OK I FINALLY got this chapter done. I really hope you like it. I am not going to be updating as much as I used to because I have a lot on my plate. I will still try to update once a month.

I would like to credit SarahSchneider2012 because I used her making up on Valentines Day idea. Please Review and let me know what you think.

Spencer got in the car and tried to determine her best course of action. She could call Toby. Or she could just go home...Toby's house...she'd gotten so used to thinking of it as her home too. She decided to go get Amelia and go home. When she pulled in to her parents Toby was in the driveway. She took a deep breath and got out of the car.

"I have been calling you all afternoon" he said forcefully.

"I know" she said hesitantly.

"And?!" He urged.

"I'm so sorry" she sniffled.

"You're sorry?!" He asked angrily. "Amelia is Caleb's?!"

"No!" She shrieked "she's yours, of course she's yours."

"Then why does her doctor have Caleb listed as the father?" He fumed.

"Because he is listed as the father on her birth certificate" she admitted quietly.

"He what?!" He yelled. Toby turned walking in a circle with his hands in his hair.

"I made a mistake" she sobbed quietly.

"All you do is make mistakes!" He yelled.

"I'm getting it changed" she said hesitantly.

"I want a paternity test!" He said.

"What?!" She shrieked.

"You heard me" he fumed "I. Want. A. Paternity. Test."

"Fine" she griped. He stomped off towards his truck and Spencer went inside the house.

Spencer had gotten Amelia's doctor to do a paternity test a few days later. She sat on one side of the office with Amelia while he sat on the other. Spencer and Amelia went in first. A few minutes later they came out, and Amelia was crying loudly. Spencer left without a word and the doctor called him back.

Two days later Toby got the call from the doctor's office. He was Amelia's father. He felt like a jackass now. He called Spencer but she ignored his call. He called her three more times until she finally answered.

"What?" She snapped as she answered the phone.

"I want to see Amelia" he said. "She's my daughter and you can't keep her from me"

"I was never keeping her from you" she barked. "You can come get her whenever you want."

"I'll call you back with a day and time" he said.

Thankfully since Toby had been working excessively before Spencer and Amelia came back into his life he had a lot of time saved up. He called his boss and asked for a month off explaining the situation. His boss agreed and wished him luck.

He then called Spencer and told her he would be picking her up tomorrow and he would keep her for a week.

"No" she cried "she's my baby, you can't just take her"

"She's my baby too, Spencer" he reminded.

"Fine" she said hanging up without a word.

Toby came over the next morning and knocked on the door of the barn. Melissa answered the door.

"Amelia is in the main house with my mom, she has her things, and is ready to go." She said curtly.

"Where's Spencer?" He asked.

"She's not here" Melissa snapped.

"I'll go to the main house then" he said turning and leaving. Toby walked over to the house. Veronica was holding Amelia when she opened the door.

"Hello Toby" she said giving him a sympathetic smile. Peter sat off to the side sipping his scotch and glaring at Toby as if Toby was the one at fault for the break-up. Were they broken up? He wondered. Or was it just more time apart? No, she had packed her bags. It was over.

"I'll bring her back on Sunday." He told Veronica "Spencer can come ho…she can come see her whenever she wants"

Veronica nodded.

As Toby left he could hear Spencer crying in the barn. He didn't want to take Amelia away from her any more than he wanted her taken from him. It had been less than a week and he had been in agony not seeing his little baby every day. He imagined it was worse for Spencer since she had given birth to her and been there every day of her life except for their trip to NYC and the handful of nights Veronica had taken her. That night as Amelia slept he called Caleb. He needed to know how Spencer and his so called best friend could put Caleb's name as the father of his baby.

"Toby, what's going on?" Caleb asked nervously.

"Spencer called you?" he asked.

"Yeah" he sighed.

"I'm calling because I need to know why" he said.

"It's something Spencer should tell you" he said. He hated when people said that.

"Spencer isn't even speaking to me" he said "Were exchanging Amelia through her parents"

"What do you mean, exchanging her?" he asked.

"She left me Caleb, over something that is not even completely my fault" he said. "Please, if you're my friend, tell me"

"She went into labor two weeks early. She was scared but she changed her mind about the adoption at the last minute. She kept sobbing don't let them take my baby. I promised her I wouldn't let them. She started losing a lot of blood, more blood than I thought a person could lose and survive. They took her to surgery. While she was in surgery, the couple that planned to adopt the baby pulled out. I thought she was going to die and they were gonna put Amelia in foster care, I couldn't let that happen man. I told the nurse I was her father and by the time she got out of surgery the birth certificate had been printed. She was furious until I explained."

"Thank you, Caleb" he said.

