Hearts Like Ours

By: Liv-x-Case-Benson & CaseyBensonNovak

Chapter 2: Giving

After work, she drove to her favorite boutique and bought Olivia a new leather jacket. Then, she returned to the office. It was now eight. She wondered how late Olivia was working.

Olivia was off work by 7:45 the night and went home to grab a few things - like a change of clothes and other miscellaneous items - and walked up to Casey's office door at 8:22, knocking.

Casey sat on her desk. "It's open."

Olivia opened it. "Hi," she smiled, walking in, closing - and locking - the door. She walked right over to the redhead, and kissed her slowly, purring as she wrapped her arms around her. "Mmmm."

"Mmmm. Someone doesn't waste any time. Hey. I have a present for you."

Olivia pulled back. "No, I don't. Because in this job any second could be your last. You have a present for me?"

Casey nodded and handed her the wrapped leather jacket.

Olivia smiled, tearing the paper to shreds, gasping. "Casey...it's gorgeous," she said, slipping off her jacket and pulling on the new one which fit perfectly, before hugging her. "Thank you so much!"

Casey purred. "It's sexy on you. I love it when you wear leather."

Olivia growled by her ear. "I might wear it another way too. You'll just have to wait and see."

"Oh?"

Olivia nodded. "Mhm. Are you finished here?"

"Now that I'm done fixing my desk.."

The detective raised a brow. "Fixing?"

"Everything was on the floor. I had to reorganize it."

"Oh yeah. Well, had to improvise..." she said, kissing her neck.

Casey moaned. "Mm. I guess so.."

Throwing her other jacket over her arm, Olivia handed Casey hers.

Casey smiled.

Olivia smiled, zipping her new jacket. "Nice... Now how are we going to do this? Do you want me to ride with you?"

"I think we should drive separately."

Olivia nodded. "Exactly," she said, unlocking and opening the door, waiting for Casey to walk out.

Casey followed her.

Olivia walked out, closing and locking the door, going to the elevator.

An hour later they were in Casey's apartment.

Olivia sighed, walking to lean on the back of the couch. "So any ideas?"

Casey pounced on her.

Olivia fell onto the couch, kissing her passionately."Mmmm, Case."

"Mmm." Casey buried her head in Olivia's chest.

Olivia smiled, kicking her shoes off. "You're so warm..." she wrapped her arms more tightly around her."God, so beautiful. Mmmm."

Casey purred. "Mmmmm."

Olivia kissed her again, growling, going down to suck on her neck.

"Today was...amazing..."

The detective smiled. "Yes it was. Are you ready for an even better encore?" she said, kissing her.

"Always."

Olivia sat up, unzipping her jacket and shouldering her duffel bag. "What do you say we get more comfortable?"

"How?"

"...Your bed?"

"Mmm."

Olivia stood. "Lead the way."

Casey led her into her bedroom. The room was immaculate, with every inch of the room perfectly clean.

"Wow. You have way more time than me," the detective said, setting her bag by the dresser before hanging her jacket on a chair.

Casey shrugged. "Yeah. I hate messes. Do you want a beer?"

Olivia shook her head. "Not right now. Maybe later."

Casey slid under the covers. All that could be seen was a lump. A few moments later, her blazer fell to the floor, followed by her blouse. Her naked arm emerged from the covers to drop her lacy bra. Casey moaned from beneath the covers as she discarded her skirt. Then, ever so slowly, her panties joined the remainder of her clothing. Casey trembled in eager anticipation, and she was still completely hidden under the covers. She knew Olivia was watching.

Olivia smiled, going over to close the door, then she stood beside the bed and proceeded to discard her shirt, slacks and socks. Clearing her throat, she then discarded her bra and boxers before tapping – what she was 99.9% sure was – Casey's head.

Casey's head emerged slowly. "Damn. You found me." She pouted.

Olivia smiled. "What was I supposed to think was under here?"

"Just a lump?" Casey tried.

"Yeah. Sure. So...would you like me to join you?"

"God...you look...hot.."

Olivia placed her hands on her hips, doing a 360 degree turn. "Do I?" she asked with a smirk before walking over to bring her bag to the bed, dropping it by her feet.

"What is in there? Your handcuffs?"

Olivia shook her head. "A change of clothes and other things to think about a little later."

"Other things?"

Olivia smiled, sliding in beside her. "Yes. You'll just have to wait and see. I intend to fully tire you out, just so you know."

