Dan started mounting Arin, who was on his knees upon the couch. He positioned his hard dick to Arin's butt hole, and caressed the man's cheek. Arin couldn't contain his excitement, and exclaimed his inner desires to the Jew. "I want you to plow me. Hard."
"I'm gonna give you five across the ass!"
Dan did so while simultaneously penetrating Arin's anus, plunging his enormous penis all the way into him until the mass of flesh could no longer be seen. Arin's anus pulsed from the pleasure and the pain; he was not expecting his first time to be so discomforting, however he was happy he connected with his loved one. Dan decided he gave Arin enough time to settle into the experience, and announced his intentions to the man. "I'm going to start moving, ok?"
Dan started plunging his dick in and out of Arin's ass, starting slow and picking up speed over time. Arin's dream had come true, quite literally. All that he could think about was the giant penis threatening to enter his intestines, especially since he could not ignore the pain. Dan was moving at a fast pace now, focusing only on how fast he can pump. Arin's cries of pleasure confirmed the adequacy of his fucking, and he continued at paces that made Arin moan the most. As time went on, Dan soon started reaching his limit, not lasting as long as he or Arin would expect. Despite his attempts to hold back, it was soon made apparent to Arin that Dan was on the brink of cumming, and Arin started thinking about how his own cum would be inside of his ass. Arin's own dick was incredibly erect, and he was about to cum as well. "Damn Arin, I can't hold it in anymore, your Anus is too tight." Dan's erection was pulsating intensely, and Arin could feel it.
"It's okay, go ahead and cum in my ass. We'll be even then."
The Jew pumped as hard as he could to release as much cum and possible, and with on final thrust he began releasing all of his semen from his balls. Arin found himself in mutual pleasure with Dan, and began cumming all over the couch. Dan's cum, which was also Arin's, began pouring through Arin's inner cavity, and threatened to follow through his intestines into his stomach. The two were screaming out in pleasure, and cum stained the couch permanently. After an intense and long session of orgasms, Dan and Arin slumped into each other, surrounded by sperm which was mostly Arin's. After a silence, the Grumps looked into each other's eyes. Then, Dan opened his mouth and said a single thing to Arin.
"Mycaruba"
The next day, Ross came into the Grump room early. He found himself deep in thought, pondering the large amount of indeterminable white stains on the couch.