Casey 2.0 (4/?)
Chapter title: Truth or Dare
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Casey always had feelings for her. But he realizes that he needs to become someone he himself can be proud of before he is worthy of her. So after he leaves high school he does just that and returns Neptune at the beginning of her sophmore year at Hearst ready for the chance he's always wanted.(Casey and Veronica CaVe)

Characters/Pairing: Veronica/Casey (mentions all VM characters at some point)
Spoilers: entire series
Word Count: 4529
Disclaimer: I don't own Veronica Mars or any of the movies or organizations i mention in this chapter.

Thanks to everyone who has reviewed, alerted and/or favorited this fic.


Veronica Mars is officially my girlfriend and we are in an established, trusting, healthy and loving (well on my part, I'm still not sure on hers) relationship.

I must have done something really fucking good in a former life to deserve the fucking heaven I've been in for the past month.

After our first date we've spent almost every single day together in some capacity, whether it be coffee before class, lunch, the whole day on weekends or just making out in the lesser used section of the library. I can't get enough of her and of that part, I know she feels the same way. We have officially reached the point of comfort in our relationship where respect has been achieved and we both understand where things are going.

And the last step to us being together completely, is most likely not far away. In other words, I'm pretty god damn positive that we are finally going to sleep together soon.

Now don't get me wrong, I haven't been pressuring her. We've both been aching for each other since the beginning, but one or both of us always comes to our senses and we stop, or we just get interrupted.

But it's getting harder, two nights ago we went to a movie and we were that couple that makes out in the back row from the beginning to the end. I'm not even sure I could tell you the name of the movie, let alone who was in it or what happened.


Week #6

Post date #25

November 24th 2007

I was on my way up the stairs when I heard the door bell ring.

I'd gotten back from a date with Veronica about a half hour earlier and had tried to watch some TV but lost interest quickly. I was tired, in serious need of a cool down and really not in the mood to deal with anybody, especially any of the girls that Luke had been bringing around. But he wasn't there and they obviously weren't going away, as proven by the incessant dinging of the bell, so I retreated down the stairs and flung open the door.

I was fully prepared to shoo whoever had the nerve to be so persistent, but promptly shut my mouth at the sight of Veronica smiling, holding up a bag of cookies and standing there in her pajamas with a duffel bag at her feet.

I smiled and leaned against the door way. "Are you selling Girl Scout cookies? Cuz if so, you're out of uniform and I must insist that you put it on before I make a purchase."

She gave me the head tilt, arched up on her tiptoes to kiss me and responded happily. "Well first of all, I'm not selling anything, I'm offering, no purchase necessary. And second, I am not now, nor have I ever been, a Girl Scout and after the other day I'd have been kicked out anyways. "

I laughed and grabbed the cookies from her opening the bag and tossing one in my mouth. "Ok, so what is it you are offering Miss Mars?"

She gave me a coy smile, wrapped her arms around my neck and mine instinctively circled her waist pulling her close. "Ok, so here are the facts. My dad, is gone, until tomorrow. Mac, is in San Diego with Dick. And Wallace, well we all know I can't bunk with him."

Definitely not, that Piz kid may have accepted that he lost her, but he still wants her. Wait..... Bunking? "You need to stay somewhere?"

She blushed a little and kissed me softly. "Yeah."

"Why?" In truth I didn't care, she was gonna stay with me regardless. Al I could think of was having her in my bed and holding her all night. It was gonna make the waiting that much harder but it would be so worth it.

"You have to promise not to laugh."

"Ok, I promise." Well at least I hoped.

"Well, when you dropped me off I was tired and decided to take a shower." And with that I was immediately thinking of her in the shower, naked and wet and alone. Oh. God. I shook my head and refocused on what she was saying. "When I turned on the water and was about to get into the shower I realized that there was something moving behind the curtain…"

And with that I went straight into protective boyfriend mode. "Was there somebody in there? Did they try to hurt you? Did…"

She stopped me with a kiss and then pulled back smiling. "Um no, it wasn't a person."

