Chapter five:
Leo and Raph are in the kitchen getting some food, Raph warming up some leftovers forbidding Leo to do so; in worry of Leo somehow breaking the microwave like he does with the toaster. Neither really feeling like telling Donnie that the microwave got broken, it's a pain for Donnie to move it to try to fix it as it hangs on the wall. They eat the leftovers glad to have something in their stomachs.
"Wanna watch something?" Raph offers after they put the dishes in the sink to wash later. He scoops Leo up bridal style as soon as the other gives him a sound of confirmation. He smirks when the other looks to him at this. "What? I like carrying you this way." He takes him out to the living room setting him down on the couch. He picks out the Space heroes movie for them to watch, as Leo spots a glimpse of its DVD case.
Leo smiles in excitement as it had been a little bit since he last saw it. So he thinks it'll be a great little movie for them to watch. He thinks it is a masterpiece after all, despite having originally been skeptical about the movie being any good.
Raph joins him on the couch and wraps an arm around Leo who snuggles up against him. He lets out a soft pleased sound, only meant for Leo's ears, as they get comfy cuddling to watch the movie.
Behind them Casey notices this happening and smiles at seeing the two being happy. He's glad that they were able to get together.
It's been a day since the three had their little talk with Casey.
Casey feels a hand on his shoulder and turns to see April. He shares a smile with her as their eyes meet.
"How are you doing?" April inquires planting a small kiss on Casey's cheek getting a blush.
"I'm doing alright." Casey kisses her cheek, trying to appear confident as if to regain some dignity, getting a giggle from the female.
"Don't be so worried about it. As cute as it is you don't lose any of your dignity for blushing." April tells Casey, running a hand down his arm as she moves a little away from him. "You are cute like this though." She playfully teases earning a snort from Casey.
"I'm not cute. I'm awesome and cool." Casey corrects her and does a movement with his hands; having them in the air at chest height with palms down then sliding his hands away as if on a surface.
"Whatever you say." April nuzzles Casey's jawbone with affection. She shifts only enough to look at his face. She relaxes at seeing Caseys smile, which does worry him for a moment. She spots it pretty quickly despite that he tried to hide it. "It's okay, you didn't do anything wrong. I'm just used to the two making noises at me when I give them affection. Just wanted to make sure what I was doing was ok."
"Oh yes, yes. It's good, great in fact! Wait what kind of noises do they make?" Casey knows that it makes sense for turtle mutants to make noises. He just isn't sure if he knows which of the sounds she means. He's heard Raph make some sounds when they would hang out, just thinks that none of them sounding like a noise to a mate or even potential mate.
April gives him a slight teasing smirk which tells him that he's not giving any answers. Something she confirms when she speaks. "Oh you'll find out." She sends a wink his way before heading off to go do something.
Casey stands there staring after April. He turns away and glances around. His curiosity starting to get the better of him. He spots Mikey heading into the kitchen so he moves to follow. He approaches the other in the kitchen as said other glances to what they have left. He supposes that the other must be figuring out dinner. "What are you thinking of making?" He inquires moving closer causing Mikey to turn to him.
"Maybe we'll have some rice, fish, and steamed veggies. That usually ends up really good, especially with some of my special sweet and sour sauce."
"Mm." Casey hums as he can almost taste it now. "It sure does." He leans against Mikeys shoulder who grins at this. He chuckles warmly when the other nuzzles his head. He blinks when he hears the other let out a chirp that sounds happy. He hasn't heard Raph chirp like that and he blushes softly, finding it super adorable coming from Mikey. "How does everything about you manage to be so adorable?" He questions nuzzling Mikey back who churrs lovingly.
"I'm just good at it." Mikey playfully boasts getting a chuckle from Casey.
"You sure are." Casey confirms and feels his heart sing happily when Mikey kisses his cheek. He thinks that he truly does like the attention from the two. He supposes that just leaves Donnies turn to give him affectionate attention. He decides that he will do him next. He doesn't doubt that he'll like it too, since he honestly did feel like Donnie was pretty good looking. He can't help an image of him having Donnie against a wall, dominating his mouth with his tongue. He pushes it away with the help of hearing Mikey give a few loving chirps. He supposes that there's always time for loving each of them like that. He kisses Mikey's cheek who lets out a string of happy sounds. He wants to hear even more and nuzzles Mikey's jawline. He gets a churr for this.
"Well good to see that things are going well at least." A voice comes from the entrance of the kitchen making the two jump then turn. Raph is standing there with a slight smile. He heads to the fridge grabbing one of the few beers in there, Splinter lets them have it once they came of age though only allowing a certain number of it in the lair.
Not to mention that whole mandatory Splinter lesson about alcohol, the dangers, things that can happen when drinking it, and to be responsible about drinking it.
What turned out interesting was that the four turtles made their own rule, whoever drank the last one would buy the next stock of it. So sometimes a single one will be left in the fridge until someone drinks it no longer caring about buying more; Usually Raph ends up being the one having to buy more.
Knowing Raphael though he probably doesn't care as much as some may think. He probably has a hidden stash of his own somewhere, and uses the buying the family more to replenish his own hidden stash. Though he does still try to resist drinking the last one for as long as he can.