Casey smirked. "You can try, Detective. I require lots of energy."

"Ah, well then..." She wrapped her arms around Casey, kissing her softly. "I promise I won't try to hurt you. I can be rough.."

"I trust you."

Olivia kissed her again, rubbing her back, moaning. "So sexy..."

"Mmm."

Olivia bit her lip, moaning as her hands made their way south.

Casey gasped.

Olivia's hands squeezed firmly, kissing harder.

"Kiss me."

"Where?"

Casey moaned. "Mmm..you decide..."

Olivia kissed her again as one hand made its way in between them to pinch Casey's clit.

"Fuck me," Casey exclaimed without thinking. She blushed.

Olivia smiled, rubbing Casey's clit. "I will, but you need to be wetter," she moaned.

"I...fuck, Liv..." Casey's clit hardened painfully, forcing a whimper out of her.

Olivia sucked on her tongue, sliding three fingers into her, groaning. "Mmm, so hot..."

"Mmmm..."

Olivia sat up, pushing the covers back and moving down to sit between Casey's legs, pulling her fingers out to suck them clean.

Casey watched, whimpering. She squirmed beneath the detective.

Olivia smiled. "Have you ever used any toys?"

"No."

Olivia smiled, her hands stroking Casey's belly. "Then you'll need to be wetter. Don't worry. I can handle that." With a smirk, she lowered herself, kissing Casey's clit and sucking on it.

Casey gasped, her fingers threading through Olivia's hair. "Ohhh...mmmmm..." Her arousal flooded her very core.

Olivia smiled. She debated stopping and introducing Casey to her toy, but if she'd never used one, then she definitely needed to be wetter. Olivia's tongue ventured in, swirling around inside. "Mmmm..."

"Mmm. Do you want me?" Casey moaned. She tried – and struggled – to maintain her composure.

Olivia pulled back up, moving in to kiss her lips, "So much... Do you want me?"

"Always."

Olivia's tongue caressed Casey's, moaning. "Do you want me first or a toy?"

"I-I'm scared."

Olivia held her close. "Sshh, I know. It's going to be fine. Is there anything I can do to help you?"

"Be gentle. Except..."

Olivia nodded, encouraging her to continue. "Except...?"

"I also want it rough."

"Okay, so you want me first, right?"

Casey nodded.

Olivia nodded, lying on her side and throwing one of Casey's legs over her hip, holding her firmly to her, kissing her. "Ready?" she purred, nuzzling her neck. "It's going to be fine. All new things are a little scary. But I'm here."

"I'm ready," Casey whimpered.

Olivia held her gently, her fingers gliding down Casey's stomach as she slid three into her, thrusting in and out slowly. "Tell me if you want it faster, ok?"

"FUCK!" Casey cried.

Olivia purred in her ear. "Mmmm, perfect. Just perfect. I'm going to go a little bit faster," she said, doing so. "How do you feel?"

"I feel...more...I need more.."

Olivia sucked lightly on her neck, speeding up.

"Ohhh fuck..."

Olivia's thumb rubbed her clit. "Mmm, so beautiful, sweet, sexy... Going to come, hmm?" she purred in her ear.

Casey screamed. Unable to control it any longer, she came hard. "Fuuuuuuuucccckkkkk!"

Olivia thrust gently with the aftershocks. "That's it. It's okay," she said, kissing her. She continued until they were gone, then held her gently. "It's okay, How do you feel?"

"I feel...Jesus, Olivia."

She smiled, kissing her cheek. "Hmmm. It didn't hurt, did it? I knew you were a little worried it would. I could see it."

"Olivia? That's not what I was worried about."

"Then...what? I thought it was that."

"The...toy.."

"..Oh... Would you like to see it and touch it before? We can do that."

"Will it help?"

"I think so. Would you like to?"

"Yes..."

Olivia smiled, kissing her lightly, sliding to the floor and opening the bag, pulling out an average sized vibe, sliding in beside her again, handing it to her.

Casey examined it carefully. "It's...how long is it?"

"About 6". The biggest they make is 9, but I didn't think you'd be ready for that... Though I do have it with me, just in case," she said with a smile.

"My last boyfriend was nine inches. It's just.. What scares me is that this time it is a woman..doing it.."

"What scares you exactly? Talk to me. It's okay," Olivia said, wrapping an arm around her.

"Does it feel real?"

"Which one? This one or the other one?"

"Either?"

