Blindfolded
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee.
Chapter 1: The Hobbit's Lips
Noah Puckerman was blindfolded and tied to a chair, naked, on his twenty-ninth birthday. He could hear snickering as someone began giving him a blowjob. He didn't know who they were or why everyone was laughing. After he came in the person's mouth, the blindfold was removed, and he saw Kurt Anderson kneeling before him, wiping his mouth. Noah broke free from the chair and glared at his girlfriend, Quinn Fabray, and the rest of their friends. He was angry and embarrassed. Quinn had planned the whole thing as a joke, but it had gone too far.
Soon Noah yelled at Quinn, his voice full of hurt and betrayal. He couldn't believe that she would do something like that to him. Quinn was apologetic and insisted that it was meant to be funny. She had even asked Kurt to do it. But Noah wasn't having any of it. He felt humiliated and violated. He had trusted Quinn, and she had betrayed him.
Noah stormed out of the room, leaving his friends and Quinn behind. He hadn't spoken to her since. He was still trying to process the events from earlier, and he was still angry at Quinn for what she had done. He didn't know if he could ever forgive her.
Noah thought his twenty-ninth birthday would be an unforgettable night. Little did he know that Kurt's ex-husband, Blaine Anderson, had a surprise in store for him. Noah was unaware that Blaine had planned this special treat for him. Blaine had been there all along, waiting to surprise him with this truly personalized and intimate gift. It was a moment Noah would never forget.
Noah had his head down, lost in his thoughts, as he sat on the bed. He didn't notice Blaine entering the room until he knelt before him. When Noah looked up, his eyes widened in surprise at the sight of Blaine completely naked, with his penis in his mouth. Noah then gasped and blushed, surprised by what he saw.
As Noah felt Blaine's lips on his own, and felt a wave of pleasure, Blaine's hands traveled up and down his body, exploring every inch of him. Noah closed his eyes and got lost in the moment. Blaine then straddled Noah, pressing himself against him. Noah truly felt pleased now; he felt a connection between them as their lips continued to move together.
Noah didn't realize Blaine had locked the door until he heard Quinn and Kurt pounding on it. He quickly pulled away from Blaine, his cheeks turning red as he realized what they had been doing. Smiling at him, Noah kissed him one last time before unlocking the door. Stepping out of the room, Noah tried to act as though nothing had happened, but he knew his face was still flushed. Despite this, he couldn't help but smile, feeling the connection between them that he had never experienced before.
Blaine was about to leave when Noah stopped him by asking everyone else to leave his house. Then, Kurt threw divorce papers at Blaine, causing him to pause. Quinn stood nearby but couldn't bring herself to look at them. Soon, Kurt stormed out, taking Quinn with him.
Noah eagerly scooped Blaine up and carried him back to his bedroom. His heart thumped with anticipation for the pleasure that would soon follow. Once they were inside the room, Noah gently laid Blaine down on the bed and quickly undressed him, carefully removing each piece of clothing. Finally, Noah secured Blaine by tying his hands to the bedposts, ensuring he was safely bound.
Noah leaned in and kissed Blaine all over his body, exploring every nook and cranny. The moment was palpable as Noah caressed and kissed every inch of Blaine's body. Blaine moaned and writhed in pleasure as Noah brought him to the brink of ecstasy.
Finally, Noah entered Blaine, and the two moved in perfect synchrony, their bodies in tune. The sensation of being connected was overwhelming, and Noah and Blaine moved together in a passionate embrace. They made love for the next four hours, their bodies entwined in a blissful and beautiful union. When they finished, Noah and Blaine lay in each other's arms, feeling completely content and satisfied.
Blaine said, "I didn't tell Quinn or Kurt about my plan."
His voice shakes slightly as he continues. "I asked Kurt for the divorce. It was my decision, and he didn't ask me for it. Quinn had planned to seduce you, but I stepped in and stopped her. Kurt tried to get me to stop, but he knew you'd freak out if you saw him instead of me."
Blaine paused, looking down at the ground. Then he said, "And so I took the blindfold off." Noah pulled Blaine closer to him, but said nothing.
