"Sam, Dean, please!" Red begged, just like they have rehearsed, "They're going to come back to finish what they started."
"Not if we're not here," Dean replied, stomping on the ground like he was heading for the door, "The only reason they came after you was to get to us, if we leave, they won't come after you!"
"You think it'll make a difference to them that you're gone?!" Red demanded, "It didn't make a difference to all of the others!"
"I'm sorry," Sam added in, "Look, we're going to call some other hunters, they'll come and finish these guys off." Then he slammed the front door to make it sound like they had left.
To make as little sound as possible they lowered themselves to the floor, iron weapons in hand, and waited.
It was about an hour before anything happened. Then at last Sam caught a shadow moving. "Over there, he explained raising his gun and pointing to the figure.
Dean and Red turned around and saw the shadowy monster from the mirror making its way to the kitchen. Not the one they were hoping for, but okay. Sam fired, but other than going through the monster, it seemed to have no effect on it. The creature charged at them, much like it had Red that morning. Dean body slammed in, sending to the ground. Red and Sam leapt on it, too, holding it to the ground. "How long did this take the last time?" Dean asked, trying to keep hold of the struggling creature.
"I don't know," Red said, pressing her whole wait down on the monster, "Four, five minutes, maybe?"
"Five minutes?!" Dean exclaimed.
Just then there was growling sound from the kitchen window. The trio turned their head to look at the window and saw two faces of the eyeless monsters, waiting at the window. It dawned upon what was going on: The mirror monster was meant to unlock the window and let the eyeless monsters in.
"That must be how they got in last night," Sam said.
The creatures burst through the glass and galloped towards the three. They quickly stepped out of the way, causing them to land on their partner in crime, the mirror monster.
Sam, Dean and Red quickly drew their knives, readying themselves for the next attack. The creatures turned in their directions. They attacked again. Red raised her knife and buried it in the creature's shoulder. Dean stabbed the other one right in the head with his own knife, killing it. In the helter-selkter of it all, there was the loud of something bursting. They all turned around and saw wisp of black smoke where the mirror monster use to be.
The eyeless survivor ran off and crammed itself back through the window. Dean, Sam and Red quickly followed it, jumping out the window. Hearing the footsteps behind it, the creature turned around, growled, fiercely, then deciding it couldn't take on it pursuers in its injured state, took off again. They continued to run after the creature, at full speed and barely keeping up with it, even injured, when suddenly...it was gone. "Where'd it go?" Dean exclaimed, looking around.
"It's like it just-vanished," Red said.
They searched the yard for the monster, but there was nothing to be found. "I don't believe it," Dean lamented in anger, rejoining his companions.
"How did this happen?" Red added in frustration, "We were right on its tail!"
"I'm starting to think there's a chance these things may be smarter than us," Sam said.
"They're gonna be onto us now so we need to move you and Alice to somewhere safer," Dean said, leading the band towards the Impala.
"And where would that be?" Red asked.
"We have this place in Kansas," Dean said.
"What?!" Red and Sam both exclaimed simultaneously.
"Come on Sam," Dean, "You've said it yourself we've never encountered these things before, we've made her a target, we've got a nearly impenetrable bunker to stash her in so, why not sash her there at least until we can work things out?"
"You guys have a bunker?" Red asked.
"Long story," Sam said quickly, "But, he's right, we need to get you out of here, and I don't see how things could get any worse in the time between the drive there in back."
Just then Red saw something dart across her driveway. "Uh, guys," She said, "Over there," Red pointed where she had seen the blur. Just then another one of the creatures ran past.
"Alright," Dean said, "Everybody in the car."
They drove silently, keeping close to the creature, the headlight's trained on it as it hurried through town. The creature ran until it was outside the city limits, in the countryside until it came to an abandoned farm. The creature scampered into a hole under the house disappearing. The three ran over to the hole. "So," Dean began, "How we gonna get in there?"
"Don't know," Sam said, "Better be ready, though."
They all pulled out their iron weapons, staring down the hole.
"There is one thing we could do." Red said.
This time they had an idea what she was thinking. That she was just small enough to fit in the hole. "No," Dean said firmly.
"I won't go completely in," Red argued, "Just far enough to see how deep it goes."
"And run into the extremely deadly monster that can rip you to pieces in seconds that we know just went down there," Dean replied.
"Look one of you can hold my feet and when I say to, or if anything unexpected happens, you pull me up." Red suggested.
Dean and Sam looked at each other, deciding what to do. Dean could tell Sam though they should do it. Dean, not so sure. At last Dean gave in. "Alright, but at the first sign of trouble, we're pulling you up."
"Sure thing," Red said, getting down on her knees and beginning to crawl into the hole. Both Dean and Sam knelt down, each grabbing on to one of her legs. "You see anything yet?!" Dean called down to her.
"Not yet!" Red called back, continuing her descent down the hole, "It's pretty deep down here! I haven't found the monsters yet, though!"
After a few more minutes of Red exploring the hole, Dean called down, "Have you found the bottom, yet?!"
"No!" Red called back, "I actually don't think I can stretch my body any further!"
"Alright then we're gonna pull you up!" Dean called down.
"Okay," Red said. But just there was a growling sound. "Guys!" She called out, " I think there's something down here with me."
The brothers began to pull her back up, something pulled back and Red started screaming.
"Red!" Dean shouted down into the hole, pulling harder on her legs, Red screaming all the while. Finally whatever was on the other side pulled so hard they yanked Red's legs right out of Sam and Dean's hands. "Red!"
But there was no answer. Just screaming that slowly faded away.