Somewhere Outside of Appleloosa

We look outside of Appleloosa, where the ponies and buffalo are seen having a huge party. A short distance away from the town, a stallion in a cowboy hat and poncho converses with a rubber chicken he calls Boneless.

Cowboy Stallion: [Tough Cowboy Voice.] Well, Boneless. Looks like our work here is done.

Boneless the Rubber chicken just sloped back in the saddle as the cowboy continues to talk as if he agrees with its statement.

Cowboy Stallion: Yep, those ponies never partied so hard. Thanks to me: Cheese. Cheese Sandwich.

Suddenly Cheese started wobbling in all his joints which causes his hat to fly off. As we hear Cheese Sandwich yell in the air happy as his Boneless Chicken then falls to the ground as then a stranger pony picks it up.

Cheese Sandwich: Woo-hoo-hoo! That was a doozy!

???: [Cowboy Voice.] Howdy Partner. I was wonderin' if you're Cheese Sandwich?

As Cheese Sandwich then picks up his hat he notices this stranger had a mustache cowboy attire on as he must've been from Appleloosa but doesn't remember him there.

Cheese Sandwich: Who are you?

The cowboy then puts the Rear end of Cheese Sandwich.

???: [Cowboy Voice.] Oh, no one just wanted to see if the Party-master was going to Ponyville?

Cheese Sandwich: You betcha. Say I don't think I have seen you before are you new?

???: Yep, in some ways and old in others but if you want a next location try... Ponyville?

Cheese Sandwich: Wow! You are Psychic! That's what my cheesy sense was telling me? Tell me can you read minds?

???: No. Anyway I wasted to long need to go work on my next 'key' for my certain ponies.

Suddenly the pony in front of Cheese Sandwich disappeared in a bright light and Cheese then looked to see where he had disappeared but couldn't find him.

Cheese sandwich: What a weird fellow wouldn't you agree Boneless?

Boneless didn't say anything but we see Cheese go back to his monologue.

Cheese Sandwich: Well, Boneless. Looks like our next party is gonna be in... Ponyville.


Ponyville

We see Lucky flying in the air and a balloon flying before him and another as he had an idea who this is.

Lucky Heart: Well, well, looks like somepony is in for a the most Amazing Party EVER! [Looks at us.] We all know who that now do we? You guessed it! The one, the only, accept no substitute...

Lucky then lands on the end of the bridge as we see Pinky Pie crossing over it as Lucky got the timing right as confetti's behind Pinky.

Lucky Heart: Pinkie Pie!

Pinkie Pie: Yes? My most lovely and sweet boyfriend.

Lucky Heart: I was just talking to some of our friends listening to us and reading about us.

Pinkie Pie: [Realizing.] Ohhh, you mean... [Pointing at us.] them?

Lucky Heart: Yes indeedy, so you got something planned for today?

Pinkie Pie: Yep!

Then we hear music as Pinky and Lucky walk together through the streets of Ponyville.

[Pinkie the Party Planner By Pinkie Pie, Lucky Heart, and All of Ponyville]

[Pinkie Pie]

Every single day there's something new you can plan for,

We then see Lucky following Pinkie and mimicking her as she hops on her hooves and then hoof stands and backwards crawling as we see the Cutie Mark Crusaders, Apple Bloom, Sweetie Bell, Scootaloo, Alexander, Arrow, and Ace.

The blue and pink duo then trot to the vender as Pinkie is on the right side and Lucky is on the left.

[Pinkie Pie]

Every single day there's something wonderful to do,

But nothing makes me happy like a day that I can say,

"Today I planned a party, and it's just for you!"

Vendor Pony: How's it going today, Pinkie?

Pinkie Pie: Great, thanks! Got any streamers today?

Vendor Pony: [chuckles.] You betcha! Big party planned? [Gives them to Lucky.]

Pinkie Pie: Don't you know it!

Then balloons then raise up as we fade to another scene as Lucky and Pinky are together as Pinkie watch the clock spin the minute hand clockwise and the hour hand counter-clockwise.

Lucky is holding a scroll of all Pinkie needs for the party supplies.

[Pinkie Pie]

Don't have much time to gather all the things I need

If I'm really gonna make this party fly

We see Lucky and Pinkie jumping on other ponies houses and then go down a tarp but Lucky went through one and Pinkie stopped herself at the edge of the tarp and see all of Ponyville cheer for Pinkie Pie.

For today's another day that all of Ponyville will say...

[Crowd]

There goes the super party pony Pinkie Pie!

As they see Pinkie Pie jump off the tarp and onto all the houses with ease as Lucky immediately crashes through the Pots and Pans vender as he doesn't seem happy as Lucky gives him a sheepish smile before Pinkie Pie then comes in and lifts up Lucky and Lucky Pays for all the damages that can happen and the two are on their way.

We then see Mr. and Mrs. Cake taking their babies on a walk as they talk about Pinkie Pie.

[Mr. and Mrs. Cake]

She planned our first foal shower where we played all sorts of games,

We see Pinkie Pie and Lucky Heart as the two now have pacifier's in their mouths but drop it and smile at the Cake Family before leaving behind a confetti bomb to which the Cake Family likes.

Having so much fun as we chose Pound and Pumpkin's names!

We then see Diamond Tiara as she and Silver Spoon were having dessert as Lucky sees them and waved before Diamond Tiara gave the stink eye at him before he realizes who she was and then sees her take Silver Spoon dessert as she threw her cupcake away and takes Silver Spoon shake.

[Diamond Tiara]

She planned my cute-ceañera my dad made me, I won't lie.

I demanded all the best, I suppose she passed the test.

Lucky then used his magic and while Diamond Tiara was distracted he gave the Shake back to Silver Spoon as she smiles at that and drinks her shake as Diamond Tiara then sees Silver Spoon drinking that Shake she then glared at Silver Spoon.

