GREEN RIVER, UTAH

Oshea sighed as she stepped down the sidewalk, her arms crossed over her chest. Instead of her usual attire, which was more formal, she was clothed in a pair of white jogging shorts and a green hoodie that was only partially zipped up. Her hair was messy and tugged back into a ponytail and there were bags under her eyes from not sleeping well. They had arrived in the city only an hour before and after getting a hotel room and putting their suitcases inside, they had immediately gone out to interview victims' relatives and friends. She was supposed to be talking to the friends of the college girl, but instead she was just wandering about the small, empty park just outside of the college's campus.

He smirked a little as he moved away from the tree, walking towards her with his hands stuck in the pockets of his dark jeans. "Well someone doesn't look too happy to see me."

"You alone or did you bring your... pets?" She said quietly, shivering a little.

"We're alone," He said, now standing in front of her. "Besides, you and your sis blew up my pets, remember?"

"Oh... that's right," She said quietly, keeping her eyes down. "What do you want, Jonah? Are you going to rub it in my face that I'm to blame for... for causing the apocalypse?"

He shrugged. "Quite the opposite. You couldn't have known coming back from Heaven would start the end of the world, and even if you did, the angels did that, not you."

Oshea looked up at him, shocked by his answer. "Oh... well, thank you." She whispered, rubbing her arms.

"I wasn't finished. You aren't strong enough to face what's coming, none of you are, and you can't just run around putting a knife through each demon's throat. If you keep that up, pretty soon there isn't going to be any body else to stab."

"What do you suggest I do, Jonah?" She said quietly, spreading her arms out before letting them fall to her sides. She sighed. "I feel so lost... and numb... and I just... I don't know what to do..."

Jonah sighed. "Well the thing with any door, it can be closed. We just have to find the right one."

"Why, Jonah...? Why are you telling me this? Why are you trying to help after what you did? You killed my sister... and me. Is this another trap? Are you just using me?" Tears had gathered in her eyes and were spilling down her cheeks. "I don't think I could take that again, Jonah. I really don't..."

"Oh, Oshea," He sighed as he put both of his hands on her cheeks, wiping away a stray tear as he looked into her eyes. "Of course I am using you. You think I can do this myself? Whoever starts it, has to end it." He pulled away from her. "Now don't get me wrong, I enjoy a good apocalypse now and again, but the whole point of us demons' existence, is to make the human race as miserable as possible. That's all fun and games until we run out of people. If demons overrule this earth, there won't be anymore people except for the ones we ride around in. I don't know about you, but that doesn't sound all too great to me."

Oshea closed her eyes as he touched her cheeks and brushed her tears away. "At least you're being honest with me." She said softly, opening her eyes. "Fine. Just tell me what I need to do and I'll do it."

He grinned a bit as he turned away, starting to walk. "Follow me."

xx

Sam Winchester sat at the end of the bed, holding a box of Chinese takeout in his lap. "Well I wasn't able to find out anything at all from the guys I talked to." He said, taking a bite of his chicken. He had been the last one back from questioning people related to the victims except for Oshea, who still wasn't back yet. He had come into the hotel room, bearing a plastic bag with boxes of Chinese food for the rest of the group. "The cashier guy was extremely normal. Lived with a few friends in an apartment, worked full time at the Piggly Wiggly. Had a steady girlfriend. I checked out the apartment and there was nothing out of the ordinary there either. No hex bags, spell books, etcetera. There was a lot of blood, too, so we probably can rule out vampires. I don't think any of them would be that wasteful."

"Same with the secretary. She worked at a law firm, and the place was spotless. Nothing suspicious in her office, and everyone there seemed to be head over heels in like with her. So if there's any pissed off co-workers out there, they seem to be hiding it very well," Ella said with a shrug as she took a bite of rice from the takeout container.

Sam looked over to Dean, swallowing a bite of his Chinese food. "Did you find out anything? And where is Oshea?"

Dean shook his head. "Nada. Looks like miss law firm secretary is as likeable in her home life as in her work life."

