Delectable Sweetness: Aww, thank you. Stacey: Uh oh I think I must have forgotten that little conversation detail when switching between this story and the This Is The Year timeline. I'm really sorry. litafan82: yay! It's AO time now! :) maxin: I'm glad you like the story! She may have lost it to Jenny, but she will soon have her Alex. :)
A/N: For those of you who have read This Is The Year, you'll probably recognize some of this chapter as part of their Valentine's Day during their senior year of high school. I hate copying and pasting things from my other stories so I promise this is the only time I'll do that. Oh, and our girls are eighteen now. How time flies. It seems like just yesterday they were little preschool girls. By the way, this chapter isn't rated K or T. In fact, it's kind of on the M side, so proceed with caution.
February 14, 1992
The now eighteen-year-old Alex and Olivia had been a couple for a little over a month and they were already experiencing their fair share of relationship problems. Neither had wanted to break the hearts of the girls they were with, but they could no longer deny their feelings for each other. They were falling deeper in love as time went on and it wasn't fair to their girlfriends or to themselves, so they admitted their feelings to each other on New Year's Eve. They had spent thirteen years as friends and they knew there was going to be an adjustment period as they went from hanging out and playing video games with each other to kissing and making love to each other.
Alex and Olivia felt as if their first time together was life-altering. Alex had lost her virginity to Casey three months prior to her first time with Olivia, but she considered her first time with Olivia to be one of the best experiences of her life and she wasn't shy about letting Olivia know that. Before Alex, Olivia never knew sex could be beautiful and passionate and so full of love. What mattered most to Olivia is getting to actually feel Alex and see her at her most beautiful, which is why on their first Valentine's Day as a couple, Olivia felt as if there was nothing else she would rather do.
They had just made up from an argument and, luckily, her mom was on a date so they had the house to themselves. Even though it wasn't her first time having sex with Alex, Olivia was extremely nervous about this Valentine's Day with Alex. Ever since she had learned what two girls could do to each other in bed, Olivia had been fantasizing about doing those very things to Alex. She had always wanted to make Alex feel sexy and that's exactly what she had in mind for their Valentine's Day together.
Olivia closed her bedroom door and watched as Alex undressed herself.
"Leave your glasses on," she told her. "They're sexy."
"I don't want you leaving anything on," Alex said as she started undressing Olivia.
Olivia laid down with Alex and started to kiss her. Alex slightly opened her mouth so Olivia could slide her tongue inside. Olivia tried to forget about everything that had happened with their argument while she began to gently rub Alex's clit.
Alex straddled Olivia's waist and Olivia couldn't help but take in the view. Alex was completely naked and reacting to every move of Olivia's fingers. Olivia became even more aroused as Alex started caressing her own breasts. She started moving her hands down her body and made sure that Olivia's gaze was wherever her hands were leading.
"I'm ready," Alex whispered and Olivia slowly entered her. Even though Olivia was gentle, Alex needed time to adjust to being so filled. Olivia and Alex looked at each other for reassurance and Olivia mouthed the words 'I love you' to her. When Alex mouthed the words 'I love you more' Olivia couldn't help but smile.
Alex gave Olivia a quick kiss and slowly started to ride her fingers. Olivia's hand was starting to hurt, but there was no way she was going to stop once she saw how Alex was so rhythmically moving her body and starting to toss her head back. Olivia looked down and noticed that Alex's wetness was coating her hand. She knew it wouldn't be long before Alex reached her breaking point.
With a few strokes of her thumb on Alex's clit, Olivia started to feel Alex's walls tighten around her fingers. Knowing they were home alone, Olivia urged her not to hold back, so Alex started moaning Olivia's name as loudly as she could. Hearing Alex moan turned Olivia on even more.
"Are you wet for me?" Alex asked as she started running her fingers along Olivia's opening.
"Only for you," Olivia told her.
Olivia was gripping the sheets as Alex started to taste her. Alex knew the one movement that always brought Olivia to orgasm, but she wasn't ready for that yet. Tonight she wanted to take her time with Olivia. She slowly maneuvered her tongue along the outside of Olivia's opening and up to her clit. When she reached Olivia's swollen clit, she gently started to run her tongue across it. Olivia felt so many sensations as Alex began entering her with her tongue. Alex was being gentle with her and paying attention to the way her body responded to every lick and every caress. Olivia started to moan as Alex gently sucked on her clit.
"Right there, baby," Olivia told her as she started running her fingers through Alex's hair.
Olivia felt her body quiver as Alex continued sucking on her clit. She knew
Alex wanted her to hold back as long as she could, but Olivia couldn't hold back any longer. She began gripping the sheets as hard as she could while riding out her orgasm. She knew her girlfriend was climaxing, but Alex didn't want to stop tasting Olivia. She felt herself become aroused again when Olivia's wetness started flowing into her mouth. Alex swallowed as much of it as she could before finally making her way back to the pillow.
Olivia started smiling as she wiped her wetness from the sides of Alex's mouth and her chin. "You were amazing," she told her.
"So were you," Alex said and started to kiss Olivia. "Do you want to exchange Valentine's gifts now?"
"I thought we already did," Olivia teased. "Besides, I'm giving you the greatest gift you could ever ask for."
"Oh, and what is that?" Alex asked, mimicking Olivia's tone.
"Me," Olivia said and Alex couldn't help but smile.
"What am I going to do with you, Olivia?"
"Do you want the G-rated answer or the X-rated answer?" Olivia asked.
"Let's stick with G for right now," Alex insisted. "I'm a little X-rated out."
"Fine," Olivia sighed. "I do have a gift for you, though."
"What is it?" Alex asked. "Babe, tell me."
"It's in the living room. Wait right here."
"Liv?"
"What's up?"
"I will never get tired of seeing you naked. When we have a place together, I never want you to wear clothes."
"What about when it's cold?"
"There are plenty of things I can do to warm your body up," Alex said and pulled her girlfriend back on the bed with her.
"But your gift?" Olivia asked in between kisses.
"It can wait," Alex insisted. "This is the first Valentine's Day that I get to make love to you. There's no gift in the whole world better than that."
"Alex?"
"Yeah?"
"I've been waiting for this moment since I was five-years-old."
Alex rested her head on Olivia's thighs and started to run her fingertips along the wet patch of dark curls in between Olivia's legs. "Babe, you didn't know what sex was when you were five."
"I know," Olivia responded. "It wasn't sex that I was waiting for. I love having sex with you. I really love it and when I say I love it I mean I really really love it."
"Babe," Alex said and let out a giggle that only Olivia had ever heard before. "I get what you're trying to say. I love it, too."
"Like I was saying before I was so rudely interrupted," Olivia teased, which made Alex let out that same giggle again. "Like I was saying, I wasn't waiting to have sex. I was waiting for the moment when you would become my girlfriend. I feel like that's all I've ever wanted and now that I have you I'm never going to let you go."
"You never have to, Liv," Alex said softly. "I've always been yours and I'm always going to be yours."