"Well then what was it?"

"A snake."

"What?" I pulled back and started lifting up her sleeves and pant legs. "Did it bite you? Are you ok?"

She cupped my cheeks with her hands and kissed me again. "Casey I'm fine, it wasn't poisonous, I don't think, I mean it's not like I stopped to ask it, but I'm pretty sure. But anyways it scared the crap out of me so I grabbed some stuff and got out of there. No one can get it out of there until tomorrow and I don't have anywhere else to stay and well, none of those other places would be where I really wanted to be anyways. So I was thinking…"

My worry ebbed and I smiled and nuzzled against her. "You were thinking?"

"Sleep over? Complete with junk food, ridiculous movies and truth or dare. I even brought a sleeping bag."

I pulled back and sure enough there was a green sleeping bag next to the duffle. I kissed her and pulled her inside. "Sleepover. Absolutely. Junk food. Definitely. Movies. Always. Truth or dare. Possibly. But sleeping bag?" I looked over at her as I closed the door behind us and she smiled. "Not gonna be needed. Why would you need a sleeping bag when I have a nice warm bed complete with a nice warm me for you to cuddle up to?"

She grabbed my hand, leaned her body into mine seductively and I immediately started reciting the state capitals in my head. "So is that a yes then?"

"That's a hell yes. What do you want to do first?"


Big scary snake. Night with boyfriend. Big scary snake. Night with boyfriend.

Um yeah, not really any contest there.

The minute I saw it I started tossing stuff in my duffle and had literally walked out the door before I realized I was only wearing a towel.

I hightailed it back inside, threw on some PJs and then ran right back out to my car.

In truth it's not like a towel would have been an issue for Casey, or for me. But we were still trying to wait and if I had shown up like that….the waiting would have been over.

I knew he'd say yes to me staying, but I wanted to play the whole thing off anyways and really I just kind of couldn't wait to spend the night in his arms.

We started off the night with 'The Breakfast Club' and finished off the cookies and then "Pretty in Pink," eating 3 bags of microwavable popcorn. Ok, so I hate 2 and a half, and he ate a half of one, but we shared. By the time the second movie was over I was a little tired and a little hyper and he hadn't removed his hands from me in over an hour.

I was sitting there between his legs resting against his chest and he had his arms around me, his hands resting on my stomach when I had a thought. He hadn't said no.

"Truth or dare Casey?"

I heard him laugh and he leaned his head down to capture my lips. "Really V?"

"Yes really. Please Casey." I turned in his arms and straddled his hips bringing my lips to his pulse point. "Please baby. One each."

He moaned a little as I nipped at his ear and pulled me close again. "Ok, one each and I pick truth."

I smiled against his skin and then leaned back. "Why did you transfer to Hearst?"

His face froze and he turned completely white. That was all the answer I needed and it completely proved my theory, but I still wanted to hear it. "Case?"

He looked down as if ashamed and when he met my eyes again he looked worried. "Veronica, I…I don't want you to think…..it's not like I was.....I just….fuck."

`I cupped his chin and made him look at me. "Casey, no matter what you say I'm not going anywhere."

He looked relieved but took a deep breath and lowered his head again before responding. "It was you. I'd always wanted you and I knew I didn't deserve you so I changed for you, well, and for me, but a lot of it was for you. And I just didn't want to wait anymore, I at least wanted to be in your life so I decided to move back. I transferred to Hearst to be near you."

When he looked back up it was with worry, but it was soon gone when he saw the smile on my face. "You're not freaked out by that?"

I shook my head. "No, I already kind of knew or at least figured. And I'm honored actually. You've given up a lot to have me in your life and that means a lot to me and …." Before I could finish his lips met mine and were then traveling down my throat and over my clavicle. I let out a low moan before I could stop myself. Waiting Veronica waiting.

I used my hands and brought his face back to mine. "Casey, wait, hold on."

He was breathing hard and had a crazy lustful gaze in his eyes. "Yeah?"

I giggled a little and kissed him lightly. "It's your turn. And I pick truth too."