Sure it was pretty good all thanks to Pinkie Pie.

Pinkie Pie: Thanks, [Looks at Lucky.] I guess?

As Lucky shrugged his shoulders as he had no idea if it was either an insult or a compliment. Then a Art Vender that heard about what Party Pinkie Pie was planning.

Art Vendor: What color paints do you need?

Pinkie Pie: I'm gonna need the full rainbow!

Then the Vendor then puts all the paint in Lucky Hearts Saddlebag.

Art Vendor: A paintbrush too?

Pinkie Pie: Yes, if you please!

The Vendor then threw it in Lucky's bag as the two then head over to Peachy Pitt a Unicorn pony vendor that sells banners.

Lucky Heart: Miss Peachy Pitt we're going to need a something from you.

Peachy Pitt: And what from me?

Pinkie Pie: Your biggest banner! This party's gonna be the best!

As Lucky Pays for the banner the banner is then put in Lucky's bag and Peachy Pitt smiles at Pinkie and her parties.

Peachy Pitt: Haha I don't doubt it! [Lucky then Hands Peachy Pitt a party hat.]

We then see Lucky and Pinkie then travel to each Vendor for party supplies as Lucky handles all the supplies that Pinkie Pie needs for the party she is planning as the crowd behind them sing for their super party pony Pinkie Pie.

[Crowd]

Every single day there's something new we can plan for

Every single day there's something wonderful to try

But nothing makes us happy like a day that we can say

"Today there'll be a party planned by Pinkie Pie!"


At Sugarcube Corner

We then see Pinkie Pie creates the greatest Banner ever as her friends the rest of The Mane Six and the rest of the Heroic Six, all around see her create this banner in front of Sugarcube corner.

Rarity: I don't know how she does it.

Knight Rider: She's amazing!

Alister Allstar: She's sensational!

Twilight Sparkle: Wow, look at her go!

Applejack: Oh, boy! This is gonna be good!

Fluttershy: Go, Pinkie, go!

Lucky Heart: Way to go Pinkie!

[Crowd]

There's no other pony like her, no pony that could be

As great! (As great!) As fun! (As fun!)

As our super party pony Pinkie!

Then Lucky Heart and Knight Rider then pick up the ends of the banner poles and lift them up and Pinkie Pie let out her Confetti once more as she expressed how happy she is about this party.

Pinkie Pie: Ooh, I am so, so, SO excited because today I'm planning the birthday bash of... [Shows Rainbow Dash Picture.] Rainbow Dash!

Then Rainbow Dash moved away from her own banner as she actually had the exact picture of Rainbow Dash in every way possible.

Rainbow Dash: Yeah!

The two share a double high hoof as everyone there was excited to see Pinkie Pie so happy.

Pinkie Pie: [Serious Face.] Rainbow Dash.

Rainbow Dash: [Worried.] Yes, Pinkie?

Pinkie Pie: You realize that, by enlisting me as your party planner, I guarantee that this is going to be the funnest, most fantabulous, superbial party in Ponyville?

Rainbow Dash: [Unsure.] Uh...yeah? I guess.

Pinkie Pie: [Covered Rainbow Dash Mouth.] No guesses! Parties are no picnic.

Fluttershy: Oh, I like a nice picnic party.

Then Pinkie Pie growls at Fluttershy as Lucky found Pinkie Pie behavior a bit serious then they usually are.

Fluttershy: Oh!

Pinkie Pie: Parties. Are. Serious! And you have my certified Pinkie Party Promise that you will have the best birthday party ever!

Lucky Heart: And you have my promise that you won't worry about anything bad happening to your party.

Rainbow Dash: Thanks Lucky.

Lucky Heart: No, problem I'm like the second pony who knows how to have a good time.

Pinkie Pie: Great! So, who's ready to join this super duper party pony to plan this super duper pa-rty?

???: I am.

Then everyone gasps at this cowboy stranger who is actually Cheese Sandwich as he had a party horn in his mouth as he blows in it.

Cheese Sandwich: [blows party horn]

Pinkie Pie: Who are you, stranger?

Cheese Sandwich: [Spits out party horn.] Name's Cheese Sandwich. I plan parties.

Lucky Heart: What an amazing coincidence! Pinkie Pie plan parties as well.

Pinkie Pie: Yep, I'm Pinkie Pie, and I'm planning a party!

Cheese Sandwich: Oh, it's no coincidence, my little pony. My cheesy sense was a-tingling, telling me a party was in the works.

Pinkie Pie: A cheesy sense? Ah! Double amazing! I have a Pinkie Sense!

Lucky Heart: Cheesy sense and Pinkie Sense, so cool! Can you sense what mine is?

Then Cheese Sandwich stares as Lucky as he seemed to be peering into his soul as he figures it out.

Cheese Sandwich: You have "Lucky's Law" Anything bad that can happen will happen to you.

Lucky Heart: WOW! That's amazing! Did you sense Pinkie Sense as well?

Cheese Sandwich: Yes.

Lucky Heart: Triple WOW! So are you here to enjoy Pinkie Pie's party for Rainbow Dash?

Cheese Sandwich: Not quite, you see I happen to be the premiere party planner in all of Equestria. If there's a party in need, there I'll be. Be it wingding, hoedown, hootenanny, or shindig, I'm your pony.

Pinkie Pie: A pair of party pony planners in Ponyville?! What can be more perfect?!

Lucky Heart: Yeah!

Rainbow Dash: I'll tell you what, making this party epic! 'Cause this isn't just any birthday. It's also the anniversary of when I moved to Ponyville!

Knight Rider: Such a coincidence you moved on your birthday Rainbow Dash.

Lucky Heart: This is going to be awesome Anniversary! And on you're birthday!

Rarity: Good heavens, Rainbow Dash. It's your "birth-iversary"!