Toby felt like a huge dick. He'd gotten pissed off and yelled at Spencer thinking she'd done it to be spiteful or hurtful or selfish, when in reality she hadn't even done it at all. It was late so he decided to call Spencer in the morning and apologize profusely and beg her to come home. At 2 am Amelia began crying and she wouldn't stop. He did all the things he knew he needed to do he checked for a dirty diaper, he fed her, burped her, and rocked her, nothing soothed the baby. He didn't dare call Spencer. She would think he was an inept father. He called the only person he could think of.

"I'm sorry to wake you" he said.

"No, its fine" Aria said "what's up?"

He relayed the events of the last two hours while postulating everything that could have gone wrong.

"Ok Toby, you win I'll come over" she said. She was there 20 minutes later. "I know you can get her to stop crying" he said optimistically.

"She's not going to stop crying" Aria informed him.

"What do you mean?' he asked. Aria looked around the nursery until she laid eyes on the diaper bag pulling some contraption out of it. She put one end in Amelia's ear. A few seconds later it beeped.

"Just what I thought, 101.2" Aria shook her head. "She's sick"

"Sick" Toby said "What do I do, take her to the doctor's office? The ER?"

"The first thing you do is call Spencer" Aria said.

"No, I can't tell Spencer, she'll take Amelia from me" he said.

"If you don't tell her she'll cut your balls off." Aria replied.

Toby did as Aria said and called Spencer. She told him she'd meet him at the ER.

Since an illness is more serious for an infant, the ER took Amelia right away. The doctor had determined she had a version of the illness that Spencer and Toby had been down with a few weeks ago. The doctor was just showing Toby how to administer the medicine when Spencer came in. Amelia made a face at the taste of the medicine. Spencer rushed over to Amelia, kissed her head and felt her face for fever.

"Well, I should get home and get her back down to sleep" Toby said when the doctor finally discharged her.

"No, I am taking her home with me Toby. I'm sorry, but you can have her another time when she's not sick." Spencer said.

"Spence" Aria interjected. "You need to let Toby take Amelia. It is his week and how is he ever going to learn to take care of her if you step in on every little thing?"

"Aria" she said "with all due respect, this is none of your business!"

"Look Spencer" Aria said firmly. "You both love Amelia. Toby is her father and he deserves time to be with her too."

Spencer rolled her eyes at Aria. She clearly didn't get what it was like to be a mom. That wasn't really her fault.

"Why don't I stay with Toby this week? I will help him if things get out of hand that way you don't worry about him or Amelia?"

"Fine!" Spencer said angrily.

Spencer reluctantly went home by herself. Aria went home to pack a bag and explain to Ezra why she was going to be gone for the week.

"Why are you spending the week with Toby?" he asked with a confused expression as he sipped his coffee.

"He needs help with Amelia or Spencer will take her away from him" she said sighing. "He needs to learn how to take care of Amelia. They broke up and that means there is going to be a custody battle soon and Spencer will win if Toby can't prove he can take care of her.

"Maybe he can't" Ezra said clasping his hands.

"No, he can" Aria insisted. "He just needs a little help to get started. Do you want him to lose his child?"

"No, of course not" he admitted. "I think that it is great that you want to help him and I will do anything I can to help."

Toby had gotten Amelia down by the time that Aria returned.

"I can't thank you enough for doing this Aria." he said.

"You're welcome" she replied.

*FIVE DAYS LATER*

Aria was frantic looking for Toby's credit card. He had given it to her to go grocery shopping and now she couldn't find it. She didn't want to tell Toby because she was worried he would be furious. She was pretty sure she had the card when she got back to the house. It had to be in the house somewhere. She decided to check the drawers of his desk thinking maybe he had put it in there. She was rummaging through the top drawer when she came across a blue velvet box. She opened the box to make sure and of course there it was a big beautiful engagement ring. She was still holding it when the door opened.

"Aria?" he said perplexed as he came in.

"I was looking for the credit card you gave me, it has disappeared." she said.

"I have it." he said simply. "You left it on the coffee table and I put it back in my wallet before Amelia could get her hands on it and do something to it"

"Is this what I think it is?" she asked holding up the ring box.

"Yes" he admitted "I had planned to propose to Spencer next week, on Valentine's Day."

"Toby!" Aria squealed. "You have to propose to her!"

"No, I don't" he said bitterly. "She left me Aria, she obviously doesn't want to marry me"

"Toby she has been waiting months for you to propose to her. I bet you if you do it would change things between the two of you"

Toby rolled his eyes.

"Ok" Aria suggested "If I can get her here on Valentine's Day, will you propose?"

He thought for a minute.

"Yes, if you can get her here, which I doubt you or anyone else can" he said.

Aria left and went to the Hastings because she knew that Spencer was at school. She had asked Mrs. Hastings and Melissa to meet with her.

"As you probably know I have been helping Toby with Amelia. He really doesn't need the help but that is beside the point." she started. "I was looking for something I had misplaced and came across an engagement ring."

Both of the Hastings women perked up at this.