He smirked and fell back against the cushions bringing me with him as I fell against his chest. "Did you ever wonder what would have happened if my parents hadn't brainwashed me?"

I smiled and leaned back to look at him. Despite the time we'd been together and the nearly daily dates it was one of the only things we hadn't discussed. The fact that I'd always wondered and obviously so had he. "Yeah, all the time."

His smiled grew and his eyes lit up. "Really?"

I nodded. "Yes really, you were my 'what if.' The one that got away. I always wondered." He laughed a little and I caulked my head questioningly. "What's so funny?"

"Nothing. Well, it's just that Luke used to tell me that if you knew how I felt it might make all the difference, that for all I knew I was you're 'what if.' I shit you not, those were his exact words. "

I laughed out loud. "That's hilarious. When the fuck did he get so smart?"

Casey just shrugged and pulled me close. "I don't know. But it definitely keeps things interesting."

"That it does." His hand reached up to touch my cheek and I leaned into his touch.

"I'm happy we got our chance Veronica, that we know now what would have happened and that's it is in fact happening."

I smiled. "Me too Casey."

He leaned in to kiss me and before his lips met mine I yawned and he laughed. "Tired baby?"

I blushed and giggled a little. "Yes, apparently I am."

He promptly picked me up and carried me towards the stairs. "Well let's get you to bed then. We wouldn't want you to miss your beauty sleep."

"Hmmm and all this time I thought you were the beauty in this relationship."

He laughed and held me closer as we ascended the stairs. "I think we can argue that on both sides."

"You'll always be the pretty one to me."

"Right back at ya kid."


It felt good to have told her the truth but even better to know that she felt the same. Things were going better than I ever thought they could and I was gonna do everything I could to keep it that way.

But in all honesty that was the last thing I was thinking about as I carried her up the stairs. All that was on my mind was the fact that in only moments she'd be in my bed and that she was fucking adorable when she was tired.

When we got to my bedroom, I closed the door behind us, laid her on the bed and kissed her forehead. She smiled up at me as I pulled the covers over her and she pulled me in for a kiss, a nice long and slow one. Fuck, I really wasn't sure I was gonna make it through the night.

When the kiss ended I sat on the edge of the bed and grabbed her hand. "I'm gonna change. Do you need anything?"

She smiled and brought my hand to her lips. "Nope, just you. Hurry ok."

I nodded and stood up. "I'll be back before you know it."

With that I walked over to my dresser grabbed some pajama pants and retreated to my bathroom. The minute the door closed my hands were on the counter my head was down and I was trying like hell to just breathe.

Ok Casey, you can do this. Just be good.

Yeah, easier said than done. I had Veronica Mars in my bed, waiting for me, where I'd wanted her for years, and my self control was waning horrifically.

Once I finally got a grip on myself, I shed my clothes tossing them in the hamper and put on the pants. I didn't bother with a shirt, I usually didn't anyways but I figured that if I couldn't consummate our relationship, at least I could feel her skin against mine. I just hoped it would be enough to tide me over.

When I was done I left the bathroom, turned off the light and as I got to the bed I smiled. Veronica was curled up on her side under the covers and fast asleep. I laughed a little, it was probably a good thing, less temptation.

I stood there for a few minutes just watching her, enjoying the sight of her in my bed and my heart just pounded, god I loved her, so much.

When my voyeurism was hitting the point of inappropriate I finally crawled in behind her and pulled her to me. I threw one arm over her stomach resting my hand on her belly, spooning her from behind, she felt amazing in my arms. It was definitely the best moment for us yet.

I fell asleep quickly but was awoken a couple hours later when I felt her shift in my arms.

As she wiggled out of them, climbed of the bed and headed towards the bathroom, I sat up and called out to her. "Hurry back, I'm getting cold over here."

She turned and smiled. "Ok."

As soon as the door closed I sat up completely resting my back against the head board and my arms behind my head. When she came out of the bathroom a few minutes later her eyes went immediately to my torso. I swear I could feel her eyes burning into my abs and she blushed when she met my eyes realizing she was caught.