Rainbow Dash: Exactly! So what do you say, party planners?

Pinkie Pie: Oh, I think we can do it!

Cheese Sandwich: Oh, I don't think so.

Rainbow Dash and Pinkie Pie: [gasps]

Cheese Sandwich: I know so! [Takes off his hat and poncho.] After all...

[The Super Duper Party Pony By Cheese Sandwich.]

[Cheese Sandwich]

The super-duper party pony–that pony is me

I always knew that was the kind of pony I would be,

Pinkie Pie: Me too!

Everyone then started to have fun with Cheese Sandwich.

Cheese Sandwich: Come on, ponies! Who here likes to party? Ha-ha! [Grab an elderly Pony.] You do! I can tell!

Then Cheese Sandwich then brings down a screen and we see a huge cheese as we see a young colt who was actually young cheese sandwich.

When I was but a little colt, I just wanted to play

Pinkie Pie: Like me!

We then see Pinkie Pie interrupt again.

[Cheese Sandwich]

But everypony told me, "Cheese, that fun just wastes the day"

Pinkie Pie: As if!

[Cheese Sandwich]

But when I threw a party and I busted out some moves

We see Cheese Sandwich was dancing all funny like as everyone was enjoying him.

Pinkie Pie: Uh-huh!

[Cheese Sandwich]

The ponies finally saw the light and got into the groove

Then we see everypony sad now enjoying and got into the partying mood.

Pinkie Pie: You know it!

We then see everyone in Ponyville seeing Cheese Sandwich in lederhosen and playing an accordion.

[Cheese Sandwich]

The super-duper party pony–that pony is me

Pinkie Pie: And me!


Police Station

[Cheese Sandwich]

You'll never meet another party pony quite like Cheese!

We see Cheese in a police station where there were a cop and three almost look alike of Cheese Sandwich as Pinkie Pie was there as well looking through the two way mirror a bit confused on what's happening.

Pinkie Pie: [Confused.] Uh, Pinkie?

Cheese Sandwich: Hey, good-lookin', want some mayonnaise?

We see Pinkie then see Cheese hold up some Mayonnaise Jar as he goes back to singing


Pizza Island

We see a makeshift Island of a Pizza as people are having a great time and enjoying the super party planer Cheese Sandwich.

[Cheese Sandwich]

My parties are all off the hook

I never plan them by the book

I start out fun, then whoopsie-daisy

Everybody just gets crazy!

We see Cheese Sandwich was as Crazy as Lucky as the Cake was upright until we go upside down as we see Cheese Continues to sing even covered in Cake.

Bored of snacks made by your mom?

How about a giant party bomb?

We see a bomb made by Cheese Sandwich as which results in a huge party bomb.

Huge piñatas filled with cake

Or dive into my fruit punch lake!

Goldengrape: Geronimo!

It was clear that Cheese Sandwich was outclassing Pinkie Pie the super-duper party pony title as it gets even crazier to understand as his body moved around and shuffled and shifted and we see a disco ball in the background.

We see everyone then come in close and throw up Cheese Sandwich in amazement all except Pinkie Pie as she looked sad.

[Cheese Sandwich]

The super-duper party pony–that pony is me

You'll never meet another party pony quite like Cheese

C'mon, kid, take it for a spin!

We see Cheese opening a present and we see a Hippopotamus wearing a saddle as a young Colt then begins to ride it.

Colt: Golly! Thanks, mister!

[Cheese Sandwich]

Oh, when I throw a Cheese party, be sure to not be lame

And miss my pie fights, wacky kites, and streamers in your mane

Fizzy drinks, Hawaiian shirts, and brie fondue delight

You know that with Cheese Sandwich, you'll be partying all night!

Rainbow Dash: C'mon, everypony! Let's party down with Cheese!

Then everyone then runs towards Cheese even Lucky.

Pinkie Pie: [Worried.] Lucky wait!

Pinkie Pie tries to stop Lucky Heart but everyone then come in and run over Pinkie Pie.

Fluttershy: You're really a certified party pony?

Cheese Sandwich: That's right! That's my guarantee!

This shocked Pinkie Pie as she should be the Party Pony it was as if everyone forgot her.

[Cheese Sandwich]

The super-duper party pony–that pony is me-e-e-e-e

[Pinkie Pie]

[Sad.] But what about the super party pony named Pinkie...?

As she reaches out to them she then goes on her haunches as she is now sad and everyone was paying attention to Cheese Sandwich.

Cheese Sandwich: [indistinct] Thanks buddy! You're gonna love this party! Hey kid, have a streamer, on me!


Down the Street

Rainbow Dash: Yeah! Hah, now that's what I'm talking about! I'm so stoked you're here, Cheese Sandwich!

Applejack: Yeah. You sure did come on the right day.

Rarity: [sighs] Your party sounds simply divine.

Twilight Sparkle: We're so lucky to have you here.

Cheese Sandwich: Just doing my job, little fillies.

Pinkie Pie was right behind the crowd as she listens to how great Cheese Sandwich was.

Rainbow Dash: I mean, Pinkie Pie's parties are fun and sweet and all, but now this party's gonna be--

Cheese Sandwich: Epic?

Rainbow Dash: You said it! Oh, yeah!

Cheese Sandwich: Feels gouda!

Lucky Heart: I honestly don't mind Pinkie Pie's Parties but, Uh, Rainbow Dash, Pinkie Pie has done some good work at parties don't you think that was a bit inconsiderate seeing how she's here?

As Pinkie Pie smiles at how Lucky was willing to be at her party anytime and Rainbow Dash looked back and saw Pinkie Pie and felt bad.

Rainbow Dash: Uh, heh, no offense, Pinkie.

Pinkie Pie was crying as she took a bit offense to that as she then lick her tears out of her eyes and tried to be happy.

