It had been about a month since the incident with Paige. Paige was still barely talking to her and Phoebe was at her wits end. Luckily there hadn't been any demon attacks or she's not sure how they would survive. She had moved out of the manor to her new apartment about a week before and the entire time Paige locked herself in her room not coming out the entire time she had been packing up her stuff. Paige hadn't even been by to visit her place yet. Piper had been stuck in the middle of there spat acting as a go between, but there still seemed to be no reprieve. Phoebe decided she had enough and she was going to end this once and for all.

She gathered up five candles and placed them in a circle. She lit them all and began chanting:

"Hear my voice
Hear my cry
Spirit from the other side
Come to meI summon thee
Cross now the great divide. "

Instantly there was a display of lights in the middle of the circle, and as the lights disappeared, Penny Halliwell stood in its place. Penny took a step out of the circle and her body took corporal form.

"Phoebe," she said opening her arms to hug her granddaughter.

"Grams!" she said rushing to hug her grandmother.

As they released from the hug Grams took in her surroundings. "Don't tell me you moved out again."

"I did and please don't blame Piper. She tried to stop me but I chose to move for my own sanity," Phoebe said.

"Your own sanity?" Penny asked with a raised brow.

"Lets just say that Paige and I haven't exactly been seeing eye to eye lately," Phoebe told her.

"What's wrong?" Grams asked her.

"I am dating someone new and Paige doesn't agree with the relationship," Phoebe told her.

"What's his name and why doesn't Paige like him?" she asked.

"Her name is Billie," Phoebe said.

"Ah, I see," Grams said. "Your sister is homophobic?"

"No! It's not like that! At least I hope she's not like that. She believes I'm under a spell or something. She refuses to believe that I'm in love with her."

"Well is there a possibility that you are under some sort of spell?"

"Not you too, Grams. I don't get it. What do I have to do to prove to everyone that I'm not under any sort of spell, and I really love Billie."

"If you believe that you are in love with this woman then I'm not questioning that. I had to ask because if the possibility has been brought up there's no harm in testing the theory," Grams told her.

"Okay fine how would you suggest that I prove I'm not under any sort of spell," Phoebe asked.

"Leave that to me," Grams told her before chanting:

"In this home,
With this spell
Reveal all enchantments
To us Halliwells."

Instantly they felt a burst of energy then nothing. Phoebe looked at her grandmother and gasped in surprise. "Grams your glowing!"

"It's to show that there is an enchantment on me, but what we should be focusing on is the fact that you're not glowing which means you are under no type of spell," Grams told her.

"Yes, I told you guys I wasn't," Phoebe told her.

"And I'm sorry I doubted you for even a second. Alright now come, sit, and tell me all about this incredible woman you have fallen for," Grams said gesturing for her granddaughter to sit on the couch.

Phoebe smiled brightly, went and sat on the couch, and proceeded to tell her grandmother everything about Billie. They had been talking for about half an hour when Phoebe heard her door opening and turned to see her girlfriend walking into the apartment, paying no attention to the women on the couch.

She walked in with some bags in her hands using her shoulder to hold her phone to her ear. "Piper are you sure that this is her favorite meal, and that I'll be able to make it? Okay I just want this to be special it's the first time I've cooked for her and I want it to be perfect."

"I'm sure it will be," said Phoebe who had walked up behind her girlfriend, scaring the daylights out of her.

"Phoebe, fuck!" Billie said jumping and dropping her phone, "What are you doing home? You're supposed to be at work."

"Then I wouldn't get to see how flustered and cute my incredibly sweet girlfriend is when she is trying to surprise me," Phoebe said taking the bags from her hands. And giving her a light peck on the lips. Billie held her waist to keep her from moving away and deepened the kiss. They were both so completely lost in each other that Phoebe had forgotten Grams was on the couch until she cleared her throat causing them to jump apart. Phoebe took a couple of steps back while Billie picked up her phone and told Piper she'd call her back.

"Billie, I want to introduce you to my Grams. Grams this is my girlfriend Billie," Phoebe said leading Billie towards the couch before taking the bags to the kitchen.

"Your Grams? As in the dead Grams?" Billie asked shocked stepping closer to the woman.

"Phoebe, I thought you said she was a witch. She looks surprised," Grams said slightly amused.

"She is. I don't know why she looks so surprised," Phoebe said coming back to the couch.

"Well knowing we are able to do something and actually doing it is two separate things," Billie said reach out to touch Grams still in awe.

"Go ahead sweetheart it's fine," she said taking Billie's hand.

"If I wanted to talk to someone who was dead would I be able to?" Billie asked looking between them.

"There are rules and limitations, but in theory yes," Grams said.

"Why is there someone specific you wanted to contact?" Phoebe asked.

"Yeah, my Gammy," Billie told them.

"Your Gammy?" Grams questioned.

"Yes, my grandmother on my mothers side. My mom said she was a witch, and I was hoping that maybe she could help me with my new power. I can't help but to feel that somehow if I can master it then I would be one step closer to finding Christy," she responded.

"Well, dear, if you really think it would help then I don't see any reason why we couldn't try. What was your Gammy's name?" she asked.

"Elizabeth Christine Dorsey," Billie told her.

"Liz Dorsey!" Grams exclaimed, "She was one of my best friends. Phoebe you remember your Aunt Liz."

"Of course I remember Aunt Liz. You're her granddaughter. You know now that I think about it you do have her eyes. She used to talk about you all the time," she said.

"She still does. I'm sure I won't have any problem summoning her," she said with a wave of her hand and instantly Liz appeared in the circle.