Casey gets distracted when Mikey rubs his head against the underside of his jaw. He lets out a warm chuckle at the cat like behaviour. Momentarily forgetting Raph had walked in... Until the pop of a beer being opened is heard and Raph lets out a groan.
"Right now you lovebirds?" Raphael groans though it sounds more teasing than actually annoyed.
"Oh be quiet." Mikey heads over to Raph looking at his eyes. "Are you just jealous you're not getting this attention from Leo right now? Unable to show off and try to seem better at affection than us?" He teases and Casey has a feeling the youngest might get smacked.
Casey contemplates getting a snack and watch this little tease off the two are having. He wonders who will win after all.
"Pfft. I have nothing to prove to you. I know we do it better." Raph snorts and Casey leans against the table crossing his arms as he watches.
"You haven't been with someone for even half as long as I have." Mikey chuckles waving that off. "I don't think you can accurately compare us just yet."
"You bastard." Raph hisses and glares a little at the youngest turtle.
"What is going on?" Leo's voice comes from the entrance grabbing all three of their attention, to which they realize that Splinter is right there too.
"Now boys." Splinter moves towards the two turtles. "There is no need to fight. The only time one relationship is better than another is if one relationship is abusive. Which I know neither of yours is." His words cause the two turtles to glance away in different directions. He seems to be able to tell that they understand. "Good. I don't want to be hearing about this again. Raphael take that and go try to relax a little." He nods to the drink so Raph heads off with it in hand.
Leo glances to Splinter before following after Raph.
Mikey shifts and looks down apologetically at Splinter, who gives him an assuring shoulder pat which does seem to help his mood.
While Splinter makes himself some tea Casey moves over to Mikey, letting him cuddle up with him as he's glad he can be here to help bring up the mood again.
"Can you help me with making supper Casey?" Mikey requests blinking with that innocent adorable look. His eyes big, pleading, and too adorable mixed with that pout to refuse.
"Of course." Casey confirms with a smile and kisses Mikey's nose getting a giggle from him. "Where do we start?" He doesn't miss Splinters slight glance with a smile in his direction, though it was only for a moment. He follows Mikey's instructions until they've finished making supper, just on time for it to be the time they usually eat too.
Splinter had taken his tea elsewhere, sometime during the time the two were cooking.
"I'll start dishing everyone up. You go and let them know that suppers ready. Especially Donnie, he may not even hear me if I call out that it's ready." Mikey mentions causing Casey to snort as it is typical Donnie.
"Of course." Casey heads out of the kitchen hearing Mikey hum to himself after he left. He spots April lounging on her phone on the couch so he approaches.
April quickly takes notice of this and lowers her phone to look at him. "So. Found out about any of the noises?"
"Some cute ones from Mikey." Casey admits getting a chuckle from April.
"Yeah, he knows how to be so adorable it's hard to stay mad at him for anything." April confirms making Casey smile more than he already is.
"Oh and supper is ready by the way."
"Awesome!" April gets up heading to the kitchen, so Casey heads to find the others.
Casey finds Splinter in his room. "Supper." He lets him know getting a soft hum before the other responds.
"I will be there momentarily."
"Okay." Casey leaves him alone and wonders where Leo and Raph went. He tries their rooms which turns out nothing. He starts to walk around a little, worried that they went into the tunnels so he might not be able to find them. He hears some soft murmuring when he gets close to the dojo. He peeks inside trying to not be spotted.
Inside Leo and Raph are sitting together on a stack of extra mats. Leo has his head laying on Ralph's shoulder, and Raph is slightly leaning into Leo. Their murmurings slowing to a comfortable silence.
Raph offers Leo a sip of his beer which the other reluctantly drinks a little.
Leo makes a face after drinking a little.
This causes Raph to chuckle warmly at this.
It is known that Leo prefers almost any of kind alcohol that isn't beer. He will only occasionally drink beer though usually if it's a group thing. He'll do it, that doesn't mean he enjoys it.
Casey smiles a little at this, then his smile grows a little when Raph places a kiss on Leo's head. His earlier worries about not being able to find them slipping completely away. He silently admits to himself that the two do actually make a good looking couple. He's happy that Raph has been able to find someone for him, even if it isn't who he originally thought it would be. He decides that he doesn't need to keep watching them and steps into the room. He easily catches their attention by doing this. "Hey. Supper is ready." He informs them causing the two to get to their feet.
"Thank you Casey." Leo mentions and Raph just nods before the two head out of the dojo.
Casey heads towards the lab as there is one last person, well mutant, to inform. He gets inside and begins looking around. He finally finds Donnie at one of the many work benches the other has. He lets the genius finish welding whatever he's putting together. He speaks up, moving closer, when the turtle puts the face shield down.
Donnie turns to Casey allowing their eyes to meet. "Ah. Hello there Casey." He greets as the other comes to stand next to him. "How are things going?"
