Casey was a bit taken aback by her wife's order. Once her brain came out of shock, though, she did as she was told. She parted her legs ever so slowly, wishing desperately that she could see the look in Olivia's eyes. That dream, however, was rendered impossible by the blindfold. Lost in her own thoughts, Casey yelped in surprise when Olivia yanked on her hair. "Pay attention," Olivia ordered quietly.
"How can I pay attention when I can't see?" Casey asked, feeling rather defiant at the moment. "Is that not like saying jump to someone with no legs?" She immediately regretted her outburst when Olivia bit hard into her breast and then sucked on the nipple to dissolve the pain.
"Talk again, and I will gag you. Understood?" When Casey didn't answer, Olivia sighed deeply. "That question you can answer."
Casey sighed. "Yes, it's understood," she mumbled, laying her head back against the towel and allowing her body to relax. She was going insane from the anticipation of what Olivia had in store for the evening, and she hated that she would have to wait. However, she also knew that she would not regret it.
"Good," Olivia responded, and Casey had a sneaking suspicion that her wife was wearing a trademark Benson smirk. The older woman brushed her fingertips lightly up and down Casey's body, until goosebumps rose and Casey shivered in anticipation beneath her. Olivia leaned down and kissed her passionately, forcing her tongue into Casey's mouth and down her throat, making Casey whimper in pleasure. Olivia bit her ever so gently and deepened the kiss. Just when Casey was beginning to lose herself in the kiss, Olivia pulled back and said "Someone gets worked up quickly". She chuckled at the fact that Casey chose that moment to stick her tongue out at her. "Watch where you are sticking that tongue," Olivia murmured, tracing her fingertips in gentle circles across Casey's torso, taking her time when she reached the redhead's breasts, which were already perky, illuminating her arousal.
Olivia placed her hands on Casey's stomach and gently took her right breast into her mouth. She began to suck on it, using her tongue to flick against Casey's nipple. She growled quietly as her wife moaned and squirmed beneath her. Suddenly, she switched her attention to Casey's other breast, and repeated everything she had just done.
Meanwhile, Casey felt like she was losing her mind. Her body had already tensed up. She squirmed and whimpered from her position underneath Olivia. As if reading her mind, Olivia, still switching back and forth from one breast to the other, slowly penetrated her with two fingers. Casey moaned loudly, biting her tongue so she wouldn't accidentally cry out.
Without warning, Olivia bit down hard on each nipple, and pulled back as Casey clawed her. "Are you trying to bait me?" she asked. Without giving Casey a chance to answer, she added "Don't say I didn't warn you." After kissing Casey once more on the lips, the brunette gently positioned herself between her wife's legs and held them apart. She began to gently suck on Casey's clit, which was already hard and swollen. Olivia growled as her tongue circled the young attorney's most sensitive spot, which, to Casey, felt like a vibration against her. As she lapped at the redhead's clit, Olivia once more inserted two fingers into her, moving them in and out ever so slowly. With her free hand, she massaged Casey's breasts, the nipples hardening painfully.
Casey was trying her hardest not to scream, but the closer she got to her orgasm, the harder remaining quiet became. Olivia's tongue began to alternate its method of assault on her clit. She switched quickly between sucking, licking, and biting, in addition to adding a third finger inside her. Casey could feel her body tightening. Her brain turned to mush and her heart felt as if it were going to burst out of her chest, as fast as it was beating. Her swollen clit was rock hard, and she was already extremely wet.
She completely lost it when Olivia bit down a final time. She began to moan Olivia's name loudly and repeatedly, in addition to a string of words she normally didn't use in her every day life. When Olivia bit down on her clit, Casey's orgasm torpedoed through her body. She arched off of the towel as she came in Olivia's mouth. The orgasm lasted for several moments. Finally, she collapsed against the towel as Olivia slowly withdrew her fingers and swallowed. "I love you, baby," Olivia whispered as she kissed Casey on the cheek.
"I love you too," Casey murmured back with a soft smile.
Olivia untied the blindfold and handed the younger woman a bottle of soda. She opened one of her own and took a rather large sip. "You're so beautiful, sweetheart," she said, laying down next to Casey and taking Casey's right hand. Smiling, she intertwined their fingers and squeezed gently. "Are you ready to go up to the hotel?"
Casey nodded slowly. "Yes, I'm ready." She carefully stood up, feeling dizzy at first. Once she regained her balance, she got dressed and helped Olivia pack up the food and blankets. Hand in hand, they made their way back to their hotel room. When they got there fifteen minutes later, Olivia put the food away in the refrigerator that had come with the room and instructed Casey to lay on her back and close her eyes.
Casey did as she was told, wondering what would happen now. She laid completely still, attempting to listen to figure out what Olivia was getting from the bathroom, but the older woman was being so quiet that, had a pin fallen, it would have been heard. "Keep your eyes closed," came Olivia's voice several minutes later.
Quickly, she cuffed Casey's hands and said "Open."
"What-" Casey pause as her eyes flew open and were greeted by the sight of what else Olivia had retrieved from the bathroom. The toy that Casey loved so much was already locked into place around her wife's hips.