Pinkie Pie: Uh, n-none taken. [squee]

As Lucky looks back as he see Pinkie Pie walking normally before Rainbow Dash flys away we see Pinkie Pie a bit depressed as Lucky then knew that Pinkie Pie was putting up a happy face. It really bothered him when Pinkie Pie wasn't happy, it was like whenever he sees someone unhappy he needs to make them smile even if it took him a hundred years he would prefer Ponies to smile. Especially his girlfriend, Pinkie Pie her smile is one of the most beautiful and special things to Lucky if Pinkie was bothered by something he would make it his mission to fix it.


Ponyville Park

We see everyone helping out with Cheese Sandwich instructions to Rainbow Dashes party as Twilightand Rarity handle Rainbow Dash's face as Knight Rider and Rainbow Dash show up to see Rainbow Dash party in the works.

Knight Rider: Hey Rainbow you ok?

Rainbow Dash: Are you kidding?! My birth-iversary's already looking way cooler! You are my kind of party pony, Cheese Sandwich.

Cheese Sandwich: [chuckles] You got that right, Rainbow Dash. All right, party ponies, I've got some planning to do!

We then see everyone cheering as then Lucky notices a certain Pink mare isn't here helping with Rainbow Dash's birth-iversary.


Sugarcube Corner

We see Pinkie Pie waiting for everyone to show up and help with her Party for Rainbow Dash but no one showed up and Rainbow Dash banner fell down. Pinkie Pie felt blue as Lucky Heart sees Pinkie Pie sad and decided to cheer her up.

Lucky Heart: Pinkie!

As Pinkie Pie then hears Lucky she immediately tries to act casually as she picked up a pail and dumped the water into the flowers except she doesn't realize that she was dumping water down the drain something Lucky noticed but did want to say anything about it.

Lucky Heart: Pinkie? Aren't you gonna help Cheese Sandwich plan the party?

Pinkie Pie: That's okay. [chuckles nervously] He obviously has what it takes to do it all by himself. Heh.

Lucky Heart: [Confused] Really?

Pinkie Pie: Yes, indeedy! [chuckles nervously]

Lucky Heart: Pinkie, are you ok? You seem sad?

Pinkie Pie: Sad? [Forced Laugh.] Sad? Why would I be sad? After all, if Cheese really is the super duperiest partying-est pony of them all, maybe that means...

As Pinkie looks at Lucky Hearts face as it was clear that he saw right through her lies. Pinkie Pie then starts to cry as Lucky sees her cry and is shocked to see her so upset.

Pinkie Pie: [Tears in her eyes.] I'm... not.

Pinkie Pie then runs away leaving Lucky at Sugar Cube Corner as he seemed confused by her running away from home.

Lucky Heart: Pinkie Pie, wait! Come back!

Pinkie Pie didn't even listen to Lucky as she was so distraught that she didn't want Lucky to see her sad and after putting a good distance away from Lucky she then starts to trot in sadness as everyone was focused on Cheese Sandwich plan for Rainbow Dash's birth-iversary.

[Pinkie's Lament By Pinkie Pie]

[Pinkie Pie]

For all my life, all I've wanted to do

Was make my friends want to smile true

But maybe I was wrong

As she walks to the bridge and sings her song as she let loose a tear as it created a Rainbow ripple.

And Pinkie Pie shouldn't plan parties at all

As Pinkie Pie continues to be mopping we see Lucky Heart underneath the bridge as he had heard her say that before falling into the water.


Operating Room

We see a Pony Doctor working on a patient as he put out his hoof for a medical scalpel but instead got a rainbow cupcake as we see Pinkie Pie was the nurse as the doctor didn't like that at all and fired her as she then looks downtrodden and leaves.

As the Doctor went back to work on the patient we see the patient was gone as he questions what had happened.


Outside the Hospital

We see Pinkie Pie out of her nurse attire walk away sad and we see the Patient the doctor was working on was actually Lucky Heart as he took off his mask and gown continued to follow Pinkie Pie from a distance.


In Ponyville

We then see Pinkie Pie doing mail as she is being a messenger pony now as she packages in each mailbox.

[Pinkie Pie]

I'll try to get up on my hooves

And try a different task

As we see Lucky Heart behind her we see he is wearing a trench coat and funny glasses and mustache to hide his face from Pinkie Pie but sees a Pony open her mail box and knocks both her and Lucky Heart away as it was packed full of streamers and confetti.

Pinkie Pie found this funny but the pony who opened the mailbox wasn't.


Construction Area

We see earth ponies working on making a house when we see Lucky Heart watching from a makeshift bush and looks to find Pinkie Pie creating a Column of balloons.

[Pinkie Pie]

I'll find something new to do

As Pinkie Pie was finished Lucky then noticed that the building in question was tilted before falling around Pinkie Pie and everyone there but luckily no one was hurt.

There's gotta be more to me than planning a party or two

As Pinkie Pie and the construction pony then kicks her off her crew as Lucky follows Pinkie Pie.


Back at Sugarcube Corner

We see Lucky is now flying and looks in the window as we see Pinkie Pie putting away her party cannon.

[Pinkie Pie]

I put away my party cannon, I deflated all my balloons

The bubbles all burst, now what is next for you?

For you...

[Song Paused]

We see Lucky Heart enter through the window and Pinkie Pie notices him but is pretty much sad.

Pinkie Pie: [Sad.] Oh, hey Lucky, aren't you going to Rainbow Dash's birth-iversary?

Lucky Heart: I would go if a certain somepony could come with?

Pinkie Pie: Sorry, Lucky I just don't have any partying in me right now.

This shocked Lucky as he knows that Pinkie Pie would rather have a good laugh then not party. Lucky needed to get her spirit of Laughter back as he then looks over to a portrait of when Pinkie Pie first party she planned.

Lucky Heart: Hey Pinkie remember this?

