Chapter Three:
We'll Play Who Kills Monster First
By April3604 & Addicted to Ackles


Candy dialed Bobby's number and waited for him to pick up.

"Hello?"

"Bobby…it's Candy…Candy Thompson."

"Dear God, girl do you know how long it's been? After hearing about your father I sure thought that…"

"We're fine…well sort of."

"What do you mean by sort of?"

"You have to promise you won't blow up on me ok?"

"Oh Lord what have you and your sister gotten into now?"

"Well, long story short Lys and I stole from John Winchester's storage unit not knowing it was John Winchesters, for Bela to get some information my sister and I have been looking for. So later on the Winchester's showed up and we beat the hell out of each other and…"

"Don't tell me all for a rabbit's foot?"

"Let me guess, the brothers have already called you?"

"Which one of you touched it?"

"Lys."

She heard Bobby grumble something but couldn't understand what he said. "Listen, I got some information. You need to burn that thing tonight or you won't have another chance. So you and the Winchester's are going to have to put your differences aside and burn it…together."

Candy sighed heavily hitting her head against the window a couple times. "Bobby…do we have to?"

"You, your sister and the Winchesters need to grow up and get over this damn feud already!"

"Dean and I already tried that once," mumbled Candy making Lys look at her strange and Bobby ask, "What?"

"Nothing," she said sighing running a hand through her hair. "Alright, give me dick heads number and I'll call him."

"Candace…"

Candy rolled her eyes. "Fine, give me Dean's number." After Bobby gave her his number he said something about her and her idgit sister and Winchesters and hung up. She stared at the number seriously not wanting to dial it.


Flashback

Eighteen year old Candy walked into the old diner to get some food for the road. Her dad was across the street filling up with gas along with her fourteen year old sister Lys. "Hi can I get three burgers three fries and three drinks to go please"

"Sure sweetie I will get this right out to you." The waitress said and Candy took a seat at the counter.

"That's a lot of food for one girl. You sure you can eat it all?" She heard someone say next to her. She turned and saw a boy around her again and was automatically drawn to him.

"It's not all for me but you would be surprised how much I can eat," she said and smiled at him.

"My name is Dean by the way," he said and stuck out his hand.

"Candace but everyone calls me Candy."

"I love candy."

"Is that the best line you can come up with?" She asked with a smirk on her face. It wasn't the first time she had heard that.

"Well I was going to say I love to eat candy but I think that would have been out of line."

"Good call Dean," she said as the waitress brought out her food. "So do you live around here?"

"No we are just passing by. What about you?"

"No we just stopped to fill up"

"We? I hope you don't mean you and your boyfriend."

"No me, my dad, and my sister."

"Good because I was about to get upset," he said causing Candy the blush a little and she wasn't the blushing type. "So how long you staying?"

"No very long but now I wish we were staying longer," she said and Dean moved closer to her.

"Well maybe you should," Dean looked at her and she bit her bottom lip and he moved in even closer as if to kiss her, she heard a familiar voice.

"Get the hell away from my daughter!" Lawrence Thompson said and walked over the two.

"Dad...we were just talking," Candy said as she got up.

"Candy go wait outside with your sister."

"But dad..."

"Now Candace!" He said and she looked back at Dean before walking out. Lawrence waited until Candy was outside before laying into Dean. "I know who you are and you better stay the hell away from my daughter or it will be the last thing you do."

"Hey! Don't threaten my son you son of a bitch," John Winchester said as in walked into the diner.

"John Winchester...can't say it's good to see you."

"Dean go outside and check on Sam," John said and Dean walked out and saw Sam by the car and saw candy standing with her sister.

"What's going on?" asked Lys looking at her sister.

"Dad being his usual overprotective self and now I think he's flipping on Dean's dad."

"You always get men in trouble with dad."

"Shut up…I'm going to go apologize." She grinned at Lys who just rolled her eyes following her sister.

"Hey," Candy said as she bit her lip and put her hands in her back pockets.

Dean smiled at her as he leaned on the car. "Hey."

"Good grief," said Sam rolling his eyes and turning his back on them.