Ella frowned a bit as she held the food container with one hand and flipped open her cell phone with the other. "She should be back by now..." She pressed down the 2 button, which was Oshea's speed dial, and waited as it rang a couple times and then went to voicemail. "Odd," She said flipping it closed and letting it drop back on the mattress.

"Do you think we should go look for her?" Sam asked with a frown as he watched Ella drop her phone onto the mattress.

"I'm sure she's fine... but if she's not back by the time we finish eating we should go check out the campus," Dean said with a nod.

xx

When they all had finished eating, Sam volunteered to go to the college campus to check out the victim's roommate while Dean went to the girl's family and Ella stayed at the hotel to do more research and to be there in case Oshea came home. Sam moved through the campus, remembering the time he had spent in college with a hint of sadness. He jogged up the stairs in the dorm building and knocked on the door of the dorm that the victim had lived in.

A petite redhead answered the door a few moments later, dressed in a snug fitting black v-neck top and a pair of skin tight blue jeans. "...Yes?" She said, arching a brow at the tall unfamiliar man standing at her doorway.

"Hey, I'm sorry to bother you. My name's Ethan. Patty and I were really close, and... well after her death I remembered that we had taken a bunch of pictures together while we were hanging out and I was hoping maybe... I don't know, maybe that I could come in and get them?" He said softly, shuffling his feet and trying to act sad.

"Oh, of course, come in," She said, smiling a little sadly as she stepped back to give him room to walk through the doorway. "She's never mentioned an Ethan to me before, then again Patty and I haven't known each other very long."

"We haven't been friends for long, maybe a year or so." Sam said with a nod as he stepped into the room and looked around. "We met during the summer at the beach while her family was on vacation. There was an instant connection. I was hoping to ask her out one day, but never got up the courage... now I guess I never will." He said, pulling out a flash drive from his pocket. "I think they're on her computer. Do you know where it is?"

She nodded, pointing over to the left side of the room to a still slightly cluttered desk. "I haven't gotten a chance to get her things out of here... she and her parents quit speaking not long before she died, quit having anything to do with her, and they won't return my calls." She stepped over to the white Macbook and pulled it open, turning it on and after waiting a moment, she tapped at the keys a few times when the log in screen came up, and then stepped aside. "There you go."

Sam nodded, offering her a little smile. "Thanks. This means a lot to me." He sat down at the computer desk and looking through the files on the computer. When he couldn't find anything, he opened the internet. The college's website appeared on the screen as her homepage. After a few clicks, Sam got to the student email accounts. He clicked on Patty's name and a screen appeared asking for a password. Sam drummed his fingers against the edge of the keyboard a moment before clicking the password hint. The hottest man alive. Sam blinked and typed in the usual suspects: Johnny Depp, Heath Ledger, George Clooney... Rob Pattinson. When none of them worked, he remembered the pictures of actors he had seen among Patty's files and tried one more. Jared Padalecki. He wrinkled his nose a little and rolled his eyes as the account opened for him. After flicking through the normal emails about school and social life, he found one email that stood out to him. Hi, I am Teddy. Once you read this you cannot get out... He saved the email onto the flash drive then logged out and closed the windows he had opened before turning back to Patty's roommate. "I think I got everything I need. Thanks again."

"No problem, Ethan," She smiled a little as she watched him leave the room.

x

x

A/N: I don't know if I mentioned it in any previous chapters where Jonah was mentioned, but when we wrote him, we pictured Ian Somerhalder from Vampire Diaries. I actually made a Jonah/Dean/Oshea fanfic video that used clips from Supernatural, Vamp Diaries, and clips of Alicia Witt, who we most recently chose was best to portray Oshea. But of course YT with their stupid copyright stuff muted the audio. Oh well. And also in case I haven't mentioned it before, the first version of the angel Joel, the "Jo Bro" version, we pictured him as Logan Lerman, and the new version of Joel is now played by Joseph Gordon Levitt. Jael was based on the looks of Zooey Deschanel, and Ezra was based on Crispin Glover. I think that's about everybody. So when you read, those actors are the ones we suggest you picture those characters as, because thats how we pictured them when we came up with them :)