"Toby had planned to propose on Valentine's Day" she continued. "Spencer has been waiting months and months for him to propose and I just know if he asked her she would say yes."

Aria went on.

"Toby agreed that if I could get Spencer to go over to the house on Valentine's Day, he would propose. I don't think I would have much luck but maybe two married women such as yourselves could say something to convince her to go over."

"It's worth a shot" Veronica said.

"I know she has been miserable without him" Melissa added.

"Well let's get those kooky kids back together" Aria said.

*2 HOURS LATER*

Spencer walked into the barn with her bag slung over her shoulder. She was in her own little world thinking about Amelia when she heard Melissa sobbing.

"Melissa?" she asked heading over to the couch where she was sitting. "What's wrong?"

"Nothing" she sniffled. "Everything is perfect actually. I felt the baby move today and I called Wren to tell him about it and he told me he has been working to get transferred to Rosewood Memorial. At least until the baby comes but I don't know. I think we might move back here."

"That's great Melissa" Spencer said feeling that familiar pang of jealousy she always felt when Melissa got what she wanted. She was happy for her but now she and Melissa wouldn't be able to commiserate about their men because Wren would be here waiting on her hand and foot. Spencer and Amelia would need to move back into the main house as Wren and Melissa would need their own space. She thought about calling Toby but then refrained. She was still pissed at him she reminded herself. She went into the house to tell her mom the good news. Melissa was still keeping her pregnancy a secret but she was showing if you were paying close attention and when Wren showed up to be with her it would be all too obvious.

"So Melissa told me Wren is going to be coming to Rosewood. She said she thinks they may move back here" Spencer said.

"That is wonderful news" Veronica said happily. "Why don't you sit down? I would like to talk to you about this Toby situation."

She waited for her mom to start in about how she needed to make it work with Toby because she had had a baby with him and that meant they had to be together.

"You know when Melissa was about 5 your father and I were talking about getting a divorce."

"What!?" she shrieked not believing her ears.

"We were fighting all the time and I didn't know it then but he had been sleeping with Jessica Dilaurentis" her mom went on. "Your Nana came to town and took Melissa for the day so we could figure out what we were going to do. Your dad began drinking scotch and I began baking cookies for Melissa. Neither of us spoke for hours. I turned to get something and when I turned back he threw a ball of cookie dough at me. I began throwing it back at him and then next thing you know we're making up on the kitchen floor. "

Melissa had convinced Spencer to go Valentine's Day lingerie shopping with her.

"I think that it is time you two made up" Melissa lectured her.

"It isn't all on me Melissa" she pouted "he has to want to work it out too"

"Maybe he does" she said simply. "Have you asked him about it?"

Spencer rolled her eyes knowing she wouldn't win a fight with her sister.

*VALENTINE'S DAY*

Spencer was all dressed up in red lingerie that was covered by a short revealing black dress. She was shaking like a leaf and she hadn't even stepped out into the frigid February weather yet. Her mom and dad had taken a romantic weekend cruise for the holiday and Melissa was babysitting since she wasn't expecting Wren for a few more days.

She knocked on the door nervously. She heard moving from the inside and wondered idly if Toby had company. She would be extremely heartbroken if that was the case. Toby opened the door and Spencer's breath was taken away as Toby stood there in a new suit.

"You look absolutely gorgeous" he said as he took her hands.

"You're not so bad yourself" she replied.

He led her into the dining room where there was a candlelit dinner on the table.

"Toby" she said speechless over the meal he had made.

"Happy Valentine's Day baby" he said.

"Happy Valentine's Day" she replied. She looked down frowning at the rectangular wrapped present she had brought him. He reached for it and she pulled it away.

"You won't like it" she mumbled. "I should have brought something else"

"Give me the box" he insisted. She handed it over reluctantly. He unwrapped it pulling out the album.

He examined it.

"It's Amelia's baby book" she said "I've been working on it little by little"

"It is beautiful Spencer" he said kissing her "I love it"

Spencer and Toby sat down to dinner then. They sat in comfortable silence as they ate and drank. When dinner was done, Toby led Spencer to the bathroom and ran her a lavender scented bath.

"This is heaven" Spencer moaned as Toby massaged her aching muscles.

"And it isn't over yet" he teased. When they were both dried off from the bath and wearing robes Toby led her to the living room.

"Spencer, the last six months of my life have been the most heartbreaking, frustrating, crazy, fun moments of my life. I cannot imagine my life without Amelia and I can't imagine my life without you." He pulled the ring out of his pocket.

"Oh my god" she breathed as he got down on one knee. "I love you Spencer, I am going to love you forever if you let me. Spencer Jill Hastings, love of my life, mother to my child, keeper of everything I hold dear, will you marry me and make me the happiest man that ever lived?"

"Yes! Of Course Yes!" she squealed as he stood and picked her up spinning her around.

What do you think will happen next? Review and let me know what you think.