"Shut up Charlie Brown," said Dean glancing back at Sam and then turned back to Candy.

"Look, I just wanted to apologize for my father's behavior he can be very…overprotective of me and my sister."

Dean licked his lips looking Candy up and down and gave her his charming smile as he ran a finger down her cheek. "Well, if I had a daughter as beautiful and gorgeous as you then I would be very protective also."

Lys rolled her eyes as she sat on the curb and Sam joined her. "Just warn your sister he flirts with anything that has legs and big boobs," said Sam shaking his head at his brother.

"That's alright, Candy always flirts with a guy that wears a leather jacket and five o'clock shadow. She has a thing for Indiana Jones."

"You mean Harrison Ford."

"No, Indiana Jones."

The two looked at their older siblings and felt like barfing watching them flirt with each other and touch each other.

"So this your car?"

Dean glanced at the Impala and smirked. "Yeah, well until dad actually trust me to have it."

"She's hot…'67 nice year."

Dean grinned. "Knows her cars and beautiful, I like that."

"There's a lot more that I know that you'll probably like." Candy bit her bottom lip as she moved closer to him and ran her fingers lightly over his chest.

"I bet there is." He glanced towards the car and a smile spread across his face as he looked back at Candy. "Have you ever been in a '67 Chevy Impala?"

She shook her head and he opened the back door for her and she slid in.

"Oh they so aren't going to do what I think they are going to do," said Lys watching Dean and Candy get into the back seat on the car.

"Yup they are," said Sam kicking a rock. "Wait till dad sees that one."

"My dad is either going to kick your brothers ass or my sisters…preferably both as long as I'm not in the middle of it."

"That's the truth…I'm Sam by the way."

"Alyssa, but you can call me Lys." They shook hands and looked back at the car.

"Wow," said Candy as Dean put his arm around the seat. "She's in beautiful condition."

"Yeah me and my dad keep her in good condition." He licked his lips looking Candy up and down again. He just couldn't stop staring at her.

Candy leaned back and looked at Dean. "So you're a real hands on kind of guy?"

Dean smirked looking out the window to see if he still had time to make his move while their parents were still fighting in the diner then back at Candy. "Oh, I am very hands on."

"Would you like to prove that?"

Dean didn't say anything he just leaned over and kissed her. She responded to him opening her mouth and letting his tongue just take over her mouth. She rested her hand on his face while his one stayed on her hip his fingers lightly going up her shirt.

Lys made a disgusted face looking towards the Impala seeing Sam's brother's tongue down her sisters throat.

Sam and Lys heard the bell of the diner going off and turned towards it to see both their father's getting kicked out.

"Let's go girls," said Lawrence as he grabbed Lys by the hand and pulling her up and then noticed Candy was missing. "Where's your sister?"

"Playing tonsil hockey with Sam's brother in the backseat of their car."

Both Lawrence and John walked towards the car and opened both doors. John grabbed Dean while Lawrence grabbed Candy.

"Shit," said Dean.

"Shit is right," said John glaring at Dean.

"Dad…um…I, uh, we were…" started Candy looking over the roof of the car to John and Dean and then looking at her father.

"Just leaving," said Lawrence pulling her along with her sister. She turned around waving at Dean and he smirked at her.

"Dad what's going on? Look I'm sorry for making out with the kid ok?" Candy asked.

"Its not that Candace its…That was John Winchester you know, the man that tried to kill me."

"And that was his son?!"

"Yeah....he probably sent him to talk to you to get to me."

Candy held her stomach in her hands. "I think I'm gonna puke." She got into the car with Lys and her father and drove off.

All three Winchesters watched as the girls and Lawrence got into the car and drove off quickly.

John turned to Sam and Dean and said, "Don't you ever trust a Thompson."

"Thompson?" asked Dean glancing back at the rear end of the car then to his father. "You mean that was..." Dean made a face and stuck his tongue. "I have a bad taste in my mouth."

"Yeah that was Lawrence Thompson the bastard that almost got me killed and left you two orphans." John glared at the road the Thompsons had left on and got into the car the same time as his sons.

"Never trust a Thompson boys, they only lead to trouble and will probably kill you."