As Lucky showed her the portrait she immediately remembered this and she got some of her smile back.

Pinkie Pie: Oh, I remember this one: my first party ever. My whole family was there.

Lucky Heart: And so was I. What about this one with everyone meeting each other?

Lucky shows The Mane and Heroic six at Twilight welcome-to-Ponyville party.

Pinkie Pie: Yeah, that's Twilight's welcome-to-Ponyville party. She didn't even expect that one. [giggles]

Lucky Heart: [Giggles] She sure didn't. What about this one I remember helping you out in this one.

Lucky then showed Pinkie her party to gummy as both she and Lucky worked together to create a best party ever.

Pinkie Pie: Oh, look at Gummy! He just looks so excited for this birthday party!

Lucky Heart: This one just after we saved Equestria from a Changeling invasion.

Then Lucky showed another picture of Pinkie Pie creating another successful party which was actually Shining Armor and Cadance's wedding.

Pinkie Pie: Hmm. Shining Armor and Cadance's wedding sure was special, especially once I got a hold of the music.

Lucky Heart: And where we confess our feelings for one another. [Blushes.]

As Lucky wraps a foreleg around her as Pinkie Pie feels so much better now as she then realizes that she is the greatest Party Planning Pony Ever.

[Song Resumes]

[Pinkie Pie]

Oh, look at those happy faces

All the parties that I had thrown

Lucky Heart: [Follows after Pinkie Pie.] You did throw one heck of a party!

Then we see Pinkie Pie have fun as she wears her funny glasses and Lucky follows behind her.

I made them laugh, had such a blast

Lucky Heart: That's true!

A smile that's all their own

They loved seeing me, the real Pinkie

Lucky Heart: Yes!

To Show them the time of their life like they've never known

[Lucky Heart]

like they've never known

[Pinkie Pie]

Like they've never kno-o-own

Pinkie Pie: Oh, Thank you Lucky for cheering me up and showing me that Cheese Sandwich is nothing compared to the true party pony, now I need to show them that there can be only one super party pony. Me!

Lucky Heart: Exactly...

It took Lucky to catch onto what Pinkie Pie said as he then was confused on what Pinkie Pie is going to do.

Lucky Heart: Wait? What?

[Pinkie Pie]

I've got to get back out there, have to show them that I've tried

Then we see Pinkie Pie then at amazing speeds pick up all her party stuff as Lucky got a bit worried at what Pinkie Pie is planning. We see Pinkie Pie then crush a Cheese Sandwich she made herself as to express her anger towards her rival and Lucky follows her and sees a cheese sandwich and eats it before following her.

For there's only one great party pony -- that is Pinkie Pie

Won't let Cheese Sandwich beat me, won't let him get me down

For I am Pinkie, the bestest party pony around!

As Pinkie Pie leaves to find Cheese Sandwich Lucky had a feeling that she isn't going to do anything fun related.

Lucky Heart: [Looks at us.] Why do I feel like something bad is going to happen? I best go and check on her to see if she doesn't do anything wrong.

Lucky then follows after Pinkie Pie.


Meanwhile at the Party preparations

We see everyone helping out and having fun as Derpy then have some chocolate from a fountain as Cheese Sandwich and Rarity, Alister Allstar, and Applejack follow Cheese Sandwich.

Rarity: I must say I marvel at your superior party planning expertise, Cheese Sandwich. [giggles]

Applejack: Well, they don't call him the super duper party planner for nothin'.

Alister Allstar: So true. [Chuckles.]

We then see Pinkie Pie come in and still wearing her party outfit.

Pinkie Pie: That's it! This pony has gotta get her title back! And I know just what to do!

As Pinkie Pie looks pleased with herself on an idea she had until Lucky came up right behind her.

Lucky Heart: Pinkie Pie!

Pinkie Pie: Lucky! You came!

Lucky Heart: Yeah, well I—

Lucky's mouth was then covered as she then talks for him.

Pinkie Pie: There's no need to say anything, I almost forgot that I was the party planner for this party not some out of town pony! I have so much to thank you for showing me how much ponies love my parties then Cheese Sandwich.

Lucky Heart: Actually I— [Mouth covered again.]

Pinkie Pie: There isn't anything that needs to be said, I still love you for being such a good and wonderful and loving and caring boyfriend in all of Equestria! Now sit back and let the real party planner handle this.

Pinkie Pie then kissed Lucky deeply as he was then awestruck by that kiss as it dazed him a bit as Pinkie leaves to confront Cheese. When Lucky see's Pinkie approach Cheese he wanted to know what Pinkie was planning.

Rainbow Dash: Totally awesome!

We see a light in a shape of Rainbow Dash lighting bolt, as Seamus Keegan then turns on a spotlight where Applejack see's Rainbow Dash Cutie Mark.

Applejack: Huh. Best I've ever seen.

Twilight Sparkle: I can't believe it!

Red Feynix: I can't believe that!

As Twilight sees what Red is looking at we see Cheese Sandwich has sculpted a likely huge chunk of Ice and shaped the ice into Rainbow Dash Cutie Mark.

Pinkie Pie: Freeze, Cheese!

We then see Lucky and Pinkie Pie come in from behind Rarity and Fluttershy as Lucky wasn't sure this was a good idea as Pinkie Pie then gave her best determined face to Cheese Sandwich.

Pinkie Pie: I challenge you... to a goof off!

Then all the Ponies and Spike Gasp at that.

Lucky Heart: No! Not a good off!

Applejack: [whispering] What's a goof off?

Lucky Heart: It's an ancient form of Goof off combat! It started long ago...


Lucky's interpretation

We see it was a dark and stormy night as we see thunder and lightning and two jesters.

Lucky Heart: [Narrating.] It started when two jesters claimed to be the better jester then the other, it started to annoy each other as they fought with rubber chickens and seltzer bottles.