"They're going pretty alright." Casey confirms with a soft hum. His mind bringing up the image of himself kissing Donnie once more. He wonders if it'd be wrong to steal a kiss from the other while they're alone here. He knows he has a fancy for Donnie and April to start with, and Mikey quickly grew on him as well as he thought about maybe joining them, so he isn't surprised by these thoughts. He wouldn't mind kissing any of them, however he doesn't want to cause trouble by kissing one on the mouth for the first time without the others around.
"I can see that somethings on your mind." Donnie mentions causing Casey to blink as he thinks he spaced out for a moment. "Go ahead. You can tell me what it is."
"I just was thinking about a way I wanted to kiss you. Are we just doing the affection and cheek kissing? Or is mouth kissing okay?" Casey inquires giving Donnie pause, though he doesn't mind since the blush Donnie gains is kinda cute.
"Kissing is alright. It's mainly any sort of sexual things that we save the first time being together for." Donnie lets Casey know still with that blush dancing across his cheeks.
"Great!" Casey tries to ignore that his own cheeks warmed slightly in a blush. "Come here." He slightly leans against a nearby wall, using a finger to beckon the turtle over.
Donnie heads over letting Casey gently grab his upper arms. He squeaks lightly when he's turned so his back hits the wall, Casey in front of him. He blinks at the other who smiles happy to be able to do this. "Casey."
"Don't worry Dee. I won't break the rules. This is just a kiss. Unless you don't want to." Casey wants to make sure that this is okay, he doesn't want to ruin this all not when he's more sure than he's ever been that he does want to join them.
"It's okay. You can continue." Donnie confirms causing Casey to release some tension in his shoulders he didn't notice. "Just surprised me is all."
"Okay." Casey hums not hiding that he's glad to hear this. He leans closer letting his breath brush over Donnies lips. He feels a light shudder pass through the other at the anticipation of this kiss. He is so going to enjoy this. He closes the remaining distance sealing his lips onto Donnies own. He hums softly just before moving his lips to properly kiss the genius.
Both of their eyes closed as they kiss one another.
Casey's arms wrapping around the others middle.
Donnies hands coming up to slightly grip at Casey's shoulders. His mouth moving as he returns the kiss with just as much love and passion.
Casey lets out a happy sigh into the kiss, letting himself enjoy this simple kiss knowing that a good tonguing can come later. And oh boy will he give Donnie a good make out session one of these days. He focuses on the kiss not giving any thoughts to anything else anymore. He keeps up the movements of the kiss with Donnie doing the same. He feels one of the others hands slide up the back of his neck, the slight roughness of callused fingers feeling somehow good against his skin.
The callouses just a reminder of the years of grip training, hard work, and expertly using a bo staff in countless fights.
Casey presses a little harder into the kiss which gets a slight churr from Donnie. He finds that when Donnie does that it is hot, unlike how adorable it is with Mikey. His body warming and he has to suppress the sexual thoughts coming up, even ones involving all three of his potential lovers, so he won't go too far with this kiss. He reminds himself that there will be plenty time for all of that later. He kisses Donnie for a little longer before the two of them break apart.
They both open their eyes to half way and instantly let their eyes meet each others.
Casey gives a smile that Donnie quickly returns. He brings a hand up cupping Donnies cheek. His thumb gently brushing the warm skin there. "I can get used to doing this with you all." He admits to Donnie who gains a happy twinkle in his eyes.
"Well that is good to hear." Donnie confirms and after a brief moment he blinks. "Did you come in here just for a kiss."
Casey pauses slightly glancing up just above Donnies head, his mind taking a moment to remember why he had originally came in here. "Oh!" He says as he remembers it and his eyes go back to Donnie. "Thanks for reminding me. Me and Mikey finished supper. You're the last to be told, the others are probably waiting for us."
"Oh. Then we should get going." Donnie mentions to which Casey nods.
Casey lingers there with Donnie for a brief moment before he pulls away. He walks with the other into the kitchen where they join the family at the table. He starts to eat the food finding it delicious, typical for when Mikey cooks, and out of the corner of his eye he spots Mikey lean closer to Donnie who is beside Casey.
"How was it?" Mikey's inquires in a whisper with a slight smile.
Casey wonders if Mikey picked up on that he had kissed Donnie. He supposes it would make sense since Mikey has been with Donnie for awhile, so the youngest turtle can probably see signs that Donnie was kissed.
"Good." Donnie whispers back with a slight blush, causing Casey to smile proud of himself.
Mikey glances to Casey with a sparkle of excitement in his eyes.
Casey meets his eye and silently promises to show him what he did. He sees Mikey get even happier before the turtle turns away. He is going to show all of them that he's serious about joining them. He knows for sure without a sliver of a doubt about it, that this is what he wants.
After dinner...
Casey is pulled away by Mikey into the dojo since it's Leo and Ralph's turn to do dishes.
"Show me." Mikey requests with adorable eyes, and Casey cannot say no to that look.
Casey pushes Mikey up against a wall giving him a smile. "It's just a kiss, that's all that happened, but I think I'll do it the same way I did with Donnie." With that he leans in sealing their lips together.
Mikey giving a hum of appreciation as he returns the kiss.
The twos eyes are closed as their mouths move together in a rhythm, much like Casey and Donnie had earlier.