END Flashback


Candy grunted as she dialed Deans number. He was the last person he wanted to talk to or for that matter work with now or anytime but she had to help her sister.

Dean and Sam were walking through an ally when his phone started to ring, "Hello?"

"Hey baby it's me."

"Candy? What the fuck do you want and how did you get this number?"

"I have my way. We need to talk."

"I don't have a damn thing to say to you." While Dean was arguing with Candy, Sam steps in a piece of gum, getting it stuck to his shoe.

"If you want to save your brother you will talk to me."

"Fine what is it?"

"We need to burn this damn thing tonight."

"No shit Sherlock but how do we do that?"

Sam tries scraping off the gum against the sewer grate.

"Just meet us at the cemetery in an hour." She said and hung up the phone.

While trying to scrape the gum off, Sam's shoe ends up coming off his foot, falling into the sewer.

Dean slammed his phone shut and looked back at Sam who is sulking, "What?"

"I lost my shoe," Sam said pouting looking at the gutter below him. Noticing Sam's lack of a shoe, Dean rolled his eyes and walked back to the car.

Dean pulled into the cemetery and parked next to Candy's car and got out. The two girls were standing in the middle waiting on them.

"Didn't think you would show," said Candy with her arms across her chest.

"Oh, I always come on time sweetheart," said Dean smirking.

"Hmmm, really?" she asked putting her hands on her hips. "Because I remember a time when you didn't." She grinned at him and he just glared.

"Ok, enough with the bickering," said Lys. "I just want to get this over with so I don't have a freaking target on my back."

"Speak for yourself," said Sam. "You're the one with the foot."

Lys stuck her tongue out at him and the four of them walked towards the middle of the cemetery. As they were walking Sam grabbed the foot from Lys and she glared at him as he smiled.

As she had her eyes on him she felt her foot get stuck in a root on the ground and fall over. Sam laughed and Candy helped Lys up.

"Not funny, Sam," said Lys pushing him and grabbing the foot back but he pulled it over his head. "No fair! You're freaking Sasquatch!"

"Would you two knock it off?" asked Candy. "You're like children."

Lys and Sam went to help Candy and Dean with the fire but they stopped them.

"No, knowing your luck one or both of you will catch on fire," said Dean. "So stay."

Once Dean and Candy were finished they were about to put the foot in when they heard a gun being cocked behind them. The four turned around to see Bela.

"You fucking bitch," said Candy staring at her wide eyed.

"Oh, sweetie it's just business. Now give me the foot."

"Who's this?" asked Dean looking at Candy.

"Bela, the woman that we stole the foot for," said Lys.

"Give me the foot and no one is going to get hurt."

"No, you see you're not going to pull the trigger," said Dean. "I can read people and…"

Before Dean could finish that sentence Bela shot Lys in the leg. Lys made a noise as she fell to the ground and Sam grabbed her holding her up and looking from her to Bela.

"You British son of a bitch!" yelled Candy walking over to her but Dean grabbed her holding her back.

"If she's willing to shoot your sister then she's not hesitant shooting you," said Dean holding onto her.

Candy looked over at Lys who was cradling her leg. "Lys you ok?"

"I've been better," said Lys wincing as she looked at the bullet wound.

"Now, how much more blood must be on your hands Candace before I get what I want."

"Fine," said Dean and looked over at Sam. "Sam give her the foot."

"What?"

Dean made a face. "Give her the foot."

"Your fucking crazy, Dean," said Candy turning around. "You give her that thing and both our siblings die!"

"For once in your life, trust me," he said staring her in the eyes and she tried to figure out his game plan.

Sam stood up leaning Lys on a headstone and glanced at Dean then towards Bela. "Heads up!" He threw the foot and without thinking Bela caught it in her hands.

"Shit," she said shaking her head.

"Now, put it in the fire," said Dean.

Bela grimaced as she threw it in the fire and watched it burn. "I hope you are all happy. You just made me lose a client."

"You better get the fuck out of here before I kill you," said Candy growling at her and walking towards Lys an helping her up.

