Finn, Maddy, and Victor are startled by the miracle of Rachel being alive after being stabbed multiple times. Finn is relieved to see his girlfriend alive.

"Thank God, you're alive." cried Finn.

"Yeah. I'm hurt badly. But I think I'm okay." assured Rachel as she attempts to stand up.

"Let me help you up."

Rachel holds on to Finn as he assists her up. As Finn goes to examine her wounds, she pulls something out from the back of her pants.

"Baby...I'm sorry I have to do this. But..." Rachel began before - STABBING FINN in the stomach.

"NO!" Maddy screamed out.

"What the hell?!" exclaimed a shocked Victor.

Finn gasps in pain. He looks up at the girl that he loved, who he thought loved him. Betrayal in her eyes. She's not the person that he thought she was.

"It was fun while it lasted. But I'm afraid that it's time for me to move on with my ultimate goal. My ultimate revenge." Rachel informed Finn before stabbing him again. This time much deeper.

"Rachel...Rachel...Why?!" a fading Finn asked before losing consciousness.

Rachel pulls the knife out of Finn's stomach and his body falls onto the floor. Rachel turns to a horrified Maddy and Victor and gives them a sinister smile. Maddy looks at Rachel's shirt and realizes that there are NO stab wounds on her shirt. Just bright red fake blood.

"Gotcha, didn't I?" asked Rachel, observing that Maddy was examining her shirt. "Well, it's all part of the plan."

"What plan?" asked a confused and devastated Maddy.

Rachel smiles before answering, "All in good time, Maddy." She threateningly points the knife at Maddy and Victor. "Now get into the living room."

Victor stands in front of Maddy as they cautiously walk into the living room. He is not about to let Maddy get hurt. Rachel pushes them into the living room. Maddy gasps in horror upon seeing both her father and some other man tied up to chairs with their mouths taped.

"Daddy!" exclaimed Maddy as she attempted to approach him. But Rachel pulls her back.

"I don't think so." said Rachel.

Rachel pushes Maddy to the wall and points her knife at her. Victor stares at the other man, whose head is facing down.

"Who is that other man?" asked Victor.

The other man raises his head up and is revealed to be - KEVIN LASSITER.

"Kevin Lassiter?" asked a shocked Maddy. "But he was just…" Then it just hit Maddy, who stares at Rachel as she finally realizes the truth…

"Lassiter never did any of this…did he?" asked Maddy.

"No." Rachel confirmed.

"But I don't get it. Why? How? What…" Maddy stuttered, trying to figure everything out.

"Well, you see, Maddy…we paid that security guard to break him out and then my partner…the guy who pretended to 'kill' me...killed him and stowed Lassiter away so that we would actually do the killings ourselves. But then in the end…we'd frame Lassiter and everyone will believe that he was the one who killed everyone. They already believe that he's the one who killed Billy Calhoun, Aria, and Principal Roosevelt. And they will believe it when I kill you, Victor, your father, and everyone else who may still be alive here."

Maddy is shocked by all of this.

"Why are you doing this?" asked Maddy.

Now is the time to explain everything.

"Five years ago, my sister Crystal was raped by Billy Calhoun." Rachel began.

James's eyes widened by this news. He knows exactly where this is going.

"And your Daddy dearest over here was the presiding judge. He and Billy's lawyer, whowas Aria's father, made some kind of deal and because Mr. Shaw used a loop-hole in the legal system, he made Billy look innocent and my sister a lying whore. Crystal lost that trial and Billy went free. That trial, which was supposed to help her heal by putting her rapist away, not only failed to do that...but it made her look like a villain. People began to believe everything that Billy and Aria's father said about her. People around town would call her a whore and a liar. They harassed her. They destroyed her life. She couldn't live with herself after all of that. She killed herself. Just like your mother did."

"I thought you said that your sister was murdered and that they never caught her killers." Maddy reminded her.

"She was murdered...by Billy's lies, by Mr. Shaw giving the Jury a bad image of her, and by your father letting Billy go. They murdered her by making her feel that she was wrong and couldn't stop it, and drove her to suicide. So yes, they murdered her and got away with it.

James is struck by this statement. He is filled with guilt.

"I'm sorry." muffled James.

"What's that? I didn't hear you." said Rachel.

Rachel approaches the tied up James and rips the tape off of his mouth.

"I'm so sorry, Rachel." said James. "I never meant for that to happen."

"But you did let it happen...by letting her rapist go." Rachel reminds him.

"The law forced me. I had no choice."

"Fuck the law! You knew damn well what he was."

James tears up as he nods.

"Yes. I knew. I didn't need evidence to see that Billy Calhoun was a monster." James admits. "I didn't want to let him go. But my job is to uphold the law. It was my job. I was only doing my job."

"Well, your job is the reason that I'm going to kill you like I killed Billy for raping my sister. My partner killed Aria for her father's sins and Principal Roosevelt."

"Why Principal Roosevelt?" asked Maddy.

"Because...he was with friends Aria's father and as the Jury Foreman, he was paid by Mr. Shaw to convince the Jury that Billy was innocent." Rachel revealed.

"But why kill all of us? Me, Finn...your own boyfriend and our friends. What did we do to you?" asked Maddy.

"I have to kill you to keep up the appearance that Lassiter went on a killing spree. Then I will kill him and claim that it was in self-defense. I will be the hero of Tippecanoe who stopped the infamous Kevin Lassiter. So, I'm afraid...you have to die now."

Maddy is horrified but ready to fight as Rachel raises her knife up in the air.