Until we see one was victorious in making people laugh and the other walks away in shame.

Lucky Heart: [Narrating.] It was said that one could only be chosen and the people choose the better and the other was never heard from again and faded into obscurity!


Present time

Lucky was now worried and so were the others as they listened to him.

Lucky Heart: There hasn't been another goof off ever, until now.

Fluttershy: Oh, No. That doesn't sound good.

Lucky Heart: It isn't!

We then see Cheese put on a fez as he stares down at Pinkie Pie Challenge.

Cheese Sandwich: This Cheese has stood alone a long time, Pinkie Pie. You think you can out-goof me?

Pinkie Pie: Oh, I don't think so. I know so! And the stakes are high, Cheese Sandwich. Whoever wins will be dubbed the ultimate super duper party pony and headline the Rainbow Dash birth-iversary bash!

Twilight Sparkle: And the loser?

Pinkie Pie: Doesn't!

Rainbow Dash: [gasps]

Rest of main cast: [gasps]

Pinkie Pie: [Taunting.] So, are you in, Cheese? Or are you... boneless?

Cheese Sandwich: Nopony calls me boneless. Right, Boneless?

As we see the rubber chicken doesn't really reply as Pinkie Pie continues to challenge him.

Pinkie Pie: Then the goof off is on for high noon!

Twilight Sparkle: Um, Pinkie? It's already 3 o'clock.

As it is shown on the Clock as Pinkie then set it at another time.

Pinkie Pie: Oh. Oh, well then. Make it 3:10 to goof off!

As Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich stare at each other Lucky has felt like this wasn't fun at all it was just to much for him to see that Cheese and Pinkie were great Party Planners but they could be working together on this then Goof off each other.


Ponyville, 3:10

As it was now 3 to 10 we see Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich wearing the appropriate attire to goof off. As we see Pinkie Pie Wearing cowgirl boots with spurs and a large cowboy hat with an arrow through it and Cheese was wearing squeaky shoes and mismatched socks and fur winter hat and a fish on top of him.

We everyone in Ponyville waited for the Goof Off to start and this worried Lucky Heart as Twilight Sparkle brought him next to her and has a rule book for a Goof off with her.

Twilight Sparkle: All right, everypony. According to my official goof off rulebook...

Rainbow Dash: She actually has a goof off rulebook?

Spike: Are you kidding? Twilight can find a rulebook for everything!

Matilda: Shhh.

Twilight Sparkle: The two competitors have free range to goof about -- be it by singing, dancing, playing, prancing, joking, or performing -- to make the judge chortle, chuckle, giggle, guffaw, hoot and holler, whoop it up, and party down.

We then see Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich psych each other out but then Cheese then opens his mouth and we see a mice play tuba.

Twilight Sparkle: The funnier, sillier, wilder, and goofier, the better. Rainbow Dash, since the winner will be headlining your party, you are the judge.

Rainbow Dash: [Nervous.] Heh. Big tense competition on my birth-iversary. What could be better?

Twilight Sparkle: Lucky, you are the second judge, seeing how you have some knowledge of what a Goof off is.

Lucky Heart: [Sad.] Lucky me.

Twilight Sparkle: Cheese Sandwich, Pinkie Pie, are you ready?

Pinkie Pie: I was born ready!

Cheese Sandwich: I was ready before I was born!

Twilight Sparkle: Then... Let the goofing begin!

As Twilight flys away leaving Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart to judge who should lead the Party Planning for the Birth-iversary.

[Goof Off By Cheese Sandwich and Pinkie Pie]

We then see Cheese Sandwich on a roll as Pinkie Pie changes her outfit with a twirling hat and funny fake mustache.

[Pinkie Pie]

It's your birthday party, a very special day

We see Rainbow and Lucky look at Pinkie Pie as she is juggling cupcakes while on top of a ball.

I've got a song, it won't take long, I just wanted to say

She then throws the cupcakes at Lucky and Rainbow Dash as the two eat it up.

Happy, happy, happy, happy

Happy, happy, happy, happy

Happy, happy, happy, happy birthday to you!

We then see Cheese Sandwich rolling on a big cheese before landing in front of Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart as the two found him fun as Pinkie showed her anger.

[Cheese Sandwich]

If you wanna be the life of the party

But you're feeling just a little uptight

We then see Cheese wrap all his hooves around up tight and then plays with Lucky's face as Rainbow Dash found it funny.

Call the doctor, beg and plead

"Doctor, tell me what I need"

Try to put a little cheese in your knees!

As Cheese dance with literal cheese on his rear hooves A double hook from the sky then picks up both Lucky and Rainbow as it was Pinkie Pie in a basket with a ton of Balloons. Lucky Heart and Rainbow Dash smile at Pinkie Pie idea as they both fly.

[Pinkie Pie]

Bubbles and balloons, bubbles and balloons

What's a birthday party without bubbles and balloons?

Star-shaped or trapezoid, look what I can do

Only Pinkie Pie can make a bubble shaped like you!

We then see Lucky Heart and Rainbow Dash shaped like bubbles as the two laugh at that before Cheese Sandwich grabs the two.

[Cheese Sandwich]

Just let yourself go floppy, for now this is your chance

Pretend you have no bones and do the rubber chicken dance!

Cheese Sandwich: Hit it, Boneless!

We then see a puppet of the Chicken Boneless dancing as Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart look at each other confused before Pinkie Pie used a trampoline to get their attention.

[Pinkie Pie]

Cooler than a rubber chicken and tastier than cake

Come on, you, let's party down and do the Gummy shake!

Pinkie Pie: Hit it, Gummy!

We then see a real Alligator as Pinkie continues to see dance for it.

Pinkie Pie: Uh-huh! You know it! Shake it!

Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart Smiles at this and then two cheese hats come in from out of nowhere as we see Cheese Sandwich made a float of Cheese with thrones to the both of them.