When she got back to the bed she crawled over to me and rested on her knees before leaning into kiss me. I brought my hand to the back of her head and deepened the kiss and before I knew it she was climbing into my lap and my hands were roaming over her ass,

Waiting Casey, waiting. "Fuck. Waiting Casey." I pulled back and she was already laughing at me.

"Am I being too tempting?"

I kissed her again and smiled. "You're always too tempting. " I moved my lips from hers and trailed them down over her jaw to her neck and bit her lightly.

She gasped in response and shifted in my lap. "You know Casey, just because we're waiting it doesn't mean we can't have fun."

She had a good point and believe me I'd thought about it more than once, or twice, fuck, I'd thought about it a few million times to be honest, but I was afraid if I started anything I wouldn't be willing to stop and I really wanted us to do this right. So I'd decided to wait for her to mention it which she just finally had. But instead of telling her all that I decided to play along. "Oh, and what are you suggesting?" I asked as I pulled her earlobe between my teeth and slid my hands over her perfect butt.

She moved into me and moaned as one of my hands founds its way under her top and a rogue finger slid under the band of her pants discovering the swell of her left butt cheek. "Well, there's lots of other stuff we can do."

I smirked against her skin and slid my whole hand inside her pants and under her panties until I had a palm full of Veronica's ass in my hand. "Hmmm, well I like the sound of that."

She shuddered as my other hand moved further under her top and cupped her left breast. Her response was soft and breathless. "Knew you would."

"So am I on the right track here Veronica?" I asked as I used both hands to lift her shirt up and off of her until she was topless in front of me. It wasn't the first time I'd seen her like this, we'd gotten that far the majority of the times we'd made out, but it was obvious that we would be furthering our knowledge of each other's bodies even more that night.

When my mouth found her right breast her arms flung around me and held me to her. "Oh god. Yes."

I smirked again, cupped her under her ass and lifted her off on me before lying on top of her on the bed. When I ground my erection against her covered center she rose up against me crushing her naked chest to mine and I let out a low moan.

God, I was so ready to feel her. So I captured her lips with mine and as one hand massaged her breast, the other found its way down her body and dipped inside her pants. She was so wet that I could feel it soaking through her panties, I swear it just made me harder and as I stroked her through the wet material, she panted and moaned and squirmed beneath my touch. "Casey?"

I pulled away from her lips and with a lust filled gaze my eyes met hers. "Yeah baby?"

As she answered I pressed my finger further into her through her panties and her words were more of a sigh. "Touch me. Please."

I smiled, swooped down taking her lips again and as my tongue explored her mouth; my left hand rolled her nipple between its fingers and my other hand made its way inside if her panties and I slid a finger over her wet slit.

She gasped again and rose off the bed as it trailed over her clit and I took a deep breath. She already felt amazing and I hadn't even ventured inside of her yet.

I moved off of her and laid on my side next to her, one leg over hers keeping her legs spread as my fingers moved over and between her silky folds and our lips stayed connected.

When I pulled my lips from hers I just stared at her flushed skin for awhile. Her chest heaving and sweaty, her lower half wiggling and trying to pull my fingers inside of her. It was a breathtaking sight. I was so immersed in her and her body that I didn't notice her hand moving until it was on my chest. She slid it down and I gasped as it found its way inside my pants and cupped my straining erection. Veronica Mars had her hand on my dick. Could life get any better?

When her hand moved under my boxer briefs and closed around my dick I took in a sharp breath. "Veronica." And finally let my finger slide home.

As I entered her with one finger she gasped and pulsed around my digit. God she was so tight, I'd never felt anything like it before. Even my finger was finding it hard to move and fuck I couldn't even imagine what it would feel like to actually be inside of her. But I reminded myself that it would be awhile before that happened we were doing this right and I didn't want to change that.

As my finger moved in and out of her, her hand continued fisting my cock and I knew I wasn't going to last long. So I added a second finger and smiled when her breath hitched and she mewled. "Casey, um oh god."

