"Welcome to the second episode of Total Drama: Back To the Island!" Chris announced. "Last time, the contestants faced their biggest fears and competed in a race around the island. In the end, we had to say goodbye to Junior. Let's see what happens this time on Total Drama, Back to the Island!"

Everyone was in the mess hall, eating Chef's infamous food. This "breakfast" looked like green mushy spaghetti with a dry white sauce. "How old is this food?" Sabrina complained. Olivia stood up to throw away her food, but instead got a deadly glare from chef forcing her to sit back down. "I just had a death defying experience." Olivia said. "I don't want to die from food poisoning."

Chris then barged in through the door. "Hello, campers! Please follow me for today's challenge!" He said. The camera happily got up from their seats to follow Chris. The next challenge should take their minds off the food.

Everyone was led to two stages. "Today's challenge," Chris began, "is to perform and create a musical." Chris Pointed at a big box steeped to the brim with index cards. "Those cards will provide you a genre and setting for your musical."

(in the confessional with Lexi)

"A musical? Really?" Lexi said annoyed. " I'm so tired of this show!"

(Back to the stages)

"Chef and I will be judging your musical on a scale from 0 -100." Chris said. "The challenge begins... Now!"

Aaron ran to the box and pulled out a card that read: Romantic movie theater. "What?" He complained. Jackson put his hand in the box and pulled out a card that said: Murder Mystery Total Drama. "Musical murder mystery? On the island?"

The two teams began setting up their stages and making their scripts. The yellow team's script writers, Peter, Lexi, and Rachel, were having communication issues. The same situation was occurring with gray team's stage setters, Fiona, Shane, and Kyra.

Time eventually ran out and Chris called everyone to the gray team's stage. Jackson played a detective searching for the killer of Olivia on the island. The murderer, Fiona, went into hiding on the island. The singing was average, if not below average. Chris gave this play a rating of 32 while chef gave a 41.

The yellow team's play was about a love triangle between a cool kid, Peter, and a nerd, Aaron who both loved a cute girl, Isabella. The play was quite touching with good singing voices. However, Aaron threw up on Chef and Rachel from stage fright in the middle of the play. Chris gave a rating of 50 while chef gave a 0.

"Sorry yellow team," Chris said, "but you lost. Tonight you will be sending another camper home. You should really stop losing."

A few hours before it was time to send a contestant home, Skylar was trying to persuade the contestants of the yellow team to boot Sabrina off the island, calling her pure evil.

James noticed Kyra sitting at the dock of shame, kicking her legs with a guilty expression on her face. "What's up?" James inquired. "Oh! Nothing!" Kyra said surprised. James had an unsatisfied look on his face. "Okay fine, but promise not to tell anybody?"" James crossed his heart. "Alright. Well.. I didn't participate in first challenge. I was completely skipped." Kyra admitted. James looked shocked. James promised to keep this secret, though Sabrina was eavesdropping behind a tree with a sinister look on her face.

(In the confessional with Sabrina)

"Now I have a fail safe." Sabrina said putting her feet up. "If I'm to get voted off, I can just tell everyone about Kyra cheating and I'll stay on the island while she is sent home. Perfect!"

(The elimination ceremony with the yellow team.)

Everyone had a sticker, except for Aaron and Sabrina. Sabrina didn't look scared at all while Aaron had fear all over his face. "The safe one between you two is..." Chris started, " Sabrina."

Sabrina wasn't surprised while Aaron was escorted by Chris, Rachel, and Isabella to the dock of shame. He was depressed as he boarded the ship to loserdom. "Bye!" Isabella and Aaron simultaneously shouted.

"Two down, twelve to go." Chris announced. " Tune in to see who'll be eliminated next time in the third episode of Total Drama: Back to the Island!"