Author's Note: So, this is a pretty little chapter. Sorry! But comparatively it covers a lot. Thanks to everyone who reviewed for the first chapter: ValzBrownie, Sophbells, Endor Solo, and Ashy143 (correct me if I'm wrong, but is this your first time reviewing my stories? If so, awesome! Thanks for doing it:))! All of you guys are awesome, and I appreciate how much support you've given me in writing these HSM stories! Enjoy chapter 2!

"Wait, you bought your Mom a dog for Christmas, and then it ate her favorite necklace?" I laughed.

"Yeah. See, that's my luck with Christmas presents. They never work out the way I want them to." Warren chuckled as I wiped at my eyes. "I'm glad to see my awkwardness is still amusing you."

"Well, these stories you're telling are hilarious!" I stared at him. "Are you sure these are all true?"

"Sadly, yes." Warren gestured to my now empty smoothie cup. "You want me to get that for you?"

"Sure, thanks." I smiled as he took it from me and walked over to the nearest trash can, dropping it in. So far it had been a really relaxed and fun first date. We had wandered around the mall, looking at the Christmas decorations and displays and eventually climbing into the photo booth to take pictures. I pulled them out of my purse and chuckled. Warren was really cute. There was no denying that. He had short brown hair and green eyes and he was sweet, kind, and funny. I sighed. Why am I still missing Nate then?

"You okay?" Warren walked back up to me. "Are you finally ready to admit you've been faking having a good time this whole day and really want to run home and awkwardly ignore my text messages?"

I laughed. "No, no, no. Nothing like that. I've had a great day. Really."

Warren quirked an eyebrow. "So, what's the problem?"

I sighed again. "Nothing. Really."

"Sounds like it." Warren motioned me to a couch near by. "Seriously, what's up?"

I bit my lip as I sat down. "Well, say I had this friend."

"Uh oh." Warren laughed as I shot him a look. "Sorry. Continue."

"Well this friend of mine... she was best friends with a boy. And he was a great guy and all. And anyway... they fell in love. I guess. Maybe. Whatever, that isn't the point. The point is, they got together. And then a year later... they broke up." I paused, and glanced at him, trying to gauge his reaction, but I couldn't read anything into his expression. "After they broke up, the girl really tried. Tried to forget. Tried to move on. But, she couldn't. And I mean, she really couldn't. She tried and tried. But it was hard because she still wanted him to be her best friend. She wanted that more than anything. But they can't be friends anymore because.. because they broke up. And she hates it." I turned towards him again. "She really does. So when she sighs on dates, sometimes the guys she's out with, they think she isn't having fun. And she is. But she just keeps remembering this other guy. Because they were best friends and he was a huge part of her. And now he's gone." I looked into his eyes, willing him to understand. "Do you get it?"

He nodded. "Yeah. It actually kind of reminds me of a song." He smiled and sang quietly.

It takes a minute,

For it all to sink in,
That this is what I wanted,
That this is where it ends,
Too many second guesses,
And awkward questions,
Yet here we stand,

We're past the mountain,
That stood between us,
But now we're standing in an empty room,
I thought I'd be happy to be here,
But where do we go now,

Did I really know the right thing to do?

I stared at him. "Woah. You have a really nice voice."
He grinned. "Thanks."

"No, its like, really nice. But really, a Luke Murray song?" I rolled my eyes.

Warren chuckled. "You don't like Luke Murray?"

"Eh, he's okay. I guess you could say musically I admire him, but I definitely think he's overrated. I don't listen to much of his stuff."

"Oh, you think he's overrated huh?" Warren looked like he was about to burst out laughing.

"Uh, yeah. What's so funny?" I raised an eyebrow at him.

"Nothing. Have you ever seen a picture of Luke Murray?"

"Well, yeah, girls are constantly fawning all over him. But I guess I don't think much of his rock star image. But come to think of it... you kind of look like him." I looked at Warren, then blinked and looked again. "Come to think of it, you look a lot like him."

Warren grinned "Welllll..."

Suddenly I gasped. "Oh my gosh... Warren, what's your last name?"

He laughed. "Murray."

I stared at him, feeling like someone had just thrown a bucket of cold water on me. "But I-I don't understand. Are you his twin brother or something? Tell me you're his twin brother..."

"Nope." He hid a smile as I paled. "My full name is Warren Lucas Murray. As in, Luke Murray."

"Oh... crap." I said faintly. "But you're so-so real!"

Warren laughed again. "Yep, unfortunately, I'm as real as real can be. Real faults. Real quirks. Real ovverated-ness." I blushed.

"But, what are you doing in Albequerque?" I asked, trying to adjust to the fact that I had been with a celebrity for the past three hours.

"I was born in Albequerque. Derek and I were on the same soccer team growing up. When I was thriteen I moved to Los Angeles to pursue my career in music. Derek and I kept in touch. I'm spending the holiday's with my family here in town. I really was at Derek's house using his computer when I saw you were online. And my name really is Warren. It's not like I've been lying to you this whole time or anything." Warren suddenly looked concerned. "Are you mad?"

"Mad! Mad? Uh, shocked, confused, startled, embarrassed, and completely dumbstruck would all describe me right now. But mad? No."

Warren smiled. "Good. Because I don't want this to change your opinion of me."

I glanced at him. "Seriously? You just told me you're an award-winning artist and you want me to treat you the same."

"Preferably." He took my hand, his face suddenly serious. "I know this sounds cheesy and dumb, but Ella, you're the first normal person to treat me like a normal person in a long, long time. Honestly, I can't thank you enough."

"You're welcome." I looked at him, remembering his funny stories and dorky jokes. "Okay... I think I'm cool with this then."

"Awesome." Warren stood up. "And by the way, I understand about your "friend". Tell her I wish her the best of luck with her ex and that the guys she goes out with should learn to be more patient." He winked at me.
"I will. Thanks." I hugged him. "Wait a second. You're famous. How are dozens of girls not mauling you right now?"

He laughed. "It's my home town. Everyone in this part of it knows me. No girl has a crush on me. Well at least not cause I'm famous. Possibly because of my rakish good looks, my stunning sense of humor and my amazing pick up lines." He wiggled his eyebrows.

I rolled my eyes. "Famous or not, you're still a dork."

"A cute one?" He grinned.

I laughed. "Maybe. Let's keep walking now before you start serenading me again."

"Okay." As we turned to walk in the other direction I felt a happy smile form on my face. Oh my gosh. I'm on a date with Luke Murray right now. Didn't see that one coming. I glanced at him again. But more importantly, I'm on a date with Warren.

Suddenly Warren grabbed my arm and pointed. "Look! Misteltoe!"

I looked over to where he was pointing and felt myself freeze. A sprig of misteltoe was hanging from an arched doorway. But that wasn't what made me stop short. Underneath the misteltoe stood Michelle. And she was kissing Nate

What did you think? Hope you really liked it! I know this chapter was very Warren and Ella based but don't worry the Christmas stuff will be coming soon and more HSM characters. :) And maybe some Natella? I don't know, I'm starting to like Warren too much I think! But don't worry, I'm pretty sure Natella is meant to be! What do you think? Leave me your opinion in a review! Haha by the way if you're wondering if the character of Warren (specifically his famous side Luke Murray) was partially inspired by all the Justin Bieber hype, you would be right. Sorry to his fans out there, I don't have Bieber fever, but its like Ella said: Musically he's fine, but I just think he's overrated. I don't listen to much of his music. Anyway, please review if you liked it and let me know what you think! Thanks for reading!