Noah sighed and said, "Before Santana came out as gay, I remember her wanting me to have sex with Matt Rutherford in the shower when we were dating. After the pandemic, I was raped by one of my superiors. I tried to tell Quinn about it, but she didn't want to listen or take me seriously. You were the first guy I wanted to be with, and I loved it when your lips were on Puckzilla."
Blaine and Noah watched as Tina Abrams returned, tears streaming down her face. She was on the phone with her husband, Artie. They didn't pay much attention to her and continued the intimate moment they had started. When Tina finished her call, she took off her jeans and underwear without saying a word and lay between them. Blaine and Noah embraced her, and eventually, all three fell asleep in a tangled embrace.
Tina's stomach lurched when she awoke to hear Noah and Blaine yelling at Artie on the phone. She tried to figure out what was happening, but couldn't. Noah's voice was loud and angry.
"Nothing happened, Artie!" he yelled. "I love Blaine, okay? I'm gay, Artie! If I were straight, I still wouldn't touch Tina!"
Another pause followed, then he yelled, "Whatever, man! I'm done with this conversation!" Tina was shocked and didn't know what to think. All she knew was that Noah and Blaine were standing up for her, which made her heart swell with pride.
Noah entered the room, and Tina removed her shirt. Soon, he picked her up and held her in his arms. Blaine took out his phone and snapped a picture of her, six months pregnant and naked. Tina gazed at the phone, full of hope and anticipation. Noah held her tight, his arms protectively encircling her. It was a moment of pure joy and love to be remembered forever.
Tina quickly put on Noah's football jersey and boxers, not because she didn't have any clothes, but because Noah had requested it. He held her legs up as she got comfortable. She began to finger herself through the slit in the boxers while taking a picture with her phone and sending it to Artie.
She was convinced that if she did this, Artie would forgive her for asking Blaine to perform a sexual favor on Noah. Despite her attempts to make amends, she knew Artie was still angry. She felt deep sorrow for her actions and wished Artie could find peace. She knew it was wrong to pressure Blaine into doing something he might have been uncomfortable with. She hoped Artie could forgive her.
Nancy Abrams, Tina's mother-in-law, soon arrived at Noah's house a few days later with Tina's belongings. She promised to talk to Artie, while letting Blaine know Kurt was now staying with him. She was worried about Artie but relieved to discover Kurt cared enough to take him in. Tina was heartbroken to see her things there, but comforted knowing Artie was in good hands. She thanked Nancy for bringing her things and said goodbye.
As Nancy drove away, she thought about Artie and how he had been since the accident. She was glad to know Kurt was with him now and that he wasn't alone. She only hoped Artie would find a way to forgive Tina soon.
Tina rummaged through the box until she found Artie's football jersey. She quickly stripped out of her clothes and pulled the jersey over her head, feeling the warmth and comfort against her skin. There was something special about wearing Artie's jersey, which made Tina feel closer to him.
Tina glanced up to see Noah standing in the doorway. She told him that the others were on Artie's side. So, she decided to stay at Noah's without telling them. She sighed and said, "They all think you will dump Blaine, and he will return to Kurt." She knew it wasn't true, but it still hurt to think that her friends would choose sides instead of being happy for Blaine and Noah.
Burt Hummel, Blaine's former father-in-law, soon called Blaine in disbelief. As Blaine answered the call, Burt exclaimed to Kurt, "Puck is not the same person he was before, son! You left Blaine, and Quinn left Puck! Do you even know what Puck has been through?" Burt then explained the horrific experience Puck endured—how he had been chained up like a dog and raped for hours by someone he trusted. The person sent Burt videos of the incident, which he could not bring himself to watch. Burt was in shock and could not believe someone could do such a thing to another. He was stunned that someone he once trusted could be so heartless.
Burt was committed to bringing Puck's torturers to justice. He wanted to make sure no one went through something like that again. Burt was determined to seek justice for Puck and all victims of cruel violence. He was determined to ensure no one suffered through something like this again.