[Cheese Sandwich]

'Cause I like to make you smile, smile, smile

Yes I do

It fills my heart with sunshine all the while

Yes it does

'Cause all I really need's a smile, smile, smile

From these happy friends of mine

We then see two cows wearing Rainbow Dash face masks as Pinkie Pie came in from under the rug.

Pinkie Pie: That's my song!

Cheese Sandwich: What do you mean? I have no idea what you're talking about.

Pinkie Pie: [Angry.] THAT'S IT!

[Pinkie Pie]

Roll out the party cannon

Pinkie Pie then took out her party cannon and It then blasted confetti all over Cheese Sandwich.

When you hear the party cannon song

Ka-BOOM!

Pinkie Pie then got into the Cannon and blasted herself out of the cannon and scared Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart.

[Cheese Sandwich]

Why should you compromise? Try this one on for size

We then see a huge Party Tank as Cheese was in the drivers seat and Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart became a bit more worried it was going to far.

'Cause nothing quite says cheer like the ringing in your ear

Of the cheese supreme cannonball surprise!

As it Lunched both Lucky and Rainbow and land on the ground hard as we see Pelican came out of the cheese supreme cannonball surprise. Then Pinkie Pie then had a huge cake piñata with Rainbow Dashes colors as she danced on top of it.

[Pinkie Pie]

¡Dale, dale, dale

No pierdas el tino!

Porque si lo pierdes

¡Pierdes el camino!

(Translation: Give it, give it, give it

Do not loose the focus!

because if you lose it

You lose the way!)

As a Pelican landed on top of the Piñata as Lucky saw this and then as it purched on top of it, the Piñata falls, Lucky Quickly pushed Rainbow out of the way as it crushed him.

Rainbow Dash: Lucky!

Pinkie Pie then stopped what she was doing she sees Rainbow checking on Lucky Heart as he tries to pull himself out and was sad.

Rainbow Dash: Lucky are you ok?

Lucky Heart: Yeah. I'm sorry that you're not getting the best party.

Pinkie Pie then heard that she Rainbow face was not one of joy but of sadness and when she saw that face her eyes grew dim before they turned into a rainbow color and go back to her normal color.

Pinkie Pie: [gasps] Rainbow's not having the best party ever! I... I broke the Pinkie Party Promise!

We then see Cheese make a seal play a huge horn as Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart are sad.

Pinkie Pie: Stop! The goof off is off!

Everyone was confused by that as Rainbow Dash and Lucky Heart look at her.

Rainbow Dash: But we haven't named a winner.

Pinkie Pie: You don't have to. I forfeit. Which means... Cheese Sandwich wins.

Cheese Sandwich: [laughs] [sighs] ...I do?

Pinkie Pie: Yes. You get to headline Rainbow Dash's party.

Twilight Sparkle: But, what about you, Pinkie?

Pinkie Pie: I... [sniffles] I don't.

Then Pinkie Pie cries and then runs back home.


Outside of Ponyville

We see Pinkie Pie then leave as she packed all her stuff and hits the road. But all her friends are there and tries to stop her from leaving.

Rainbow Dash: Pinkie, wait! I'm sorry I got all swept away by Cheese Sandwich.

Twilight Sparkle: We all are.

As everyone agrees to that as Pinkie Pie sees Spike walk up to her sorry as well.

Spike: [sighs] Sorry, Pinkie.

Pinkie Pie: No. I'm sorry I let my pride get in the way of you having the best birth-iversary ever. Cheese Sandwich really is a super duper party planner, and he'll be a terrific headliner. I should've been a big enough pony to admit that and let you have your day.

Then Lucky got in her way and tells her another reason she should stay.

Lucky Heart: Are you kidding? You're both super duper party ponies. Sure, Cheese Sandwich is a great guest party pony, but you're Ponyville's permanent party pony.

Then everyone hugs Pinkie Pie as they lover her no matter what.

Rainbow Dash: Yeah! Nopony could ever take your place, and we could never have a party without you.

???: Lucky Heart and Rainbow Dash are right.

We see Cheese Sandwich as he feels guilty about something.

Cheese Sandwich: I never meant to take your place in Ponyville. I just wanted to show you and Lucky what a great party pony I am, Pinkie.

Lucky Heart: [Confused.] Really?

Pinkie Pie: Why us?

Cheese Sandwich: Well...

[Cheese Confesses By Cheese Sandwich and Pinkie Pie and Lucky Heart]

[Cheese Sandwich]

I fear I told a little fib about my pony past

I hope that when you hear the truth, you will not be aghast

I wasn't quite the super party pony like I claimed


Cheese Sandwich Flashback

We see Cheese Sandwich was a lonely colt as he wore glasses and didn't have a Cutie Mark on his flank.

[Cheese Sandwich]

The fact is that I was so shy, nopony knew my name

We then see Cheese Sandwich leave his city all sad as he traveled down the road.

I stumbled into Ponyville one afternoon by chance

We then see a party hat on the road and Cheese Sandwich trips on it and landed in a big pile of party hats and we see Young colt pull him out of the pile to show the party.

And found the biggest ever celebration party dance

Everything was perfect, cheer was filling up the place

We see a Colt and Fillie come in with a new jester hat and gave him a grilled cheese sandwich and then a few ponies then throws him in the air and smiles to see everyone smile.

And I saw that everypony had a smile upon their face

Then a Rubber Chicken was thrown into Cheese Sandwich face as he rips the cheese sandwich in two.


Present Time

[Cheese Sandwich]

I vowed that day to change my life, the past I did set free

For now Cheese Sandwich was a party pony full of glee

We see Cheese Sandwich then play Accordion and two ponies slide down the accordion slide.

