Like Ships In The Night

Chapter 8: The Choice

I knew you were trouble when you walked in

So shame on me now

Flew me to places I've never been

Til you put me down

Taylor Swift

A/N: wow! It has been a LONG TIME since I have updated this story. I didn't want to leave any of you beautiful people hanging! So HERE IS CHAPTER 8 AHHHH

SHOUTOUT: goes to Kay! Your review made me smile, and yes, your timing was impeccable!

PLEASE REVIEW, PLEASE?!

Disclaimer: I want Grant Gustin, but he belongs to Ryan Murphy. So does Glee :(

It had been weeks since the infamous night at Scandals. Kurt and Sebastian had both completely ignored Blaine's attempts at apologizing, including texts, calls, chocolates, and flowers. He was completely lost and alone. On one hand, he still loved Kurt and felt terribly guilty for lying to him and humiliating him. The other part of him was screaming for Sebastian, the connection they shared. He knew he had to get them back, but that only one could really be in his life. Blaine knew he had to make a choice. His first love and best friend or the first man in his whole life who had made him feel completely and totally alive? As he was sitting alone in his house, he felt his phone buzz in his pocket.

So, you lost both of them

Blaine had no idea who the text was from, who else knew about his chaotic mess with Kurt and Sebastian? He started to text the mystery person back, but a new message interrupted him.

Meet me at the Lima Bean in 15 minutes. It's for your own good.

When Blaine arrived at the Lima Bean, he sat down with his Caramel Macchiato and waited for his mystery texter to show up. "I tried to warn you, Blaine". Blaine's face dropped as he shook his head.

"Dave, you're the one you texted me?"

"It would seem so," Dave said with a somber look on his face. He rested his varsity jacket on the back of his chair as he sat down across from a skeptical Blaine.

"What did you mean just then? You tried to warn me about what?" Blaine asked as he folded his arms against his chest. Dave sighed as he stared back at Blaine,

"About Sebastian. I told you that he would only use you for his own purposes, and that's EXACTLY what he did."

"How do you know what he's like Dave? You don't even know him!" Blaine was defensive now, he didn't like a relative stranger coming into his already fucked up life only to say I told you so.

"Because he did the same thing to me," Dave shot back aggressively. "We met at Scandal's one night, went back to his gorgeous palace and he fucked me. Hell, I thought he actually gave a damn about me. The guy took my virginity and broke my heart all in the same night. I woke up the next morning and he was gone. The next time I saw him at Scandal's, he was grinding on some other guy and just smirked at me." Blaine was shocked by Dave's confession.

"I. . . I don't know what to say," Blaine could barely get the words out. Dave's face was still frustrated.

"Sebastian Smythe is an asshole," Dave said, the words seemed to roll of his tongue. "And it seems to me like you were falling head over heels for the bastard too. For fuck's sake Blaine, how could you cheat on Kurt for that guy? How could you humiliate him like that?" Blaine ignored Dave's strangely jealous tone and asked him what he had been wondering the whole conversation.

"Were you there that night at Scandal's? How do you know about that night?" For the first time during their chat, Dave fell silent. "Dave?"

"Kurt told me," Dave said regaining his confidence. "I've been taking care of him these past couple of weeks." A thousand thoughts ran through Blaine's mind. Even though he and Kurt had essentially broken up, he was still furious at the thought of Kurt with someone else. Especially after Kurt had judged Sebastian so harshly.

"Thank you Dave," Blaine said coldly as he stood up quickly as he put his jacket on. Dave watched Blaine leave worried about what the ex-warbler would do.

Kurt Hummel was almost asleep when he heard a car pull up outside his house. He was startled when someone rang his front doorbell, and proceeded to knock almost to the point of knocking the door off its hinges. He ran to door and flung it open as his ex-boyfriend stumbled his way through the threshold. "Blaine what are you doing here? It's one in the morning!" Kurt could smell the whiskey dripping from Blaine's breathe. "Have you been drinking?"

"Why dontchu tell me about your new lovah boy hmmmm?" Blaine's slurred speech made it almost impossible for Kurt to understand what he was saying.

"What are you talking about Blaine?" Kurt asked, trying to hold the other boy up.

"Imma talkin bout DAVE," Blaine was getting angry now, Kurt could sense it. "Heee told me that he protecks you now."

"Dave has just been a good friend to me Blaine, and nothing more than that. If you think you can use my friendship with Dave to justify your disgusting relationship with that whore, Sebastian, you're delusional!" Blaine's fists began to tighten as his anger built up.

"DON'T TALK ABOUT SEBASTIAN THAT WAY!" Blaine shouted so loudly that his voice echoed through the quiet house. "You're calling him a whore? Look in the mirror sometime Kurt. You're desperate enough to fuck the guy who bullied you! You're fucking pathetic!" Kurt slapped Blaine across the face as the world around Blaine stopped spinning.

"Get the hell out of my house!" Kurt used all the strength he had to shove Blaine out the door he came in and slammed it shut. Tears were streaming down his face, he was tired of crying over Blaine.

Sebastian Smythe was a bit self destructive. After what had happened with Blaine, he had gone on a bender for a couple of days. . . maybe a week. He had gone to Scandal's every night trying to get the thought of that curly haired prick out of his head. He'd gone through all his usual hookups and all of them were as meaningless as he felt. His feelings for Blaine were as real as he thought, and the thought of that made him nauseous. Sebastian had started to succumb to the weakness of falling in love, which he swore an oath against for this reason: heartbreak. He hadn't experienced it in years and he hated it more than anything else. Everyone at Dalton knew him as the gorgeous, athletic, promiscuous rich kid who did what he wanted, and who he wanted. He knew he had to get Blaine Anderson out of his system for good. Clearing his body of the aches and pains of wanting somebody. As Sebastian was plotting, he heard a sound at the door. This is going to be too easy.

Sorry for the cliffhanger lovelies ;) So what is Seb's new evil plan? Are Kurt and Blaine completely over? I don't know about you, but I actually LIKED Kurt in this chapter. DID YOU LIKE IT? DID YOU HATE IT? Let me know in the reviews! The more reviews I get the faster I update (wink wink). Love you babes .XXX