Casey leans a little into the kiss making it harder getting a pleased hum from Mikey. He feels those hands that are similar to Donnie, yet somehow different in their own way, brush his neck. He feels slight sparks of heat at the feeling of it. He knows it's not as intense as with Donnie, but it is there. He lets himself kiss Mikey for a little longer before he pulls away. He opens his eyes to look at Mikey who is looking back at him.
"Donnie wasn't kidding." Mikey mentions with a smile coming onto his face.
Suddenly a hand guides Caseys head so he's now facing April.
"My turn. Don't leave me out." April licks her lips before crashing her lips onto Caseys. Her eyes fluttering closed like the pretty girl she is.
Casey returns the kiss closing his eyes as he gives April the same treatment. He presses into the kiss, even kind of forgetting that he has Mikey still against the wall.
April is the one to pull away this time and the two look at each other. "You ever kissed before Casey?" She questions looking pleased. "You've got some skill."
"I've only kissed a few girls before. Never went further than that." Casey admits and turns to Mikey who chirps.
"Then if you really want it when the time is right we can all have your first time together." Mikey doesn't need to clarify for Casey to understand what he means.
Casey lightly blushes though tries to play it off as if he isn't blushing. "I'm down for that." He tells them and notices the two share a big smile with each other.
...
Raph pauses in front of Leo's closed bedroom door. He takes a breath reminding himself that he and Leo have been dating for over two months now. He can do this. He gently knocks before opening the door. He steps inside when Leo's voice calls for him to come in. He closes the door behind himself and he heads on over to Leo's bed.
Leo is laying back in his bed with his upper body propped up against pillows and the wall. He watches as Raph sits on the bed next to him. "How are you doing?"
"I'm fine." Raph hums happily and leans closer stealing a kiss that Leo happily returns. He enjoys the sparks of pleasure from the kiss. His left hand starting by Leo's right shoulder before he lets it slide down a little. He can feel Leo lean into his touches and he lets his hand come to rest on Leo's hip. He licks Leos bottom lip getting the other to easily open his mouth. His tongue plunging inside to dance with the blue banded turtle's tongue. He lets out a pleased hum as Leo is just as into the kiss as he is.
Leo's tongue gets pushed back by Raphs in a show of dominance, and much to Raphs pleasure Leo doesn't fight it. He instead wraps his arms around Raphs neck.
Raph repositions them, managing to not break the kiss. He gets to where he has Leo laying on his back on the bed, with the red banded turtle on top of him. He feels Leo's inner thighs brush against his legs as Leo lightly presses his legs against the turtle that is between his legs, which makes a shiver of desire go through him. He can already feel his cock hardening in his shell. He doesn't drop down yet though he does keep kissing Leo. He drops his hips down grinding against Leo.
Their bulges where their hard cocks are hidden rubbing against each other. Both of them breaking the kiss to tilt their heads back letting out moans. They keep up the movements to get even more sounds from each other. Their breaths panting hotly into the rooms air. Their fantastic arousal spiking with every second that passes by.
Raph pulls his hips away, getting a momentary whine from Leo, letting himself drop down. His erection gently slapping Leo's shell.
Leo drops down immediately after with his own erection twitching to show interest. His eyes dart down to get a good look at his boyfriends cock. He swallows saliva and Raph can tell that Leo doesn't just have a desire for it, he has a craving for it.
"Do you have lube?" Raph inquires causing Leo to blush, he adores that blush so much. He swears it adds to his beauty.
Leo reaches for his nightstand and tries to open the drawer... But the angle is wrong.
Raph reaches over taking over. He reaches inside finding two round things. He pulls them out finding a half empty bottle of lube and a red dildo. "Damn Leo." He smiles at Leo who covers his face in embarrassment. He chuckles putting away the dildo. "How many times do you use that?"
"I used to use it more... Haven't used it in awhile."
"Mm. Guess with the whole pretending to flirt thing you didn't really have time to do that." Raph figures and gets a slight nod from Leo. "That's okay." He moves his body over top of Leo's own. He smiles at the other who peeks through his fingers. "Just means that I can give you a real thing instead. Plus it'll make the orgasms I'll give you all the better. Because I bet you're going to feel so good that you'll have more than one." He adds before swiping his tongue over his top lip. "Gotta admit. Knowing you've used that before is pretty hot."
"Have you ever done this before?" Leo inquires uncovering his face. His hands resting on his chest instead.
Raph shakes his head and pops open the lube. "Just watched enough porn and also read stories online enough to get the idea of it." He admits putting some lube on his fingers. "Casey gave me his old laptop when he got a new one so I could check it out at any time. And what about you?"
"Haven't done it either." Leo admits watching Raph lower his fingers. "I only ever used the... Fake cock... And my imagination." He admits with saying that he used the dildo quieter than the other words.
"Well then we can share our first time together." Raph churrs at the thought of it and pushes his fingers in. He was planning on starting with one, but after seeing Leo's dildo he knows the other can handle it. He still starts slow and gentle as it has been awhile. He watches Leo's face to gauge if he's in pain or not.
Leo gasps softly at the stretch though he doesn't seem to be in too much pain.