I leaned in for a kiss and then rested above her lips. "Just let go Veronica. I've got you baby, I've got you."

And she did. As her was walls contracted they held my fingers inside, her pace on me increased and before I knew it my vision whited out and she pulled me over the edge with her. I throbbed, spilling all over her hand as she came all over my still moving fingers. "Oh god Casey! Oh god." "Veronica! Ahh god!"

When our movements finally stilled I fell against her chest both of us breathing hard and I rested there for few moments before removing my fingers from her still pulsating center and raising my head to take in her appearance. Her hair was disheveled and her eyes were closed as she continued to steady her breathing. It was by far the most beautiful thing I'd ever seen and as soon as her eyes opened she rose up, her lips meeting mine.

We lost ourselves in sensual slow kisses for the longest time before her hand finally retreated from my bottoms and mine from hers completely. I could still smell her arousal and god if it didn't make me want her more, but I was happily sated and as she watched with lidded eyes I brought my fingers to my mouth and licked them clean. Fuck she tasted amazing and I looked forward to the first time I'd be able to bury my face between her legs. Her face reddened from my actions and I smiled before kissing her again with the taste of her on my tongue.

"Feel good baby?"

She nodded and smiled. "Amazing. You?"

I kissed her again hard. "You have no idea."

It was then that I realized her hand was still covered in well, me, so I kissed her one last time got up and walked towards the bathroom. She sat up the minute I left the bed and tilted her head. "And where do you think you're going?"

I turned and smiled. "Don't worry Veronica, you're gonna get a good long cuddle, but first we need to clean up."

And then as her eyes followed my movements I walked into the bathroom grabbed two hand towels and ran them both under warm water. When I returned to the bedroom I grabbed two pairs of boxers from my dresser, tossed one pair to her and dropped my pants and boxers right there in front of her. She raised an eyebrow appraisingly and I laughed as I walked back over to the bed. "Like what you see?"

She nodded and smirked. "Almost as much as I liked what I felt."

I leaned down and kissed her as I used the first towel to clean off her hand and then wiped myself down. When I handed her the second one I really expected her to get off the bed and go into the bathroom to change in to my clean boxers. But instead she grabbed my hand and smirked. "Be my guest."

I went to speak and totally choked on my words. "Rea…I mean really?"

"You showed me yours; it's only fair if I show you mine."

I did not need to be told twice so with unsteady hands I grasped the waistband of her pants and pulled them down her hips and off her legs taking her panties with them. And then there she was completely naked on my bed. I'd like to say I was a complete gentleman and cleaned her up quickly without leering, but leering definitely took place. I took my time taking in every contour of her perfect body and then brought the towel to the apex of her thighs cleaning her up gently and lovingly.

When I was done she pulled me in for a kiss and handed me the boxers. I hated to do It but I knew that if I didn't have at least something to deter me from her the waiting thing would be damned so I redressed her bottom half before stepping into the clean boxers I'd pulled out for myself.

When I finally lay back down she was in my arms immediately and when her still bare breasts grazed over my skin I got goose bumps. I was surprised she'd left her shirt off but I wasn't complaining.

She leaned up to kiss me once before resting her head on my chest, hand on my stomach and sliding a leg over mine so that half of her body was resting on me. And with one arm around her and the other resting on her hand, we both closed our eyes.

As I laid there in complete bliss I felt her giggle against my skin and couldn't help but laugh. "What's so funny?"

Without removing herself from the warmth of my body she kissed my chest and entwined our fingers. "I've never had so much fun at a sleep over."

I laughed out loud and kissed her temple. "No shit."

A little while later as I felt her breathing steady I ran my fingers through her hair and held her tight. "Goodnight Veronica."

Her response was quiet and sleepy but made me smile none the less. "Night Case."

And as I drifted off to sleep I couldn't push the smile from my face. She was mine there was no mistaking it anymore and soon, I'd have her completely. And god was I ever looking forward to it.


Thanks for reading! Review please!

It only takes a minute to show this fic some love, please review!