Olivia pulled out the other, handing it to her as well. "What do you think?"

Casey shrugged. "It feels nice but what about...inside.."

"I...I, uh, I brought something else too. if you want to try it this way," she said, showing her the leather harness. "Or we wouldn't have to use it..."

Casey sat up. "I want it but.."

Olivia set it to the side. "..But..."

"But does it hurt?"

"It won't if you're wet enough..."

"Am I?"

"Do you think you are? It's not really a question I can answer," Olivia said.

"I think so.."

Olivia nodded. "Which one? With or without the harness?"

"Surprise me." Casey closed her eyes.

"Okay." Olivia stood, stepping into the harness and slipping the larger one into it. She climbed back up on top of Casey. "Ready?"

"Y-yes."

Olivia leaned down, kissing her gently. "Are you sure?"

"I trust you.."

"Okay, but it's always okay to change your mind," she said, resuming her previous position, but not before placing a pillow under Casey's hips. "Relax, it'll help," she said, gently penetrating her, going until she was fully seated and stopping.

Casey moaned, throwing her head back. She had been penetrated before, many times. But this was different. This was a woman doing it to her. It was Olivia, who she loved with more fire than she had ever felt. "Deeper...oh yes."

Olivia thrust her hips steadily as she held Casey's. "Mmmmmm...oh..."

"Oh...fuck me," Casey whimpered.

Olivia grabbed Casey's hips, going faster and harder. "Yes, like this?"

"Fuuuuuuuucckk."

Olivia went faster, feeling Casey clench around the toy, seeing her already streaming onto the sheets, but, somehow, the detective knew she could take more, so she went faster. The toy was pressing against her throbbing clit with each thrust. Every moan and whimper from Casey brought her even closer to her peak. She saw Casey's knuckles clutch the sheets so hard they were turning white as she went harder, picking up the pace. Had she been taking her time, the detective would've noted how beautiful Casey looked caught in the moment: hair splayed over the pillow, her cheeks flushed, her lips barely parting in every whimper, but they were beyond that at this point. Even though Olivia would've liked to take her time, Casey wanted it differently and Olivia was more than happy to oblige.

Casey whimpered. "Olivia, fuck me...fuuucckk...yes!" She squirmed on the bed, arching her body. Her clit ached painfully. Every inch of her body burned with the fire she felt for Olivia. "I want it...deeper...and harder. Take me, Olivia!" the attorney begged. She was very passionate in bed.

Olivia leaned down, kissing her passionately as she wrapped Casey's legs around her waist, pulling away until less than an inch was inside then going back in, groaning. "So wet...so perfect. Yes! Do you want more? Hmm?" she purred, going faster and faster. "Just say it... God, fucking perfect!"

Casey screamed, thrashing her head against her pillow. "Harder!" she urged. "Harder, Olivia!" She had never screamed for anyone as passionately or loudly as she did for Olivia. She was so close.

Olivia growled in her ear, going harder and faster. The sweat was dripping onto the sheets from them both. It was crazy, fast-paced, passionate, soft, rough...everything. "Yes..." she panted. "Anything...for you... Oh..." she moaned. "Fuck!"

Casey gasped. "Lose control, detective...oh fuck...do what you want to me...please!" she whimpered.

The detective hit the highest setting on the toy, thrusting a bit more gently, sucking on the ADA's breast, sucking on one and caressing and squeezing the other, rhythmically in time with the thrusts and alternating. She moaned from near pain from the toy pressing against her clit combined with the intense vibration.

As Olivia began to assault her breasts, Casey lost it. She screamed at the top of her lungs, coming hard against Olivia. "Fuck me...oh...fuck, Olivia...harder..." Slowly, the redhead came down from her high. She collapsed on the bed with a cry.

Olivia thrust gently once more, coming with her, screaming. She barely managed to turn the toy off before collapsing onto Casey from exhaustion, panting.

"Fuck."

Olivia nodded, holding her gently, smiling, "Was...that...hard...enough?"

Casey only whimpered in response.

Olivia just kissed her cheek gently, stroking the other with the tips of her fingers, nuzzling her neck as her body evened out.

"God."

Olivia smiled. "..Yeah... You're amazing..."

"Mmmm. As are you."

"So...now how do you feel?" the detective asked.

"Mm. Incredible."

"I wonder if my second wind will kick in. I'd really like it to, but..."

"But you're too tired." Casey sighed and slid under the covers.

"Well, if you think you could take it..."

