"If music be the food of love play on, give me excess of it, the appetite may sicken and so die." Eva giggled as Reid recited a part of Shakespeare's twelfth night to her, as she lay in bed about to go to sleep after Reid recited his nightly stories. He found no need for the book because he could remember it all from memory.

As Reid went to go on, Eva held his hand in her own. "Spenter why did Momma's friend try to take me, where is Momma?" Reid sat down on the bed next to Eva, pain pushing its way in to his heavy heart. "I don't know Eevee, I think he tried to take you because he is your dad, is he not?" he asked looking into Eva's dark brown eyes.

Her eyebrow's furrowed in confusion. "No" she shouted "He is not my daddy." She said her small face and round cheek's looking pinker. "Do you know who your daddy is Eevee?" she looked at him her eyes beginning to shin. "Not sure, momma said he was good, clever man, and one day I meet him, but her friend is no." she said her voice going in to a dreamlike state as she imagined her real father.

An Idea struck Reid. Maybe Eva's father would know were Cara could be he would have to track him down.

The next day Reid rushed into Penelope Garcia's office, if that was what you called it. "Hey Reid what's up?" she asked smiling her usual smile at him, while taping away at her computer, without looking at the screen.

"I need to find out about Eva's real dad." He said breathing hard. Penelope looked at him shocked not really knowing what to say, he still didn't know which made it difficult for her to answer him. "Um ok, I guess I could take a look at her birth certificate, it's got to be on here somewhere." He smiled at her realising it was just that easy.

"Do you think once you find it and we find out who it is, we could search for his were abouts?" He asked his heart beating with hope and excitement. Penelope grimaced then turned to him slapping on her fake smiley face. "Oh honey, you don't even have to ask. I'll find him, I'm crazy good at this you know, and you never know he could be right under your nose." She said desperately hoping he would get it, she couldn't just tell him, they had all agreed to let him figure it out, and they couldn't just drop it on him like that.

They all knew what happened 4 years ago with Cara, Reid had told Morgan and Morgan told Garcia, who told JJ who told Hotch and Rossi. In the end everyone knew. Reid was the baby of the family; they always wanted to know when something like that happened. To them it was like a baby taking its first steps, to them Reid was talking his first steps into adult hood.

Reid looked around confusion circling in his dark brown eyes. What did she mean by that, he didn't have a clue. Reid was a very intelligent man but he struggled with anything that wasn't technical, like metaphors he still found it hard to not take them literally.

"Ok." He mumbled still confused. " Reid, I've got a hit, I've found her Birth certificate." Penelope gasped glad she wouldn't have to tell him. They waited for the page to load, "Uh, apparently there was no dad, Cara didn't list one." She said quietly. Reid groaned slightly pulling at his hair as frustration took over. "I'm sorry Spence." She said sympathetically.

"Tell me where Cara Dustin is." Hotch said his voice cold but calm as he faced Todd Cyril. Reid felt his blood boiling under his skin as he tried not to lunge for Todd; he had barely felt like this. He didn't really have an angry side, well before now anyway.

"I don't know." Todd whispered, his hands in cuffs under the table, his eyes looking at the table. "Tell me damn it," Reid shouted his voice making Todd jump slightly. "Reid." Hotch said his voice comforting this time as he tried to calm him.

"At my apartment you said that you would never tell me, that indicates that you know," Todd looked up at Reid for a moment his skin pale and his energy drained. "I said I don't know I only told you that for effect." Reid knew Todd was lying he could see it in his body language, his arms were tucked away, and he couldn't make eye contact.

"Don't lie to me Todd, we know you have her." Reid said, Todd didn't answer he just looked at his shoes and rubbed his nails anxiously. "Why aren't you on Eva's birth certificate if you're her father?" Todd looked up at Reid confused. "Cara said that she put me on it when I was asleep." Reid took the copy of Eva's birth certificate, out of the folder he held and pushed it over too Todd. "You're not on it Todd." Reid said.

"That's not right; I am her father I am." He said his voice getting higher with fear as he spoke. "You told agent Hotchner that you met Cara June 21st. Well if that's true, you can't be her father the dates don't match." he said staring down Todd as he squirmed.

"S-she did tell me about this one man that she had sex with before me, but I can't remember. No I have to be her father. I demand a paternity test!" He yelled. "We can arrange that." Hotchner said. "Now please tell us about Julia Andric's." Todd froze his already pale skin turning paler. "I don't know who she is." He whispered as he looked back down at his shoes and violently scratched at his skin, causing it to bleed slightly.

"You do," Hotch said "You know her very well; she was your first victim." Reid took another photo out of the folder and handed it to Todd. "First you kidnapped her from her home in Las Vegas. Then you tortured and raped her. She was 16." Hotch said his arms folded and his cold stare looking through him. Todd shook his head and stared at the floor. "You know you did, because you went to prison for 7 years for it."

"7 years, 6 months, two weeks and 3 days." Reid corrected. Hotch shot an unreadable look at Reid. "When you got out you tracked her down didn't you." Hotch said taking another Photo from Reid. "And you strangled her to death, then you took her out to the forest and dumped her, you obviously felt remorse, because you positioned her like she was sleeping. Admit it, and tell us were Cara is and we might be able to cut you a deal." Hotch said looking at Reid as if to say get a pen.

Todd burst out crying, "I loved her and she rejected me, I regret what I did, I still love her so much. Cara was just a decoy at first, but then I fell for her, and she told me Eva was mine. He put his head in his hands and shook. "I'm sorry, Julie I'm so sorry."

"Todd, tell us were Cara is please." Reid asked his voice slightly sympathetic. "She left me." He screamed. "No-one leaves me, no one!" Todd screamed. "I'll never tell you."