Chapter 9: Wrong Place, Wrong Time

Kurt had it all planned out. He was gonna surprise Sebastian with a stay home birthday dinner that Friday and throw a party that Saturday. The rest of the family was out doing their own things. Even though Finn still acted strange and now his dad was starting to too.

Blaine had even opted to help out. They cooked and talked in the kitchen of the Hudmel household.

"This is gonna be perfect. He has no idea what we're planning. Everything set for tomorrow?" Kurt asked as plan sat the chicken on the table.

"Yeah, everything's ready. Everyone is all set and prepared." He smiled. Even though it pained him to see Kurt happy with someone else, he was just glad that he was happy. It's the best he could do for now.

"Good. Now I'll just call Sebastian and get this thing started." Kurt said as he picked up his phone. His smile started to slowly fade as he caught Sebastian's voicemail. He hung up and looked at his phone suspiciously.

"He didn't answer?" Blaine asked as he walked in the living room. Kurt decided to follow him.

"No and its strange." Kurt didn't want to jump to conclusions so he tried again. Same answer.

"I'm sure he's on his way over." Blaine said walked to the door.

"Um, I hope this isn't too much to ask, but could you stay with me?" Kurt asked. Blaine wasn't sure that was the best idea, but he smiled and took off his coat.

"Sure. So… about that new vogue?" And they continued for the next half hour in that discussion, with the occasional glance at the door to see of Sebastian was coming there.

"Where the hell is he?" Kurt thought to himself.

SESESESESESE

Earlier that day.

"Dude, I think has totally forgotten my birthday." Sebastian said as he sat on the hood of his car. Eli just looked at him.

"I highly doubt that. He seems like such an organizer that he'd never forget something this big." Sebastian had thought the same thing. But then he thought about the helmet looking thing in Kurt's closet.

"And I think he's keeping something from me." That made Eli's eyebrows shoot up.

"Really? What could he be keeping from you?" Eli smirked.

"I don't know. And I'm feeling down." Sebastian said. He normally never felt like this. Sure he had been quite possessive of Kurt lately. But it was all in the name of love right?

"I know what we should do. Let's throw you a party, tonight? It is your birthday after all." Eli smiled like a Cheshire cat.

"I-I don't know."

"Dude, Kurt forgot your birthday, you should have some fun. I'm sure he's having fun with that hobbit. Which by the way we still need to do something about."

"A party you say?" Seb quickly changed the subject.

"Yep, if I call right now, I'm sure Hunter can have everything set up." Eli said.

"Alright then it's on. But wait…"

"What now!" Eli groaned.

"What if Kurt calls?" Sebastian asked looking like a lost kid.

"Oh my G- dude, you are turning into a love-struck puppy. Enough of this! You are in charge. Kurt, well he's kind of the girl in the relationship. Man up, and show him that he doesn't get to push you around." Sebastian got off of his car and smiled.

"Text me when and where." Sebastian smiled. This was gonna be a good night.

Present time.

Sebastian didn't know what to feel. On one hand he felt like the king of the world, the next he felt guilty. He had had about four beers and was downing his fifth one when someone sat next to him.

"Hey, man haven't seen you since our morning blowjob." Parker said.

"Well, I've been busy. I have a boyfriend you know."

"Yeah, he must be a pretty cool guy to do this for you." Sebastian's smile faltered.

"Actually he didn't even remember. My friend planned the whole thing."

"Ouch, and is your boyfriend here?" Parker asked curiously. Sebastian shook his head no.

"Nope, and I'm having a great time, see?" Sebastian looked at Parker with a sarcastic grin.

"Well how about we change that?" Parker asked as he stood up.

"I can't."

"Why not, you let me give you a blowjob?"

"That was before I told Kurt that I wanted him only. Our relationship hasn't been very good lately." Sebastian said.

"Well if it's not going well, why can't we have fun?"

"Because I love him." Sebastian deadpanned.

"Well if he loved you wouldn't he be here right now?" Sebastian sighed. He couldn't do this. It would destroy Kurt. All of a sudden he felt his phone vibrate.

"He's texting me right now. Excuse me." Sebastian said and walked away. He looked down at his phone and groaned.

It was a picture of Kurt and Blaine at Kurt's house with dinner in the background.

'Seems like he's moving on. You might as well move on up those stairs and have a good time. You know Kurt sure is.'

J.

Sebastian was so hurt, that he ran through the crowd of people bumping into a surprised Eli as he went to find Parker.

"Hey." He said nervously.

"Hi?" Parker looked at him questioningly.

"That offer still on the table?"

"What about your boyfriend?"

"What boyfriend?" Sebastian smirked and grabbed Eli's hand and walked up to a secluded bedroom.

KBKBKBKB

Kurt sat on the couch looking miserable. Blaine had stayed and the watched movies and waited for Sebastian, but he never came.

"I don't understand. I've called him 10 times; I even texted him. What hell?" Kurt asked he put the dinner he had made away.

"I'm sorry Kurt; I know you wanted this to be special. Maybe he was upset." Blaine said.

"It doesn't matter. I'm tired of my boyfriends' not opening up to me!" He looked at Blaine as he said that. "I-I'm sorry. I didn't mean…"

"It's okay. Just remember I'm still here for you." Blaine said as he grabbed Kurt's hand.

Beep, Beep

"Maybe that's him." Kurt said as he grabbed his phone. "Oh no."