A super duper party pony -- that's what I became

I traveled all Equestria, and all did know my name

We see Cheese Sandwiches all over Equestria before Cheese Sandwich himself then jumps through the map.

But that never would have happened on my own, I'll tell you why

Then we see Cheese Sandwich then grab the two into a hug.


Cheese Sandwich Past

We see Young Cheese sandwich wearing a jester hat as a young Alicorn colt which was Lucky Heart carrying a bag full of party hats and rubber chickens lifts up Cheese sandwich jester hat as he was shocked to see a Alicorn and a Young Pinkie Pie who was juggling Rubber chickens while on a ball.

For the one who threw that party, it was you two, Pinkie Pie and Lucky Heart

Lucky Heart and Pinkie Pie: Me?


Present Time

Cheese Sandwich: Yes!

Pinkie Pie: Hah, really?!

Cheese Sandwich: Really!

Lucky Heart: Really?

Cheese Sandwich: Really!!

Pinkie Pie: So Lucky and I was the ponies that threw the awesomely spectacular party that inspired you to become an awesome spectacular party thrower?

Cheese Sandwich: Swear on Camembert!

[music warps down to a pause]

Rainbow Dash: Enough with the warm fuzzy stuff, you three. It's my birth-iversary, and you gotta throw me a bash!

Pinkie Pie: Yeah!

Cheese Sandwich: Let's go!

Lucky Heart: Only this time let's do it together!

Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich: YEAH!!!

[Music Resumes]

[Lucky Heart and Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich]

Super duper party ponies -- that is me and you


At the Birth-iversary

We see Lucky Heart, and Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich as all three are putting in their expertise into this Party.

A party thrown by one is good, but not as great as two, but not as awesome as three!

Come on and let's join forces, have thrice the expertise

We see Pinkie Pie dragging her cannon until Lucky lifts both Cannon and Pinkie Pie ontop of Cheeses Cannon as we see Rainbow Dashes party supplies are seen as we see Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich are being lifted by Lucky Heart as all three sing.

Now let's all go to the party planned by Pinkie Pie, Lucky, and Cheese!


Nighttime

We now see everyone is there enjoying the party made by Lucky, Pinkie, and Cheese as it was more amazing then ever. It had a pool of punch, Rainbow Dash shaped Balloons, ridding Hippopotamus, Roller coasters, Cannoned Confetti, and Fireworks.

We see everyone is enjoying the party as then we see a stage being set as we see Cheese first.

Cheese Sandwich: All right, everypony! We are here to celebrate the birthday...

Then we see Pinkie Pie coming out of nowhere.

Pinkie Pie: ...and anniversary...

Then Lucky falling down from the sky before getting back up to finish their party introduction.

Lucky Heart, Pinkie Pie and Cheese Sandwich: ...of Rainbow Dash!

Then we see a huge present flys in the sky as we see its Rainbow Dash that exploded from the present.

Rainbow Dash: Hey, everypony! Who's ready to get their party on?! Hit it!

[Make a Wish By Pinkie Pie]

[Pinkie Pie]

Get your hooves up, party's starting out right now

We see Lucky firing rockets in the air as they are Rainbows Cutie Mark or Rainbow Dash's head as Cheese Sandwich is rolling on his big Cheese wheel as Rainbow Dash is enjoying it.

Everypony, everypony get down

We see Rainbow blowing out her Rainbow Cutie Mark themed birthday cake candles and then we see Pinkie Pie singing, with Lucky Heart playing Banjo and Cheese Sandwich playing Accordion.

Time to make a wish, better make it right now

It's been a year and today is your birthday party

Make a wish, it's your birthday

We see Rainbow Dash playing hit the piñata as confetti comes out for all the Fillies and Colts to have fun.

Make a wish, it's your birthday party

We then see Lucky, Pinkie, Cheese, and Rainbow Dash eat a pizza cupcake as the three take one one bite while Rainbow continues to eat.

Make a wish, it's your birthday

We then see Applejack, Seamus, Red, and Twilight act as back up dancers to Pinkie Pie song. After that we see Lucky, Rainbow and Cheese having a blast in the punch pool before Pinkie Pie surprise Lucky allows him to fall out before Pinkie then worries about him and continues to sing as Lucky was ok as he then gives a peck on the cheek of Pinkie as she blushed a shade of pink as she continues to sing.

Make a wish, it's your birthday party

We then see everyone enjoying the party as Rainbow had the best party ever.

Then we see Lucky Heart come by with a cupcake and offer it to Cheese Sandwich.

Lucky Heart: You really did a good job Cheese.

Cheese Sandwich: Thanks.

The two eat the cupcakes as Rainbow Dash comes up to cheese all happy.

Rainbow Dash: Cheese Sandwich! Oh, I gotta tell ya, you and Lucky and Pinkie have totally made this the best birthday/anniversary super combo ever! Hah, it's totally--

Lucky Heart and Cheese Sandwich: Epic?

Rainbow Dash: Yeah, it is!

Cheese Sandwich: That's all I needed to hear, little filly. [Puts a cowboy hat on his head.]

As Pinkie was writing on her book on friendship we see Cheese gives her a case when it opens we see it's a Rubber Chicken as it shines a rainbow color on the outside.

Cheese Sandwich: Just a little memento of my visit.

Pinkie Pie: You're giving me your special rubber chicken friend?

Cheese Sandwich: Oh, he's not the only one. [Takes out another Boneless with Number two on it.] Well, Boneless Two, another job well done. But it's time we mosey along. Another town, another party.

Lucky Heart: What a weird Pony?

Pinkie Pie: Yeah? I never did get that pony's name.

Rest of main cast: Cheese Sandwich!

Pinkie Pie: [giggles] Oh, yeah!

Lucky Heart: [Air Kisses us.] That's Pinkie Folks!


A/N: I'm definitely going to say the the mystery stranger we saw earlier are the same pony as in the others.