Annabeths POV
We were planning our prank on the guys.
"Pass me the paint please!" I said to Juniper. We were filling a bucket with paint, feathers, paper, and popcorn. When we got the popcorn, 3 people went to prevent any more kidnappings.
"Done!" We stood back to look at our work. It was a bucket filled with sticky goop. We took some rope and snuck to the entrance to the basement. We secured the rope around the door frame and built a stand for the bucket. Turns out Thalia is an expert knot-tyer. We set up a trip wire so when someone steps out onto it they'll get a goopy surprise. We tied the bucket to the rope, set it on the stand, and put the camera in place. What? I want blackmail material. We retreated upstairs and waited. I feel like I'm forgetting something...
"Now can I throw the popcorn?" Katie asked, exasperated.
"Yup." We said. She threw it. But before it hits the ground...
Pipers POV
I have no clue why, but Grover just dared me to scream. So.
"Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh!" I scream as loud as possible. Percy and Nico start laughing manically. I looked at them warily.
"You just led your friends into a prank. Mwahahshaha!" Percy said. What!? I should have known this would happen. Well knowing Annabeth, the guys are about to get it good. I broke into an evil grin.
" Oh crud." I hear someone say. Splat! I hear the sound of goop hitting someone's head. Click! Annabeth must've run out of blackmail material. Soon I see Leo come in laughing. But he was perfectly fine. That's when Nico came in behind him, covered in feathers and...rainbows? I couldn't help it. I burst out laughing.
"Hey Piper. Truth or Dare?" Nico asked, challenging me.
"Truth," I say, playing it safe.
"Which of your friends would make the best fish?"
What. The. Heck.
"Reyna...?" I said cautiously.
"Wonderful," he says, and heads off to who knows where.
"Fish?" I ponder. "What could that mean?" Then it hit me.