"What?" Blaine asked as he went over to Kurt and looked at his phone. "Oh crap, not our mystery tormentor."

"It says, 'You want to know where your boyfriend is? Come to this address. I can tell you one thing, it's gonna be a hell of a surprise. J'. What is that supposed to mean?" Kurt asked.

"I don't know, but isn't that the address to the Warblers new leader's house?" Kurt looked at Blaine in surprise. "I only know that because Nick and Jeff hang out there."

"I don't understand. I bet Eli's behind this." Kurt said as he threw his phone on the couch.

"Maybe Eli thought that you had forgotten his birthday and decided to throw one for Sebastian. It's what I would do for you." Blaine said. "Shall we go to a party?"

Kurt grabbed his coat and his keys. "Yes, yes we shall.

KBKBKBKBKB

Man was the party hectic. It seemed like everyone was there. The guys from Dalton Academy, some people from McKinley, and a lot of unknowns. Kurt and Blaine walked through the house and spotted Nick and Jeff on the couch making out.

"Wow, they sure know how to go at it don't they?" Kurt asked.

"Hey, it's a party; people do a lot of crazy stuff."

"Hey it's two of the New Directions." Hunter said as he stumbled towards them.

"Yeah, what the hell is going on here?" Kurt asked. Hunter looked around and gestured with his beer.

"It's a party for Sebastian. Yeah, his stupid, neglectful boyfriend forgot his birthday, so Eli set the whole thing up." Hunter said as he walked away. Kurt felt hurt. Did Sebastian really feel that way? He had to talk to him, now.

"Come let's go upstairs, I don't see him down here." Kurt said as they walked up stairs. There were a lot of rooms. They decided to check all of them. And they didn't like what they found either.

"Ugh, these people have no decency." Blaine said as he closed another door.

"Okay this is the last one." Kurt said. 'Please don't let him be in here.' Kurt thought to himself.

Once he opened the door, he immediately wished he hadn't. He felt instantly sick, but he couldn't look away. Blaine looked in to see what he was staring at.

There was a drunk Sebastian fucking into some random guy hard on the bed. They didn't really pay any attention to who was watching them. Sebastian just pounded harder into the guy.

Blaine slowly closed the door while Kurt walked away. He walked through the house and bumped into Eli who stared at Blaine in delight.

"Well, well, well look who came to the party. Hey, Kurt." Eli said to the boys.

"You know Eli I really don't have time for this." Kurt said and pushed past him. Blaine tried to follow, but Eli stood in the way.

"You don't have to leave. You remember that night. It could happen again." Eli smirked. Blaine looked scared. He didn't know what to feel in that moment.

"I have no idea what you're talking about." Blaine tried to get past Eli again but failed.

"You know what I'm talking about. That night was so beautiful. The way that tight little hole felt around my cock. Oh and the lovely screams you made. You can't tell me Kurt made you feel like that."

"I have to go."

"Give me a chance. You know Hummel is too much of a prude to accept you back after what we did. And might I remind you that it wasn't the first time I made you come, but the way you looked after that third orgasm. I saw fireworks and I know you did too."

"Look, what we did cost me my soul mate. So fuck off." Blaine said.

"Kurt has Sebastian now, and you are stuck in the friend zone. You might as well have some fun. 'Cause if Sebastian can help it, you'll never have Hummel again." Eli laughed.

"Oh really; why don't you go upstairs and see if that theory is still valid." Blaine was the one to smirk now and rushed off to find Kurt.

"What the hell did he mean by that?" Eli asked himself and walked upstairs to find Sebastian reaching his orgasm in someone else. "Oh Fuck!"

KBKBKB

"What was that about?" Kurt asked.

"Oh, just Eli being an ass." Blaine said as he decided to drive them to Kurt's house. Once they were there, Blaine decided to stay with Kurt that night.

They snuggled under the covers in Kurt's bed as he cried into Blaine's arms. Blaine felt bad for Kurt, but he also loved that he might be able to get him back.

SESESESESESE

Sebastian woke up and looked around to see that he wasn't in his room. He saw a body next to him. He smiled thinking that Kurt had come and gave him the best birthday ever. However, he was wrong.

"What the hell?" he said as he sat up.

"Dude, don't yell." Parker turned over and went back to sleep. Sebastian couldn't believe it. He had cheated. Oh, god. How was he gonna tell Kurt? He checked his phone to see a lot of voicemails, missed calls, and text. He checked his text to see one that made his stomach lurch.

It was from J. and it didn't look good. He opened it and sighed dejectedly.

'I got you a present and might I say it's priceless.' It was a picture of Kurt and Blaine watching Sebastian fuck Parker. 'I can be a friend sometimes and your worst enemy the next. HAPPY BIRTHDAY!'

J.

"Dude you are so fucked." Eli said as he watched Sebastian rush to the bathroom.

Next time on DLS: Sebastian's Surprise party takes place and it definitely isn't pretty. Sebastian and Kurt argue over his infidelity. Finn has a breakdown. Kurt's secret is revealed. And Blaine makes a move.

A/N: Ooh some major drama here. I hope you all like this chapter. Had it done in one day. Hope you check out the trailer for this story on Youtube. The link is on my profile. Ooh and spread the word about this up on tumblr. I don't have one yet, but might later on. Read and leave lots of Reviews. XOXO ShadowBeauty.