Burt ended the call, and Tina, Blaine, and Noah reacted differently. Tina put her hands over her ears; Blaine covered his eyes while Noah covered his mouth. However, none of these actions could shield them from the pain. Tears flowed down their faces as they struggled with intense sadness and sorrow. Each had lost something precious to them, and now they had to pick up the pieces and move on. The situation was challenging, but they had one another, which could never be taken away.
Soon Artie calls Tina's phone before she yells, "Rachel knew it was just a dream, Artie! Why don't you? Puck is still Puck, and Blaine is still Blaine! I don't even know why you guys are so freaked out about a dream I had in high school!"
She lets Artie speak, then yells, "Would it have been better if Puck was with Kurt?" and ends the call.
Then Artie calls Noah's phone next, and he answers, yelling, "This is stupid, Artie! Are you married to Santana? Is Tina married to Rachel?"
Noah lets Artie speak again, then yells, "Blaine could have tried to make it work with Kurt, but he chose to be with me! This relationship with Blaine might not last, or we could grow old together! We don't need you guys to decide stuff like that for us! Now, forgive Tina and tell the others. They are not allowed to come back here!" before Noah ends the call.
Artie quickly dials Blaine's number and waits for him to answer. When Blaine finally picks up, he stares at Noah before saying, "Fuck you all!" and then passionately kissing him as he ends the call.
Tina experienced a confusing mixture of emotions as she observed Noah and Blaine together. On the one hand, she was elated that they had discovered each other and were clearly enamored. On the other hand, she felt remorseful for the dissolution of their other friendships due to their union. It seemed like a double-edged sword, as she struggled to determine which feeling predominated. She yearned to be content for them, yet could not help but feel guilty about the demise of those connections. It proved to be a challenging choice for her, but she resolved to confront this dilemma.
Blaine was overwhelmed with emotion when his parents brought him his belongings. All he wanted was to be reunited with his daughter, Tracy. But the reunion was not to be, as Tracy had died from COVID-19. Blaine was overcome with grief and tears.
Noah comforted him. He knew all too well what Blaine was suffering through, for he too had lost someone to the virus. His daughter, Beth, had died of COVID-19 months earlier. Soon, Noah held Blaine close as the two shared their sorrow and pain.
In that moment, Blaine and Noah found solace in each other. Both having experienced the same tragedy, they were able to find some relief in the presence of someone who truly understood their pain.
After Blaine settled into his new home, Noah and he couldn't help but admit their love for each other. They soon spent six hours in each other's arms, filling each other with love and passion, until they decided to make the relationship official on Facebook. Rachel St. James was the only one who showed understanding and forgiveness in the comments, offering support to Tina. Kurt, on the other hand, immediately blocked Noah from his profile.
An hour later, Santana apologized for her earlier actions and asked Tina if she would be a surrogate for Noah and Blaine once she had her son, Arthur Jr. Tina accepted Santana's apology, and they became friends again, looking forward to the next chapter in Noah and Blaine's lives.
That night, Noah and Blaine lay naked in bed, side by side, with each other's hand resting on the other's hip. Soon, Noah pulled Blaine closer, smiling as he spoke, "I hate that Tracy and Beth are gone, but I hope they're happy that we're together now. I love you, Blaine."
Blaine smiled back, looking into Noah's eyes, and said, "I love you too, Noah." They hugged tightly, both feeling blissful knowing that, despite everything between them and their friends, they still had each other.
Then Rachel texts Noah the message, "Blaine is still my best friend, Puck. You better not hurt him. By the way, Burt was half right. Kurt did leave Blaine to save him, but it wasn't from gay bashers. It was to keep him from learning that Kurt had been fooling around on him with other guys he met at Dalton since Tracy died."
Noah shows Blaine the text before Blaine goes under the covers and gives Noah a blowjob. Then Noah replies to Rachel, saying, "Blaine is over Kurt and couldn't care less right now, Rach. Blaine has me now, and I love him more than Kurt." Soon after, Noah shuts off both of their phones before moaning Blaine's name repeatedly. While Tina records Noah's moaning with her phone and then sends the audio clip to all their friends.
Chapter 2 will be up soon.