Disclaimer: I don't own Glee, nor do I completely own Nick and Jeff (although I'm pretty much creating their personalities myself since we haven't gotten to know them too well on the show).

A/n: Fair warning… this chapter is M-rated! Someone requested a follow up to 55, "Cocktail" and I decided that this word would work well for that. This is taking me a long time to write, however, because I want it to be hot and I keep second guessing myself (I've written smut before, but not with three characters!).

Calendar

+JJ 8PM.

Nick smiled as he saw the notation on the calendar, just as the doorbell rang. Nick glanced at his watch, glad that JJ was right on time. Then again, JJ was always on time for everything and that was part of what made him perfect for this little surprise for Jeff.

"I'm glad you could make it," Nick asked, taking JJ's coat to hang in the closet as the other man came into the living room.

"I wouldn't have missed it… Jeff only turns 21 once, and I'm definitely up for helping you make his fantasy come true. Besides, it's not like there are a lot of options for guys to help you with this." Nick nodded, smiling and glancing down at his watch again to see how long they would be waiting for Jeff to come home.

"So, we have like, five minutes before he gets here, and I have no clue what we're supposed to even really do…"

"Does Jeff know I'm here?" Nick shook his head. "Okay… do you want to surprise him, or are we all going to talk about this before we get started?"

"I… I guess surprise him."

"Okay… I'm going to wait in the bedroom for the two of you. Just let me know if you ever want me to leave, okay?" Nick nodded, taking a deep breath as he realized that he was starting to get really nervous about all of this. "Hey… relax, okay? This is going to be fun." JJ disappeared into the bedroom just as Jeff walked in the door, dropping his backpack on the floor by the couch.

"God… I'm so glad to see you. Today has been hell…" Jeff began. Nick walked over, pressing a soft kiss against Jeff's lips.

"I have something that might just turn your day around," Nick whispered, starting to unbutton Jeff's shirt. "JJ is in our bedroom right now, and if you still want to he's fully prepared to have some fun with us tonight…"

"What?" Nick smiled at Jeff's confusion.

"You. Me. JJ. Threesome."

"Right… okay…" Jeff smiled. "You're cool with this?"

"I called JJ, didn't I?" Nick smiled, pulling Jeff towards the bedroom. The truth was that Nick felt a little nervous about all of this because he didn't want to screw up their friendship with JJ. But the other man had agreed, and now it was just a matter of time until they knew exactly what was going to happen.

JJ was waiting in the bedroom, with his shirt already off. Nick felt Jeff take a deep breath, before the blonde man turned towards him. "I'm nervous…"

"Me too…" Nick replied, smiling at his boyfriend. He took Jeff's hands. "We're just going to try this… if it's too uncomfortable, we can always ask him to leave." Nick leaned in and pressed a kiss against the man's lips as they started removing each others' clothing. Nick smiled as Jeff held out a hand towards JJ, who walked over to join them. Nick pulled Jeff's body closer to his own as JJ pressed up against Jeff's back. That was part of what Nick and JJ had agreed on beforehand – they were both going to focus on making Jeff happy tonight.

"Is this a dream? Or am I really standing between two hot guys that want to have sex with me right now?" Jeff asked.

"It's all real, Jeff. We're here to make sure that you have a good time tonight…" Nick whispered as JJ started kissing down the side of the blonde's neck. Nick pushed Jeff's shirt off the man's arms and JJ threw it away from them. Nick pulled away from the kiss, letting JJ take over as he removed his own shirt and started to undo Jeff's pants to take them off. Soon Jeff was standing there naked, and Nick couldn't help staring at how beautiful his boyfriend really was. "God, Jeff… you're gorgeous."

"He is…" JJ replied. Nick watched the way the other man's hands stroked across Jeff's chest, until the blonde leaned his head back against JJ's shoulder and moaned.

"So hot…" Nick got down on his knees in front of his boyfriend, gently breathing on Jeff's cock as it stood at attention. Finally he leaned in, licking up the underside of it and watching the way Jeff's knees trembled.

"Maybe we should move him over to the bed… I don't know if he's going to be able to stay on his feed if you keep that up," JJ commented. Nick nodded, standing up and gently pulling Jeff over towards the bed with JJ following them. It was getting impossible for Nick to ignore the fact that his pants were far too tight, so he quickly undid them and dropped them to the floor as JJ steered Jeff down onto the bed, kissing all over the man's chest as he fondled Jeff's package.

Nick lay down next to Jeff, grabbing the man's lips in a kiss. "Tell us what you want, Jeff… this is your fantasy." Nick smiled as Jeff looked at him.

"You. In me." Nick nodded, gently stroking Jeff's face and leaning in for another kiss as he reached over for the necessary supplies in their nightstand. He covered his fingers in lube, gently turning Jeff on his side before he started gently playing with Jeff's entrance. Nick watched Jeff's reactions carefully, making sure that the other man was enjoying the attention he was receiving from both Nick and JJ. Nick slowly prepped Jeff for what was coming. "JJ… too much…"

"Do you need me to stop?" Nick asked as JJ backed off, watching as Jeff shook his head.

"I want… between you two…" Jeff muttered breathlessly. Nick glanced over at JJ, who nodded and started to take off his own pants before grabbing the bottle of lube to start preparing himself for Jeff. JJ worked more quickly than Nick, finally leaning in to press a kiss against Jeff's lips. Nick watched as Jeff pushed JJ over so that he was on his back, lifting the man's legs so that he could position himself between them and slowly thrust into JJ. "Nick…"

Nick gently pushed Jeff forward so that he was leaning over JJ's body before Nick carefully covered himself with lube and started to slowly press himself into Jeff's body. Nick pulled out slowly before thrusting back into his boyfriend, forcing the other man further into JJ and making the man on the bottom cry out at the sensation. It happened over and over again before Nick felt Jeff start to tighten around him – a signal that Jeff was close. Nick leaned down and pressed a kiss against Jeff's neck. "Come for me…" he whispered, feeling the way Jeff tightened around him with every thrust – a sensation that made it difficult for him to keep from coming himself. Finally Jeff gave in and came, pulling Nick and JJ with him. Nick collapsed against Jeff's back, doing his best to roll so that they didn't both land on top of JJ.

"So?" Nick asked, pressing a few more kisses against the back of Jeff's neck.

"I should tell you about more of my fantasies…" Jeff replied. Nick smiled as his boyfriend reached out and took JJ's hand. "Thank you… both of you. This is amazing."