Raph thrusts his fingers in and out, waiting for some pain to go away before he will spread his fingers to stretch Leo. He finally moves his fingers apart as Leo relaxes a little. He knows that he should get Leo nice and open, he may be a little bigger than the dildo Leo's been using as the other is sure to find out. He kisses along Leo's jawline while he stretches out his mates entrance, enjoying the sound of a churr that escapes the other.
After a bit of preparation Leo shifts clearly starting to get impatient. "Raph." He slightly whines at the other.
"I hear you." Raph confirms and he pulls out his fingers. He smirks as he doesn't miss that momentary flash of Leo missing them inside him, even though the other clearly knows that something better will replace them. He lines up his hardened cock to Leo's entrance. He lets his cock head nudge and rub against that entrance like a warning he's going in.
Leo almost holds his breath in the anticipation of finally feeling this, finally being taken by someone he loves so dearly.
Raph begins to thrust his cock inside. Groaning at the warm tight feeling as he sinks deeper into that wonderful hole. He pauses once he's fully inside to give Leo a moment to adjust. He gets a nod from Leo after a few moments so he pulls back then thrusts inside again.
Leo moans out raising his hips in an attempt to meet with each of Raphs thrusts. He doesn't hold back his voice at all as they fall into a nice rhythm of thrusts.
"Fuck! Leo you feel so good!" Raph groans out slightly tilting his head back while picking up the pace of his thrusts a little. He enjoys every sound of pleasure spilling from Leo's mouth. He wants more, he wants to make Leo absolutely crumble into pleasure. He wants to see the faces Leo makes as he loses himself in the moment. And oh he is going to make sure he gets what he wants. He gradually picks up the pace of his thrusts, leaning over Leo's body to place kisses down his neck. He gets a slight churr that results in a full churr when he drags his tongue up that same neck. He kisses the underside of Leo's chin while the other tilts his head, allowing the red banded turtle better access to his neck. "Such a good boy." He sets an even quicker pace now pounding Leo into the bed.
Leo's moans having increased to a loud pleasurable sound. His hips still moving to try to keep up yet are falling behind, as Raphs thrusts are rather quick rough and oh so good. He can't get enough of it. "Raph!" He cries out in pleasure with his hands gripping tightly onto the others shoulders.
"Fuck Leo." Raph groans back at the other moving as fast as he can within Leo.
The bed is slightly creaking from their movements, not that either of them really notice.
Their moans and groans filling the room to the beat of the sounds of the thrusts. Making a beautiful harmony of pleasure.
Raph swearing that he got addicted to the feeling of being buried deep inside Leo from first entry. He uses his body to hold the other in place, as best as he can since his thrusts do shift Leo, while he has his way with the fearless leader.
Leo's legs spread wide and wantonly, all for Raph to use his body as he pleases. His moans streaming from his mouth loud and unrestrained.
Neither of them even concerned if anyone else hears them. Too caught up in each other to even bother remembering anyone else.
"Leo!" Raph groans out not letting his powerful thrusts miss a beat. "Fuck, Leo I love you."
"Raphie!" Leo calls out a nickname that hasn't been used in a long time. "I love you! Please!" His hips twitching as feeling the warm hard cock inside him was a feeling he never thought he'd have, and it's making him be driven towards orgasm much faster than usual.
Raphs fingers brush the blue banded turtles tail causing Leo to arch into his body. "You like that fearless?" He teases while still pounding into that deliciously tight body. "You like when I play with your tail?"
"Yesss!" Leo slightly slurs out from the pleasure causing Raph to chuckle. He gasps and whimpers a little between his loud moans as his tail is played with further. His body having never ending jolts of pleasure shooting through him. His dull nails digging into Raphs shoulders as he is being drawn into overstimulation. Yet somehow he finds it to be too good to even care.
Raph lets out a churr before kissing at the right side of Leo's neck. "You gonna cum for me my darling blue?" He inquires before planting another kiss on that neck. He gets a slight sound of confirmation, as Leo's mind has been turned to mush from the overstimulation so he can't form many words. He finds that the only word Leo manages to make is his lovers name. He smirks against the skin of the others neck at this. "Then cum for me. I want you to cum so I can dump this load into your nice tight entrance." He gives one more neck kiss. "Then maybe one day we can get Donnie to find a way for me to get you all knocked up. All pretty with my eggs." He slams his cock dead onto Leo's prostate.
Leo throws his head back with a scream of pleasure, his eyes closed from the force of it tearing through his body, and his cock twitches as he cums. His seed splashing onto both of their torsos.
Raph grips Leo's tail with a loud groan as that entrance gets impossibly tighter. He clamps his teeth down onto Leo's neck, marking him as his and no one else's, just before he starts cumming into Leo in long messy squirts. He keeps his hips pushed as far forward as they can go. Wanting to implant his potent seed as deep inside the other as he can.
The two of them lay there basking in the glow of their orgasm; Leo not able to do much as his body feels like jello and Raph has him stuck in place.
Not that Leo minds.
Finally after ensuring that he has completely emptied his load of seed into Leo Raph lets go of his neck. He gives a lick to the bleeding bite mark he left behind while panting.