"You did promise to completely exhaust me. I have a lot of energy."

The detective pulled away. "That's true. Do you have a position you prefer?"

"No."

"If you can get to your hands and knees, I could go a hell of a lot deeper," Olivia pointed out.

Casey crawled onto her hands and knees.

Olivia put a pillow where her head would go. "Are you sure you're okay to go again this soon?"

"Yes."

Olivia positioned herself behind her, sliding in easily. Holding her hips, Olivia worked slow and steady to begin with.

Casey whimpered loudly.

Olivia reached through Casey's legs to rub her clit.

Casey nearly fell. "Oh God."

Olivia wrapped her free arm around her stomach. "Gotcha!"

"Fuck...take me..."

"Lean down onto the pillow," she whispered.

Casey obeyed.

Olivia went fast, plunging deeply within Casey, groaning.

Casey screamed.

Olivia held her hips, going faster. "Feel good, hmm?"

"Fuck me...oh God...fuck me harder..."

Olivia pressed Casey hard into the mattress, going harder and faster, feeling Casey drip onto the mattress.

Casey screamed once more. Releasing a string of expletives, the attorney squirmed on the mattress.

Olivia turned the toy on it's lowest setting, continuing to thrust deeply.

"Ohhhhhhh yes...deeper...fuck yes."

Olivia turned the setting to medium, thrusting faster.

Casey lost it. Screaming as loud as she could, she came, shaking against Olivia.

Olivia pressed herself into Casey, letting the vibration take her over, screaming into her shoulder, falling to the side, still holding onto Casey, turning the toy off.

Casey whimpered. "I hope Mrs. Davis doesn't come knocking on the door."

Olivia sighed. "Big deal. Who is she anyway? The landlady or something?"

"My elderly neighbor." Casey giggled. "I bet she heard everything."

"More than likely," Olivia whispered in her ear. "You felt so good I just couldn't help it."

"I have never screamed like that." Casey blushed.

"Honestly? I can't remember ever either. Must've been spectacular, huh?" she asked, kissing her deeply.

"Mm. Yes." Casey laid her head on Olivia's chest.

Olivia moaned. "Mmm, I love you. I love us. Will you do something for me?"

"Anything."

"I...want to watch you," she said, managing to take off the harness and remove the toy, "use this. I love being with you. More than anything, but...I want to watch you."

Casey took it, looking at Olivia. "Don't leave me."

Olivia turned on her side, wrapping an arm around her. "And miss this show? You've got to be kidding," she said, kissing her neck.

Casey smiled. Opening her legs, and revealing her hardened clit, the redhead smirked. Taking the toy, she turned it on high, pressing it onto her clit. "Olivia," she moaned.

Olivia moaned. "Yes baby? What is it? What do you want to do with that?" she purred, feeling herself become wetter by the second.

"I want it..you..inside of me. I want to come screaming for you."

Olivia moaned loudly into her shoulder. "Please! Please, do it! God...you look so fucking hot! Oh... yes, come on!" she groaned.

Casey plunged the toy into her core with a cry. Her free hand massaging her breasts, the redhead threw her head back. "Olivia...mmmm...yes.." she moaned. Casey buried the toy in her aching center, turning it to its highest setting. "Fuck! Oh, fuck yes!" Her moans picked up with each passing second. Finally, she came screaming for Olivia.

Olivia moaned, pulling the toy out, pressing it against Casey's clit. "Come on. Come for me...A-again, baby, please! Fuck I'm so close!" she moaned, straddling Casey's thigh. "Oh God! I-I'm-I'm gonna...Fuck Casey! Come, come for me! Scream...Fuck...!"

Casey cried out. Olivia's words sent her over the edge a second time. " OLIVIA, I'M COMING...OH GOD!"

Watching Casey made Olivia fall off the edge. "CASEY! CASEY, YES...OH GOD! I-I'M COMING! FUUUCK!" she screamed, coming all over her leg, panting.

Casey collapsed on the bed. "S-sorry it was so q-quick."

Olivia relaxed on top of her, holding her tight. "N-no! N-never be s-sorry! Meant i-it felt t-too good. God... I love you."

"God..I love you too.."

Olivia kissed her. "Exhausted yet? Or do you want me to do what I showed you earlier?"

"You decide, beautiful."

Olivia, somehow, regained her strength, moving to between Casey's legs, licking her clit. "Mmmm..."

"Mmm...fuck...so good.."

