A/N: YES! Alright I have a few things to say. I know I might have mixed up She and He a lot in some of my paragraphs. Please disregard them. And whatever other mistakes I have made. Anyway. YES! I am starting to lose this damn writer's block and I know how to continue the story. Thank you for the reviews guys. And yes... there obviously will be some love conflicts going on.

Chapter 12: Matt

Am I bad? What am I doing? Why do I feel... Ashamed? Prudence thought. She felt Jeff's hands on her neck now. He was still looking in her eyes. Whispering, "Love me, angel." It gave proof of chills that spread from her head to her toes. Her mind was screaming. "YOU LOVE SLENDER! NOT THIS DEMON!" But every inch of her body wanted to give into Jeff's gestures. How could this be? Then again... She only exchanged one kiss from Slender... It didn't prove she was with him. Was it wrong to think of Jeff in such a way? She only recently met him. But the more she was with Jeff... The more sexually attracted she was to him. Not to mention Jeff was about seventeen or eighteen... She was sixteen going on seventeen. He was more her age.

Jeff held Prudence's face, his heart growing more frantic. This feeling hurt... The feeling his heart was portraying was completely new to him. He stepped away from her. His eyes looking down.

Prudence was breathless, her face flushed. Her heart pounded. Slender... She thought. Jeff turned his back to her. "Well, my new pet... Come with me..." He said with a sinister laugh. Prudence held her breath and obeyed him like a lost puppy...

Jeff had Prudence by her hand, pulling her as he went. They weren't in that town any more. They were near an abandoned insane asylum. The aura there made Prudence sick to her stomach. Jeff seemed somewhat cautious... More alert.

"Where are we going?" Prudence asked, her mind-set on where he was planning on going.

"To have fun. I want to show you what it feels like..." Jeff said, still keeping his eyes rapid on their surroundings.

"What 'what' feels like?" She asked.

"To be a rebel." Jeff turned to face her, his smile was widened and he opened his mouth, showing his teeth. Prudence smiled, feeling more free then she has ever felt.

They both ran from the asylum and reached another town just beyond some woods and fences. They managed to jump the fences and when they reached the city, Jeff grabbed Prudence by her hands.

"Just follow my lead, alright angel?" Jeff said, using Prudence's new pet name he gave her. She smiled at it, she never would have guess that would be in such a demonic killer's vocabulary. She followed Jeff as he sprinted across the streets of the town. Passer bys ignored the both of them as they began their journey. Jeff put his hood on, as did Prudence and she followed him into a candy store. There were a few people inside. A fat kid holding onto a skinnier kids shirt collar, an old man who looked annoyed as hell and a a perky girl who was jamming to music on her head phones while sweeping the floors.

"Come on, twerp. I ain't got all day ya' know! Buy me candy or I'll punch you!" said the fat kid to the poor scrawny kid. The kid was grabbing a shit load of chocolate bars. His forehead beated sweat.

"Alright, alright!" he said. Jeff laughed at how pathetic it was. He walked over to the two boys and stood behind them. With a flick of a finger he poked the fat kid away from the scrawny one. The scrawny kid looked at Jeff, dropping some candy bars. The fat kid darted at him.

"Whatya think you're doing, kid?" the fat kid said attempting to punch Jeff, but Jeff stopped his fist without even looking. Prudence giggled.

"What are you doing picking on this nerd?" asked Jeff. He leaned in on the fat kids face (without revealing his own face) and spoke in his ear. "Because you and I both know you don't need another chocolate bar. So I suggest you book it, maybe take a few laps around the block. Lose a few.. Or a lot..." Jeff patted the fat kid's stomach.

"Why don't you mind your own business. Smoke a joint or whatever you teenage losers do now-a-days. Scram!" The fat kid said. The scrawny kid stood with a wide smile on his face. He was grateful someone finally was brave enough to stand up to the fatty.

