A/N: Heh heh... I uh made a few mistakes in my last chapter like some spelling errors, like maybe more than usual... I apologize. And I mentioned in one paragraph about Prudence's stomach and weight... She is not completely obese.

Lol, she's whatever you picture her to look like... I created her to show that aspect so too whom ever fantasizes about being Slenderman's or Jeff's interests they can picture themselves as Prudence. I do sometimes lol anyway...

Shout out to all my followers who review. I appreciate it so so so much. I never had this much reviews. I know to some of you who get way more reviews than this and think "pst, 30+ reviews? That's nothing." But to me it's pretty satisfying. So thank you :D

Chapter 14: Her Heart

"How can sh do this to me... After what I have done for her. After pouring my beat less heart to her... This is unfair. Heart wrenching unfair..." Slenderman moped as he held on to Sherly's hand. She was instantly drifting off to sleep ever so often and Slenderman had to lift her up until she begged to be placed back down.

"Where's Prudence, will she ever come back...?" Sherly asked, rubbing her eyes and face. Slenderman stood taller.

"Sherly, how would you like to live with me?" Slenderman asked her... He only asked because he knew Sherly's family has long gone past. Even her grandmother to which she was supposed to go. Unfortunately, Slenderman has grown somewhat attached to Sherly like a father would his own daughter. He picks her as potential for a future proxy. Even though he is growing somewhat more attatched to Sherly by the day, he will never replace Prudence... He was in love with her and he doesn't think he could ever fall out of that.

Sherly stopped walking and looked up at the nice tall man. Her eyes wide and full of tears... "You want... me to live with you?" She asked. Slender, still holding her hand, turned to look down at her.

"Of course I do..."

"So... are you my new daddy?" She asked. Slender smiled underneath that false face of his and nodded.

"I guess you can call me that if you like?" Slenderman said with a gentle voice so calm and collective it made Sherly smile. He bent down to her height and allowed her to run into his arms. With that being down, Slenderman decided it was time to find Prudence...

"What have I done?! I can't believe I did that! Jeff is not who I love. It's Slender... Slender is my one and only master..." Prudence said to herself. She was running towards a forest and started stumbling as she ran. Her jacket was barely on, it hung around her forearms as she stumbled across the ground. She finally allowed herself to fall in a heap on the dirt mud floor. She curled herself in the fetal position feeling utter guilt as it washed over her like a wave.

"I bet you feel ashamed... Prudence.. You should feel this way..." Matt spoke to her. Prudence wasn't crying. She just lied there.

"Why do I feel this way?"

"Because you love someone else... It's normal to feel this way after betraying someone who would do absolutely anything for you..." Said Matt. Prudence looked up to see a ghostly figure appear in front of her. It was Matt. She didn't know if it was her imagination or what. She sat herself up only halfway to see Matt directly. She rubbed her eyes a few times, making sure it wasn't a trick of the light.

"I am so... Ashamed I ran away..." Prudence whispered.

"How do you think I felt when I hurt you... But now I am here to make right with what I have done... Because there are forgiving beings who promise things and keep them... So I promised to guide you the right way... Slenderman will look for you... But I know you love him... AND Jeff... Jeff will also look for you... You chose this life... Even if it's wrong... You chose to murder... The path that mustn't be chosen..." Matt said, holding onto Prudence's chin. She looked down in disbelief at herself.

"What should I do?" She asked, feeling completely lost...

"Do what your heart says..." Matt was vague... But Prudence nodded helplessly as he began to disappear. She looked down for a moment, trying to think of what she should do... She felt lost. Ashamed. Exposed. She couldn't find any explanations to what she was feeling. Everything was so hard to explain, she felt maybe she should just give up and find a way back to her REAL home... Or maybe she should go back to Slenderman... But... She loved Jeff? Or did she? Did he love her?

"Prudence..." Said a familiar robotic voice that rang through the air like wind. She looked around, her heart beating. "Prudence, it's okay..." She heard it again...

"Sl-Slender?" She called. "Slender?" She was a little louder... "SLENDER?!" She was screaming now. She was still on the ground.

She suddenly felt a warm hand on her shoulder, she turned to see Slender standing a great ten feet above her. He bent over closer to her... He held out a flower to her...

"Will you accept my offering?" Slender asked her. She looked up with wide and misty full eyes. Oh, how desperately she want to hug him... But something stopped her...

"I thought you loved me Prudence... We seemed to fit perfectly... You... and me..." It was Jeff, who stood behind her. A knife in hand. Prudence went into shock. "You make a great killer Prudence... You like it... You liked what I did to you... The feelings that were going through the both of us. How heated we felt..." Jeff said, slowly walking over to Prudence. Slender stood up straight. Anger was corroding him with every inch of his body. The scariest thing Prudence has ever seen Slender do. His tendrils allured his back. He was going back and forth in a spastic motion. He was mainly static. Slenderman was becoming even more of a monster than Prudence ever has seen him. His mouth stretched wide open. His back bent in a monstrous hunch. His tendrils lifted him higher. His fingers curled in sharp like claws that seem to keep stretching.