Olivia smiled, lapping faster, sucking on her clit.

Casey squirmed, whimpering.

Olivia bit into her clit.

"FUCK!"

Olivia smiled, sucking her clit and gently probing her with one finger.

Casey squirmed. Her fingers tangled in Olivia's hair, and she whimpered loudly. "Olivia...I'm so close..."

Olivia slid her hands under Casey's thighs, pressing her face into her, sliding her tongue in and out. "Mmmm...come..."

Casey lost it. Screaming out, she came hard in Olivia's mouth.

Olivia purred and moaned, drinking her up until she stopped. Then she climbed up beside Casey again, kissing her so she could taste a bit, wrapping her arms around her.

Casey whimpered, snuggling in her arms. "Oh my God," she murmured.

Olivia smiled. "Mmmmm, so good," Olivia moaned.

"Happy Valentine's Day, Olivia."

"Happy Valentine's Day, Casey. My favorite girl," she purred.

"Mmm."

Olivia cuddled her closer. "Anything else?"

"I'm tired, beautiful."

Olivia smiled, pulling the covers over them, snuggling her close. "Hey Casey?"

"Yes?"

"How about a date tomorrow night?"

"A date?"

The detective nodded. "Yeah. I-I'd hate to never see you like this again. But I want it to be more normal."

"So...I mean more than a one night stand?"

"Yes, of course you do. I would never do that to you."

"Really?"

Olivia nodded. "I promise."

Casey smiled. "A date it is. I require lots of attention, officer."

Olivia kissed her again. "Oh you'll get that."

"Mmm. Okay. Tomorrow night. What are we doing?"

"Hmmm? A movie?"

"What movie?"

"Your choice."

Casey shook her head.

"We could do something else," Olivia suggested.

"I want you to pick.."

"I thought you had one you wanted to see."

Casey shook her head. "I don't mind either way."

"We could just go to dinner..."

"Whatever you want."

"Hmmm. Well, I think a movie would look less suspicious."

Casey smirked. "Can I crawl into your lap in the scary parts?"

Olivia nodded. "Of course. We could sit in the back too. Make out if we get too scared by the movie."

"Mmmmm."

"I love you Casey."

"I love you too!"

Olivia moaned, kissing her. "Mmmm, you tasted great."

Casey blushed. "Thank you."

Olivia smiled. "Maybe tomorrow, after the movie, you'd like to see about me?"

"I can tonight."

"Okay."

"If you want."

Smiling, Olivia nodded. "Please! Please taste..." she pleaded. "I want you there. Please baby," she said, kissing her passionately.

Casey slid down between her legs. "Mmmm."

Olivia moaned, her hands going through Casey's hair, pulling. "..Oh, yes, yes, yes..."

Casey smirked, gazing up at her.

Olivia smiled. "Oh...god...more!"

Casey squirmed. Gently, she kissed Olivia's clit.

Olivia squirmed. "Mmmmm. More."

"Fuck..." Casey bit her.

Olivia gasped. "Fuck!"

Casey moaned, sliding her tongue into the older woman. Her nails raked against Olivia's thigh.

"Mmmm. Yes...yes...yes. Mmmm, warm." She took Casey's hands, placing them on her breasts, rubbing gently, purring.

Casey squeezed again, pinching each of Olivia's nipples. "Fuck." She burrowed her tongue inside of the detective, moaning against her.

"Oh...God! M-m-more!"

Casey's tongue curled inside of Olivia. Her teeth nipped at the older woman's clit.

Olivia's hips began to buck as she moaned. "A little more..."

Casey bit down one last time, before her lips nursed the sting. She moaned against Olivia, letting out an occasional purr.

Olivia lost it, screaming for her, her hands pulling on her hair, then going down to push Casey in as deeply as she could.

Once Olivia's orgasm had subsided, Casey laid down beside her.

Olivia smiled, cuddling into the young ADA. "Mmmm, my favorite girl."

"My sexy cop...will you hold me tonight?"

Olivia wrapped her arms firmly around her. "Yes."

"I love you."

"I love you too. So much."

Casey laid her head on Olivia's chest. "Goodnight, Liv.."

"Goodnight Case."

With a contented purr, Casey fell asleep in her arms.

Olivia kissed her cheek, sighing in content before falling asleep.

Author's Note: What do you think?

Please R & R!

Reviews: Little Isis, SVUprincess1998 & guest

Liv-x-Case-Benson & CaseyBensonNovak