"Why don't you make me?" Jeff said, tilting his head revealing his face. He was bent over to the boy's height. The boy made a face of terror.

"What the hell is wrong with your face?!" The fat kid insulted. Jeff took it as a compliment.

"Why aren't I beautiful? I suggest you start running before I kill you... Literally..." Jeff threatened. The fat kid shoved Jeff out of his way and ran, (more like waddled) to the door.

"You're a freak!" He managed to let out before booking it away from the store. Jeff turned to Prudence and the scrawny kid. Both of them clapping in amusement.

"Thank you so much sir!" Said the scrawny kid.

"Heh heh. I wouldn't take it to heart, kid," Jeff said, turning to face Prudence. "Now let's have fun." Jeff too his hood off, revealing his face. The scrawny kid gasped and Prudence smiled.

"Hey! Everyone! I suggest you all pay close attention, for this will be your last day of being awake!" Jeff announced. Everyone in the store was paying attention. The perky girl sweeping took out her ear buds and ran to the counter to the old man... WHo still looked unused.

Jeff jumped up on the counter, startling the girl and the man. He took out his knife and stuck it to the man's throat.

"I-Is it money you want? I-I'll give you all the money in the register!" the man offered. Jeff laughed.

"What I want... is for you to go to sleep... Ha... Hahah!" he said shoving the knife deep in his throat. The man coughed and blood-shot everywhere. The girl screamed and darted towards Prudence.

"I'm calling the cops!" she screamed, trying to dial the number on her cell.

"That won't do. You see... They already are after me. Calling them won't do you any good, my dear." he looked to Prudence, gesturing for her to kill the girl. Prudence shook. She didn't know what to do. He threw her the knife and Prudence caught it. Stunned and confused. Suddenly that feeling surged up in her stomach again. Jeff laughed. The girl fell backward on her rump, looking up in horror at Prudence. Prudence was staring at the blood stained knife, then she shifted to the girl. She was crying. Prudence stared at her... The feeling got stronger and stronger.

"Do it, angel..." Jeff whispered. He still was laughing. Prudence knelt to the girl. The feeling was now an eerie pain. In that moment Prudence took the girl by her neck, digging her nails into the girls skin.

Kill her Prudence, do it! Do it Do it Do it DO IT! DO IT! That annoying feeling seemed to have messed with her head. The voice she usually depicted as her conscience turned evil for that slightest minute. In that eerie and painful moment she lunged the knife into the girl's chest. She died instantly. She began laughing. Jeff was satisfied.

What are you doing, Prudence? This isn't you... Go back to Slenderman... A familiar voice rang in her head. She was shocked by this and instantly fell to the ground.

Come on, Pru... Listen to me... This isn't you. You are not a murderer... Prudence looked at the knife in her hand and at the dead girl on the floor of the candy shop.

"I just killed someone..." She whispered. Jeff nodded and walked over to her.

"Yes you did... It was amusing to see..." Prudence was crying.

"I am sorry..." she said.

"Don't be sorry. It was great!" Jeff praised her, handing her a lollipop. She took his offering and turned to look at him. He noticed the pain in her eyes. He lifted her to her feet and gently grabbed her hand.

"The feeling will pass... It's okay to feel guilt. But look at all this free candy! Now that is fun!" Jeff said in a calm voice that some how soothed Prudence. She managed to smile slightly and ignore the guilt.

How could you? The voice said. Prudence knew that voice... Suddenly a flash back flashed in her head... A flash back of the day she was training in the scrap yard with Matt. The voice she has heard... Was Matt!

A/N: Alright. The next chapter will be more interesting. Jeff and Prudence will be getting some romantic action going on in the next chappy. Any who I have not forgotten about Slendy... he also will be joining the story soon as well as Sherly ) so stay tuned my Creepypasta lovers ;);) Lol btw those of you who like BEN DROWNED I was thinking of making a separate story of Jeff and BEN... idk it might sound kind of silly