"You can't love a monster like that... You didn't enjoy the way he kissed you like the way I did. You went further with me then Slender has ever gotten. Slendy's a man of what... thousands of years old... I am eighteen... A human... He will never be able to give you... Pleasure... And you and I both know... You. Love. Me..." Jeff was mainly saying that to Slender who became even more angry.

Slenderman stretched himself up, his head looking up as he screamed the most demonic screech that could be heard from miles and miles away. Prudence covered her ears as did Jeff. Slenderman was speaking in many tongues that could not be made out. It sounded like a disprogramming robot. It looked like lightning around them as Slender became more angry by the second.

"Look at that monster..." Jeff pointed out, holding Prudence back. Prudence watched Slenderman throw the biggest tantrum. She was terrified of his form. He was like a nightmare...

"THHH EEEEE OOOOOOPPPPPEEEEERRRRAAAATTT- OOOOORRRRRRR! THHHHEEEEEEEE OOOOPPPPEEEERRRRRR ATTTTTOOOORRRR!" Slenderman screeched. It was hard to make out what he was saying. What Prudence could make out was... The Operator... He spoke again in another messed up, robotic monstrous tone.

"*%#(#*#*#*#*#*#*... PRRRRRRUUUUUUDENCE! AAAWWWWWW AAAAKKKK EEEEEE!" Considering his voice was distorted like a broken record of computers malfunctioning Prudence could only make out the last words... or... Er... Slurs of his sentence... Prudence Awake...

Instantly Prudence awoke. She was breathing heavily in a way that made her heart burn. She realized it was all a dream. She must have fallen asleep when she fell in the forest. unfortunately doing those things with Jeff was not a dream... Meeting Matt and reconnecting with Slenderman was all a dream that became a nightmare. Prudence stood up and turned to face Jeff.

"I am sorry I didn't wake you sooner... You were having a nightmare and I didn't want to startle you... I also... want to apologize for... What we did..." Jeff said, holding her hand. She instantly pulled away from him and wrapped her arms around herself.

"I am sorry..." She began.. her voice raspy. "I am sorry that I didn't stop... I am also sorry... But I love Slenderman..." Prudence was soft when speaking to him. For some reason Jeff became extremely angry. He reached in his pocket and pulled out his knife. Prudence didn't realize it until he pinned her to the ground, holding the knife to her neck...

"You little slut! You like toying with both of our emotions. How dare you use me! I was just about to tell you how I felt... But you go ahead and take Slendy's side! May I remind you what we did?" Jeff moaned in her ear. Prudence didn't move. The sound of bats and crows came from everywhere. She was still. The wind blew and kissed either side of her cheeks as if egging her to get up and fight. But she still would not move. She awaited what was to come to her as Jeff pressed the knife deeper into her neck. She coughed as blood began to seep her skin.

"You can't go back now, angel... I'm your demon now... I own you... You can't escape who you are Prudence... You can't go back to that fairy Slendy... He can't give you what you need!" Jeff whispered again. He began to lick the blood that flowed from her neck and onto the knife. Prudence was hoping it was a dream, but the pain reminded her it wasn't. She had no escape, so she allowed Jeff to torture her.

"Prudence... If I can't have you... No one can..." Jeff said and lifted the knife up.

"Jeff! You love this girl! Why must you kill her?" Said the soft voice in Jeff's mind that reminded him he still had good left in him. This voice reminded him of the old Jeff... He did not like this voice...

"Shut up! She hurt me!" Jeff said aloud... Still holding the knife in the air. Prudence was looking into Jeff's eyes. Begging...

"Yes, but you are hurting her now... If you love someone... You mustn't hurt them... You have to protect them..." Jeff stared back down into her eyes... Her breath steady, but her lip quivered. Her eyes watered. My... Angel... My... Prudence... Jeff thought to himself. He shook his head and dropped the knife on the ground...

"I didn't mean a word... of what I said..." Jeff whispered... But as he said that her heard the static sound of Slender.

"Get. Off... Of her Jeff...!" Slenderman stood over the both of them. Prudence closed her eyes in relief and began crying. "She isn't your's to call your own... Her heart belongs to me..."

Jeff's mind sparked once again as he stood up off of her. He lifted the knife off the ground, pulled Prudence up and held the knife once again to her throat. He was holding her hair back so it was easier to get to her neck. Slender hesitated. Sherly stood several feet behind him. Jeff let go of Prudence's hair and moved it to her chest where her heart should be.

"If you want her heart... You have to fight me for it..." Jeff said with his carved smiled wider than ever...