Leo is also panting with the high of the pleasure slowly wearing off.
After a few long moments Raph pulls his soft cock out of Leo. He lets his cock go back into hiding, just as Leo's does as well. He shifts off of his lover instead laying beside him. Pulling his mate into an embrace in his arms.
Leo happily nuzzles into Raphs embrace.
The two sharing a resounding churr that they release for the other. They are smiling happily.
"Go ahead and rest my love." Raph places a kiss on Leo's forehead. "You more than earned it."
The two end up falling asleep right there in each others arms.
...
"Casey!" April calls getting the other human's attention.
It's been awhile since Casey became officially a part of the threesome, making it a foursome. He couldn't be happier with how things have turned out. "Hey April!" He heads over to her from the other side of the living room. "What's up?"
"Feeling up to having your first time with us? We're going to meet up in Donnies room tonight. Leo and Raph will be out on a date tonight. And Splinter left for his two week spiritual trip just a little ago."
Casey blushes. He knew that this would come up though he can't quell the slight nervousness mixed with his excitement. "Sure." He agrees and smiles softly at seeing Aprils face light up at his agreement.
"Great! Meet up in Donnies room at eight tonight." April dashes off to the dojo where the turtles are doing a little extra practice for the day.
Casey shifts feeling his heart beat a little faster in excitement of being able to fully join them. Sure is as much a part of the three as any of the others in the relationship, but the one thing he isn't a part of is the sex... Yet. Now he is getting a chance to be able to change that. He had been waiting for this moment, waiting for them to be ready to do this with him. He settles on the couch trying to calm himself down. He can wait for tonight when the fun begins.
That night...
Leo and Raph left for their date an hour ago.
Now Casey is making his way towards the door that opens to Donnies room. He can feel his heart beating slightly faster than usual from his anticipation. He swallows back some saliva and stops in front of the door. He knows that once he goes inside there's no turning back. He smiles to himself and grips the doorknob with his hand. He twists it open stepping into the room. He finds three pairs of eyes turn to him as he does so.
"That's everyone!" Mikey chirps with excitement as Casey joins the three on the bed.
"How do you all want to start?" Casey inquires only to be pulled by Donnie towards himself.
"With your attention on me." Donnie tells Casey with a smile before tugging Casey into a kiss.
Casey returns the kiss and feels the slight tug. His mind thinks that it is an invitation to get on top. He hesitates wanting to make sure he read Donnie right. Just before his eyes close he sees out of the corner of his eye Mikey pushing April down.
The two locked in their own kiss.
Casey becomes a little braver at this and pushes Donnie down. He climbs on top of the other settling himself between said others legs.
Donnie lets out an appreciative moan at this. His moan sends a shockwave of pleasure down Casey's spine.
Casey links his tongue with Donnie as the other opens his mouth enough to allow this. He can taste the leftover pizza Donnie ate earlier. He finds it quite good with Donnies natural taste that he can't quite explain. He lets one hand trail down Donnies side growing bolder in this with every passing moment. His hand comes to rest upon the others hip where he lightly massages it.
Donnie lets out a slight churr and his hips buck up slightly in a pleading manner. He manages to brush against Casey's crotch revealing the almost completely hard cock. He lets out another churr when he brushes against it, bringing Casey to full erection.
Casey feels Donnies hand dip beneath his shirt lifting it up, while trailing his hand along Casey's skin. He can feel the calluses from Donnie not only expertly using his Bo staff but also the hard work he does in the lab. He groans into Donnies mouth at the feeling of this. He gives a slight surprised moan when that thumb of Donnies brushes his nipple.
Their kiss is broken so Donnie can remove Casey's shirt tossing it aside to the floor.
This break from the kiss allows Casey to notice that Mikey already has Aprils upper clothes off. He also can see Mikey massaging one beast with his hand, using his mouth to pleasure the other one, getting moans from April. He is soon brought back to Donnie as the other tugs him down. He kisses Donnies jaw then spreads kisses to the others neck. He gets some small moans for his actions which make his cock weep to be released from its cloth prison. He lets one hand go to Donnies crotch as his curiosity gets him. He feels a bulging slit that he plays with it causing a hard cock to drop into his hand. He sneaks a peek at it seeing that it is pretty good for a human, probably about average for a mutant of his size. He wraps his hand around it starting to pump it getting some more moans from Donnie. His gaze is drawn away when he sees movement.
Mikey has moved April closer to Donnie and Casey. He smiles at Casey when their eyes meet.
April sealing Donnies lips in a kiss that he returns.
"How is it so far?" Mikey inquires pouring lube onto his fingers then tossing it to Casey.
Casey moves away from Donnie to catch the bottle of lube. "Really good." He admits and blushes as Donnie, without looking so he can continue to kiss April, manages to open his pants letting free Casey's erection.
Mikey licks his lips at the sight of this. "Seems like it." He positions his fingers at Aprils pussy entrance. "We have condoms if you want. Though if you are up for it Donnie really likes to have cum pushed deep inside him." He thrusts a finger into April as Casey glances to Donnie.
