He bought her Doc Martens for Christmas. She had seen them on display when she went shopping with Quinn and fell in love with them. Rachel had told Finn about them once, and how even though they weren't really her style she loved them, but they were too much money. He had frowned and said that maybe she'll get enough Christmas money to get them and Rachel agreed. But when she went to his house two days after Christmas, a box with her boots sat on the couch and she smiled and tackled him. He had only gotten Quinn a nice shirt from American Eagle, something that Rachel had suggested. They had became friends again, Finn and Quinn and since they were Rachel made sure that Finn got her something. (He rolled her eyes when she had told him that, and took him shopping and picked it out herself. She was just lucky that Quinn had pointed it our earlier that afternoon). And the look on Quinn's face when Quinn realized Finn had spent more than double the amount on Rachel's present, well that made Rachel feel really good.