Sheeijan gave me this idea and this would be what would have happened if I wanted to reveal everything if Jack ate the chocolate.
"CHOCOLATE!" Sophie squealed as she ran towards a stone bench with the chocolate eggs. Aster hopping behind her with a smile, he loved to see the happiness on the children's faces when they ate his chocolate.
Jack flew down and landed balanced on his staff, his nose scrunching slightly at the sweets as he watched Bunny hand Sophie one and smiled as she gobbled it up.
"Aster! That's chocolate, it'll rot her teeth!" Tooth cried as she stopped by his side. North laughed and pulled Tooth back enough so she wasn't nose to nose with the Pooka.
"One won't hurt, try one." Aster laughed as he handed her a milk chocolate one and North a peppermint flavoured one. She eyed it warily before popping it into her mouth and sighing at the taste, she would have to floss and brush later but she would enjoy the treat.
"Here," Aster grunted, shoving a bit of chocolate in front of Jack's face causing him to stumble back and falling off his staff. He landed on the ground with a grunt, scowling as Aster let out a laugh still holding the chocolate.
"No thanks," Jack replied, he was not going to eat another bit of chocolate. He hasn't since the late 1800's after the incident in Antarctica and he swore to never eat one again.
Aster frowned before looking down at the sweet in his hands, it was one of the best one he had made so far and was a little confused as to why Jack wouldn't take it. "Why not, there's'nothing wrong with it, if that's what ya are sayin'." He reassured, holding out the sweet once more.
(Changed scene)
Jack looked at it warily before shrugging and removing his hoodie, he didn't want to wreck it if he had the same reaction to the chocolate like last time.
"What're you doin' Frostbite, there's a lil ankle-biter here." Aster spluttered as he covered the giggling child's eyes. North covered Tooth's as she began to swoon.
"I don't want to wreck my hoodie, it's the only one I have." He said shrugging before taking the chocolate from Bunny. "The first time I ate chocolate I had a weird reaction." Jack said with a shrug as he saw the others give him an incredulous look.
Smiling nervously at them he moved backwards a safe distance once he laid his staff on the table and popped the candy in his mouth. Unlike last time this had a caramel flavour but he could still taste the coco as the flavour exploded in his mouth. He let out a grunt as he toppled over, landing on his knees and hands.
Tooth gasped, "What was in that candy?" She asked Aster who was staring at Jack with wide eyes.
"It was just normal caramel chocolate." He breathed back as he watched Jack raise his hands and slam them on the ground, frost bursting out under his palms before throwing his head back and screaming.
"Sweet candy and Easter eggs," Aster blurted out remembering in the last second that he held a child in his arms as he watched Jack's body morph.
"moi deti!" North gasped out as he watched Jack slam six arms on the ground, the frost blooming out and forming into four blades before crawling up his arms into bracers and across his chest in a vest of ice armour.
"Jack?" Aster called as he handed Sophie to Tooth and carefully hopped over to the heavily breathing Jack. His eyes widening as the familiar tribal markings of the Winter Clan spanned across his armour and skin. Aster stared in disbelief, Jack couldn't be a pooka? But what esle explained the reaction to the chocolate and explain the Winter Clan's markings on his flesh?
Jack hearing his name looked up and gave a tired smile. "I told you I had a weird reaction to chocolate."