Disclaimer: i dont own glee.
"no. no! I wont let that jackass take you!" Blaine cried.
"calm down hobbit. We need to figure out this riddle. Gimmie the paper Finnept." Santana said, calming down but tears were still streaming her face. "Enjoy your freedom while it lasts. It won't take long before the tiny girl gets harmed. You must use your greatest weapon aginst the enemy, little birds, to reach the greatest peak of accomplishment. This little brunette here, I believe you call her Rachel Berry, is in great fear. She keeps calling out the same two names, Santana, Finn. I would hate for either of them to join your handicapped, trouty mouthed, songless, and Irish friends. Death is ready to go shopping for the highest fashion. Unless you do not wish to save your Maria, you better get your ass moving, little Tony.' Well damn."
"we have to sing something, but damn. What do we sing?" Puck asked.
"I think we're supposed to sing something from West Side Story, but what?" Mike suggested.
"Well, we can't do any song with Maria. Rachel played Maria. And it seems it has to be sung by Tony, wouldn't you agree?" Tina suggested.
"Then that leaves Something's Coming. I feel as if though he wants us to sing a duet with Tony and Maria. I mean, in the letter, he said he could prove that Rachel was unharmed, maybe he was referring that if I sing a supposed duet with Maria, maybe he could prove that she is okay?" Blaine questioned.
"I think that's maybe what he wants. You should sing One Hand, One Heart. That's the only duet." Santana pointed out.
"then that's what we'll do. And we've got to keep a close eye on Kurt." Will stated, referring to the pale boy that turned impossibly paler.
Blaine had dressed up as Tony thanks to the help of his scared-as-hell boyfriend and Emma. He was going over his lines in his head. He was afraid that if he messed up one simple line, it would cost him his life. Or worse, Rachels'.
He walked out to the nearby hill. The killer said to reach the greatest peak of accomplishment, and the greatest peak was at the top of the hill.
"you ready, Tony?" Kurt asked, tears in his face.
"Kurt, no matter what happens today, I want you to know that I love you. You move me, Kurt." Blaine smiled before kissing his boyfriend.
Kurt smiled when he pulled away, walking back to the bottom of the hill to stand protectively next to his brother.
Blaine stood confidently at the top of the hill, before calling out.
"Maria? Maria? Are you there? It's me, Tony!"
No Answer.
Blaine turned around slightly to look at what was left of the New Directions, nothing but hope in their eyes.
Blaine gulped before starting again.
"Maria, if you're out there, please respond to me."
Yet again, no answer.
Blaine decided to take his chances.
"I, Anton, take thee, Maria.."
Blaine was about to give up hope when something from the other side of the hill made him stop.
"I, Maria, take thee, Anton.."
Blaine instantly smiled quickly before going back into character.
"For richer, for poorer.."
"in sickness and in health.."
Rachel had made her way up the hill and was now holding onto Blaine for dear life, a faint smile on her lips that none of the New Directions knew if it was a stage smile or not.
"to love and to honor.."
"to hold and to keep.."
Santana and Finn were at the bottom of the hill, crying and being held back by Mike and Tina.
"from each sun, to each moon.."
"from tomorrow to tomorrow…"
Rachel and Blaine held onto each other as if they'd never see each other again. That is what they feared most.
"from now to forever.."
"till death do us part."
"with this ring, I thee wed."
"with this ring, I thee wed."
Kurt held onto Finn's hand, scared to death. He needed to survive. He pleaded to himself that he would.
"make of our hands, one hand.
Make of our hearts, one heart.
Make of our vows, one last vow:
Only death will part us now."
"make of our lives, one life.
Day after day, one life."
"Now it begins, now we start
One hand, one heart;
Even death won't part us now.
Make of our lives one life,
Day after day, one life.
Now it begins, now we start
One hand, one heart,
Even death won't part us now."
Blaine was crying. He pulled Rachel into a tight hug. Rachel whispered into his ear, like she was told to do.
"go get Kurt."
Blaine nodded and walked down the hill. He took his boyfriends hand and pulled him to the top of the hill.
"im so sorry, Kurt."
Once they got to the top of the hill, Rachel looked between the two.
"death said he was shopping for the highest fashion, but death lies. Im so very sorry, Blaine." Rachel said, before pulling the knife from behind her back and stabbing Blaine through the heart.
Kurt gasped in shock and horror, glaring at Rachel while both the boy and Rachel were crying.
"why?" Kurt screamed, getting on his knees next to his boyfriend.
"he made me, Kurt. I'm so sorry. But he made me.." Rachel said handing Kurt the note before running off into the woods that lied at the bottom of the other side of the hill.
"KURT!" Will ran up the hill, catching the pale boy before he passed out.
Mike took the note and read aloud.
"I am just enjoying this game so very much. I do apologize for the mishap, it seemed as that Death did not want the highest fashion when he went shopping, he apparently wanted the triangle eyebrows. I told you little Rachel was unharmed. 5 down. 12 to go. who will be next? Mwahahah. Here is the next riddle:
Death took it's toll by taking Tony away from Maria. It was such a risky move, as that the song stated that not even death could part them. Songs lie. I will not reveal myself, but I will reveal clues. I plan on not taking the lives of the one I own's loved ones. I have plans for them. You have lost your trouty mouth, horrible singer, wheelchair-bound, Irish, and now slicked hair friends. The next one to join them is the dullest crayon in the box. if you wish to save them, you must relieve the greatest sexual tension within the group. Rachel and I will be watching, her by force."
"who has the greatest sexual tension?" Puck asked, holding onto Quinn tightly.
"I don't know. I mean, they're Mr. Schue and Ms. Pillsbury, but who would be sick enough to make Rachel watch them have sex?" Tina suggested.
"what about you, Chang Squared?" Santana asked.
"that is entirely racist and Mike and I have no sexual tension." Tina said, letting Mike wrap his arm around her waist.
"wait a minute.."
"what is it Quinn?" Finn asked.
"who here had sex with Santana last, being her last girlfriend, making them have sexual tension?"
Brittany raised her hand.
Song used was One Hand, One Heart from West Side Story.
Kill Counter (i forgot to do it for the previous chapters):
Killed:
Artie Abrams
Sugar Motta
Sam Evans
Rory Flanagan
Blaine Anderson
Missing:
Rachel Berry