Synchronized Melodies
Arrangements: Season 2 Episode 15 Sexy
"Why are we going to Rachel's house, you aren't still questioning your sexuality or anything are you?" Kurt asked him suspiciously as Blaine led him up the porch steps. Blaine laughed at that and assured the soprano in the negative as he opened the front door.
"You can't just walk into some else's home!" Kurt hissed at him. Blain sighed before peeling off one layer of the lie that he and Rachel had unintentionaly erected.
"This is my home, as well." Kurt's face didn't seen to register what Blaine had said.
"What!" was this a joke or something? What: are they married and living together now? He would have laughed were it not completely unfunny.
"Rae!" Blaine called upstairs, not answering the boy next to him, who was shocked- he hadn't heard anyone shorted Rachel's name for a nickname- not even his step-brother.
"What're you- Oh hi Kurt," Rachel hadn't seemed to be surprised at Blaine being there-only Kurt. She was completely dressed down, Kurt noticed- in yoga pants and a shirt that seemed to be to big for her- obviously someone elses's. While Kurt had been scrutinizing her outfit the siblings had been having a silent coversastion in which Blaine told his sister that he didn't want to lie to Kurt anymore and that it was time to come clean. Rachel agreed but gave him a look that he would have to explain his change of heart later.
"Kurt, why don't we move this to the kitched- my cookies should be almost done," maybe cookies would help this coversation. She led the two Warblers into the kitchen just as the timer went off. She removed the last batch from the oven before Kurt spoke up.
"Okay, what's going on here? Blaine said something about this being his house as well?" he looked confusedly between the two.
"We've been keeping something from New Directions, including you," Rachel started.
"It was unintentional at first because we never knew if we'd have to meet in competition, so what was the point!"
"But then the whole Jesse and Shelby thing happened and by the time we found out we would compete many of our fellow glee clubbers would have seen it as me (once again) fraternizing with the enemy."
"And Rachel's stock was low enough in glee club as it is- I didn't want her to be treated worse-"
"I know you and Blaine are close and you and I havee become closer and we're so sorry we kept it from you, but we-"
"What is it?- Just spit it out: what have you been keeping from me?"
"Blaine's my brother."
"-And Rachel's my sister," Blaine added unneccessarily.
"We're twins, to be exact," Rachel clarifyed.
"Shelby's the surrogate to us both," Blaine blurted out. He was nervous because Kurt's face hadn't changed. Rachel sensed Blaine's anxiety and spoke up.
"Kurt, we're really sorry but can you please say something?" Kurt seemed to wake out of a daze, opening and closing his mouth before speaking.
"So you two... Are related, siblings?" He asked both Andersons' nodded. He supposed he should have guessed from their last name being the same, though, Anderson is a pretty common last name.
"So, wait- you two didn't actually go on a date last week- did you?"
"No, no," Blaine quickly assured him. So quickly that Rachel raised an eyebrow at him before turning back to Kurt.
"We planned on telling you after the party, but Blaine chickened out," she teased before pinching her brother, who was slightly flushed. Then Blaine slapped her hand away. Kurt watched the intereaction with interest.
"No wonder you sounded so good together," Kurt mumbled to himself so that neither good hear him.
"What?" asked Blaine.
"So, did you want to continue keeping this a secret or..."
"Well," Rachel looked to Blaine. They hadn't really talked about what would do after they told Kurt.
"We definitely aren't telling anyone before Regionals," Blaine said.
"But we're not sure what we're going to do afterwards-" Rachel said.
"We'll just see how it goes," Blaine finished. Kurt nodded.
"Do you mind if I ask you a question?"
"Sure," Rachel said at the same time that Blaine said "Anything."
"Are you hiding another relation?"
"We have an elder brother," Blaine added.
"I was thinking more like if I find out Patti is your aunt or Barbra is you second cousin- I will never forgive you!"
"Believe me, if we were related to Barbra-"
"Or Patti," Blaine added.
"Or Miss LuPone, Everyone would know," Rachel said, with Blaine nodding in agreement.
"Full disclosure: I have an aunt who is a dead ringer for Anne Hathaway," Kurt added grinning. And after that Blaine and Rachel felt forgiven. Both were happy that they didn't lose their crush and best friend, respectively over this.
A/n: The big reveal to one of New Directions! Thought it went okay, what'd you all think?
Next stop Regionals! (Anyone get the reference? Anyone at all? Ahhhh, I shall convert you all... no worries)