Bela just smiled at her. "Well, girls, what you have been looking for has been under your noses the whole time but you are just blind to see it, tata." With that she walked away and Candy felt her upper lip twitching in anger.

Once Bella was gone, Sam helped Lys over to the car to try and get the bullet out of her leg. Dean wasn't sure what Bella meant by her comment or what it was Candy was looking for but he sure as hell wanted to find out. He walked over to her and she just rolled her eyes at him. "What now Dean?"

"You want to tell me what that was all about?"

"Not really....so if you don't mind I need to check on my sister," Candy said and started to walk off but Dean grabbed her by the arm.

"Sam has it under controll. Now what is it that you are looking for this time?"

"Its none of your fucking business Dean," she said and jerked her arm away and started to walk off again.

"That's right just walk away like you always do. Miss I don't need anything from anyone." Candy turned back to him and slapped him hard across the face.

"I don't need anything from anyone. Especially you!"

Sam was done with Lys and they couldn't help but over hear their sibling fighting and wondered just what it was they were talking about. As far as Lys knew, Candy had only saw Dean one time and that was when they were younger.

"You know what Candy you are still just as much as a bitch now as you were then. You are always ready to put the blame on someone else instead of yourself!"

"Whatever Dean you know what, I hope I never see you again!"

"Right back at ya sweetheart!" he said and they headed back toward the car. "Sam let's go!" Dean yelled and Sam finished up Lys and helped her into Candy's car.

"Thank you Sam" Lys said.

"Your welcome." Sam smiled at her before he walked over and got into the impala and Dean was about to when he saw Candy just standing outside her car and she appeared to be crying. Dean had never seen her cry before and it made him wonder what was really wrong with her.

Candy leaned against the car with her face in her hand. She couldn't believe that after all they had gone through the past few days and they still didn't have the colt. She honestly had no idea what belle had meant by what she said but she had to find out.


Flashback

Dean sat at the bar drinking a beer when he looked over towards the pool table and smiled seeing a girl bent over wearing a skirt and he knew he had to try. She was getting a lot of attention from the other bar occupants and Dean got up first walking over to her.

"Hey, baby, you sure you know how to handle that?"

The girl stood straight up and said, "Are you man enough to show me?"

She turned around and both of them went wide eye. "You!" The both yelled at the same time.

"Well, I've sobered up," said Dean looking her up and down. "Damn…"

"You better be saying damn about it being me and not because of how hot I look." She couldn't help her eyes traveling up and down his body. He was more built from when they were teenagers but he still had the five o'clock shadow and that damn leather jacket.

"Well, Legs you sure have grown up." She just glared at him.

"Shut up, Winchester."

"What are you going to do? Have daddy yell at me again?" He took a sip of his beer and smirked.

"For your information my father died a few years back." She put the pool stick on the table and turned back around folding her arms and looking away from him.

"Oh, look I'm sorry."

"Whatever, look how about we just pretend that we don't know each other and everything will be fine."

"Yeah, sounds good to me." He walked back towards the bar but kept his eye on her making sure she wasn't getting into any trouble.

As Dean had started to drink more he couldn't help but feel a pit of jealousy in his gut from seeing Candy flirt with other guys. Even the littlest thing she did just laughing at them or touching their shoulders was setting off this spark of jealousy in him.

"So which one did you say?"

Dean overheard a couple guys that just sat at the bar.

"That one, the blond with the red top and denim skirt."

Dean looked over at Candy and noticed they were talking about her.

"You think she'll go for it?"

"Course not, but has that ever stopped us before."

Dean gritted his teeth and got up from the bar. If they were talking about what he was thinking they were talking about he had to get Candy out of there quick.

He walked around the bar and towards Candy. "Candy."

She turned around and rolled her eyes. "What Dean?"

"Look, I think you better come with me."

She made a face. "Why?"

"Trust me alright, I overheard some guys talking. Just come with me."

"I don't think so." She shook her head and turned back to the guy she was talking to.

"You ready sweetie?" asked the guy and she looked at him then noticed a couple guys looking at her by the exit and then walking out.

