..I wanted to sleep here."

"It's not exactly the warmest weather though."

"It's not that bad." Lucy murmured.

"I heard you were crying."

'Damn Happy!' Lucy stared out into the ocean.

"Were you?"

"It was nothing Erza. Why are you out here? What happened to Jellal?"

"I came because you weren't in bed and he left."

"..."

"You still haven't told me why you were crying Lucy."

"I don't really have to though."

"At least come back and get some sleep."

"I will later." Lucy pulled her knees up to her chest and laid her head down. Erza still hadn't left though. It was silent for a few minutes before Lucy spoke again still not lifting her head though. "You're still here."

"I want to make sure you're safe."

"I can take care of myself."

"You do not have your keys or whip."

"..." Lucy groaned as she remembered how she had left her weapons in her bag back at the cabin.

'I would do that.'

"Lucy if something is bothering you, you're always able to tell me."

"I saw you and Jellal kiss."

"What?"

"I saw you guys! Me and Natsu were searching for you and I saw him on top of you."

"Lucy, you have the wrong idea. We did not kiss."

"But..."

"You didn't watch the whole thing did you?"

"Well...no." Lucy lifted her head and looked at Erza. "I thought you loved him."

"I do, but as a brother. There is someone else that captured my heart."

"Oh...sorry."

"Why did it bother you so much? Thinking that Jellal and I kissed."

"...Promise not to laugh...or get mad?"

"I would never laugh at you when you're hurting Lucy."

"Well...I planned on telling you how I felt before we headed back to Fairy Tail, but then I saw you guys...and it hurt."

"How do you feel?"

Lucy blushed and looked away from Erza. "I like you. I like you a lot Erza."

"Are you saying that you like me more than a friend?"

"Yes." Lucy hung her head and waited for the worst from Erza.

"I see. Well this makes things more interesting."

"What do you mean? Are you mad?"

"Of course I'm not mad. It's just I didn't let Jellal kiss me because I wanted my first kiss to be with you."

Lucy turned to look at Erza for any sign of joking, but found none in Erza's serious eyes. "You really mean it..."

"Yes I do. Lucy..." Erza slowly leaned in closer to Lucy as if asking permission to kiss the girl. Lucy let her tears fall as she helped close the gap between them. Their lips touched and Lucy smiled as Erza pulled her closer for a gentle hug. When they pulled away both girls were smiling and Erza started to wipe Lucy's tears away. Lucy threw her arms around Erza and refused to let go.

"Want to head back now Lucy?" Erza asked with a smile.

"Only if you sleep next to me."

"Don't I usually?"

Lucy laughed as she and Erza started their walk back to the cabin.

'I'm glad I didn't get a silent night and I guess I should thank Happy sometime.' Lucy thought happily.