"Goodbye, sweet Maddy. You were always a true friend."

Rachel goes to swing the knife down at Maddy.

"NO!" shouted Victor.

Victor gets in the way and is accidentally stabbed in the shoulder and falls to the floor. Rachel decides that she'll finish off Victor first. But before she can put in another stab at him, Maddy grabs a lamp with a glass shade from the table and throws it at her. The lamp shatters against Rachel's face and she falls backwards.

"RUN!" Victor instructs Maddy.

Maddy proceeds to run away. Rachel recovers and gets up. The injured Victor uses his feet to trip Rachel. But she quickly gets up and kicks him in the face. All James can do is sit there and watch helplessly as Victor is attacked and Rachel begins to chase his daughter.

Rachel runs across the foyer and into the dining room, which is where she saw Maddy run to. But upon arriving at the dining room, she doesn't see her anywhere. She realizes that Maddy went into the kitchen and storms into the kitchen herself. Rachel sees the backdoor closed and assumes that she went out the backdoor. She runs over to the door and attempts to open it. But it's locked. She couldn't have gone out the backdoor. That means...Maddy is still in the kitchen.

Rachel turns around to face the entire kitchen. There are so many places for her to hide. Rachel points her knife forward, ready to stab anything that comes in front of her.

"Come on out, Maddy." Rachel orders. "There's no point in fighting this. You've already lost."

Rachel walks around the kitchen in search of Maddy, who is nowhere to be seen. She finds the closed closet door beneath the staircase. She quietly reaches for the doorknob, hoping to sneak up on Maddy. She opens the closet door. GOTCHA! Nope. Maddy is not in there.

"Shit!" exclaimed Rachel.

Rachel continues looking around the kitchen for her target. As moves away from the stove area and skims through the nook area, the bottom cupboard of the island quietly opens and Maddy quietly sneaks out. Rachel making noises and groaning out of frustration helps Maddy quietly sneak out of the island cupboard. Rachel takes a moment to breathe as she becomes extremely frustrated over not finding Maddy.

"Where the fuck are you, bitch?" Rachel mutters to herself.

Rachel continues to look around for Maddy. She feels a presence behind and spins around - CLANK! Maddy whacks Rachel in the face with a hard skillet. Rachel becomes disoriented by this but able to fight still. So Maddy continues to hit her in the head multiple times. After several blows to the head, Rachel drops to the floor. Not moving nor breathing. Perhaps Maddy actually killed her. Maddy slightly cries over this. Not only does she believe that it's over but that she had to end it by killing her friend. Maddy walks away from Rachel's body and returns to the living room.

Upon returning to the living room, Maddy checks on Victor, who is sitting against the wall and holding his wound.

"Are you okay?" asked Maddy.

"I'm alright. Go save help your Dad." said Victor.

Maddy goes to untie her father.

"I'll have you out in no time." Maddy assured her father.

James looks up and sees something behind Maddy that horrifies him.

"BEHIND YOU!" James shouted.

Maddy turns around in time to find Rachel coming at her with the knife. She catches her wrist before the knife could penetrate her body. Maddy and Rachel struggle over dominance of their strength. Maddy tackles Rachel to the wall. The struggle and the impact makes Rachel lose her knife. Maddy and Rachel proceed to fight each other; punching each other, pulling at each others' hairs, slapping each other, and throwing each other around the living room. It's a battle between the final girl and the female killer.

Rachel gets the upper hand and throws Maddy and she accidentally collides with the tied up Lassiter, resulting in both Maddy and Lassiter to fall to the floor. While lying on the floor, Lassiter feels Rachel's knife at the tip of fingers. So he grabs the knife. Meanwhile, before Maddy attempts to recover from the fall, Rachel holds her down and proceeds to choke her. Maddy attempts to pull her hands off of her neck. But Rachel is so enraged that her strength has reached maximum levels.

"You've made this so much worse. Now I will kill you slowly and make it hurt." Rachel threatened.

It appears that Maddy is losing consciousness. However, before anything more could - the sound of flesh ripping his heard. Rachel screams out as it's revealed that she's been stabbed in the back with her very own knife by - LASSITER. She looks up at him and is shocked that he's free from being tied up.

"How did you..."

But Lassiter doesn't let her finish her question and proceeds to slice her throat. Rachel chokes and gasps as blood flows out of her throat wound like a waterfall. Lassiter throws Rachel aside to the floor. Rachel Fillmore, the Washington killer, is dead. But Lassiter turns to Maddy, who becomes terrified upon realizing that she's his next target. Lassiter raises the knife up.

"NO!" James begs for his daughter's life.

"Don't hurt her!" Victor also begs for Maddy's life.

Maddy grabs a large broken piece of broken shard of the glass lamp shade. Lassiter goes to swing the knife down at Maddy. But she quickly jumps up and rams the glass shard into Lassiter's heart. Lassiter gasps in pain over this, dropping Rachel's knife in the process, before dropping to his knees. Maddy gets the knife and stares at Lassiter. He gives her a smile. A smile of approval and permission to finish him off. And that is exactly what Maddy does. She stabs Lassiter in the heart. He gasps one last time before he stops breathing. His eyes roll back and Lassiter falls backwards onto the floor. Kevin Lassiter, the original Washington Killer, is dead.

Maddy sighs in relief over this. It's finally over. She goes over to her father and uses the knife to cut the rope and free him.

"You did good." James assures and comforts his daughter.

Maddy smiles.

"Thank you, Daddy." said Maddy.