She licked her lips and turned back to Dean thanking God he was still behind her. She looked into his eyes and saw the worried look. She turned back to the guy and smiled. "Actually, the guy I was waiting for just showed up, so…sorry."

She went to turn back around and the guy grabbed her arm. "Listen here girly, you were giving me all the signs so I think it's best you come with me now."

"Hey," said Dean grabbing hold of the guys arm that was on hers. "Let her go man." Dean and the guy just stared into each other's eyes. "Just let her go and no one is going to get hurt."

The guy backed off and walked away. "Thanks, Dean."

"Told you to trust me." He shrugged.

"Right, trust you, a Winchester."

"Hey, I thought we were pretending we didn't know who we were."

She smiled and grabbed her beer. "You know you're right. So stranger, how about we go find a booth and talk?"

Dean smirked. "Sure." He ordered another beer and the two of them walked towards the booth.

At first they sat across from each other just talking and whatnot but then more drinks were being poured down their throats and they were both getting drunk.

"Oh my God," said Candy leaning over the table staring into Dean's eyes. "I never noticed how green your eyes were. They're like…gems…like these gems that I saw in this jewelry store. Ugh they were gorgeous but Lys totally said no." She sat back and sighed.

"Well, your eyes are very beautiful," said Dean taking a sip of his beer.

"Awe, thanks Dean," she said and moved over to his side of the booth. "See isn't it better when we pretend we don't know who we are?"

Dean put his arm around her shoulders and nodded as he smiled. "Yeah, you're right. I don't get this bile in my throat when I think of who you're related to."

She scrunched her face up and smacked him on the arm. "Jerk."

"I'm sorry…how about I make it up to you?"

"Hmmm, how?" She turned her head to look at him but he didn't say anything and his hand was on her face, his thumb tracing her bottom lip lightly making her close her eyes and Dean took this opportunity to kiss her. She moaned into the kiss as he devoured her mouth into his. His hand moved to her side lightly grazing the side of her breast causing her to shiver as his thumb gently went over her nipple over her tank top. His hand landed on her waist pulling her closer to him and her hands landed on his chest. Her nails dug into his chest and went down causing him to moan into her mouth.

He let go of her lips both of them breathing heavy and looking at each other. Dean sucked on his bottom lip looking from her swollen lips to her eyes.

"Maybe we should take this somewhere else?" he asked in a low lustful voice that sent shivers down Candy's spine.

End Flashback


One Week Later

Candy and Lys had been searching under every stone they knew of to try and figure out what Bela had meant by right under their nose. It made no sense to them at all.

Lys was reading a newspaper they had gotten a few miles back and something caught her eye. "Hey Candy, about 10 miles up the road, this guy and is brother was attacked. He was the only one to survive."

"Ok so?"

"So the police said the two men that died looked like they were attacked by an animal."

"I guess it's worth checking out. It's not like we got anything better to do."

"Candy don't worry. We will find the colt." Lys told her sister but Candy was starting to think they never would.

She pulled up to the hospital and parked the car. They got out and grabbed two FBI badges and headed to the entrance when none other than Dean and Sam Winchester walked out and almost ran into then.

"You have got to be kidding me," Candy said and Dean glared at her.

"What the hell are you two doing here?"

"Following your sweet ass," she said sarcastically. "What do you think we are doing here?"

"I don't know and I don't care. Come on Sam," Dean said and walked around them.

"We aren't leaving!" Candy yelled at him and he turned back to her.

"Yes you are. If I have to drag you out of here myself."

"I would love to see you try baby," Candy said and Dean started to walk over to him but Sam stopped him.

"Dean just let it go man."

"Aw Sam, I knew you were the more reasonable one," Lys said and smiled at him. "Nice ass too."

Sam frowned at her before pulling Dean away and back to the car.

Candy and Lys watched Sam pull Dean away before Dean could murder Candy and Candy smirked at him while waving her hand.

"Oh, he wants to play who kills the monster first, we'll play and we will win," said Candy glancing at Lys who smiled back.

"The Thompson sisters always get their monster," said Lys.

"Even if we have to play dirty with the Winchesters." The Impala drove by and both girls grinned at the brothers who were staring at them.