Casey lets out a groan as Donnies hand strokes his cock. He knows he's clean and he knows that Donnie would be very careful about that. So he doesn't have any worries. He licks his lips at this. "Then I'll give him what he likes." He wets his fingers with the lib before putting the bottle between him and Mikey. He looks down and notices Donnies tail twitches. He uses his lubed fingers to feel until he finds that Donnies entrance is below the tail. He pushes his fingers inside hearing both April and Donnie groaning into their kiss. He's seen enough porn videos to know what to do. He starts by thrusting his fingers in and out of Donnies hole, occasionally shifting the direction of the thrusts trying to locate the spot that makes Donnies pleasure spike. He smirks to himself as he finally hits it gaining a louder moan from Donnie.
One that makes Donnie almost break his kiss with April.
April moans back the same way making it clear that Mikey has found her sweet spot. Her back arching and her hips pushing towards Mikey.
Casey notices that Mikeys arm is moving pretty quickly. He supposes that it isn't really a surprise considering the others energy. He still picks up the pace of his own finger thrusting anyways. He enjoys digging out those moans from Donnie.
As the two males prod that sweet spot inside them both April and Donnie separate their kiss, moaning out in a passion song for their current dominants.
"Can't keep waiting. I need to go in." Mikey mentions taking out his fingers and grabbing the lube. He rubs lube onto his erection, Casey guesses April is using some kind of birth control since Mikey has no condom on, before putting it back where Casey had put it.
Casey spreads his fingers while Mikey gets himself ready. He will ensure Donnie is truly ready for his cock. He can't help watching Aprils face when Mikey enters her.
April tilts her head back with a moan as she is stretched by Mikeys cock.
Casey continues to stretch out Donnie while watching what's happening with the other two.
April pants softly as the other continues to push inside until he is fully inside of her.
Mikey moans a little at the feeling of being inside of April. He looks to Casey who catches his eye giving him a slight wink.
Casey swallows some saliva and unable to wait much longer he pulls out his fingers. He grabs the lube pouring it on his erection, shivering slightly as it feels a little chilly against his hot cock. He uses his hand he used to stretch out the one he is going to take. He moves his cock into position, his eyes now focused on Donnies face, as he gives a slight pressure to the entrance with the head of his cock.
Donnie blinks lustfully pleading to Casey at feeling the teasing at his entrance. "Please Casey. Please, I need it. I need you in me!"
"How can I say no to a pretty face like that?" Casey responds smiling lovingly at Donnie. He finally pushes his cock inside groaning at the warmth; his groan sounding at the same time as Donnies moan at being entered. He goes slow and gentle at first not wanting to make his first time with Donnie bad. He stops once fully inside and finds it so pleasurable as it's warm, not to mention somehow a little tight, making his body beg him to start moving.
Donnies mouth is hanging open and his eyes look a little foggy with pleasure. He is letting out soft happy pleasured sounds.
Mikey begins moving in thrusts inside April getting even more moans from her.
Donnie seems to hear the other two begin truly fucking. He blinks at Casey in a beautiful way to the human, then shifts his hips in a beg for movement to begin.
So Casey obliges, unable to resist the feeling of being inside Donnie and that plea from him, and pulls out until it is just the head of his cock inside. He plunges back in while drinking in the moan that Donnie releases. He does it again and again loving every single moan spilling from the others mouth. He lets out his own small moans at how good it feels to have Donnie clenching around his erection.
The fours moans mixing in the air around them like a symphony of love and desire.
Donnie staying on his back while April remains on her hands and knees. They are in position so they can kiss if they want, or if their minds remember that they can through their lust.
Mikey is the first between him and Casey to begin picking up the pace of his thrusts. His actions drawing out even more, and slightly louder, moans from April for this.
Casey slightly gets lost in his desire and follows Mikey in speeding up his thrusts.
Donnie giving him similar louder and more frequent moans as he does so. His hands shifting to grip at the sheets before letting go to shift his hands again.
This causes April to notice and he shifts her hands to grip onto Donnies.
Donnie grips onto her as well as the two of them are fucked by their other two partners.
Casey hadn't been fully sure about watching the fun. Yet now that he's here he can't help finding it so hot to watch Mikey buck into Aprils pussy. He swears that all three of them are so hot in this moment of love and passion. He can't help but to begin to pound into Donnies tight wet heat even faster. His excitement going past levels he even knew existed.
Donnie crying out then he almost screams when Casey slightly shifts the angle. His sweet spot having been hit which makes Casey smile a little to himself.
Casey mentally pats himself on the back for his lucky shot at Donnies sweet spot on the first shift. He keeps aiming for that spot, his thrusts making Donnies body rock, getting such loud moaning from his partner. He doesn't let up in his pounding which he knows is fine as Donnie isn't complaining.
Donnie keeps moaning and seems to have become possibly lost in the pleasure. He can hardly string proper words together. His body trying to rock into Casey's thrusts speaking enough for him.
Casey lets out a rumble trying to imitate a happy turtle sound. He gets a responding chirp from Donnie that fades into more moaning. He hadn't been sure that his attempt sounded that good. He shrugs it off as his mind is quickly taken over by the pleasure Donnie is giving him.
Mikey is letting out moaning chirps while he is very audibly slamming into April. He's probably going about as hard and fast as he can.
Casey picks up the pace until he can't possibly go any faster or harder. He is glad that they are alone in the lair since none of them are being even slightly quiet.
They are being so loud that if anyone was in the lair then they'd know exactly what was happening.
Casey watches Donnie seeing the turtles face cutely move in pleasure. He really is fucking Donnies brains out. He has the genius reduced to a pleasured pile of mush. He feels a hand touch his cheek bringing his attention to April. His thrusting not even stuttering despite his gaze being brought to April looking at him.
April looks as pleasured as Donnie. She slightly pulls Casey closer and manages to seal their lips in a kiss.
The two moaning into each others mouths while they share a kiss. Their lips moving in a dance of harmony.
Mikey kisses up Aprils spine then up the back of her neck, before nibbling on the centre of the back of her neck.
Aprils hand that had been on Casey's cheek is dropped back to link with Donnies again. Her lips movements pausing as Mikey starts to gently bite at her neck.
Casey pulls away letting himself look to her face. He licks his lips at the sight of her overwhelming pleasure. His gaze brought to Donnie to see him as well.
Donnie has a line of drool dripping down from the side of his mouth. His tongue hanging out of his mouth. With his moans not stopping in the least.
Casey lets out a rather loud moan while he lets himself chase the pleasure of his orgasm.
"Case-!" Donnie attempts to call out his hips starting to twitch as he begins working himself to orgasm. He is cut off by a cry of his pleasure as he is starting to become overstimulated; yet looking to be loving every single second.
Casey feels his orgasm coming like a building pressure begging to release.
Mikey pulls away from Aprils neck managing to catch Casey's eye. He licks his lips as their eyes meet. He speaks once his tongue is back in his mouth. "You beginning to get close to cumming too?" He questions getting a nod from the human male. "Inside. Let's leave our marks into them for this time. You'll be able to be with all of us at some point to mark us as yours too."
"Deal." Casey agrees to this sharing a slight smirk with Mikey, before the two turn back to their partners. He leans down biting at Donnies neck as a need to leave his mark, in more ways than one, starts to take over. He feels Donnies head roll to the other side to give him more access to his neck. He groans into the others skin as said others entrance starts to clench around Casey.
"Casey! Casey!" Donnie begins chanting with his hips twitching as he is drawn ever closer to orgasm.
Casey pulls his mouth away from Donnies skin to speak. His breath ghosting over that spot. "Cum for me." He tells the genius turtle. "I'm gonna cum inside you love." He gives a lick to Donnies neck before continuing. "Give me the best right place to dump my seed inside of you."
Donnie arches towards Casey's body as much as his shell will allow. His mouth wide open as he lets out a slightly choked cry of Casey's name. His cock twitching and jumping as he sprays their torsos with cum.
Casey groans out as the entrance gets impossibly tighter. He clamps his teeth onto Donnies neck and his hips give a final slamming thrust. He pushes his cock as deep inside Donnie as he can before letting this pressure release. He moans out Donnies name, into said others skin, while his cock twitches as it pumps rope after rope of cum deep inside of Donnie.
Donnie lets out another loud moan as he feels himself be filled with cum.
Casey almost misses the sound of April crying out, with her cry being followed by Mikeys own cry.
Indicating that April came and the fluttering around Mikeys cock made him cum.
Casey manages to get his gaze up enough to catch a look at the two.
April looks blissed out. Her hands clutching Donnies tightly, with Donnie more than likely digging his fingernails into her skin to the point of blood.
Not that either Donnie or April seem to care.
Mikey's hips are pressed against her, twitching as he pumps his cum into her.
Casey looks to Donnie as best he can without letting go of his neck. He sees that the other is blissed out. He smirks despite riding the high of his orgasm.
Things calm down moments later as everyone starts to come down from their highs.
April collapses onto the bed with her hands slipping from Donnies now limp hands.
Mikey falls onto his side after pulling himself free from that now soaked pussy.
Donnie letting his body lay there limply on the bed. He didn't really have to move from his back on the bed anyways.
Casey withdraws himself from Donnies soaked ass, only to also collapse on his side on the opposite side of Mikey.
All four of them are panting from the activity they just performed. They let themselves have a few moments to enjoy the afterglow of it all.
"Wow." Casey is the first to speak between the four of them. "That was awesome!"
Donnie lets out an agreed sound. His mind still too much mush from the pleasure to give any other response.
April lets out a happy sound and her eyes closed as the sleepiness starts to set in for her.
"Glad you liked it. There's so much we're going to show you, and not to mention do with you." Mikey hums not even shifting to sit up from where he lays. "But now that we've done this first time with you, together, you can do more with one or two of us instead of just with all of us. It is the rules and you did great following it."
"Sounds good to me." Casey agrees, and a part of him can't wait to see what else they have in store for him next time.
The end.
AN:
This was completely written on my phone. So hopefully any autocorrects were caught.
I hope you all enjoyed this story! I've been working on it on and off for awhile so hopefully I did alright, and didn't mess up a part after coming back from a break from this story.
Thank you for reading!
KitKat.